SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 22
Download to read offline
‘My English’
Second Language Learning as
Individual and Social Construction


Kurt Kohn
University of Tübingen (DE)
kurt.kohn@uni-tuebingen.de
www.ael.uni-tuebingen.de
Non-native speaker attitudes towards English

Late 1970s near Boston, Kurt and Neil
     NNS: “Can I say it like this?”
     NS:      “Never mind, I understand you.”
     →      I want to be like you 
     →      You don’t seem to care 

Evidence of a NNS’s exonormative preference for NSE
      Typical of an ELT/EFL/TESOL background
      Deviations from the NSE role model are at best tolerated
      Deeply entrenched in teachers’ and learners’ minds

And today?
      More emphasis (in ELT) on communication, greater
       tolerance for deviations, particularly in CLIL classrooms
      Educational regulations for ELT institutions (in Europe)
       continue to be based on an exonormative NSE role model

Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   2
Excellence in ELT

             is still largely measured and experienced
 in terms of compliance with an externally given NSE role model.

               ELT pupils and students at school and university
                  are being praised for meeting NSE norms.

                         Deviations may be tolerated,
                but they are not taken as evidence of success.

             Generally, communicative competence is the goal,
                 but it is the communicative competence
                             of native speakers.

               At the same time, however, English outside the
              ELT classroom has undergone dramatic changes.



Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   3
Non-native speakers on the rise

Labov 1970: “In the sociolinguistic study of language learning, we
can begin with the fundamental observation that children do not
speak like their parents” (p. 33). [We may add: learners do not speak
like their teachers]
Graddol 1997/2000: “Native speakers may feel the language
'belongs' to them, but it will be those who speak English as a second
or foreign language who will determine its world future” ( p. 5).
Widdowson 1994/2003: “How English develops in the world is no
business whatever of native speakers in England, the United States,
or anywhere else. They have no say in the matter, no right to
intervene or pass judgement.” (p. 43)
Kohn 2011: “Owning a house is one thing; however, making it one's
home is yet another. If non-native speakers accept ownership, they
also need to begin to feel responsible for themselves. Before being
able to shape the future of English, they need to get their own
English into shape. But which direction should they take?” (p.73)
  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   4
A NNS’s ownership of English
   – Shattered dreams or a conceptual misunderstanding –

My first serious encounter with the double-edged nature of a
NNS’s ownership of English happened at an ELF conference – the
NS presenter’s message was that for a NNS of English a NSE
orientation was fundamentally wrong and impossible to pursue
with any hope for success.
The wall too high to climb - the fruit too sweet and out of reach
anyway – just not my sociolinguistic reality. I found myself
excluded from the enchanted garden.
But here I was, a Faustian creature with two souls: a NNS with a
desire for some kind of NSE orientation – a desire I was told was
unrealistic – a desire, however, that was part of my English self.
This was when my quest into the nature of NNS’s ownership of
English began – both as a researcher and as a NNS myself.
I found my answer in a social constructivist understanding of NNS
ownership, i.e. the conceptualization of language learning as the
cognitive, emotional and behavioral creation of “my English”.

 Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   5
Making English my own

How do I make English my own?
    → I acquire it
But how do I acquire English? [compare: acquiring a car]
    I develop/construct/CREATE my own version of it in my mind,
     my heart and my behavior
        → based on my target language model, my native language,
             my attitudes and motivation, my goals & requirements,
             my learning approach, and the effort I invest
    And I do this in communicative, social interaction with others

  In this social constructivist sense, the English I develop is my own
                                     – “My English” –
It is inevitably different from the TL model toward which it is oriented.
       – Not an option, rather part of the human condition –

  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   6
Creating “My English” is about . . .

. . . creating my communicative-linguistic knowledge & skills
  lexical and grammatical means of expression
  how these can be used to fulfil language & communication-
   related requirements of performance regarding what is
   possible, appropriate, feasible, and probable (Hymes 1972)

. . . creating my requirements of performance
  a little child in first language acquisition
  an immigrant in second language acquisition
  a ELT learner in lingua franca situations

. . . creating my individual and social identity orientation
  Who do I want to be?                   →     e.g. am I comfortable with myself?
  What/who is my role model?                         →     e.g. some kind of NSE
  By whom do I want to be accepted?                              →     desire for participation


 Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   7
“My English”
           Implications for communicative competence



 More than getting linguistic means of expression right in terms of
  possibility, appropriateness, feasibility, and probability

 More than being able to use linguistic means of expression for
  achieving communicative needs and purposes

 Expressing oneself in keeping with one’s individual and social
  identity: Expressing One’s Self
   → Perceived success
   → Hearer satisfaction
   → Speaker satisfaction


  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   8
“My English”
                                    Implications for ELF
English as a lingua franca – the variety bias
    Typical definitions of ELF seem to suggest that it is a “thing”
    The power of concepts: “the way we think and talk about
     language influences the way we think & talk about . . . “
    The “thingness” of ELF is deeply rooted in the intuitive
     perception and understanding of English teachers: teaching ELF
     is seen as teaching a certain variety of English
ELF is not a “thing” – a thought experiment
    Imagine a group of people in an international ELF context
    What language do they use? What kind of English?
    I can only speak “My English” > NS, SL or learner English
ELF is about using “My English” under LF conditions
   Accommodation strategies
   Meaning negotiation strategies

  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   9
My own Standard English

Imagine my aim was Mid-Atlantic Standard English (MASE)
→ My own simplified, sketchy, uncertain, even “wrong”
    internal representation
     cognitive & emotional creative construction process
     based on the language of the people I (like to) talk to
     possibly influenced by linguistic descriptions
      (which are constructions themselves)

What shapes my learning of MASE?
     My own cognitive-emotional construction and representation
     Linguistic descriptions and teaching models of MASE only
      influence me through the constructive process of mediation
      and adaptation

  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   10
Native speaker / Standard English
                        as a target model for learning


Strong version of a                                     Learners are required to comply
NSE orientation                                         with the NSE (teaching) norms –
                                                        the closer they get, the better

                  Understanding language learning
       as a behaviorist copying process lurks in the background



                                                       Learners take NSE as a model for
Weak version of a
                                                       orientation – they create their
NSE orientation
                                                       own version of it

                 Understanding language learning
  as a constructivist process of cognitive and emotional creation



Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   11
ELT research and practice
           Theoretical beliefs & pedagogic orientations

1. An exonormative NSE orientation appears to be a given
   [> BE or GA in German secondary schools]
2. The (strong!) exonormative NSE orientation is generally accepted
    by both teachers and learners
3. Any deviation from the NSE model is at best tolerated; it is
   “never” experienced as something positive
4. Even in communicative approaches, learning is oriented toward
   a NSE model
5. A new turn is brought about by CLIL: content and language
   integrated learning

        Endonormative processes (“My English”) are not valued
        Because of the (strong) exonormative perspective, learners tend
        to stay (partially) alienated from their own creativity resulting in
        frustration, anxiety and even fear
  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   12
ELF research and practice
           Theoretical beliefs & pedagogic orientations

1. ELF development is seen as a creative endonormative process
2. Deviations from NSE are accepted if they are communicatively
   successful > focus on comprehensibility
3. The endonormative nature of ELF development is regarded as
   incompatible with an exonormative NSE orientation
4. Emphasis is on spoken ELF communication
5. A new turn (Seidlhofer 2011): teaching ELF is about the process of
   developing the kind of English users/learners are able to make
   authentic for themselves – including NSE (!)


        Need to go beyond communicative acceptability
        > speaker satisfaction (Albl-Mikasa 2009)

        Need for more attention to written ELF communication
        (Horner 2011)

  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   13
A constructivist resolution
                                   of the ELT/ELF divide

The divide between ELT and ELF
    ELF emphasizes endonormativity against exonormativity
    Because of ELT’s exonormative bias, ELF-based pedagogic
     suggestions are met with suspicion in ELT: “Do you want me to
     teach incorrect English” (German teacher and teacher educator)
The need for a reconciliation
    Challenges arising from ELF-specific sociolinguistic realities
    Inconsistent educational regulations for schools in Germany
What should be done?
    ELF: extension of the endonormative view to include a
     “weak” NSE orientation
    ELT: adoption of an endonormative conceptualization of
     language learning & teaching (“My English”) along with an
     acceptance of a constructivist, “weak” NSE orientation
  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   14
ELF in the foreign language classroom


Focus on raising awareness for LF manifestations of English
     to increase tolerance for others and for oneself

Focus on developing ELF-specific comprehension skills
     to get accustomed to NNS accents and “messy” performance

Focus on developing ELF-specific production skills
     to improve pragmatic fluency and strategic skills for
     accommodation and collaborative negotiation of meaning in
     intercultural ELF situations

                Exposure to a wide variety of ELF speakers
                Focus on form within communicative tasks
                (with a weak NSE orientation)
                Interaction in ELF communication

  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   15
ELF in the foreign language classroom, cont’d
Focus on developing the learner’s sense of ownership (“agency”)
   to ensure speaker satisfaction and self-confidence
What are the conditions that make this possible?
   Imagine an “inhibited” learner in school . . .
   Liberation though communicative participation in an authentic
       speech fellowship or community of practice
How can “liberating” conditions be successfully implemented through
educational approaches & scenarios?
   CLIL - Practice Enterprise - Creative Writing
   “Pushed output processing” (Swain 2006) - with increased self-
       satisfaction as a target (instead of better compliance with an
       external norm)
   Authentic & autonomous web-based communication & collaboration
   All with the aim to explore and extend one’s own creativity
      (→ Vygotsky’s zone of proximal development)

  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   16
The potential of e-learning

An e-learning platform like Moodle,
  enhanced with web2 tools (e.g. forum chat, Skype, wiki, blog),
  and combined with online CLIL resources
provides a great potential for autonomous, authentic and
collaborative language learning:

  Flexible practice activities (reading, writing, listening, speaking)
    with texts, images, sound and video
  Real (online) communication & interaction
      for content and language integrated learning
      with new possibilities for “incidental” language learning

   Blended Language Learning to enhance face-to-face
   classroom activities
                                         (→ Kohn 2009, 2012)

   Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   17
Examples from our European projects

 BACKBONE: Pedagogic Corpora for Content and Language
  Integrated Learning
    http://projects.ael.uni-tuebingen.de/backbone/moodle
    http://purl.org/backbone/searchtool

 PELLIC: Practice Enterprise for Language Learning and
  Intercultural Communication
    http://projects.ael.uni-tuebingen.de/pellic

 icEurope: Intercultural Foreign Language Communication
  and Learning
    http://projects.ael.uni-tuebingen.de/iceurope/moodle

 TELF: Tübingen English as a Lingua Franca Corpus
   http://projects.ael.uni-tuebingen.de/telf


  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   18
Closing remark

Let us embrace the non-native speakers’ “own” English – guided
by their “own” NSE orientation – pushed by their communicative
needs and identification purposes – fuelled by their creativity!

According to the constructivist insight, a learner’s "own mark" is
more than being allowed to drop the copula or 3rd person 's' – it is
rather about being allowed and encouraged to be oneself.


                                    Excellence in TESOL
                                 takes a giant step forward
                          when learners are given the space
                            for developing their own English
                                  – for being themselves –
            in keeping with their individual and social identities



Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   19
Final quotes
Keith Gilyard 2011: “ . . the idea that students were writers and not
merely people learning to write, that they already had meaningful
things to express, and that those gestures toward meaning had to
take priority over the rigid, narrow, formal exercises laid out in many
writing classrooms” (p.28).

                  “. . . that NNS of English are speakers of English and not
                  merely people learning English”

Jane L.H.: “Taking ownership is really about identity, creativity, and
the energy we use to express these in words: using/constructing
language to communicate in a way that no other can exactly
duplicate because of the user’s inherent uniqueness. [. . .] I see my
own perception of my native language and its ecology change as I
watch my students take ownership: learning its structures,
experimenting with vocabulary and voice, and imprinting all with their
own identity. I don’t think it gets any better.”      (TESOL online
discussion, Feb 16th, 2012

  Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   20
References
Albl-Mikasa, M. (2009). Who’s afraid of ELF: “failed” natives or non-native speakers struggling to express
themselves? In Albl-Mikasa, M., Braun, S. & Kalina, S. (eds.). Dimensionen der Zweitsprachenforschung –
Dimensions of Second Language Research. Festschrift für Kurt Kohn. Narr Verlag, 109-129.
Gilyard, K. (2011). True to the Language Game. African American Discourse, Cultural Politics, and
Pedagogy. Routledge.
Graddol, D. (1997/2000). The Future of English. A Guide to forecasting the popularity of the English
language in the 21st century. The British Council.
Horner, B.(2011). Writing English as a lingua franca. In Archibald, A. et al. (eds.). Latest Trends in ELF
Research. Cambridge Scholars, 299-311.
Hymes, D.H. (1972). On communicative competence. In Pride, J.B. & Holmes, J. (eds.). Sociolinguistis:
Selected Readings. Penguin, 269-293.
Kachru, B. (1985). Standards, codification and sociolinguistic realism: The English in the outer circle. In
Quirk, R. & Widdowson, H.G. (eds.). English in the World: Teaching and Learning the Language and
Literatures. CUP, 11-30.
Kohn, K. (2009). Computer assisted language Learning. In Knapp, K. & Seidlhofer, B. (eds.). Foreign
Language Communication and Learning. Handbooks of Applied Linguistics 6. Mouton-de Gruyter, 573–603.
Kohn, Kurt (2011). English as a lingua franca and the Standard English misunderstanding. In De Houwer, A.
& Wilton, A. (eds.). English in Europe Today. Sociocultural and Educational Perspectives. Benjamins, 72-94.
Kohn, K. (2012). The BACKBONE project: pedagogic corpora for content and language integrated learning.
Objectives, methodological approach and outcomes. Eurocall Review (to appear).
Labov, W. (1970). The Study of Non-standard English. National Council of Teachers of English.
Seidlhofer , B. (2011). Understanding English as a Lingua Franca. OUP.
Swain, M. (2006). Languaging, agency and collaboration in advanced second language proficiency. In
Byrnes, H. (ed.). Advanced Language Learning: The Contributions of Halliday and Vygotsky. Continuum, 95-
108.
Widdowson, H. (2003). Defining Issues in English Language Teaching. OUP.

     Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   21
Thank you



Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Acquisition as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012   22

More Related Content

What's hot

Grammar Translation Method
Grammar Translation MethodGrammar Translation Method
Grammar Translation Method
Marisol
 
Task Base Language Learning
Task Base Language LearningTask Base Language Learning
Task Base Language Learning
Marco Lokoy BNFM
 
Competency based language teaching (revisi)
Competency based language teaching (revisi)Competency based language teaching (revisi)
Competency based language teaching (revisi)
Yani Yani
 
Lambert’s Socio Psychological Model
Lambert’s Socio Psychological ModelLambert’s Socio Psychological Model
Lambert’s Socio Psychological Model
Dr. Cupid Lucid
 

What's hot (20)

Fundamental aspects of language teaching
Fundamental aspects of language teachingFundamental aspects of language teaching
Fundamental aspects of language teaching
 
Introduction to English for Specific Purposes
Introduction to English for Specific PurposesIntroduction to English for Specific Purposes
Introduction to English for Specific Purposes
 
World Englishes
World EnglishesWorld Englishes
World Englishes
 
Communicative Language Teaching
Communicative Language Teaching Communicative Language Teaching
Communicative Language Teaching
 
Cambridge Delta module 3
Cambridge Delta module 3 Cambridge Delta module 3
Cambridge Delta module 3
 
TBL (Task based learning)
TBL (Task based learning)TBL (Task based learning)
TBL (Task based learning)
 
English for Specific Purposes by Tony Dudley Evans
English for Specific Purposes by Tony Dudley EvansEnglish for Specific Purposes by Tony Dudley Evans
English for Specific Purposes by Tony Dudley Evans
 
Monitor Model Theory
Monitor Model Theory Monitor Model Theory
Monitor Model Theory
 
A critical view of ELT history
A critical view of ELT history A critical view of ELT history
A critical view of ELT history
 
Motivation in second and foreign language learning zolt'n dornyei
Motivation in second and foreign language learning zolt'n dornyeiMotivation in second and foreign language learning zolt'n dornyei
Motivation in second and foreign language learning zolt'n dornyei
 
Error analysis
Error analysisError analysis
Error analysis
 
Grammar Translation Method
Grammar Translation MethodGrammar Translation Method
Grammar Translation Method
 
Community Language Learning
Community Language LearningCommunity Language Learning
Community Language Learning
 
Content Integrated Language Learning ( CLIL)
Content Integrated Language Learning ( CLIL)Content Integrated Language Learning ( CLIL)
Content Integrated Language Learning ( CLIL)
 
Community language learning (CLL)
Community language learning (CLL)Community language learning (CLL)
Community language learning (CLL)
 
English as a native, second, foreing language and lingua franca
English as a native, second, foreing language and lingua francaEnglish as a native, second, foreing language and lingua franca
English as a native, second, foreing language and lingua franca
 
Task Base Language Learning
Task Base Language LearningTask Base Language Learning
Task Base Language Learning
 
Competency based language teaching (revisi)
Competency based language teaching (revisi)Competency based language teaching (revisi)
Competency based language teaching (revisi)
 
Formal instruction and language learning
Formal instruction and language learningFormal instruction and language learning
Formal instruction and language learning
 
Lambert’s Socio Psychological Model
Lambert’s Socio Psychological ModelLambert’s Socio Psychological Model
Lambert’s Socio Psychological Model
 

Viewers also liked

Second language acquisition
Second language acquisitionSecond language acquisition
Second language acquisition
jrey007
 
Theories of second language learning
Theories of second language learningTheories of second language learning
Theories of second language learning
Peter Szabo
 
Second Language Acquisition: An Introduction
Second Language Acquisition: An IntroductionSecond Language Acquisition: An Introduction
Second Language Acquisition: An Introduction
Jane Keeler
 
Chapter 1 Language Learning in Early Childhood
Chapter 1 Language Learning in Early ChildhoodChapter 1 Language Learning in Early Childhood
Chapter 1 Language Learning in Early Childhood
Vin Simon
 
Second Language Acquisition
Second Language AcquisitionSecond Language Acquisition
Second Language Acquisition
Bhagirath Khuman
 
Second Language Acquisition
Second Language AcquisitionSecond Language Acquisition
Second Language Acquisition
Hala Nur
 
Second Language Learning
Second Language LearningSecond Language Learning
Second Language Learning
paulapaulas
 
Second language learning classroom
Second language learning classroomSecond language learning classroom
Second language learning classroom
cuaality
 
Second language acquisition!
Second language acquisition!Second language acquisition!
Second language acquisition!
Irina Payares
 

Viewers also liked (20)

ESOL learners’ views and experiences of language learning, integration and id...
ESOL learners’ views and experiences of language learning, integration and id...ESOL learners’ views and experiences of language learning, integration and id...
ESOL learners’ views and experiences of language learning, integration and id...
 
Second language learning
Second language learningSecond language learning
Second language learning
 
Second language acquisition
Second language acquisitionSecond language acquisition
Second language acquisition
 
Second Language learning
Second Language learningSecond Language learning
Second Language learning
 
Theories of second language learning
Theories of second language learningTheories of second language learning
Theories of second language learning
 
Second Language Acquisition: An Introduction
Second Language Acquisition: An IntroductionSecond Language Acquisition: An Introduction
Second Language Acquisition: An Introduction
 
Chapter 1 Language Learning in Early Childhood
Chapter 1 Language Learning in Early ChildhoodChapter 1 Language Learning in Early Childhood
Chapter 1 Language Learning in Early Childhood
 
Input and Interaction in second language learning
Input and Interaction in second language learningInput and Interaction in second language learning
Input and Interaction in second language learning
 
second language acquisition
second language acquisitionsecond language acquisition
second language acquisition
 
e Learning Content curation
e Learning Content curatione Learning Content curation
e Learning Content curation
 
ESOL Entry2
ESOL Entry2ESOL Entry2
ESOL Entry2
 
Second Language Acquisition
Second Language AcquisitionSecond Language Acquisition
Second Language Acquisition
 
Second Language Acquisition
Second Language AcquisitionSecond Language Acquisition
Second Language Acquisition
 
Second Language Learning
Second Language LearningSecond Language Learning
Second Language Learning
 
The Nature of the Second Language acquisition and Learning
The Nature of the Second Language acquisition and LearningThe Nature of the Second Language acquisition and Learning
The Nature of the Second Language acquisition and Learning
 
Second language learning classroom
Second language learning classroomSecond language learning classroom
Second language learning classroom
 
Principles Of Instructed Second Language Learning
Principles Of Instructed Second Language LearningPrinciples Of Instructed Second Language Learning
Principles Of Instructed Second Language Learning
 
English (as a second language) learning at rural india
English (as a second language) learning at rural indiaEnglish (as a second language) learning at rural india
English (as a second language) learning at rural india
 
Second language acquisition!
Second language acquisition!Second language acquisition!
Second language acquisition!
 
Language Learning in Early Childhood
Language Learning in Early ChildhoodLanguage Learning in Early Childhood
Language Learning in Early Childhood
 

Similar to Kurt Kohn 2012 "‘My English’ - Second Language learning & Teachings as Individ…

9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
blondellchancy
 
English 344 dialogism
English 344 dialogism English 344 dialogism
English 344 dialogism
lisyaseloni
 
002 week 4 identity, investment and language learning copy
002 week 4 identity, investment and language learning copy002 week 4 identity, investment and language learning copy
002 week 4 identity, investment and language learning copy
lisyaseloni
 
Applied linguistics and theories of language learning.pptx
Applied linguistics and theories of language learning.pptxApplied linguistics and theories of language learning.pptx
Applied linguistics and theories of language learning.pptx
ALPINESCHOOL2
 
Second language acquisition in the classroom
Second language acquisition in the classroomSecond language acquisition in the classroom
Second language acquisition in the classroom
Elih Sutisna Yanto
 
Engl 625 Session 1
Engl 625 Session 1Engl 625 Session 1
Engl 625 Session 1
lisyaseloni
 
Preparing future academicsclaim1and2
Preparing future academicsclaim1and2Preparing future academicsclaim1and2
Preparing future academicsclaim1and2
Nettie Boivin
 
Second language acquisition
Second language acquisitionSecond language acquisition
Second language acquisition
edac4co
 
2 lilac module 2 oh ts
2  lilac module 2 oh ts2  lilac module 2 oh ts
2 lilac module 2 oh ts
Sam Reynolds
 

Similar to Kurt Kohn 2012 "‘My English’ - Second Language learning & Teachings as Individ… (20)

Kurt Kohn 2012 My Language - My English. Towards a Lingua Franca Pedagogy
 Kurt Kohn 2012 My Language - My English. Towards a Lingua Franca Pedagogy Kurt Kohn 2012 My Language - My English. Towards a Lingua Franca Pedagogy
Kurt Kohn 2012 My Language - My English. Towards a Lingua Franca Pedagogy
 
Beyond communicative language teaching: new sociolinguistic realities, new ch...
Beyond communicative language teaching: new sociolinguistic realities, new ch...Beyond communicative language teaching: new sociolinguistic realities, new ch...
Beyond communicative language teaching: new sociolinguistic realities, new ch...
 
Kohn 2018_ELF - From research to pedagogy_RELC Conf 12-14 March 2018
Kohn 2018_ELF - From research to pedagogy_RELC Conf 12-14 March 2018Kohn 2018_ELF - From research to pedagogy_RELC Conf 12-14 March 2018
Kohn 2018_ELF - From research to pedagogy_RELC Conf 12-14 March 2018
 
Kohn 2013 Intercultural communicative competence: an English as a lingua fran...
Kohn 2013 Intercultural communicative competence: an English as a lingua fran...Kohn 2013 Intercultural communicative competence: an English as a lingua fran...
Kohn 2013 Intercultural communicative competence: an English as a lingua fran...
 
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
 
English 344 dialogism
English 344 dialogism English 344 dialogism
English 344 dialogism
 
English 344 dialogism
English 344 dialogism English 344 dialogism
English 344 dialogism
 
002 week 4 identity, investment and language learning copy
002 week 4 identity, investment and language learning copy002 week 4 identity, investment and language learning copy
002 week 4 identity, investment and language learning copy
 
Decline and fall of the native speaker
Decline and fall of the native speakerDecline and fall of the native speaker
Decline and fall of the native speaker
 
Applied linguistics and theories of language learning.pptx
Applied linguistics and theories of language learning.pptxApplied linguistics and theories of language learning.pptx
Applied linguistics and theories of language learning.pptx
 
Second language acquisition in the classroom
Second language acquisition in the classroomSecond language acquisition in the classroom
Second language acquisition in the classroom
 
Engl 625 Session 1
Engl 625 Session 1Engl 625 Session 1
Engl 625 Session 1
 
Psychology and Language Learning (I Bimestre)
Psychology and Language Learning (I Bimestre)Psychology and Language Learning (I Bimestre)
Psychology and Language Learning (I Bimestre)
 
Learner Autonomy
Learner AutonomyLearner Autonomy
Learner Autonomy
 
Unit 2-6508(2).pptx
Unit 2-6508(2).pptxUnit 2-6508(2).pptx
Unit 2-6508(2).pptx
 
Age
AgeAge
Age
 
Preparing future academicsclaim1and2
Preparing future academicsclaim1and2Preparing future academicsclaim1and2
Preparing future academicsclaim1and2
 
MTB-MLE Unit 3 (Group 3 Knowing L1).docx
MTB-MLE Unit 3 (Group 3 Knowing L1).docxMTB-MLE Unit 3 (Group 3 Knowing L1).docx
MTB-MLE Unit 3 (Group 3 Knowing L1).docx
 
Second language acquisition
Second language acquisitionSecond language acquisition
Second language acquisition
 
2 lilac module 2 oh ts
2  lilac module 2 oh ts2  lilac module 2 oh ts
2 lilac module 2 oh ts
 

More from Kurt Kohn

Kurt Kohn (2019). Virtual intercultural communication practice and learning. ...
Kurt Kohn (2019). Virtual intercultural communication practice and learning. ...Kurt Kohn (2019). Virtual intercultural communication practice and learning. ...
Kurt Kohn (2019). Virtual intercultural communication practice and learning. ...
Kurt Kohn
 
Kohn, Teaching towards ELF competence in the English classroom, ELF 7 Athens,...
Kohn, Teaching towards ELF competence in the English classroom, ELF 7 Athens,...Kohn, Teaching towards ELF competence in the English classroom, ELF 7 Athens,...
Kohn, Teaching towards ELF competence in the English classroom, ELF 7 Athens,...
Kurt Kohn
 
Petra Hoffstaedter & Kurt Kohn (2014). Task design for intercultural telecoll...
Petra Hoffstaedter & Kurt Kohn (2014). Task design for intercultural telecoll...Petra Hoffstaedter & Kurt Kohn (2014). Task design for intercultural telecoll...
Petra Hoffstaedter & Kurt Kohn (2014). Task design for intercultural telecoll...
Kurt Kohn
 
Hoffstaedter & Kohn (2014). Role play and interpreting in virtual reality
Hoffstaedter & Kohn (2014). Role play and interpreting in virtual realityHoffstaedter & Kohn (2014). Role play and interpreting in virtual reality
Hoffstaedter & Kohn (2014). Role play and interpreting in virtual reality
Kurt Kohn
 
"Intercultural communication practice 2.0" Kurt Kohn, Online Educa Berlin 2013
"Intercultural communication practice 2.0" Kurt Kohn, Online Educa Berlin 2013"Intercultural communication practice 2.0" Kurt Kohn, Online Educa Berlin 2013
"Intercultural communication practice 2.0" Kurt Kohn, Online Educa Berlin 2013
Kurt Kohn
 
Kurt Kohn, Collaborative Authentication - A Social Constructivist Perspective...
Kurt Kohn, Collaborative Authentication - A Social Constructivist Perspective...Kurt Kohn, Collaborative Authentication - A Social Constructivist Perspective...
Kurt Kohn, Collaborative Authentication - A Social Constructivist Perspective...
Kurt Kohn
 

More from Kurt Kohn (13)

Kurt Kohn (2019). Virtual intercultural communication practice and learning. ...
Kurt Kohn (2019). Virtual intercultural communication practice and learning. ...Kurt Kohn (2019). Virtual intercultural communication practice and learning. ...
Kurt Kohn (2019). Virtual intercultural communication practice and learning. ...
 
Kohn & Hoffstaedter 2018_Telecollaboration for ICC development_RELC Conf 12-1...
Kohn & Hoffstaedter 2018_Telecollaboration for ICC development_RELC Conf 12-1...Kohn & Hoffstaedter 2018_Telecollaboration for ICC development_RELC Conf 12-1...
Kohn & Hoffstaedter 2018_Telecollaboration for ICC development_RELC Conf 12-1...
 
Kohn, Teaching towards ELF competence in the English classroom, ELF 7 Athens,...
Kohn, Teaching towards ELF competence in the English classroom, ELF 7 Athens,...Kohn, Teaching towards ELF competence in the English classroom, ELF 7 Athens,...
Kohn, Teaching towards ELF competence in the English classroom, ELF 7 Athens,...
 
Petra Hoffstaedter & Kurt Kohn (2014). Task design for intercultural telecoll...
Petra Hoffstaedter & Kurt Kohn (2014). Task design for intercultural telecoll...Petra Hoffstaedter & Kurt Kohn (2014). Task design for intercultural telecoll...
Petra Hoffstaedter & Kurt Kohn (2014). Task design for intercultural telecoll...
 
Hoffstaedter & Kohn (2014). Role play and interpreting in virtual reality
Hoffstaedter & Kohn (2014). Role play and interpreting in virtual realityHoffstaedter & Kohn (2014). Role play and interpreting in virtual reality
Hoffstaedter & Kohn (2014). Role play and interpreting in virtual reality
 
Kurt Kohn (2014). Telecollaboration for monolingual & multilingual communicat...
Kurt Kohn (2014). Telecollaboration for monolingual & multilingual communicat...Kurt Kohn (2014). Telecollaboration for monolingual & multilingual communicat...
Kurt Kohn (2014). Telecollaboration for monolingual & multilingual communicat...
 
Telekollaboration und die alltäglichkeit des interkulturellen fremdspracherle...
Telekollaboration und die alltäglichkeit des interkulturellen fremdspracherle...Telekollaboration und die alltäglichkeit des interkulturellen fremdspracherle...
Telekollaboration und die alltäglichkeit des interkulturellen fremdspracherle...
 
Telecollaboration, lingua franca communication, and speaker satisfaction kohn...
Telecollaboration, lingua franca communication, and speaker satisfaction kohn...Telecollaboration, lingua franca communication, and speaker satisfaction kohn...
Telecollaboration, lingua franca communication, and speaker satisfaction kohn...
 
"Intercultural communication practice 2.0" Kurt Kohn, Online Educa Berlin 2013
"Intercultural communication practice 2.0" Kurt Kohn, Online Educa Berlin 2013"Intercultural communication practice 2.0" Kurt Kohn, Online Educa Berlin 2013
"Intercultural communication practice 2.0" Kurt Kohn, Online Educa Berlin 2013
 
Kurt Kohn, Collaborative Authentication - A Social Constructivist Perspective...
Kurt Kohn, Collaborative Authentication - A Social Constructivist Perspective...Kurt Kohn, Collaborative Authentication - A Social Constructivist Perspective...
Kurt Kohn, Collaborative Authentication - A Social Constructivist Perspective...
 
Kohn 2013 Pedagogic corpora: from real language to relevant language learning...
Kohn 2013 Pedagogic corpora: from real language to relevant language learning...Kohn 2013 Pedagogic corpora: from real language to relevant language learning...
Kohn 2013 Pedagogic corpora: from real language to relevant language learning...
 
Kohn 2013 e-learning 4 languages: the human dimension, TESOL Arabia 14-16 Mar...
Kohn 2013 e-learning 4 languages: the human dimension, TESOL Arabia 14-16 Mar...Kohn 2013 e-learning 4 languages: the human dimension, TESOL Arabia 14-16 Mar...
Kohn 2013 e-learning 4 languages: the human dimension, TESOL Arabia 14-16 Mar...
 
Hoffstaedter & Kohn 2012 Dolmetschen und Dolmetschtraining in der virtuellen ...
Hoffstaedter & Kohn 2012 Dolmetschen und Dolmetschtraining in der virtuellen ...Hoffstaedter & Kohn 2012 Dolmetschen und Dolmetschtraining in der virtuellen ...
Hoffstaedter & Kohn 2012 Dolmetschen und Dolmetschtraining in der virtuellen ...
 

Recently uploaded

1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
QucHHunhnh
 
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Chris Hunter
 
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch LetterGardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
MateoGardella
 
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
MateoGardella
 
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptxSeal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
negromaestrong
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
heathfieldcps1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
 
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
 
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
 
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
 
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsIntroduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
 
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
 
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch LetterGardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
 
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptxUnit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
 
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...
 
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
 
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
 
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesMixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
 
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptxSeal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
 
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
PROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docxPROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docx
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfKey note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
 

Kurt Kohn 2012 "‘My English’ - Second Language learning & Teachings as Individ…

  • 1. ‘My English’ Second Language Learning as Individual and Social Construction Kurt Kohn University of Tübingen (DE) kurt.kohn@uni-tuebingen.de www.ael.uni-tuebingen.de
  • 2. Non-native speaker attitudes towards English Late 1970s near Boston, Kurt and Neil NNS: “Can I say it like this?” NS: “Never mind, I understand you.” → I want to be like you  → You don’t seem to care  Evidence of a NNS’s exonormative preference for NSE  Typical of an ELT/EFL/TESOL background  Deviations from the NSE role model are at best tolerated  Deeply entrenched in teachers’ and learners’ minds And today?  More emphasis (in ELT) on communication, greater tolerance for deviations, particularly in CLIL classrooms  Educational regulations for ELT institutions (in Europe) continue to be based on an exonormative NSE role model Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 2
  • 3. Excellence in ELT is still largely measured and experienced in terms of compliance with an externally given NSE role model. ELT pupils and students at school and university are being praised for meeting NSE norms. Deviations may be tolerated, but they are not taken as evidence of success. Generally, communicative competence is the goal, but it is the communicative competence of native speakers. At the same time, however, English outside the ELT classroom has undergone dramatic changes. Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 3
  • 4. Non-native speakers on the rise Labov 1970: “In the sociolinguistic study of language learning, we can begin with the fundamental observation that children do not speak like their parents” (p. 33). [We may add: learners do not speak like their teachers] Graddol 1997/2000: “Native speakers may feel the language 'belongs' to them, but it will be those who speak English as a second or foreign language who will determine its world future” ( p. 5). Widdowson 1994/2003: “How English develops in the world is no business whatever of native speakers in England, the United States, or anywhere else. They have no say in the matter, no right to intervene or pass judgement.” (p. 43) Kohn 2011: “Owning a house is one thing; however, making it one's home is yet another. If non-native speakers accept ownership, they also need to begin to feel responsible for themselves. Before being able to shape the future of English, they need to get their own English into shape. But which direction should they take?” (p.73) Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 4
  • 5. A NNS’s ownership of English – Shattered dreams or a conceptual misunderstanding – My first serious encounter with the double-edged nature of a NNS’s ownership of English happened at an ELF conference – the NS presenter’s message was that for a NNS of English a NSE orientation was fundamentally wrong and impossible to pursue with any hope for success. The wall too high to climb - the fruit too sweet and out of reach anyway – just not my sociolinguistic reality. I found myself excluded from the enchanted garden. But here I was, a Faustian creature with two souls: a NNS with a desire for some kind of NSE orientation – a desire I was told was unrealistic – a desire, however, that was part of my English self. This was when my quest into the nature of NNS’s ownership of English began – both as a researcher and as a NNS myself. I found my answer in a social constructivist understanding of NNS ownership, i.e. the conceptualization of language learning as the cognitive, emotional and behavioral creation of “my English”. Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 5
  • 6. Making English my own How do I make English my own? → I acquire it But how do I acquire English? [compare: acquiring a car]  I develop/construct/CREATE my own version of it in my mind, my heart and my behavior → based on my target language model, my native language, my attitudes and motivation, my goals & requirements, my learning approach, and the effort I invest  And I do this in communicative, social interaction with others In this social constructivist sense, the English I develop is my own – “My English” – It is inevitably different from the TL model toward which it is oriented. – Not an option, rather part of the human condition – Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 6
  • 7. Creating “My English” is about . . . . . . creating my communicative-linguistic knowledge & skills  lexical and grammatical means of expression  how these can be used to fulfil language & communication- related requirements of performance regarding what is possible, appropriate, feasible, and probable (Hymes 1972) . . . creating my requirements of performance  a little child in first language acquisition  an immigrant in second language acquisition  a ELT learner in lingua franca situations . . . creating my individual and social identity orientation  Who do I want to be? → e.g. am I comfortable with myself?  What/who is my role model? → e.g. some kind of NSE  By whom do I want to be accepted? → desire for participation Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 7
  • 8. “My English” Implications for communicative competence  More than getting linguistic means of expression right in terms of possibility, appropriateness, feasibility, and probability  More than being able to use linguistic means of expression for achieving communicative needs and purposes  Expressing oneself in keeping with one’s individual and social identity: Expressing One’s Self → Perceived success → Hearer satisfaction → Speaker satisfaction Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 8
  • 9. “My English” Implications for ELF English as a lingua franca – the variety bias  Typical definitions of ELF seem to suggest that it is a “thing”  The power of concepts: “the way we think and talk about language influences the way we think & talk about . . . “  The “thingness” of ELF is deeply rooted in the intuitive perception and understanding of English teachers: teaching ELF is seen as teaching a certain variety of English ELF is not a “thing” – a thought experiment  Imagine a group of people in an international ELF context  What language do they use? What kind of English?  I can only speak “My English” > NS, SL or learner English ELF is about using “My English” under LF conditions  Accommodation strategies  Meaning negotiation strategies Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 9
  • 10. My own Standard English Imagine my aim was Mid-Atlantic Standard English (MASE) → My own simplified, sketchy, uncertain, even “wrong” internal representation  cognitive & emotional creative construction process  based on the language of the people I (like to) talk to  possibly influenced by linguistic descriptions (which are constructions themselves) What shapes my learning of MASE?  My own cognitive-emotional construction and representation  Linguistic descriptions and teaching models of MASE only influence me through the constructive process of mediation and adaptation Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 10
  • 11. Native speaker / Standard English as a target model for learning Strong version of a Learners are required to comply NSE orientation with the NSE (teaching) norms – the closer they get, the better Understanding language learning as a behaviorist copying process lurks in the background Learners take NSE as a model for Weak version of a orientation – they create their NSE orientation own version of it Understanding language learning as a constructivist process of cognitive and emotional creation Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 11
  • 12. ELT research and practice Theoretical beliefs & pedagogic orientations 1. An exonormative NSE orientation appears to be a given [> BE or GA in German secondary schools] 2. The (strong!) exonormative NSE orientation is generally accepted by both teachers and learners 3. Any deviation from the NSE model is at best tolerated; it is “never” experienced as something positive 4. Even in communicative approaches, learning is oriented toward a NSE model 5. A new turn is brought about by CLIL: content and language integrated learning Endonormative processes (“My English”) are not valued Because of the (strong) exonormative perspective, learners tend to stay (partially) alienated from their own creativity resulting in frustration, anxiety and even fear Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 12
  • 13. ELF research and practice Theoretical beliefs & pedagogic orientations 1. ELF development is seen as a creative endonormative process 2. Deviations from NSE are accepted if they are communicatively successful > focus on comprehensibility 3. The endonormative nature of ELF development is regarded as incompatible with an exonormative NSE orientation 4. Emphasis is on spoken ELF communication 5. A new turn (Seidlhofer 2011): teaching ELF is about the process of developing the kind of English users/learners are able to make authentic for themselves – including NSE (!) Need to go beyond communicative acceptability > speaker satisfaction (Albl-Mikasa 2009) Need for more attention to written ELF communication (Horner 2011) Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 13
  • 14. A constructivist resolution of the ELT/ELF divide The divide between ELT and ELF  ELF emphasizes endonormativity against exonormativity  Because of ELT’s exonormative bias, ELF-based pedagogic suggestions are met with suspicion in ELT: “Do you want me to teach incorrect English” (German teacher and teacher educator) The need for a reconciliation  Challenges arising from ELF-specific sociolinguistic realities  Inconsistent educational regulations for schools in Germany What should be done?  ELF: extension of the endonormative view to include a “weak” NSE orientation  ELT: adoption of an endonormative conceptualization of language learning & teaching (“My English”) along with an acceptance of a constructivist, “weak” NSE orientation Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 14
  • 15. ELF in the foreign language classroom Focus on raising awareness for LF manifestations of English  to increase tolerance for others and for oneself Focus on developing ELF-specific comprehension skills  to get accustomed to NNS accents and “messy” performance Focus on developing ELF-specific production skills  to improve pragmatic fluency and strategic skills for accommodation and collaborative negotiation of meaning in intercultural ELF situations Exposure to a wide variety of ELF speakers Focus on form within communicative tasks (with a weak NSE orientation) Interaction in ELF communication Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 15
  • 16. ELF in the foreign language classroom, cont’d Focus on developing the learner’s sense of ownership (“agency”)  to ensure speaker satisfaction and self-confidence What are the conditions that make this possible?  Imagine an “inhibited” learner in school . . .  Liberation though communicative participation in an authentic speech fellowship or community of practice How can “liberating” conditions be successfully implemented through educational approaches & scenarios?  CLIL - Practice Enterprise - Creative Writing  “Pushed output processing” (Swain 2006) - with increased self- satisfaction as a target (instead of better compliance with an external norm)  Authentic & autonomous web-based communication & collaboration  All with the aim to explore and extend one’s own creativity (→ Vygotsky’s zone of proximal development) Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 16
  • 17. The potential of e-learning An e-learning platform like Moodle,  enhanced with web2 tools (e.g. forum chat, Skype, wiki, blog),  and combined with online CLIL resources provides a great potential for autonomous, authentic and collaborative language learning:  Flexible practice activities (reading, writing, listening, speaking) with texts, images, sound and video  Real (online) communication & interaction  for content and language integrated learning  with new possibilities for “incidental” language learning Blended Language Learning to enhance face-to-face classroom activities (→ Kohn 2009, 2012) Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 17
  • 18. Examples from our European projects  BACKBONE: Pedagogic Corpora for Content and Language Integrated Learning http://projects.ael.uni-tuebingen.de/backbone/moodle http://purl.org/backbone/searchtool  PELLIC: Practice Enterprise for Language Learning and Intercultural Communication http://projects.ael.uni-tuebingen.de/pellic  icEurope: Intercultural Foreign Language Communication and Learning http://projects.ael.uni-tuebingen.de/iceurope/moodle  TELF: Tübingen English as a Lingua Franca Corpus http://projects.ael.uni-tuebingen.de/telf Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 18
  • 19. Closing remark Let us embrace the non-native speakers’ “own” English – guided by their “own” NSE orientation – pushed by their communicative needs and identification purposes – fuelled by their creativity! According to the constructivist insight, a learner’s "own mark" is more than being allowed to drop the copula or 3rd person 's' – it is rather about being allowed and encouraged to be oneself. Excellence in TESOL takes a giant step forward when learners are given the space for developing their own English – for being themselves – in keeping with their individual and social identities Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 19
  • 20. Final quotes Keith Gilyard 2011: “ . . the idea that students were writers and not merely people learning to write, that they already had meaningful things to express, and that those gestures toward meaning had to take priority over the rigid, narrow, formal exercises laid out in many writing classrooms” (p.28). “. . . that NNS of English are speakers of English and not merely people learning English” Jane L.H.: “Taking ownership is really about identity, creativity, and the energy we use to express these in words: using/constructing language to communicate in a way that no other can exactly duplicate because of the user’s inherent uniqueness. [. . .] I see my own perception of my native language and its ecology change as I watch my students take ownership: learning its structures, experimenting with vocabulary and voice, and imprinting all with their own identity. I don’t think it gets any better.” (TESOL online discussion, Feb 16th, 2012 Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 20
  • 21. References Albl-Mikasa, M. (2009). Who’s afraid of ELF: “failed” natives or non-native speakers struggling to express themselves? In Albl-Mikasa, M., Braun, S. & Kalina, S. (eds.). Dimensionen der Zweitsprachenforschung – Dimensions of Second Language Research. Festschrift für Kurt Kohn. Narr Verlag, 109-129. Gilyard, K. (2011). True to the Language Game. African American Discourse, Cultural Politics, and Pedagogy. Routledge. Graddol, D. (1997/2000). The Future of English. A Guide to forecasting the popularity of the English language in the 21st century. The British Council. Horner, B.(2011). Writing English as a lingua franca. In Archibald, A. et al. (eds.). Latest Trends in ELF Research. Cambridge Scholars, 299-311. Hymes, D.H. (1972). On communicative competence. In Pride, J.B. & Holmes, J. (eds.). Sociolinguistis: Selected Readings. Penguin, 269-293. Kachru, B. (1985). Standards, codification and sociolinguistic realism: The English in the outer circle. In Quirk, R. & Widdowson, H.G. (eds.). English in the World: Teaching and Learning the Language and Literatures. CUP, 11-30. Kohn, K. (2009). Computer assisted language Learning. In Knapp, K. & Seidlhofer, B. (eds.). Foreign Language Communication and Learning. Handbooks of Applied Linguistics 6. Mouton-de Gruyter, 573–603. Kohn, Kurt (2011). English as a lingua franca and the Standard English misunderstanding. In De Houwer, A. & Wilton, A. (eds.). English in Europe Today. Sociocultural and Educational Perspectives. Benjamins, 72-94. Kohn, K. (2012). The BACKBONE project: pedagogic corpora for content and language integrated learning. Objectives, methodological approach and outcomes. Eurocall Review (to appear). Labov, W. (1970). The Study of Non-standard English. National Council of Teachers of English. Seidlhofer , B. (2011). Understanding English as a Lingua Franca. OUP. Swain, M. (2006). Languaging, agency and collaboration in advanced second language proficiency. In Byrnes, H. (ed.). Advanced Language Learning: The Contributions of Halliday and Vygotsky. Continuum, 95- 108. Widdowson, H. (2003). Defining Issues in English Language Teaching. OUP. Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Learning as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 21
  • 22. Thank you Kurt Kohn – ”My English: Second Language Acquisition as Individual & Social Construction” – TESOL, 28-31 March 2012 22