It’s summer—the time of year when an arts manager’s thoughts turn to poolside fun, family vacations, and—of course—planning for A Christmas Carol, The Nutcracker, yuletide concerts, and other holiday blockbuster events.
Not on your calendar yet? Then you are missing a major opportunity.
Holiday productions equal big money for arts organizations. But how can you get the most out of this once-a-year opportunity?
New York City Ballet (NYCB) wanted exactly that—to maximize revenue. The company had been selling out most of its performances of The Nutcracker. However, NYCB could not add more performances. Growth had to come from the schedule already in place.
NYCB Director of Marketing
Karen Girty
In partnership with TRG Arts, New York City Ballet found ways last summer to increase revenue from The Nutcracker in December 2011, and as a result it generated an additional $1.1 million. Read the New York City Ballet case study.
NYCB’s Director of Marketing Karen Girty joins TRG’s Keri Mesropov and Lindsay Homer to detail how they did it—and how you can get your organization on track for big holiday season success. You’ll learn:
-how pricing and scaling can make or break holiday revenue
-best practices for timing and deploying a holiday campaign
-specific techniques Girty, Homer, and Mesropov used to drive revenue at NYCB
3. National Census of Arts and Culture
Database Networks Nationwide
D
D
D
D
D
D
4. 2011 compared to 2010
Expected Revenue Expense Budget
Higher 24%
35%
Lower
52%
About the 58% 18%
same
13%
4
5. When does your holiday program
marketing campaign begin?
August
14% September
17%
July After August October
20% 56% 27%
June November
4% 11%
May December
2% April 1%
before April
1% 3%
5
6. What portion of your annual ticket or admission
revenues do holiday programs represent?
One-third (33%)
14%
25% or less Other
60% 40% Half (50%)
17%
Two-thirds
or more
9%
6
7. Holiday NOW?
I have a season to open!
Big Opportunity:
REVENUE
7
PROSPECT POOL
8. Key Considerations
For planning your holiday show campaign
1. Start selling NOW
• Elongated sales period = more sales
2. Plan expenses according to expected revenues
• Invest big to maximize return-on-investment
• Cost of sale application: 17-26%
3. Revisit inventory and price management plans
• Sure bets: prices go up
• Underdogs: Offers to stimulate demand – TODAY
8
13. Prior to TRG Counsel
Revenue was not being maximized
• Scale-of house and
pricing impacted
revenue potential
– Scale-of-house plan
reviewed for
Story, Repertory and
The Nutcracker as
part of a larger re-
scale effort
• The Nutcracker had
Standard, Peak and
Prime pricing
– Created big swings in
per capita
revenue, but overall
per capita was flat and
did not increase with
13 demand
15. 2011 Pricing Recommendations
Collapse prices into one simplified price table
• Scale-of-house changes decreased the number of price points
available for The Nutcracker
Sweet
Seats
A B C D E F G H I
PRIME Prices $ 225 $ 135 $ 110 $ 100 $ 85 $ 75 $ 55 $ 40 $ 45 $ 25
PEAK Prices $ 215 $ 125 $ 100 $ 90 $ 75 $ 70 $ 45 $ 30 $ 35 $ 20
STANDARD Prices $ 200 $ 110 $ 90 $ 75 $ 65 $ 60 $ 35 $ 20 $ 25 $ 15
Proposed Prices SS A B&C D&E F&G H&I
$225 $135 $110 $89 $55 $29
• Prime, Peak and Standard pricing replaced with static and
dynamic pricing
15
16. Change in Gross Potential
The Nutcracker
Increase of 14%
Gross Potential No. Perfs Total GP
2010/11 PRIME $ 264,140 17 $ 4,490,380
2010/11 PEAK $ 239,055 18 $ 4,302,990
2010/11 STANDARD $ 206,275 12 $ 2,475,300
47 $ 11,268,670
2011/12 $ 272,527 47 $ 12,808,769
Difference $ 1,540,099
14% increase over 10/11
3% PRIME
14% PEAK
32% STANDARD
16
*Gross potential is 100% value of each seat if entire house is sold
17. Summary
Impact of Scale-of-house and Pricing Changes
1. The Nutcracker gross potential increased by 14%*
2. All price points available in the most visible areas of
the house
a. A more-full effect for lower attended performances
b. Per capita revenues rise as demand increases
3. Fewer price points provokes desired purchase
behavior
a. Lowers barrier to entry on low-end of price scale
b. Maximizes revenue on the top-end of price scale
17
*Gross potential is 100% value of each seat if entire house is sold
18. The Results
Nutcracker revenue increased by $1.1 million in 2011
Of that $1.1 million:
• Scale-of-house plan $600,000
• Dynamic pricing $170,000
• Sold more tickets $330,000
18
19. New York City Ballet
Retention Postcard for 2011 Nutcracker New-to-File Buyers
Front
19
20. New York City Ballet
Retention Postcard for 2011 Nutcracker New-to-File Buyers
Back
Offer
Choices
20
21. New York City Ballet
Retention Email for 2011 Nutcracker New-to-File Buyers
21
22. Results
Nutcracker New-to-File Retention offer
Ocean's Kingdom Seven Deadly Sins Romeo and Juliet TOTAL
Overall Response Rate 0.93% 0.72% 2.16% 3.80%
Total Households 19,412 19,412 19,412 19,412
Total Responders 180 139 419 738
Package quantity 360 278 838 1,476
Revenue Total $ 15,359 $ 10,774 $ 68,499 $ 94,632
Total cost of mailing $ 10,492
Cost of Sale 11%
22
23. Questions?
• Use the Q&A feature to ask questions.
– Q&A is in the lower right corner of your
screen.
– Type your question in the text box.
– Send.
23
24. In Sum
Clear the deck: Sell holiday TODAY
4 keys to success:
1. Sales cycle begins today,
does not stop
2. Invest big to optimize ROI
3. Optimize revenue via
pricing, scrupulous
management of inventory
4. Retention, retention, retention
24
25. Want to know more?
TRG can help make holiday the most wonderful
time of the year
- Demand Management Sprint
- Holiday Program Campaign Sprint
Email info@trgarts.com.
25
26. TRG’s Next Webinar
July 31st, 2 p.m. EDT
Stick with Us!:
Mapping Strategies to
Keep Patrons Loyal
Jill Robinson, President
Register at www.trgarts.com
26
A few words about TRG Arts. TRG is a consulting firm that helps arts and entertainment clients grow revenue and patronage. Since we came on the scene in 1995, our firm has honed a laser focus on achieving results in the non-profit arts industry where the risks are great and margin for error is razor-thin. Our company has helped generate millions of dollars for more than 1,000 clients we now have in the United States, Canada and abroad, including performing arts, museums, commercial Broadway, resident entertainment, and touring companies.
TRG also manages 18 community databases around the U.S.We’re America’s largest provider of permission-based data sharing networks. Why should you care about this? Data networks are a powerful information resource for patron research, prospecting, advocacy, and data analysis.
Most of you (92%) produce holiday events or experience peak visitation near holiday time around the end of the year. If you had holiday programs and peak visitation for the past two years, the largest share of you also had an interesting challenge: The revenues you were expected to generate were higher but the amount you had to spend on them were about the same or lower.
Labor Day appears to be the first day of holiday campaign season. More than half of you wait till September or later to start marketing your holiday campaigns.
For 40% of you, holiday represents a big piece of your annual revenues – one third or more.
Christmas in July….You might be saying ‘are you serious? I have a subscription or membership campaign to close out, I’m nowhere near goal and oh yeah, I’ve got a season to open! No way, no how, I’ll get to that in September or October.’ Here are the reasons we challenge that thinking: Holiday programming comprises between 20 and 50% of total annual revenues.And…66-84% of holiday audiences are NEW each year – which means we create a huge prospect pool for other offerings throughout the season.THIS is why we must be thinking about snowflakes, Scrooge and the Sugarplum Fairy right now.
So…the first, most important key to a successful holiday production is Selling starts NOW. We know the more time we have to sell, the more we’ll sell so activate NOW, TODAY those holiday direct mail campaigns, paid media campaigns and social media campaigns.Second, ensure your expense budget sets up your holiday production or exhibit for success. This is where we see a disconnect – as we saw with many of you in the summary of the questions you answered when you signed up for this webinar. This is your biggest seller of the year, so invest big to maximize your return on investment. Unless your holiday production is completely sold out, you can always afford to spend more to make more here. This holds true for any blockbuster. In the industry, we’re seeing a holiday program cost of sale range from 17% to 26% for a holiday show. Cost of sale, as a reminder is how much $$ you’re spending to make a dollar of income. Finally, take a scrub brush to your inventory management and pricing plans. Where you KNOW you’ll have demand – a Sunday matinee of A Christmas Carol – you can get more for those performances. You know today which shows will have a harder time finding an audience – deploy offers NOW to stimulate demand for these underdogs.
A small campaign is taking place this fall and that means many things….but for today, it means that inventory in paid media will be tight in many markets and will be priced at a premium. If you haven’t already, you must BOOK IT TODAY.
From Presidential candidates to a marketing guru….I am so pleased to introduce our guest today. Karen Girty is the Director of Marketing at New York City Ballet, where she manages the Company’s brand and oversees efforts to generate nearly $27 million dollars in annual sales. Prior to joining NYCB, she worked for Serino/Coyne, the nation’s largest live entertainment advertising agency, where she managed accounts for Broadway producers such as the Nederlandersand The Metropolitan Opera. Karen, welcome.
So all of the points I outlined just a few minutes ago on creating the successful sale of your holiday program, New York City Ballet was doing, spot on. Before TRG’s partnership with the Company, Nutcracker was already soaring.Those of you who are thinking about how big they are—If you work for an org 1/10 your size, would you have done anything differently?While on the subject of big performing arts centers, museums and other institutions in attendance, we know that the holiday season is peak attendance for you too. These concepts can easily translate to you.
I now want to introduce my esteemed colleague, Lindsay Homer. For nearly 5 years now, Lindsay’s been a principal consultant with TRG, working with clients such as Alvin Ailey, Oregon Shakespeare Festival, Los Angeles Philharmonic and New York City Ballet. Lindsay was the architect of the price and inventory management plans for our work with City Ballet and I now want to hand the mic over to her to describe where we started and the work that led an already-stellar Nutcracker to bigger success. Lindsay?
Scale-of-house changes decreased the number of price points available for The NutcrackerCollapsed price points from 11 to 5 thus reducing barriers to entry for patronsPrice points were collapsed similarly to Repertory to maintain as much consistency as possiblePrime, Peak and Standard pricing replaced with static and dynamic pricingPrices increased when demand existedReplaced the need to “guess” with data-informed decisions
The baseline changes to the scale-of-house plan yielded a $600,000 increase over the same number of seats as sold the previous seasonAnother $170,000 came from dynamic pricing changes during the runThe remaining $330,000 came from selling approximately 3,000 more tickets than the previous season, coupled with the fluid scale and pricing changes in a high-demand environmentKaren to elaborate on the particular way in which you managed inventory, and what to do next year on dynamic pricing.Sell more tickets—Keri to transition
As we mentioned at the beginning of the presentation, holiday blockbusters bring in between 66 and 84% of brand-new people every year. And, 8 out of 10 of those new folks leave and never return. Another strategy TRG worked with NYCB on was single ticket buyer retention efforts. How do we entice MORE of those newbies to come back, stay awhile. Karen, describe for us the strategies you used this past December…
We’d also like to invite you to our next webinar, featuring TRG President Jill Robinson.She’ll reprise her popular presentation from the June TCG Conference. You’ll learn how to identify your most valuable patrons (surprise—it’s not just major donors) and map out strategies to keep them loyal. Lots of good research on patron behavior—you won’t want to miss it.There’s more information on our website—go there to register.
Thank you so much for attending.There will be video of the webinar on the TRG website posted in the next week. We will send you an email with the link once it is posted. If you had any remaining questions, we would love to talk to you! Email us at info@trgarts.com.