SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 31
Download to read offline
THE SHADOW TRUSTEE: WHEN
DOES ADVISING BECOME
UNDUE INFLUENCE?
DAN FRANCIS - NCVO
STEPHANIE BIDEN - BWB
SRABANI SEN OBE -
FULLCOLOUR
LOUISE THOMSON - ICSA Dinner
sponsors:
Media
partner:
Headline
sponsor:
Lead
sponsor:
Digital
partner:
The shadow trustee: when
does advising become
undue influence?
Stephanie Biden
Partner, Bates Wells Braithwaite
Terminology - “shadow director” vs. “de facto director”
Shadow directors
Defined in the Companies Act 2006:
“a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the
directors of the company are accustomed to act. A person is not to be
regarded as a shadow director by reason only that the directors act on
advice given by him in a professional capacity”
De facto directors
People who act like trustees, i.e. who take or authorise action and who
are held out as being trustees.
Historically meant individuals who purported to have been appointed as
trustees but by some defect had not been. However the law has
developed somewhat, moving away from a narrowly technical definition
of de facto directors to a definition relating to individuals ‘holding
themselves out’ as being directors.
Companies and other types of charity
The terms shadow and de facto trustees relate to company law regarding
directors.
So…
The shadow and de factor trustee are characters of concern primarily for
charitable companies limited by guarantee.
But…
The Charities (Protection and Social Investment) Act 2016 brought in
new powers for the Charity Commission to disqualify charity trustees and
senior managers of charities.
Therefore…
Senior managers of charitable companies, CIOs and charitable
unincorporated associations and trusts should all understand the nature
of their role and recognise the possible risk.
What is the risk?
• Disqualification as a company director (charitable companies)
• Disqualification as a charity trustee (any legal structure)
• Potential personal financial liability (charitable companies, CIOs,
charitable trusts “trustee de son tort”)
Why are we talking about this?
Action taken by the Official Receiver
against the former trustees of Keeping
Kids Company and the charity's CEO in
post at the time of its insolvency, Camila
Batmanghelidjh.
The OR is seeking Ms Batmanghelidjh’s
disqualification as a company director
on the basis that she was a de facto
director of Keeping Kids Company.
How can senior managers manage?
• Clear scheme of delegation to senior staff and list of matters reserved
to the board.
• Receiving a senior management team report at board meetings.
• Use available guidance such as the Charity Governance Code,
Charity Commission guidance and NCVO resources.
• Section of each trustees’ meeting at which no staff are present.
What should trustees manage?
• High level of responsibility and accountability among the individual
members of the trustee board (no sleepy trustees).
• Managing the public face and influence of the charity through the
trustee board, rather than one charismatic leader.
• Trustee authority on payments of a certain size.
• If the trustees want to invite in other expertise/points of view consider
formally appointing a new trustee following a skills audit or create a
working party/subcommittee (if empowered by governing document)
chaired by a trustee and answerable to the board.
CEO as Shadow Trustee: What’s the
issue and why is it important?
Srabani Sen OBE, CEO, Full Colour
What I’ll cover…
• Perspectives
• Definition
• Issues
• Why it matters
• Conclusions
Perspectives
Chair/Trustee Chief Exec
Consultant
Definitions
“Someone who acts as a director but doesn’t sit on the board”
ICSA, the Governance Institute
“A shadow director is someone who is not appointed as a director but who
gives directions or instructions that the directors of the company are
accustomed to act upon”
ICAEW
“They are someone (director) whose involvement is not publicly known”
Someone quoted in an article whose name I can’t remember…
The issues that people talk about
• Transparency
• Accountability
• Checks and balances
• Legal stuff
The real issues
• People don’t know what “CEO as
shadow trustee” looks like in
practice
• People don’t consciously consider in
“live” situations
• Power
• Trustees failing to stepping up
Definition
“A shadow director is
someone who is not
appointed as a director
but who gives directions
or instructions that the
directors of the company
are accustomed to act
upon”
ICAEW
Markers for what “CEO stepping into ST” can look like
Trustees Chief Exec Other
• Not reading papers
• Taking papers at face value
• Not getting to know org
• Over-reliance/trust in execs
• Presenteeism
• Chairs that don’t know how to
chair
• Fear of asking the “idiot”
question
• Not understanding job of a
trustee
• Domineering CEOs
• Blindspots
• Crafting papers to get preferred
decision
• Inability to write effective board
papers
• Lining up friendly trustees to
achieve preferred decision
• Not understanding job of
trustee
• Collusion between CEO and
Chair
• Insufficient time at meetings for
proper discussions
• Bad agenda planning
• Poor framing of decisions
People don’t consider it as a live/real time issue
Lack of:
• Recognising the symptoms
• Time
• Forum in which to raise it
• Confidence
• Anxiety about annoying the CEO
• Belief that it really matters…
Appropriate execution of power
• Is it clear who has power and when?
• Formal schedule of delegation
• Knowledge/ information/ expertise – who has it and how is it used
• How do CEOs give up the power that comes with knowledge?
• When is knowledge a cover for “paradigm”?
• How much do trustees need to know to do their job?
• What skills do trustees need – beyond “Lawyer/ accountant”?
• Emotional/ personality dynamics
• Levels of emotional intelligence/ influence
• Emotion as excuse – “it’s all about the kids/ DV survivors/ disabled people”
• Willingness on part of board to exercise power
Trustees knowing/ fulfilling role
Not thought about it/ wrong reasons
Right reasons/ poor knowledge of role
Right Reasons/ good knowledge/ insufficient time
Right reasons/ good knowledge/ enough time/ unhappy to challenge
Right reasons/ good knowledge/ enough time/ happy challenge
Trustees can force CEOs into shadow trustee role
Trustee Chief Exec Consultant
• Not reading papers
• Taking papers at face value
• Not getting to know org
• Over-reliance/trust in exec team
• Presenteeism
• Chairs that don’t know how to
chair
• Fear of asking the “idiot”
question
• Not understanding job of a
trustee
• Domineering CEOs
• Blindspots
• Crafting papers to get
preferred decision
• Inability to write effective
board papers
• Lining up friendly trustees to
achieve preferred decision
• Not understanding job of
trustee
• Collusion between CEO
and Chair
• Insufficient time/ bad
agenda planning
• Poor framing of
decisions
Conclusions (Why these issues matter)
• Reputation/ scrutiny/ trust
• Context – we need to up our game in governance as a sector
• How we deliver matters as much as what we deliver –
• We know this at a theoretical level but don’t think about it enough in
practice
• Values…The clue’s in the name “shadow” trustee
B5: The shadow trustee: When does advising become undue influence?
Thank you
srabani.sen1@gmail.com
07802 790634
Shadow directors and group structures
Louise Thomson FCIS, Head of Policy (Not for Profit), ICSA:
The Governance Institute
NCVO, 16 April 2018
Charities and subsidiary companies
 A charity may set up a non-charitable company to carry out various activities
 A wholly owned subsidiary’s member/shareholder will be the parent
organisation. The parent’s undertakings likely to include:
 Holding 100% of voting rights at AGMs
 Having the majority of voting rights at general meeting
 Right to appoint/remove majority of subsidiary board
 A contractual agreement between the parent and subsidiary
 Power to exercise dominant control over subsidiary due to provisions in the
governing document.
Directors duties – Companies Act 2006
S 171 - duty to act within powers
S 172 - duty to promote the success of the company
S 173 - duty to exercise independent judgement
S 174 - duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence
S 175 - duty to avoid conflicts of interest
S 176 - duty not to accept benefits from third parties
S 171 - duty to declare interest in proposed transaction or agreement.
Subsidiary arrangements
 Overlap in personnel – trustees, directors, staff
 Separate identity
 Financial independence
 Lack of control
 Shadow directors
Shadow directors and subsidiaries
Defined as:
A person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of a
company are accustomed to act is described as a 'shadow director' and thus
treated as a director for the purposes of certain provisions.
In groups of companies there is often a concern that the parent company may be
regarded as a shadow director of a subsidiary. In this event the parent might find
itself liable for the debts of the subsidiary should it become insolvent and be
liquidated. Shadow directors are, of course, subject to the 'wrongful trading‘.
Impact
If found to be acting as a shadow director an individual risks:
 a liability to contribute to the company’s assets following the company’s
insolvency
 being disqualified from being a director following the company’s insolvency
 criminal sanctions for breaches of directors’ duties
 personal liability for breaches of directors’ duties.
Avoiding claims of shadow director in subsidiaries
 Asserting control over all or part of the affairs of a subsidiary or being concerned
in its day-to-day management should be avoided
 All or substantially all of the directors of the subsidiary should be persons who
are not employees or officers of the parent
 An agreement between the parent and subsidiary providing for the subsidiary to
have autonomy (and perhaps limiting the flow of information from subsidiary to
parent) may be helpful
 Individual members of the parent company board should avoid becoming
personally involved in giving directions regarding the management of the
subsidiary.
Thank you
lthomson@icsa.org.uk @louiseicsa1
QUESTIONS FOR OUR
PANEL
Dinner
sponsors:
Media
partner:
Headline
sponsor:
Lead
sponsor:
Digital
partner:

More Related Content

What's hot

Estimation of the probability of default : Credit Rish
Estimation of the probability of default : Credit RishEstimation of the probability of default : Credit Rish
Estimation of the probability of default : Credit RishArsalan Qadri
 
Lunch& Learn - Bridging the gap between strategy design and delivery
Lunch& Learn  - Bridging the gap between strategy design and deliveryLunch& Learn  - Bridging the gap between strategy design and delivery
Lunch& Learn - Bridging the gap between strategy design and deliveryThe PNR
 
Project Charter Template
Project Charter TemplateProject Charter Template
Project Charter TemplateDemand Metric
 
WindowsではじめるROSプログラミング
WindowsではじめるROSプログラミングWindowsではじめるROSプログラミング
WindowsではじめるROSプログラミングTakayuki Goto
 
Troop leading procedures
Troop leading proceduresTroop leading procedures
Troop leading proceduresjmsimp06
 
この手に超高精度GPSを!
この手に超高精度GPSを!この手に超高精度GPSを!
この手に超高精度GPSを!KLab Inc. / Tech
 
FOSS4G2014Osakaハンズオン:「QGISによるジオリファレンス入門」,大阪市立大学梅田サテライトキャンパス(大阪市),2013年10月27日.
FOSS4G2014Osakaハンズオン:「QGISによるジオリファレンス入門」,大阪市立大学梅田サテライトキャンパス(大阪市),2013年10月27日.FOSS4G2014Osakaハンズオン:「QGISによるジオリファレンス入門」,大阪市立大学梅田サテライトキャンパス(大阪市),2013年10月27日.
FOSS4G2014Osakaハンズオン:「QGISによるジオリファレンス入門」,大阪市立大学梅田サテライトキャンパス(大阪市),2013年10月27日.和人 青木
 
NAVAIR Integrated Master Schedule Guide guide
NAVAIR Integrated Master Schedule Guide guideNAVAIR Integrated Master Schedule Guide guide
NAVAIR Integrated Master Schedule Guide guideGlen Alleman
 
Integrated Treasury Management in Bangladesh Krishi Bank
Integrated Treasury Management in Bangladesh Krishi BankIntegrated Treasury Management in Bangladesh Krishi Bank
Integrated Treasury Management in Bangladesh Krishi BankAl Mamun
 
Visual SLAM: Why Bundle Adjust?の解説(第4回3D勉強会@関東)
Visual SLAM: Why Bundle Adjust?の解説(第4回3D勉強会@関東)Visual SLAM: Why Bundle Adjust?の解説(第4回3D勉強会@関東)
Visual SLAM: Why Bundle Adjust?の解説(第4回3D勉強会@関東)Masaya Kaneko
 

What's hot (12)

Estimation of the probability of default : Credit Rish
Estimation of the probability of default : Credit RishEstimation of the probability of default : Credit Rish
Estimation of the probability of default : Credit Rish
 
Lunch& Learn - Bridging the gap between strategy design and delivery
Lunch& Learn  - Bridging the gap between strategy design and deliveryLunch& Learn  - Bridging the gap between strategy design and delivery
Lunch& Learn - Bridging the gap between strategy design and delivery
 
Project Charter Template
Project Charter TemplateProject Charter Template
Project Charter Template
 
WindowsではじめるROSプログラミング
WindowsではじめるROSプログラミングWindowsではじめるROSプログラミング
WindowsではじめるROSプログラミング
 
Troop leading procedures
Troop leading proceduresTroop leading procedures
Troop leading procedures
 
この手に超高精度GPSを!
この手に超高精度GPSを!この手に超高精度GPSを!
この手に超高精度GPSを!
 
Sentrifugo HRMS 3.0 - User Guide
Sentrifugo HRMS 3.0 - User GuideSentrifugo HRMS 3.0 - User Guide
Sentrifugo HRMS 3.0 - User Guide
 
FOSS4G2014Osakaハンズオン:「QGISによるジオリファレンス入門」,大阪市立大学梅田サテライトキャンパス(大阪市),2013年10月27日.
FOSS4G2014Osakaハンズオン:「QGISによるジオリファレンス入門」,大阪市立大学梅田サテライトキャンパス(大阪市),2013年10月27日.FOSS4G2014Osakaハンズオン:「QGISによるジオリファレンス入門」,大阪市立大学梅田サテライトキャンパス(大阪市),2013年10月27日.
FOSS4G2014Osakaハンズオン:「QGISによるジオリファレンス入門」,大阪市立大学梅田サテライトキャンパス(大阪市),2013年10月27日.
 
NAVAIR Integrated Master Schedule Guide guide
NAVAIR Integrated Master Schedule Guide guideNAVAIR Integrated Master Schedule Guide guide
NAVAIR Integrated Master Schedule Guide guide
 
Integrated Treasury Management in Bangladesh Krishi Bank
Integrated Treasury Management in Bangladesh Krishi BankIntegrated Treasury Management in Bangladesh Krishi Bank
Integrated Treasury Management in Bangladesh Krishi Bank
 
Abaqus
AbaqusAbaqus
Abaqus
 
Visual SLAM: Why Bundle Adjust?の解説(第4回3D勉強会@関東)
Visual SLAM: Why Bundle Adjust?の解説(第4回3D勉強会@関東)Visual SLAM: Why Bundle Adjust?の解説(第4回3D勉強会@関東)
Visual SLAM: Why Bundle Adjust?の解説(第4回3D勉強会@関東)
 

Similar to B5: The shadow trustee: When does advising become undue influence?

Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer (Series: Board of Directors Boot Camp 2020...
Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer (Series: Board of Directors Boot Camp 2020...Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer (Series: Board of Directors Boot Camp 2020...
Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer (Series: Board of Directors Boot Camp 2020...Financial Poise
 
The University Program Board ( Upb )
The University Program Board ( Upb )The University Program Board ( Upb )
The University Program Board ( Upb )Erin Torres
 
Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer
Roles & Responsibilities: A PrimerRoles & Responsibilities: A Primer
Roles & Responsibilities: A PrimerFinancial Poise
 
Roles & Responsibilities a Primer
Roles & Responsibilities a Primer  Roles & Responsibilities a Primer
Roles & Responsibilities a Primer Financial Poise
 
Roles & Responsibilities: a Primer
Roles & Responsibilities: a PrimerRoles & Responsibilities: a Primer
Roles & Responsibilities: a PrimerFinancial Poise
 
AORE Leadership University 301
AORE Leadership University 301AORE Leadership University 301
AORE Leadership University 301Holly Duckworth
 
Being on the board of directors - Why it sucks and how to improve it
Being on the board of directors - Why it sucks and how to improve itBeing on the board of directors - Why it sucks and how to improve it
Being on the board of directors - Why it sucks and how to improve itEric Tachibana
 
PSYCHOLOGY TODAY: PE Partners and PE Portfolio Company CEOs
PSYCHOLOGY TODAY: PE Partners and PE Portfolio Company CEOsPSYCHOLOGY TODAY: PE Partners and PE Portfolio Company CEOs
PSYCHOLOGY TODAY: PE Partners and PE Portfolio Company CEOsLarry Stybel
 
The Guide for Non-Executive Directors
The Guide for Non-Executive DirectorsThe Guide for Non-Executive Directors
The Guide for Non-Executive DirectorsNeil Holmes
 
The Guide For Non Executive Directors
The Guide For Non Executive DirectorsThe Guide For Non Executive Directors
The Guide For Non Executive DirectorsNB
 
The-Guide-for-Non-Executive-Directors
The-Guide-for-Non-Executive-DirectorsThe-Guide-for-Non-Executive-Directors
The-Guide-for-Non-Executive-DirectorsCharlotte Lawrence
 
NYS TESOL - October Webinar 2014
NYS TESOL - October Webinar 2014NYS TESOL - October Webinar 2014
NYS TESOL - October Webinar 2014Holly Duckworth
 
Essential Board Governance
Essential Board GovernanceEssential Board Governance
Essential Board GovernanceDonnaChilds
 
Directors duties presentation
Directors duties presentationDirectors duties presentation
Directors duties presentationMaytree
 
Kraft Foods Board Of Directors Essay
Kraft Foods Board Of Directors EssayKraft Foods Board Of Directors Essay
Kraft Foods Board Of Directors EssayAmanda Crow
 

Similar to B5: The shadow trustee: When does advising become undue influence? (20)

Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer (Series: Board of Directors Boot Camp 2020...
Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer (Series: Board of Directors Boot Camp 2020...Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer (Series: Board of Directors Boot Camp 2020...
Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer (Series: Board of Directors Boot Camp 2020...
 
The University Program Board ( Upb )
The University Program Board ( Upb )The University Program Board ( Upb )
The University Program Board ( Upb )
 
Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer
Roles & Responsibilities: A PrimerRoles & Responsibilities: A Primer
Roles & Responsibilities: A Primer
 
Roles & Responsibilities a Primer
Roles & Responsibilities a Primer  Roles & Responsibilities a Primer
Roles & Responsibilities a Primer
 
Roles & Responsibilities: a Primer
Roles & Responsibilities: a PrimerRoles & Responsibilities: a Primer
Roles & Responsibilities: a Primer
 
AORE Leadership University 301
AORE Leadership University 301AORE Leadership University 301
AORE Leadership University 301
 
130210 NYSAR Boardology
130210 NYSAR   Boardology130210 NYSAR   Boardology
130210 NYSAR Boardology
 
0301 1 Jan Geissler - Establishing good NGO governance
0301 1 Jan Geissler - Establishing good NGO governance0301 1 Jan Geissler - Establishing good NGO governance
0301 1 Jan Geissler - Establishing good NGO governance
 
Being on the board of directors - Why it sucks and how to improve it
Being on the board of directors - Why it sucks and how to improve itBeing on the board of directors - Why it sucks and how to improve it
Being on the board of directors - Why it sucks and how to improve it
 
PSYCHOLOGY TODAY: PE Partners and PE Portfolio Company CEOs
PSYCHOLOGY TODAY: PE Partners and PE Portfolio Company CEOsPSYCHOLOGY TODAY: PE Partners and PE Portfolio Company CEOs
PSYCHOLOGY TODAY: PE Partners and PE Portfolio Company CEOs
 
Decision making in a crisis: Collaboration and merger
Decision making in a crisis: Collaboration and mergerDecision making in a crisis: Collaboration and merger
Decision making in a crisis: Collaboration and merger
 
The Guide for Non-Executive Directors
The Guide for Non-Executive DirectorsThe Guide for Non-Executive Directors
The Guide for Non-Executive Directors
 
The Guide For Non Executive Directors
The Guide For Non Executive DirectorsThe Guide For Non Executive Directors
The Guide For Non Executive Directors
 
The-Guide-for-Non-Executive-Directors
The-Guide-for-Non-Executive-DirectorsThe-Guide-for-Non-Executive-Directors
The-Guide-for-Non-Executive-Directors
 
NYS TESOL - October Webinar 2014
NYS TESOL - October Webinar 2014NYS TESOL - October Webinar 2014
NYS TESOL - October Webinar 2014
 
Governance Paper
Governance PaperGovernance Paper
Governance Paper
 
What every new trustee needs to know
What every new trustee needs to knowWhat every new trustee needs to know
What every new trustee needs to know
 
Essential Board Governance
Essential Board GovernanceEssential Board Governance
Essential Board Governance
 
Directors duties presentation
Directors duties presentationDirectors duties presentation
Directors duties presentation
 
Kraft Foods Board Of Directors Essay
Kraft Foods Board Of Directors EssayKraft Foods Board Of Directors Essay
Kraft Foods Board Of Directors Essay
 

More from NCVO - National Council for Voluntary Organisations

More from NCVO - National Council for Voluntary Organisations (20)

AGM 2022: Vision for Volunteering
AGM 2022: Vision for VolunteeringAGM 2022: Vision for Volunteering
AGM 2022: Vision for Volunteering
 
AGM 2022: Building networks
AGM 2022: Building networksAGM 2022: Building networks
AGM 2022: Building networks
 
AGM 2022: Membership
AGM 2022: MembershipAGM 2022: Membership
AGM 2022: Membership
 
AGM 2022: Time Well Spent
AGM 2022: Time Well SpentAGM 2022: Time Well Spent
AGM 2022: Time Well Spent
 
AGM 2022: Undertaking a governace review
AGM 2022: Undertaking a governace reviewAGM 2022: Undertaking a governace review
AGM 2022: Undertaking a governace review
 
National Volunteering Forum: Engaging volunteers and paid staff
National Volunteering Forum: Engaging volunteers and paid staffNational Volunteering Forum: Engaging volunteers and paid staff
National Volunteering Forum: Engaging volunteers and paid staff
 
Improving organisational resilience: What trustees need to consider
Improving organisational resilience: What trustees need to considerImproving organisational resilience: What trustees need to consider
Improving organisational resilience: What trustees need to consider
 
NCVO webinar: An update on changes to the Charity Governance Code
NCVO webinar: An update on changes to the Charity Governance CodeNCVO webinar: An update on changes to the Charity Governance Code
NCVO webinar: An update on changes to the Charity Governance Code
 
Undertaking a governance effectiveness review
Undertaking a governance effectiveness reviewUndertaking a governance effectiveness review
Undertaking a governance effectiveness review
 
NCVO/Zurich webinar: Beyond cyber essentials
NCVO/Zurich webinar: Beyond cyber essentialsNCVO/Zurich webinar: Beyond cyber essentials
NCVO/Zurich webinar: Beyond cyber essentials
 
NCVO/Zurich webinar: Safeguarding through covid-19 and beyond
NCVO/Zurich webinar: Safeguarding through covid-19 and beyondNCVO/Zurich webinar: Safeguarding through covid-19 and beyond
NCVO/Zurich webinar: Safeguarding through covid-19 and beyond
 
Easing of lockdown practical considerations for managing and support staff
Easing of lockdown practical considerations for managing and support staffEasing of lockdown practical considerations for managing and support staff
Easing of lockdown practical considerations for managing and support staff
 
How to manage operational change in a time of uncertainty
How to manage operational change in a time of uncertaintyHow to manage operational change in a time of uncertainty
How to manage operational change in a time of uncertainty
 
Easing of lockdown – practical considerations for managing and supporting staff
Easing of lockdown – practical considerations for managing and supporting staffEasing of lockdown – practical considerations for managing and supporting staff
Easing of lockdown – practical considerations for managing and supporting staff
 
NCVO webinar: Volunteering in a pandemic: Lessons from volunteering organisat...
NCVO webinar: Volunteering in a pandemic: Lessons from volunteering organisat...NCVO webinar: Volunteering in a pandemic: Lessons from volunteering organisat...
NCVO webinar: Volunteering in a pandemic: Lessons from volunteering organisat...
 
NCVO webinar: UK Civil Society Almanac 2020: What the latest data tells us
NCVO webinar: UK Civil Society Almanac 2020: What the latest data tells usNCVO webinar: UK Civil Society Almanac 2020: What the latest data tells us
NCVO webinar: UK Civil Society Almanac 2020: What the latest data tells us
 
NCVO Webinar: Legal and practical considerations for returning to work
NCVO Webinar: Legal and practical considerations for returning to workNCVO Webinar: Legal and practical considerations for returning to work
NCVO Webinar: Legal and practical considerations for returning to work
 
NCVO Webinar: Board Leadership: Supporting your charity through the next phas...
NCVO Webinar: Board Leadership: Supporting your charity through the next phas...NCVO Webinar: Board Leadership: Supporting your charity through the next phas...
NCVO Webinar: Board Leadership: Supporting your charity through the next phas...
 
NCVO/CFG Webinar: Financial management and accessing government funding combi...
NCVO/CFG Webinar: Financial management and accessing government funding combi...NCVO/CFG Webinar: Financial management and accessing government funding combi...
NCVO/CFG Webinar: Financial management and accessing government funding combi...
 
Assessing health and safety risk in uncertain times
Assessing health and safety risk in uncertain timesAssessing health and safety risk in uncertain times
Assessing health and safety risk in uncertain times
 

Recently uploaded

annual Budget Youth Investment plan sample.docx
annual Budget Youth Investment plan sample.docxannual Budget Youth Investment plan sample.docx
annual Budget Youth Investment plan sample.docxOwingConejo1
 
Best charity ideas parents give their children’s
Best charity ideas parents give their children’sBest charity ideas parents give their children’s
Best charity ideas parents give their children’sSERUDS INDIA
 
SPONSORED CONTENT - MyGovWatch - RFP Cliches Debunked: What Government Buyers...
SPONSORED CONTENT - MyGovWatch - RFP Cliches Debunked: What Government Buyers...SPONSORED CONTENT - MyGovWatch - RFP Cliches Debunked: What Government Buyers...
SPONSORED CONTENT - MyGovWatch - RFP Cliches Debunked: What Government Buyers...JSchaus & Associates
 
Sensitivity Training for 2023 BSKE.pptx
Sensitivity Training for  2023 BSKE.pptxSensitivity Training for  2023 BSKE.pptx
Sensitivity Training for 2023 BSKE.pptxAllidaacLuap
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 16
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 162024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 16
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 16JSchaus & Associates
 
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New ResearchCBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New ResearchCongressional Budget Office
 
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.Christina Parmionova
 
War in Ukraine and problematics of the Ukrainian refugees in USA.
War in Ukraine and problematics of the Ukrainian refugees in USA.War in Ukraine and problematics of the Ukrainian refugees in USA.
War in Ukraine and problematics of the Ukrainian refugees in USA.ival6
 
Hub Design Inspiration Graphics for inspiration
Hub Design Inspiration Graphics for inspirationHub Design Inspiration Graphics for inspiration
Hub Design Inspiration Graphics for inspirationStephen Abram
 
Item # 4 - Appointment of new PW Director
Item # 4 - Appointment of new PW DirectorItem # 4 - Appointment of new PW Director
Item # 4 - Appointment of new PW Directorahcitycouncil
 
Water can create peace or spark conflict.
Water can create peace or spark conflict.Water can create peace or spark conflict.
Water can create peace or spark conflict.Christina Parmionova
 
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM MinutesItem # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutesahcitycouncil
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 17
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 172024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 17
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 17JSchaus & Associates
 
Parents give a charity ideas for children
Parents give a charity ideas for childrenParents give a charity ideas for children
Parents give a charity ideas for childrenSERUDS INDIA
 
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements PowerpointPPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpointahcitycouncil
 
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptxDB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptxNAP Global Network
 
Civics Presentation - Salvador Galvan.pptx
Civics Presentation - Salvador Galvan.pptxCivics Presentation - Salvador Galvan.pptx
Civics Presentation - Salvador Galvan.pptxsgalvan1
 
The Federal Perspective on Coverage of Medications to Treat Obesity: Consider...
The Federal Perspective on Coverage of Medications to Treat Obesity: Consider...The Federal Perspective on Coverage of Medications to Treat Obesity: Consider...
The Federal Perspective on Coverage of Medications to Treat Obesity: Consider...Congressional Budget Office
 
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.ahcitycouncil
 
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.ahcitycouncil
 

Recently uploaded (20)

annual Budget Youth Investment plan sample.docx
annual Budget Youth Investment plan sample.docxannual Budget Youth Investment plan sample.docx
annual Budget Youth Investment plan sample.docx
 
Best charity ideas parents give their children’s
Best charity ideas parents give their children’sBest charity ideas parents give their children’s
Best charity ideas parents give their children’s
 
SPONSORED CONTENT - MyGovWatch - RFP Cliches Debunked: What Government Buyers...
SPONSORED CONTENT - MyGovWatch - RFP Cliches Debunked: What Government Buyers...SPONSORED CONTENT - MyGovWatch - RFP Cliches Debunked: What Government Buyers...
SPONSORED CONTENT - MyGovWatch - RFP Cliches Debunked: What Government Buyers...
 
Sensitivity Training for 2023 BSKE.pptx
Sensitivity Training for  2023 BSKE.pptxSensitivity Training for  2023 BSKE.pptx
Sensitivity Training for 2023 BSKE.pptx
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 16
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 162024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 16
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 16
 
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New ResearchCBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
 
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
 
War in Ukraine and problematics of the Ukrainian refugees in USA.
War in Ukraine and problematics of the Ukrainian refugees in USA.War in Ukraine and problematics of the Ukrainian refugees in USA.
War in Ukraine and problematics of the Ukrainian refugees in USA.
 
Hub Design Inspiration Graphics for inspiration
Hub Design Inspiration Graphics for inspirationHub Design Inspiration Graphics for inspiration
Hub Design Inspiration Graphics for inspiration
 
Item # 4 - Appointment of new PW Director
Item # 4 - Appointment of new PW DirectorItem # 4 - Appointment of new PW Director
Item # 4 - Appointment of new PW Director
 
Water can create peace or spark conflict.
Water can create peace or spark conflict.Water can create peace or spark conflict.
Water can create peace or spark conflict.
 
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM MinutesItem # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 17
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 172024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 17
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 17
 
Parents give a charity ideas for children
Parents give a charity ideas for childrenParents give a charity ideas for children
Parents give a charity ideas for children
 
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements PowerpointPPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
 
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptxDB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
 
Civics Presentation - Salvador Galvan.pptx
Civics Presentation - Salvador Galvan.pptxCivics Presentation - Salvador Galvan.pptx
Civics Presentation - Salvador Galvan.pptx
 
The Federal Perspective on Coverage of Medications to Treat Obesity: Consider...
The Federal Perspective on Coverage of Medications to Treat Obesity: Consider...The Federal Perspective on Coverage of Medications to Treat Obesity: Consider...
The Federal Perspective on Coverage of Medications to Treat Obesity: Consider...
 
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
 
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
 

B5: The shadow trustee: When does advising become undue influence?

  • 1. THE SHADOW TRUSTEE: WHEN DOES ADVISING BECOME UNDUE INFLUENCE? DAN FRANCIS - NCVO STEPHANIE BIDEN - BWB SRABANI SEN OBE - FULLCOLOUR LOUISE THOMSON - ICSA Dinner sponsors: Media partner: Headline sponsor: Lead sponsor: Digital partner:
  • 2. The shadow trustee: when does advising become undue influence? Stephanie Biden Partner, Bates Wells Braithwaite
  • 3. Terminology - “shadow director” vs. “de facto director” Shadow directors Defined in the Companies Act 2006: “a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of the company are accustomed to act. A person is not to be regarded as a shadow director by reason only that the directors act on advice given by him in a professional capacity” De facto directors People who act like trustees, i.e. who take or authorise action and who are held out as being trustees. Historically meant individuals who purported to have been appointed as trustees but by some defect had not been. However the law has developed somewhat, moving away from a narrowly technical definition of de facto directors to a definition relating to individuals ‘holding themselves out’ as being directors.
  • 4. Companies and other types of charity The terms shadow and de facto trustees relate to company law regarding directors. So… The shadow and de factor trustee are characters of concern primarily for charitable companies limited by guarantee. But… The Charities (Protection and Social Investment) Act 2016 brought in new powers for the Charity Commission to disqualify charity trustees and senior managers of charities. Therefore… Senior managers of charitable companies, CIOs and charitable unincorporated associations and trusts should all understand the nature of their role and recognise the possible risk.
  • 5. What is the risk? • Disqualification as a company director (charitable companies) • Disqualification as a charity trustee (any legal structure) • Potential personal financial liability (charitable companies, CIOs, charitable trusts “trustee de son tort”)
  • 6. Why are we talking about this? Action taken by the Official Receiver against the former trustees of Keeping Kids Company and the charity's CEO in post at the time of its insolvency, Camila Batmanghelidjh. The OR is seeking Ms Batmanghelidjh’s disqualification as a company director on the basis that she was a de facto director of Keeping Kids Company.
  • 7. How can senior managers manage? • Clear scheme of delegation to senior staff and list of matters reserved to the board. • Receiving a senior management team report at board meetings. • Use available guidance such as the Charity Governance Code, Charity Commission guidance and NCVO resources. • Section of each trustees’ meeting at which no staff are present.
  • 8. What should trustees manage? • High level of responsibility and accountability among the individual members of the trustee board (no sleepy trustees). • Managing the public face and influence of the charity through the trustee board, rather than one charismatic leader. • Trustee authority on payments of a certain size. • If the trustees want to invite in other expertise/points of view consider formally appointing a new trustee following a skills audit or create a working party/subcommittee (if empowered by governing document) chaired by a trustee and answerable to the board.
  • 9. CEO as Shadow Trustee: What’s the issue and why is it important? Srabani Sen OBE, CEO, Full Colour
  • 10. What I’ll cover… • Perspectives • Definition • Issues • Why it matters • Conclusions
  • 12. Definitions “Someone who acts as a director but doesn’t sit on the board” ICSA, the Governance Institute “A shadow director is someone who is not appointed as a director but who gives directions or instructions that the directors of the company are accustomed to act upon” ICAEW “They are someone (director) whose involvement is not publicly known” Someone quoted in an article whose name I can’t remember…
  • 13. The issues that people talk about • Transparency • Accountability • Checks and balances • Legal stuff
  • 14. The real issues • People don’t know what “CEO as shadow trustee” looks like in practice • People don’t consciously consider in “live” situations • Power • Trustees failing to stepping up Definition “A shadow director is someone who is not appointed as a director but who gives directions or instructions that the directors of the company are accustomed to act upon” ICAEW
  • 15. Markers for what “CEO stepping into ST” can look like Trustees Chief Exec Other • Not reading papers • Taking papers at face value • Not getting to know org • Over-reliance/trust in execs • Presenteeism • Chairs that don’t know how to chair • Fear of asking the “idiot” question • Not understanding job of a trustee • Domineering CEOs • Blindspots • Crafting papers to get preferred decision • Inability to write effective board papers • Lining up friendly trustees to achieve preferred decision • Not understanding job of trustee • Collusion between CEO and Chair • Insufficient time at meetings for proper discussions • Bad agenda planning • Poor framing of decisions
  • 16. People don’t consider it as a live/real time issue Lack of: • Recognising the symptoms • Time • Forum in which to raise it • Confidence • Anxiety about annoying the CEO • Belief that it really matters…
  • 17. Appropriate execution of power • Is it clear who has power and when? • Formal schedule of delegation • Knowledge/ information/ expertise – who has it and how is it used • How do CEOs give up the power that comes with knowledge? • When is knowledge a cover for “paradigm”? • How much do trustees need to know to do their job? • What skills do trustees need – beyond “Lawyer/ accountant”? • Emotional/ personality dynamics • Levels of emotional intelligence/ influence • Emotion as excuse – “it’s all about the kids/ DV survivors/ disabled people” • Willingness on part of board to exercise power
  • 18. Trustees knowing/ fulfilling role Not thought about it/ wrong reasons Right reasons/ poor knowledge of role Right Reasons/ good knowledge/ insufficient time Right reasons/ good knowledge/ enough time/ unhappy to challenge Right reasons/ good knowledge/ enough time/ happy challenge
  • 19. Trustees can force CEOs into shadow trustee role Trustee Chief Exec Consultant • Not reading papers • Taking papers at face value • Not getting to know org • Over-reliance/trust in exec team • Presenteeism • Chairs that don’t know how to chair • Fear of asking the “idiot” question • Not understanding job of a trustee • Domineering CEOs • Blindspots • Crafting papers to get preferred decision • Inability to write effective board papers • Lining up friendly trustees to achieve preferred decision • Not understanding job of trustee • Collusion between CEO and Chair • Insufficient time/ bad agenda planning • Poor framing of decisions
  • 20. Conclusions (Why these issues matter) • Reputation/ scrutiny/ trust • Context – we need to up our game in governance as a sector • How we deliver matters as much as what we deliver – • We know this at a theoretical level but don’t think about it enough in practice • Values…The clue’s in the name “shadow” trustee
  • 23. Shadow directors and group structures Louise Thomson FCIS, Head of Policy (Not for Profit), ICSA: The Governance Institute NCVO, 16 April 2018
  • 24. Charities and subsidiary companies  A charity may set up a non-charitable company to carry out various activities  A wholly owned subsidiary’s member/shareholder will be the parent organisation. The parent’s undertakings likely to include:  Holding 100% of voting rights at AGMs  Having the majority of voting rights at general meeting  Right to appoint/remove majority of subsidiary board  A contractual agreement between the parent and subsidiary  Power to exercise dominant control over subsidiary due to provisions in the governing document.
  • 25. Directors duties – Companies Act 2006 S 171 - duty to act within powers S 172 - duty to promote the success of the company S 173 - duty to exercise independent judgement S 174 - duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence S 175 - duty to avoid conflicts of interest S 176 - duty not to accept benefits from third parties S 171 - duty to declare interest in proposed transaction or agreement.
  • 26. Subsidiary arrangements  Overlap in personnel – trustees, directors, staff  Separate identity  Financial independence  Lack of control  Shadow directors
  • 27. Shadow directors and subsidiaries Defined as: A person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of a company are accustomed to act is described as a 'shadow director' and thus treated as a director for the purposes of certain provisions. In groups of companies there is often a concern that the parent company may be regarded as a shadow director of a subsidiary. In this event the parent might find itself liable for the debts of the subsidiary should it become insolvent and be liquidated. Shadow directors are, of course, subject to the 'wrongful trading‘.
  • 28. Impact If found to be acting as a shadow director an individual risks:  a liability to contribute to the company’s assets following the company’s insolvency  being disqualified from being a director following the company’s insolvency  criminal sanctions for breaches of directors’ duties  personal liability for breaches of directors’ duties.
  • 29. Avoiding claims of shadow director in subsidiaries  Asserting control over all or part of the affairs of a subsidiary or being concerned in its day-to-day management should be avoided  All or substantially all of the directors of the subsidiary should be persons who are not employees or officers of the parent  An agreement between the parent and subsidiary providing for the subsidiary to have autonomy (and perhaps limiting the flow of information from subsidiary to parent) may be helpful  Individual members of the parent company board should avoid becoming personally involved in giving directions regarding the management of the subsidiary.