SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 22
THE SOCIAL CANDIDACY
Poll results, Facebook, and the 2012 Presidential campaign




                 Ian Lurie, CEO, Portent
                    www.portent.com
                       @portentint
                    ian@portent.com
Overview
With the election over, it’s very clear: Candidates, pollsters and
the media must factor in social media.

Political candidates have brands, just like companies do. They’re
influenced by many of the same market forces, and social media
is one of those forces.

And pollsters can make their models more accurate, sooner, if
they factor in social media.

The team at Portent put together this evaluation of the Romney
and Obama presidential campaigns based on Facebook data
collected since April 2012.
Our analysis
Two months ago, we analyzed Facebook and Twitter data. We
reached two conclusions:

1.    The Obama campaign was overly cautious, behaving like a classic
      big brand, and therefore letting the Romney campaign stay
      closer than they otherwise might.

2.  The Romney campaign suffered from a ‘universe problem’. While
    he had a fiercely dedicated audience, he was unable to effectively
    expand it.



You can read the full analysis in our blog post and slide deck:

portent.com/blog/internet-marketing/social-media-election2012.htm
Our hypothesis
Based on those conclusions, we hypothesized that President
Obama would:

1.    Win the electoral vote by a large margin.

2.  Win the popular vote by a small but measurable one.

3.  Pollsters missed a huge pro-Obama audience who no longer
    have land lines and don’t reply to calls.
Conclusion
Two key election players – pollsters and the GOP – suffer from a
universe problem.

The pollsters need to expand their analysis to include the social
media universe. If they don’t, they’ll be excluding a key part of
the electorate. Doing so will give them more accurate data.

The GOP must find a way to appeal to the social media
mainstream. This will give them the ability to access the
audience that cost them this election.

And, the Democratic Party should learn from this election:
Study the types of media and messages that best performed,
and refine their demographic targeting.
The outcome
President Obama appears to have won the electoral college
332 to 206.

He won the popular vote by 2.2-2.4%.

Compare that to the 2004 Bush/Kerry election:

        Popular Vote Margin             Electoral Vote Margin
        2.40%                     140
                                  120
                                  100
                                  80
                                  60
                      2.20%
                                  40
                                  20
                                   0
                                        Bush/Kerry   Obama/Romney
      Bush/Kerry   Obama/Romney
The outcome
Historically, Gallup has correctly predicted presidential election
outcomes 9 of the last 10 elections. Their only miss was Carter’s
defeat of Ford in 1976.*

This year, they missed their prediction by 3-4%. Not much. But
it’s a big 3-4%.

CNN’s “Poll of Polls” had the national race too close to call
November 5th. They showed Obama ahead less than the margin
of error in Ohio.

Other ‘tossup’ states included Virginia, Colorado, Florida and
Nevada.


*They predicted a popular vote tie in 2004.
The outcome
Polling was unable to predict the outcome. We wouldn’t go so
far as to say they were wrong. But their data had the outcome
in doubt right up to election day.

Maybe it was just close. Maybe a lot of people made up their
minds at the last minute. Maybe the Obama campaign had a late
surge.

Or, maybe social media, combined with poll data, provided a
clear preview the entire time.
The outcome
Candidates and polling companies should supplement their
polling data:

1.    With social media demographic data in crucial swing states,
      where campaigns might be investing heavily in their
      Facebook and other campaigns.

2.  On a national level, to look at trends and clarify projections.
Swing states
Facebook data may help predict the outcome in crucial swing
states.

We looked at 4 swing states where the Huffington Post’s Poll of
Polls showed the outcome as a tossup: Florida, Colorado,
Virginia and North Carolina.
Swing states
  According to data gathered by Walker Sands PR, Facebook
  audience size by candidate correctly predicted the outcome in 3
  of 4 states:

                      Facebook audience size by candidate and state
         1,800,000

         1,600,000
                                      ✔*
         1,400,000

          1,200,000

         1,000,000
                                                                               Obama
           800,000
                                                                     ✔         Romney

           600,000       ✔
          400,000

           200,000

                 0
                       Colorado      Florida     North Carolina   Virginia


*Florida hasn’t been called, but Obama leads by 50,000 votes with 100% of precincts reporting.
Swing states
  Looking across all swing states, Facebook audience size was
  correct 80% of the time:

                             ✔*
           1,800,000

           1,600,000

           1,400,000

           1,200,000

           1,000,000                                     ✔
            800,000
                                                                       ✔
            600,000    ✔                                                      ✔
            400,000
                                    ✔
            200,000                        ✔
                  0




*Florida hasn’t been called, but Obama leads by 50,000 votes with 100% of precincts reporting.
Swing states
In non-swing states, Facebook did a far poorer job of predicting
the outcome: Audience size only correctly predicted the
outcome 27 of 41 times.

Why the difference?

Effort.

The campaigns likely focused their online efforts on swing
states, just as they did offline. In those states, their efforts
influenced audience sizes. In non-swing states, they didn’t
influence audience size, and lower participation meant a less
accurate predictor.
Social media trends
We updated our Facebook growth rate data to reflect the last
month of the election.

Each debate had a short-lived effect. The trend remained the
same: After the Democractic National Convention, President
Obama maintained or increased his fan growth rate; After the
Republican convention, Governor Romney saw an inconsistent
growth rate. In fact, he lost momentum after the convention.
Social media trends

         President Obama's Facebook growth rate: Rolling avg
0.250%



0.200%



0.150%



0.100%

                      Pre-convention growth rate

0.050%



0.000%
Social media trends
              Governor Romney's Facebook growth rate: Rolling avg
4.000%

3.500%

3.000%

2.500%

2.000%   Average pre-convention growth rate

1.500%

1.000%

0.500%

0.000%
Social media trends
President Obama started with a massive advantage on
Facebook: He had over 25 million fans in April. By November 1,
he had over 31 million. His campaign showed all the attributes of
a big brand: Huge followership, and an over-abundance of
caution. This came through in his first debate performance. He
needed to go on the attack and take risks to secure the
campaign, and did so.

Governor Romney started with 1.6 million fans in April. He did a
fantastic job growing his Facebook base thru August, reaching
almost 8 million. But after that, his growth rate plateaued and
began to fall. The Romney campaign was a classic small brand
with a limited universe. They were able to grow within that
universe, but couldn’t get beyond it.
Demographic gap
Facebook reflects the thoughts of a demographic that polling
companies can’t access. Facebook users belong to the
demographic group most likely to have a cell phone as their
only telephone.

Pollsters couldn’t contact that group, so they missed
President Obama’s winning margin. (From Democracy Corps).

Facebook taps that audience. And freely-available, anonymous
data that Facebook offers via their API provides a fantastic way
to observe and measure their voting intent.
Conclusion: Polling
If polling companies want to remain accurate, they need to add
social media data to their models. At a minimum, they should
use:

1.    Facebook fan growth rate;

2.  Facebook comment sentiment;

3.  Facebook audience response – comments per post, likes per
    post;

4.  Twitter audience growth rate;

5.  Facebook and Twitter audience quality.
Conclusion: Campaigns
Campaigns must have a strong ‘ground game’ in social media.
Like pollsters, they can access an audience that’s mobile and
hard to reach. This audience is only going to grow in the next
four years.

To succeed, they will need to:

1.    Monitor social sentiment.

2.  Post, measure and refine their content strategy continuously.

3.  Invest heavily in video for social distribution.

4.  Learn to use demographic targeting, if they aren’t already.

5.  Use tools like re-targeting to segment between supporters
    and potential supporters.
Conclusion: The social candidacy
We’ve entered the time of the social candidacy. Internet
marketing and social media provide access to a mobile, young,
diverse audience that can swing elections.

Campaigns and polling organizations take note: The 2012
election was a sea change in campaign media channels. Adjust
strategies accordingly.
Q u e s t i o n s?



       ian@portent.com
          @portentint
http://plus.google.com/+IanLurie


       www.portent.com

More Related Content

What's hot

How the Big Brands do Facebook Marketing
How the Big Brands do Facebook MarketingHow the Big Brands do Facebook Marketing
How the Big Brands do Facebook MarketingWebtrends
 
SOUTHEAST ASIA SOCIAL AND POLITICAL IDENTITY WITH FACEBOOK
SOUTHEAST ASIA SOCIAL AND POLITICAL IDENTITY WITH FACEBOOKSOUTHEAST ASIA SOCIAL AND POLITICAL IDENTITY WITH FACEBOOK
SOUTHEAST ASIA SOCIAL AND POLITICAL IDENTITY WITH FACEBOOKMYO AUNG Myanmar
 
Com score the power of like
Com score   the power of likeCom score   the power of like
Com score the power of likeSumit Roy
 
Government and Social Media Military Facebook Use Study
Government and Social Media Military Facebook Use StudyGovernment and Social Media Military Facebook Use Study
Government and Social Media Military Facebook Use StudyNativa
 
The End Of Email
The End Of EmailThe End Of Email
The End Of EmailSumit Roy
 
Social Networking InView (March 2011)
Social Networking InView (March 2011)Social Networking InView (March 2011)
Social Networking InView (March 2011)M/A/R/C Research
 

What's hot (9)

1-Face-PPT
1-Face-PPT1-Face-PPT
1-Face-PPT
 
Analysis_Vretas
Analysis_VretasAnalysis_Vretas
Analysis_Vretas
 
Report
ReportReport
Report
 
How the Big Brands do Facebook Marketing
How the Big Brands do Facebook MarketingHow the Big Brands do Facebook Marketing
How the Big Brands do Facebook Marketing
 
SOUTHEAST ASIA SOCIAL AND POLITICAL IDENTITY WITH FACEBOOK
SOUTHEAST ASIA SOCIAL AND POLITICAL IDENTITY WITH FACEBOOKSOUTHEAST ASIA SOCIAL AND POLITICAL IDENTITY WITH FACEBOOK
SOUTHEAST ASIA SOCIAL AND POLITICAL IDENTITY WITH FACEBOOK
 
Com score the power of like
Com score   the power of likeCom score   the power of like
Com score the power of like
 
Government and Social Media Military Facebook Use Study
Government and Social Media Military Facebook Use StudyGovernment and Social Media Military Facebook Use Study
Government and Social Media Military Facebook Use Study
 
The End Of Email
The End Of EmailThe End Of Email
The End Of Email
 
Social Networking InView (March 2011)
Social Networking InView (March 2011)Social Networking InView (March 2011)
Social Networking InView (March 2011)
 

Viewers also liked

Cut the Crap: Why Marketing Hasn't Changed And You Should Stop Chasing Shiny ...
Cut the Crap: Why Marketing Hasn't Changed And You Should Stop Chasing Shiny ...Cut the Crap: Why Marketing Hasn't Changed And You Should Stop Chasing Shiny ...
Cut the Crap: Why Marketing Hasn't Changed And You Should Stop Chasing Shiny ...Ian Lurie
 
Lets enjoy soga 170222_slideshare
Lets enjoy soga 170222_slideshareLets enjoy soga 170222_slideshare
Lets enjoy soga 170222_slideshareYoshi Kawano
 
Research and Reviews: A Journal of Pharmaceutical Science vol 7 issue 3
Research and Reviews: A Journal of Pharmaceutical Science vol 7 issue 3Research and Reviews: A Journal of Pharmaceutical Science vol 7 issue 3
Research and Reviews: A Journal of Pharmaceutical Science vol 7 issue 3STM Journals
 
Si los hombres
Si los hombresSi los hombres
Si los hombresxandecarud
 
Research & Reviews: Journal of Physics vol 7 issue 3
Research & Reviews: Journal of Physics vol 7 issue 3Research & Reviews: Journal of Physics vol 7 issue 3
Research & Reviews: Journal of Physics vol 7 issue 3STM Journals
 
Journal of Modern Chemistry & Chemical Technology vol 7 issue 3
Journal of Modern Chemistry & Chemical Technology vol 7 issue 3Journal of Modern Chemistry & Chemical Technology vol 7 issue 3
Journal of Modern Chemistry & Chemical Technology vol 7 issue 3STM Journals
 
Manhattan Square: TRIBECA
Manhattan Square: TRIBECAManhattan Square: TRIBECA
Manhattan Square: TRIBECAMichell Mendes
 
La mujer ideal
La mujer idealLa mujer ideal
La mujer idealxandecarud
 
Network marketing seminar report
Network marketing seminar reportNetwork marketing seminar report
Network marketing seminar reportHavish P D
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Gosol i saldes
Gosol i saldesGosol i saldes
Gosol i saldes
 
TV lecture: Form
TV lecture: FormTV lecture: Form
TV lecture: Form
 
Wikis (1)
Wikis (1)Wikis (1)
Wikis (1)
 
Asis
AsisAsis
Asis
 
3 Chistes
3 Chistes3 Chistes
3 Chistes
 
Cut the Crap: Why Marketing Hasn't Changed And You Should Stop Chasing Shiny ...
Cut the Crap: Why Marketing Hasn't Changed And You Should Stop Chasing Shiny ...Cut the Crap: Why Marketing Hasn't Changed And You Should Stop Chasing Shiny ...
Cut the Crap: Why Marketing Hasn't Changed And You Should Stop Chasing Shiny ...
 
Jasa Konstruksi & MP3EI
Jasa Konstruksi & MP3EIJasa Konstruksi & MP3EI
Jasa Konstruksi & MP3EI
 
Lets enjoy soga 170222_slideshare
Lets enjoy soga 170222_slideshareLets enjoy soga 170222_slideshare
Lets enjoy soga 170222_slideshare
 
Siujk 2013 (1)
Siujk 2013 (1)Siujk 2013 (1)
Siujk 2013 (1)
 
Maestro
MaestroMaestro
Maestro
 
Research and Reviews: A Journal of Pharmaceutical Science vol 7 issue 3
Research and Reviews: A Journal of Pharmaceutical Science vol 7 issue 3Research and Reviews: A Journal of Pharmaceutical Science vol 7 issue 3
Research and Reviews: A Journal of Pharmaceutical Science vol 7 issue 3
 
Si los hombres
Si los hombresSi los hombres
Si los hombres
 
Research & Reviews: Journal of Physics vol 7 issue 3
Research & Reviews: Journal of Physics vol 7 issue 3Research & Reviews: Journal of Physics vol 7 issue 3
Research & Reviews: Journal of Physics vol 7 issue 3
 
Journal of Modern Chemistry & Chemical Technology vol 7 issue 3
Journal of Modern Chemistry & Chemical Technology vol 7 issue 3Journal of Modern Chemistry & Chemical Technology vol 7 issue 3
Journal of Modern Chemistry & Chemical Technology vol 7 issue 3
 
Manhattan Square: TRIBECA
Manhattan Square: TRIBECAManhattan Square: TRIBECA
Manhattan Square: TRIBECA
 
La mujer ideal
La mujer idealLa mujer ideal
La mujer ideal
 
Network marketing seminar report
Network marketing seminar reportNetwork marketing seminar report
Network marketing seminar report
 

Similar to The social candidacy

The Universe Problem: Poll results, Facebook and the 2012 Presidential campaign
The Universe Problem: Poll results, Facebook and the 2012 Presidential campaignThe Universe Problem: Poll results, Facebook and the 2012 Presidential campaign
The Universe Problem: Poll results, Facebook and the 2012 Presidential campaignIan Lurie
 
Obama Campaign Strategy
Obama Campaign StrategyObama Campaign Strategy
Obama Campaign Strategysachin2121977
 
Obama Case by SocialMedia8
Obama Case by SocialMedia8Obama Case by SocialMedia8
Obama Case by SocialMedia8Leon Wittenberg
 
President Barack Obama Smart Branding, & Social Media
President Barack Obama Smart Branding, & Social MediaPresident Barack Obama Smart Branding, & Social Media
President Barack Obama Smart Branding, & Social Mediamhart007
 
Case Study: The Barack Obama Strategy
Case Study: The Barack Obama StrategyCase Study: The Barack Obama Strategy
Case Study: The Barack Obama StrategySocialMedia8
 
Case study the barack obama strategy
Case study  the barack obama strategyCase study  the barack obama strategy
Case study the barack obama strategyViệt Long Plaza
 
Trump vs Clinton - Polling Opinions: How the polls were wrong and how to fix...
Trump vs Clinton - Polling Opinions:  How the polls were wrong and how to fix...Trump vs Clinton - Polling Opinions:  How the polls were wrong and how to fix...
Trump vs Clinton - Polling Opinions: How the polls were wrong and how to fix...chrisbrock54
 
Digital Media - US Elections
Digital Media - US ElectionsDigital Media - US Elections
Digital Media - US Electionssuperank
 
How Elected Offficials are using social media
How Elected Offficials are using social mediaHow Elected Offficials are using social media
How Elected Offficials are using social mediaSavannah Whaley
 
Elections and new media
Elections and new mediaElections and new media
Elections and new mediaReza Fallah
 
Restaurants Owners Eating Up Social Media 2011
Restaurants Owners Eating Up Social Media 2011Restaurants Owners Eating Up Social Media 2011
Restaurants Owners Eating Up Social Media 2011hillarybressler
 
Engaging Hispanics
Engaging Hispanics Engaging Hispanics
Engaging Hispanics Sensis
 
Votesocialmedia
VotesocialmediaVotesocialmedia
Votesocialmediakesisco
 
Votesocialmedia
VotesocialmediaVotesocialmedia
Votesocialmediakesisco
 
Votesocialmedia
VotesocialmediaVotesocialmedia
Votesocialmediakesisco
 
Current State of Social Media by Albion Organizations
Current State of Social Media by Albion OrganizationsCurrent State of Social Media by Albion Organizations
Current State of Social Media by Albion OrganizationsEmily Verbeke
 

Similar to The social candidacy (20)

The Universe Problem: Poll results, Facebook and the 2012 Presidential campaign
The Universe Problem: Poll results, Facebook and the 2012 Presidential campaignThe Universe Problem: Poll results, Facebook and the 2012 Presidential campaign
The Universe Problem: Poll results, Facebook and the 2012 Presidential campaign
 
Campaigning in the Digital Age
Campaigning in the Digital AgeCampaigning in the Digital Age
Campaigning in the Digital Age
 
Campaigning in the Digital Age
Campaigning in the Digital AgeCampaigning in the Digital Age
Campaigning in the Digital Age
 
Obama Campaign Strategy
Obama Campaign StrategyObama Campaign Strategy
Obama Campaign Strategy
 
Obama Case by SocialMedia8
Obama Case by SocialMedia8Obama Case by SocialMedia8
Obama Case by SocialMedia8
 
President Barack Obama Smart Branding, & Social Media
President Barack Obama Smart Branding, & Social MediaPresident Barack Obama Smart Branding, & Social Media
President Barack Obama Smart Branding, & Social Media
 
Case Study: The Barack Obama Strategy
Case Study: The Barack Obama StrategyCase Study: The Barack Obama Strategy
Case Study: The Barack Obama Strategy
 
The in Crowd
The in CrowdThe in Crowd
The in Crowd
 
Case study the barack obama strategy
Case study  the barack obama strategyCase study  the barack obama strategy
Case study the barack obama strategy
 
Trump vs Clinton - Polling Opinions: How the polls were wrong and how to fix...
Trump vs Clinton - Polling Opinions:  How the polls were wrong and how to fix...Trump vs Clinton - Polling Opinions:  How the polls were wrong and how to fix...
Trump vs Clinton - Polling Opinions: How the polls were wrong and how to fix...
 
Digital Media - US Elections
Digital Media - US ElectionsDigital Media - US Elections
Digital Media - US Elections
 
How Elected Offficials are using social media
How Elected Offficials are using social mediaHow Elected Offficials are using social media
How Elected Offficials are using social media
 
Elections and new media
Elections and new mediaElections and new media
Elections and new media
 
Restaurants Owners Eating Up Social Media 2011
Restaurants Owners Eating Up Social Media 2011Restaurants Owners Eating Up Social Media 2011
Restaurants Owners Eating Up Social Media 2011
 
Engaging Hispanics
Engaging Hispanics Engaging Hispanics
Engaging Hispanics
 
Votesocialmedia
VotesocialmediaVotesocialmedia
Votesocialmedia
 
Votesocialmedia
VotesocialmediaVotesocialmedia
Votesocialmedia
 
Votesocialmedia
VotesocialmediaVotesocialmedia
Votesocialmedia
 
Votesocialmedia
 Votesocialmedia Votesocialmedia
Votesocialmedia
 
Current State of Social Media by Albion Organizations
Current State of Social Media by Albion OrganizationsCurrent State of Social Media by Albion Organizations
Current State of Social Media by Albion Organizations
 

More from Ian Lurie

Data Visualization For Marketers
Data Visualization For MarketersData Visualization For Marketers
Data Visualization For MarketersIan Lurie
 
Starting, Running, And Selling An Agency: Life Among The Monsters
Starting, Running, And Selling An Agency: Life Among The MonstersStarting, Running, And Selling An Agency: Life Among The Monsters
Starting, Running, And Selling An Agency: Life Among The MonstersIan Lurie
 
Core Web Vitals and SEO: Don't Panic. Improve.
Core Web Vitals and SEO: Don't Panic. Improve.Core Web Vitals and SEO: Don't Panic. Improve.
Core Web Vitals and SEO: Don't Panic. Improve.Ian Lurie
 
Big Content, Small Teams: Content Creation For The Real World
Big Content, Small Teams: Content Creation For The Real WorldBig Content, Small Teams: Content Creation For The Real World
Big Content, Small Teams: Content Creation For The Real WorldIan Lurie
 
Teaching SEO To Internal Teams: Don't Be Ridiculous
Teaching SEO To Internal Teams: Don't Be RidiculousTeaching SEO To Internal Teams: Don't Be Ridiculous
Teaching SEO To Internal Teams: Don't Be RidiculousIan Lurie
 
E-A-T: Myths, Truths, And Implications for SEO
E-A-T: Myths, Truths, And Implications for SEOE-A-T: Myths, Truths, And Implications for SEO
E-A-T: Myths, Truths, And Implications for SEOIan Lurie
 
SEO Copywriting: The Blank Sheet Of Paper Test
SEO Copywriting: The Blank Sheet Of Paper TestSEO Copywriting: The Blank Sheet Of Paper Test
SEO Copywriting: The Blank Sheet Of Paper TestIan Lurie
 
Your Content Doesn't Matter Without Technology
Your Content Doesn't Matter Without TechnologyYour Content Doesn't Matter Without Technology
Your Content Doesn't Matter Without TechnologyIan Lurie
 
The Dungeons & Dragons Guide to Marketing
The Dungeons & Dragons Guide to MarketingThe Dungeons & Dragons Guide to Marketing
The Dungeons & Dragons Guide to MarketingIan Lurie
 
Advanced SEO: No More Bullshit
Advanced SEO: No More BullshitAdvanced SEO: No More Bullshit
Advanced SEO: No More BullshitIan Lurie
 
Bullshit, Own It: A Temperamental SEO's Guide To Getting Shit Done
Bullshit, Own It: A Temperamental SEO's Guide To Getting Shit DoneBullshit, Own It: A Temperamental SEO's Guide To Getting Shit Done
Bullshit, Own It: A Temperamental SEO's Guide To Getting Shit DoneIan Lurie
 
Advanced SEO: Logs, Load, and Language
Advanced SEO: Logs, Load, and LanguageAdvanced SEO: Logs, Load, and Language
Advanced SEO: Logs, Load, and LanguageIan Lurie
 
A Beginner's Guide to PPC: Fast Times, Easy Wins, And Burned Money
A Beginner's Guide to PPC: Fast Times, Easy Wins, And Burned MoneyA Beginner's Guide to PPC: Fast Times, Easy Wins, And Burned Money
A Beginner's Guide to PPC: Fast Times, Easy Wins, And Burned MoneyIan Lurie
 
5 Lessons For Entrepreneurs: 2018 Edition
5 Lessons For Entrepreneurs: 2018 Edition5 Lessons For Entrepreneurs: 2018 Edition
5 Lessons For Entrepreneurs: 2018 EditionIan Lurie
 
Advanced Content Workflow Using GitHub and Markdown
Advanced Content Workflow Using GitHub and MarkdownAdvanced Content Workflow Using GitHub and Markdown
Advanced Content Workflow Using GitHub and MarkdownIan Lurie
 
Tip Per Minute: A Hyper-Active SEO Brain Dump
Tip Per Minute: A Hyper-Active SEO Brain DumpTip Per Minute: A Hyper-Active SEO Brain Dump
Tip Per Minute: A Hyper-Active SEO Brain DumpIan Lurie
 
Intelligent CX: 25 Years of Marketing, And Where to Go Next
Intelligent CX: 25 Years of Marketing, And Where to Go NextIntelligent CX: 25 Years of Marketing, And Where to Go Next
Intelligent CX: 25 Years of Marketing, And Where to Go NextIan Lurie
 
Burying Hate Sites in the SERPs
Burying Hate Sites in the SERPsBurying Hate Sites in the SERPs
Burying Hate Sites in the SERPsIan Lurie
 
Marketing Worldbuilding: Collaborative Storytelling for Digital
Marketing Worldbuilding: Collaborative Storytelling for DigitalMarketing Worldbuilding: Collaborative Storytelling for Digital
Marketing Worldbuilding: Collaborative Storytelling for DigitalIan Lurie
 
Lean Content: Marketing Profs B2B
Lean Content: Marketing Profs B2BLean Content: Marketing Profs B2B
Lean Content: Marketing Profs B2BIan Lurie
 

More from Ian Lurie (20)

Data Visualization For Marketers
Data Visualization For MarketersData Visualization For Marketers
Data Visualization For Marketers
 
Starting, Running, And Selling An Agency: Life Among The Monsters
Starting, Running, And Selling An Agency: Life Among The MonstersStarting, Running, And Selling An Agency: Life Among The Monsters
Starting, Running, And Selling An Agency: Life Among The Monsters
 
Core Web Vitals and SEO: Don't Panic. Improve.
Core Web Vitals and SEO: Don't Panic. Improve.Core Web Vitals and SEO: Don't Panic. Improve.
Core Web Vitals and SEO: Don't Panic. Improve.
 
Big Content, Small Teams: Content Creation For The Real World
Big Content, Small Teams: Content Creation For The Real WorldBig Content, Small Teams: Content Creation For The Real World
Big Content, Small Teams: Content Creation For The Real World
 
Teaching SEO To Internal Teams: Don't Be Ridiculous
Teaching SEO To Internal Teams: Don't Be RidiculousTeaching SEO To Internal Teams: Don't Be Ridiculous
Teaching SEO To Internal Teams: Don't Be Ridiculous
 
E-A-T: Myths, Truths, And Implications for SEO
E-A-T: Myths, Truths, And Implications for SEOE-A-T: Myths, Truths, And Implications for SEO
E-A-T: Myths, Truths, And Implications for SEO
 
SEO Copywriting: The Blank Sheet Of Paper Test
SEO Copywriting: The Blank Sheet Of Paper TestSEO Copywriting: The Blank Sheet Of Paper Test
SEO Copywriting: The Blank Sheet Of Paper Test
 
Your Content Doesn't Matter Without Technology
Your Content Doesn't Matter Without TechnologyYour Content Doesn't Matter Without Technology
Your Content Doesn't Matter Without Technology
 
The Dungeons & Dragons Guide to Marketing
The Dungeons & Dragons Guide to MarketingThe Dungeons & Dragons Guide to Marketing
The Dungeons & Dragons Guide to Marketing
 
Advanced SEO: No More Bullshit
Advanced SEO: No More BullshitAdvanced SEO: No More Bullshit
Advanced SEO: No More Bullshit
 
Bullshit, Own It: A Temperamental SEO's Guide To Getting Shit Done
Bullshit, Own It: A Temperamental SEO's Guide To Getting Shit DoneBullshit, Own It: A Temperamental SEO's Guide To Getting Shit Done
Bullshit, Own It: A Temperamental SEO's Guide To Getting Shit Done
 
Advanced SEO: Logs, Load, and Language
Advanced SEO: Logs, Load, and LanguageAdvanced SEO: Logs, Load, and Language
Advanced SEO: Logs, Load, and Language
 
A Beginner's Guide to PPC: Fast Times, Easy Wins, And Burned Money
A Beginner's Guide to PPC: Fast Times, Easy Wins, And Burned MoneyA Beginner's Guide to PPC: Fast Times, Easy Wins, And Burned Money
A Beginner's Guide to PPC: Fast Times, Easy Wins, And Burned Money
 
5 Lessons For Entrepreneurs: 2018 Edition
5 Lessons For Entrepreneurs: 2018 Edition5 Lessons For Entrepreneurs: 2018 Edition
5 Lessons For Entrepreneurs: 2018 Edition
 
Advanced Content Workflow Using GitHub and Markdown
Advanced Content Workflow Using GitHub and MarkdownAdvanced Content Workflow Using GitHub and Markdown
Advanced Content Workflow Using GitHub and Markdown
 
Tip Per Minute: A Hyper-Active SEO Brain Dump
Tip Per Minute: A Hyper-Active SEO Brain DumpTip Per Minute: A Hyper-Active SEO Brain Dump
Tip Per Minute: A Hyper-Active SEO Brain Dump
 
Intelligent CX: 25 Years of Marketing, And Where to Go Next
Intelligent CX: 25 Years of Marketing, And Where to Go NextIntelligent CX: 25 Years of Marketing, And Where to Go Next
Intelligent CX: 25 Years of Marketing, And Where to Go Next
 
Burying Hate Sites in the SERPs
Burying Hate Sites in the SERPsBurying Hate Sites in the SERPs
Burying Hate Sites in the SERPs
 
Marketing Worldbuilding: Collaborative Storytelling for Digital
Marketing Worldbuilding: Collaborative Storytelling for DigitalMarketing Worldbuilding: Collaborative Storytelling for Digital
Marketing Worldbuilding: Collaborative Storytelling for Digital
 
Lean Content: Marketing Profs B2B
Lean Content: Marketing Profs B2BLean Content: Marketing Profs B2B
Lean Content: Marketing Profs B2B
 

Recently uploaded

EED - Profits uncontained. An analysis of container shipping ETS surcharges
EED - Profits uncontained. An analysis of container shipping ETS surchargesEED - Profits uncontained. An analysis of container shipping ETS surcharges
EED - Profits uncontained. An analysis of container shipping ETS surchargesEl Estrecho Digital
 
Right to Privacy Case Studies PDF …………..
Right to Privacy Case Studies PDF …………..Right to Privacy Case Studies PDF …………..
Right to Privacy Case Studies PDF …………..mathiasanna557
 
Anantkumar Hegde
Anantkumar Hegde  Anantkumar Hegde
Anantkumar Hegde NewsFeed1
 
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe WhitleyAnother Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe WhitleyAbdul-Hakim Shabazz
 
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...virgfern3011
 
One India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
One India vs United India by Dream TamilnaduOne India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
One India vs United India by Dream TamilnaduDreamTamilnadu
 
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicioPor estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicioAlexisTorres963861
 
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...University of Canberra
 

Recently uploaded (8)

EED - Profits uncontained. An analysis of container shipping ETS surcharges
EED - Profits uncontained. An analysis of container shipping ETS surchargesEED - Profits uncontained. An analysis of container shipping ETS surcharges
EED - Profits uncontained. An analysis of container shipping ETS surcharges
 
Right to Privacy Case Studies PDF …………..
Right to Privacy Case Studies PDF …………..Right to Privacy Case Studies PDF …………..
Right to Privacy Case Studies PDF …………..
 
Anantkumar Hegde
Anantkumar Hegde  Anantkumar Hegde
Anantkumar Hegde
 
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe WhitleyAnother Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
 
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
 
One India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
One India vs United India by Dream TamilnaduOne India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
One India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
 
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicioPor estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
 
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
 

The social candidacy

  • 1. THE SOCIAL CANDIDACY Poll results, Facebook, and the 2012 Presidential campaign Ian Lurie, CEO, Portent www.portent.com @portentint ian@portent.com
  • 2. Overview With the election over, it’s very clear: Candidates, pollsters and the media must factor in social media. Political candidates have brands, just like companies do. They’re influenced by many of the same market forces, and social media is one of those forces. And pollsters can make their models more accurate, sooner, if they factor in social media. The team at Portent put together this evaluation of the Romney and Obama presidential campaigns based on Facebook data collected since April 2012.
  • 3. Our analysis Two months ago, we analyzed Facebook and Twitter data. We reached two conclusions: 1.  The Obama campaign was overly cautious, behaving like a classic big brand, and therefore letting the Romney campaign stay closer than they otherwise might. 2.  The Romney campaign suffered from a ‘universe problem’. While he had a fiercely dedicated audience, he was unable to effectively expand it. You can read the full analysis in our blog post and slide deck: portent.com/blog/internet-marketing/social-media-election2012.htm
  • 4. Our hypothesis Based on those conclusions, we hypothesized that President Obama would: 1.  Win the electoral vote by a large margin. 2.  Win the popular vote by a small but measurable one. 3.  Pollsters missed a huge pro-Obama audience who no longer have land lines and don’t reply to calls.
  • 5. Conclusion Two key election players – pollsters and the GOP – suffer from a universe problem. The pollsters need to expand their analysis to include the social media universe. If they don’t, they’ll be excluding a key part of the electorate. Doing so will give them more accurate data. The GOP must find a way to appeal to the social media mainstream. This will give them the ability to access the audience that cost them this election. And, the Democratic Party should learn from this election: Study the types of media and messages that best performed, and refine their demographic targeting.
  • 6. The outcome President Obama appears to have won the electoral college 332 to 206. He won the popular vote by 2.2-2.4%. Compare that to the 2004 Bush/Kerry election: Popular Vote Margin Electoral Vote Margin 2.40% 140 120 100 80 60 2.20% 40 20 0 Bush/Kerry Obama/Romney Bush/Kerry Obama/Romney
  • 7. The outcome Historically, Gallup has correctly predicted presidential election outcomes 9 of the last 10 elections. Their only miss was Carter’s defeat of Ford in 1976.* This year, they missed their prediction by 3-4%. Not much. But it’s a big 3-4%. CNN’s “Poll of Polls” had the national race too close to call November 5th. They showed Obama ahead less than the margin of error in Ohio. Other ‘tossup’ states included Virginia, Colorado, Florida and Nevada. *They predicted a popular vote tie in 2004.
  • 8. The outcome Polling was unable to predict the outcome. We wouldn’t go so far as to say they were wrong. But their data had the outcome in doubt right up to election day. Maybe it was just close. Maybe a lot of people made up their minds at the last minute. Maybe the Obama campaign had a late surge. Or, maybe social media, combined with poll data, provided a clear preview the entire time.
  • 9. The outcome Candidates and polling companies should supplement their polling data: 1.  With social media demographic data in crucial swing states, where campaigns might be investing heavily in their Facebook and other campaigns. 2.  On a national level, to look at trends and clarify projections.
  • 10. Swing states Facebook data may help predict the outcome in crucial swing states. We looked at 4 swing states where the Huffington Post’s Poll of Polls showed the outcome as a tossup: Florida, Colorado, Virginia and North Carolina.
  • 11. Swing states According to data gathered by Walker Sands PR, Facebook audience size by candidate correctly predicted the outcome in 3 of 4 states: Facebook audience size by candidate and state 1,800,000 1,600,000 ✔* 1,400,000 1,200,000 1,000,000 Obama 800,000 ✔ Romney 600,000 ✔ 400,000 200,000 0 Colorado Florida North Carolina Virginia *Florida hasn’t been called, but Obama leads by 50,000 votes with 100% of precincts reporting.
  • 12. Swing states Looking across all swing states, Facebook audience size was correct 80% of the time: ✔* 1,800,000 1,600,000 1,400,000 1,200,000 1,000,000 ✔ 800,000 ✔ 600,000 ✔ ✔ 400,000 ✔ 200,000 ✔ 0 *Florida hasn’t been called, but Obama leads by 50,000 votes with 100% of precincts reporting.
  • 13. Swing states In non-swing states, Facebook did a far poorer job of predicting the outcome: Audience size only correctly predicted the outcome 27 of 41 times. Why the difference? Effort. The campaigns likely focused their online efforts on swing states, just as they did offline. In those states, their efforts influenced audience sizes. In non-swing states, they didn’t influence audience size, and lower participation meant a less accurate predictor.
  • 14. Social media trends We updated our Facebook growth rate data to reflect the last month of the election. Each debate had a short-lived effect. The trend remained the same: After the Democractic National Convention, President Obama maintained or increased his fan growth rate; After the Republican convention, Governor Romney saw an inconsistent growth rate. In fact, he lost momentum after the convention.
  • 15. Social media trends President Obama's Facebook growth rate: Rolling avg 0.250% 0.200% 0.150% 0.100% Pre-convention growth rate 0.050% 0.000%
  • 16. Social media trends Governor Romney's Facebook growth rate: Rolling avg 4.000% 3.500% 3.000% 2.500% 2.000% Average pre-convention growth rate 1.500% 1.000% 0.500% 0.000%
  • 17. Social media trends President Obama started with a massive advantage on Facebook: He had over 25 million fans in April. By November 1, he had over 31 million. His campaign showed all the attributes of a big brand: Huge followership, and an over-abundance of caution. This came through in his first debate performance. He needed to go on the attack and take risks to secure the campaign, and did so. Governor Romney started with 1.6 million fans in April. He did a fantastic job growing his Facebook base thru August, reaching almost 8 million. But after that, his growth rate plateaued and began to fall. The Romney campaign was a classic small brand with a limited universe. They were able to grow within that universe, but couldn’t get beyond it.
  • 18. Demographic gap Facebook reflects the thoughts of a demographic that polling companies can’t access. Facebook users belong to the demographic group most likely to have a cell phone as their only telephone. Pollsters couldn’t contact that group, so they missed President Obama’s winning margin. (From Democracy Corps). Facebook taps that audience. And freely-available, anonymous data that Facebook offers via their API provides a fantastic way to observe and measure their voting intent.
  • 19. Conclusion: Polling If polling companies want to remain accurate, they need to add social media data to their models. At a minimum, they should use: 1.  Facebook fan growth rate; 2.  Facebook comment sentiment; 3.  Facebook audience response – comments per post, likes per post; 4.  Twitter audience growth rate; 5.  Facebook and Twitter audience quality.
  • 20. Conclusion: Campaigns Campaigns must have a strong ‘ground game’ in social media. Like pollsters, they can access an audience that’s mobile and hard to reach. This audience is only going to grow in the next four years. To succeed, they will need to: 1.  Monitor social sentiment. 2.  Post, measure and refine their content strategy continuously. 3.  Invest heavily in video for social distribution. 4.  Learn to use demographic targeting, if they aren’t already. 5.  Use tools like re-targeting to segment between supporters and potential supporters.
  • 21. Conclusion: The social candidacy We’ve entered the time of the social candidacy. Internet marketing and social media provide access to a mobile, young, diverse audience that can swing elections. Campaigns and polling organizations take note: The 2012 election was a sea change in campaign media channels. Adjust strategies accordingly.
  • 22. Q u e s t i o n s? ian@portent.com @portentint http://plus.google.com/+IanLurie www.portent.com