SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
1
POINT OF VIEW
The Disappearing Iceberg
SHARE
But really, results of new research show that
there is nowhere near as much beneath the
surface as the iceberg image suggests. What
the new science actually seems to challenge is
the metaphor of the iceberg itself.
95 PERCENT WRONG
The iceberg concept is supported by the idea,
often cited as a fact, that “95 percent of what the
brain does is unconscious.” This is said with the
clearly intended implication that 95 percent of
brand decision making is unconscious. Thus—if
this were true—marketers would need to focus
almost exclusively on subconscious processes
to truly understand consumers and influence
their buying decisions.
However, the 95 percent figure is just a
hypothetical concept. There seem to be no
scientific papers that substantiate this number.
It is undoubtedly true that a huge amount of
the brain’s energy is consumed by processes
below the level of awareness, but many of these
processes have to do with biological regulation
and low-level sensory processing, not decision
making.
Neither does the 95 percent figure fit with
evidence from our study of brands. When
we apply tools that tap into automatic, non-
conscious processes, we don’t find evidence of
a bubbling mass of associations and responses.
The Disappearing Iceberg
It has become a mantra:“Recent learning from cognitive science is challenging
long-held assumptions of the market research industry.”And the mantra is
true—but not in the way most people think. The typical assumption is that
new research into fast, instinctive processing supports the idea that people’s
considered responses to survey questions are just the tip of the iceberg—that
the bulk of the meaning that brands hold for people is below the surface.
Graham Page
Head of Global Research Solutions
graham.page@millwardbrown.com
www.millwardbrown.com
We have deployed these types of tools on
hundreds of projects in the last few years, and
what they actually show us is that few brands
evoke many ideas or responses without much
effort. For instance, we have used a variation of
the Harvard Implicit Association Test to measure
instinctive emotional responses to brands.
Compared to the strong responses elicited by
happy pictures of family and children (which
are positive) and snakes, starving children,
and Hitler (which are negative), the emotional
responses evoked by brands tend to be very
modest (and either neutral or mildly positive).
These findings are in fact entirely consistent
with the cognitive science that sparked the
discussion on changing assumptions. The core
of the science on “fast” and “slow” thinking
is that both processes contribute to decision
making, with fast processes, such as instinctive
emotional reactions, framing the slower
processes. Where possible, we will use our
fast processes for decision making such as
selecting a brand. But if and when our instinctive
responses are vague, muted, or absent, or
we are motivated to think carefully, slower
processing takes over.
The emotional responses evoked by
brands tend to be very modest.
2
POINT OF VIEW
The Disappearing Iceberg
SHARE
INSTANT MEANING
The nub of the challenge for brands is to create
an instant impression of the brand without
effortful thought. Few brands automatically
convey the type of meaning that allows people
to make the quick, effortless decisions that their
brains are wired to favor. The notable brands
that are the exception to the rule, the ones
that do create instantly relevant and positive
meaning, enjoy a major advantage over their
competitors. Volvo equals safety, Red Bull
is energy, Ikea is cost-effective style. Coke’s
relentless pursuit of “happiness” demonstrates
their ambition to create such an instinctive link.
Our mental workspace is incredibly limited.
Brands with instant meaning can get into that
workspace fast, allowing people to make quick
decisions and keep competitors from even
being considered.
Building instant meaning should be a key
objective for brands.
BUILDING ON RESEARCH
Most research encourages people to consider
their existing impressions of brands and then
try to construct something from them, such
as a personality or a set of values. We aren’t
actually testing their memories. When we ask
about the feelings generated by an ad or words
that apply to a brand, people aren’t digging
FROM DIGGING TO BUILDING
So where’s the rest of the iceberg? Perhaps
we need a better metaphor for people’s
impressions of brands and the role of research
in understanding them. For years it has been
assumed that the role of the researcher is
to dig—to go beneath the surface. This is
reflected in the language we use to describe
our analysis—we mine the data, we uncover
insights. But if there is relatively little to be
uncovered for many brands, perhaps this
concept is not serving us well.
A better metaphor might be that of construction,
of building on a foundation. When we ask
people to think about what comes to mind in
relation to a specific brand, most consumers
can come up with answers for all but the least-
known brands. They reflect on the associations
they do have, however modest they may be,
and extrapolate.
A construction metaphor may be more useful
to us than that of the iceberg. First, it’s a better
reflection of reality for most brands. Second,
it helps us better understand the nature and
task of research. Finally, it highlights not only
the challenge for most brands but also the
opportunity.
A construction metaphor may be
more useful to us than that of the
iceberg.
3
POINT OF VIEW
The Disappearing Iceberg
SHARE
GETTING THE GIST
We do know that it is the immediate gist of a
brand that counts for fast decisions. Research
questions are likely to be much more nuanced
than many of the associations that consumers
have in their minds, so looking across metrics
at the gist of the answers is likely to give a
much more meaningful insight than worrying
about whether people differentiated between
minutiae like “tastes delicious” and “has a
satisfying taste.” In our advertising and brand
research, Millward Brown has introduced
questions that focus on brand and advertising
gist rather than detail for just this reason.
Asking people in an open way for their brand
associations produces data that looks less rich
and detailed (e.g., Red Bull is energy) but is
a much more accurate view of what is in play
at the time of the decision. People can and do
answer long and complicated image grids, but
this reinforces a misleading impression of what
is going on at the moment of truth.
THE SELF-CONSTRUCTED WORLD
An iceberg is something to be wondered at and
studied. A brand is built by us, as marketers
and as consumers. Our brains are constantly
assembling thoughts and feelings in order to
into their memories for ideas they have filed
away. Instead, they are making judgments
about brands that they may never have made
before, and as they do this, they are telling
us something about the shape and nature of
the brand’s associations and what they might
mean in the real world. This is really as it
should be, since ultimately the consequences
of brand associations drive behavior, not the
associations themselves. Similarly, when
we ask people projective questions about
brands, we are not tapping a pre-established
set of values that have been subconsciously
processed—we are discovering the direction
and territory that a brand may be able to
occupy, and which will make intuitive sense to
people.
Critics of introspective research approaches
have correctly pointed out that in a research
situation, we ask people to engage with brands
and/or advertising in a much more conscious
and thoughtful way than they will in “real
life.” But that does not invalidate the results.
If people don’t register a brand’s intended
meaning or message when they are actively
thinking about it, it seems unlikely that they
would do so when they are not making an
effort.
Our brains are constantly
assembling thoughts and feelings
in order to make sense of the world
around us.
4
POINT OF VIEW
The Disappearing Iceberg
SHARE
about brands as it was about measuring what
they do think, we have realized the need for
better tools to measure real-world thinking.
The current surge in adoption of such tools
has allowed us to get to a more realistic view
of the impact of fast thinking for brands and
clarified one of the core aims of marketing: to
generate instant meaning. By using tools that
differentiate between what is easily accessible
in consumers’ minds versus what could be built
from that, we are better placed to give realistic
guidance and measurement. And marketers
would be wise to focus at least as much on the
alleged five percent as they do on what lies
below the surface.
make sense of the world around us. A building
metaphor is much more helpful for both
informing strategy and interpreting the “brand
constructs” people produce. And the metaphor
becomes more powerful for us as our research
incorporates approaches that measure fast
thinking and instinctive responses as well
as slow and effortful thinking. As we said
earlier, decision making uses both fast and
slow processes, with instinctive emotional
reactions framing and influencing the slower
processes—and the framing has a key impact
on the brands that consumers build.
BEYOND THE ICEBERG
Understanding the implications of new
cognitive science discoveries may have
challenged assumptions about what we do, but
the industry is better for it. By understanding
that our work has been as much about
measuring what consumers might think
If you enjoyed “The Disappearing
Iceberg,” you might also be
interested in:
“Ad Research Faces the Future”
“Why show faces to understand emotion
when you can watch them instead?”
“Watch Graham Page interviewed on
the BBC World News”
To read more about
mobile apps and digital
marketing, please visit
www.mb-blog.com.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Subin Associates New York Defendants in Infringment Complaint
Subin Associates New York Defendants in Infringment ComplaintSubin Associates New York Defendants in Infringment Complaint
Subin Associates New York Defendants in Infringment ComplaintSubin Associates
 
tai lieu ve nuoi cay thuy sinh
tai lieu ve nuoi cay thuy sinhtai lieu ve nuoi cay thuy sinh
tai lieu ve nuoi cay thuy sinhParadise Kiss
 
Blood & blood products
Blood & blood productsBlood & blood products
Blood & blood productsLaxinys
 
The Woodlands Real Estate Market Update 2013
The Woodlands Real Estate Market Update 2013The Woodlands Real Estate Market Update 2013
The Woodlands Real Estate Market Update 2013Tanya Lavoie Bugbee
 
Inatherm Company Profile
Inatherm Company ProfileInatherm Company Profile
Inatherm Company Profilewillemsikkers
 
ProgettiAMO IL FUTURO IVG
ProgettiAMO IL FUTURO IVGProgettiAMO IL FUTURO IVG
ProgettiAMO IL FUTURO IVGFilippo Curti
 
clean tech Industry Analysis
clean tech Industry Analysisclean tech Industry Analysis
clean tech Industry AnalysisManvindra Singh
 
Em que se tornaram estes jovens !
Em que se tornaram estes jovens !Em que se tornaram estes jovens !
Em que se tornaram estes jovens !Umberto Pacheco
 
Facebook戦略シート(地域開催分)
Facebook戦略シート(地域開催分)Facebook戦略シート(地域開催分)
Facebook戦略シート(地域開催分)Yuichi Morito
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Subin Associates New York Defendants in Infringment Complaint
Subin Associates New York Defendants in Infringment ComplaintSubin Associates New York Defendants in Infringment Complaint
Subin Associates New York Defendants in Infringment Complaint
 
tai lieu ve nuoi cay thuy sinh
tai lieu ve nuoi cay thuy sinhtai lieu ve nuoi cay thuy sinh
tai lieu ve nuoi cay thuy sinh
 
Kadirli
KadirliKadirli
Kadirli
 
La celula diapositiva
La  celula diapositivaLa  celula diapositiva
La celula diapositiva
 
Blood & blood products
Blood & blood productsBlood & blood products
Blood & blood products
 
The Woodlands Real Estate Market Update 2013
The Woodlands Real Estate Market Update 2013The Woodlands Real Estate Market Update 2013
The Woodlands Real Estate Market Update 2013
 
Elasticity
ElasticityElasticity
Elasticity
 
Inatherm Company Profile
Inatherm Company ProfileInatherm Company Profile
Inatherm Company Profile
 
ProgettiAMO IL FUTURO IVG
ProgettiAMO IL FUTURO IVGProgettiAMO IL FUTURO IVG
ProgettiAMO IL FUTURO IVG
 
clean tech Industry Analysis
clean tech Industry Analysisclean tech Industry Analysis
clean tech Industry Analysis
 
H O O P S & I M P A C T
H O O P S & I M P A C TH O O P S & I M P A C T
H O O P S & I M P A C T
 
Em que se tornaram estes jovens !
Em que se tornaram estes jovens !Em que se tornaram estes jovens !
Em que se tornaram estes jovens !
 
Facebook戦略シート(地域開催分)
Facebook戦略シート(地域開催分)Facebook戦略シート(地域開催分)
Facebook戦略シート(地域開催分)
 
La nostra scuola
La nostra scuolaLa nostra scuola
La nostra scuola
 
The Creative Edge, Ogilvy & Mather Asia Pacific
The Creative Edge, Ogilvy & Mather Asia PacificThe Creative Edge, Ogilvy & Mather Asia Pacific
The Creative Edge, Ogilvy & Mather Asia Pacific
 
Life scripts
Life scriptsLife scripts
Life scripts
 
Media movie1
Media movie1Media movie1
Media movie1
 

More from Kantar

BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017 by Martin Guerrieria, Global Brand...
BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017 by Martin Guerrieria, Global Brand...BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017 by Martin Guerrieria, Global Brand...
BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017 by Martin Guerrieria, Global Brand...Kantar
 
BrandZ™ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017
BrandZ™ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017BrandZ™ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017
BrandZ™ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017Kantar
 
The Power of Digital in Brand Building in South Africa
The Power of Digital in Brand Building in South AfricaThe Power of Digital in Brand Building in South Africa
The Power of Digital in Brand Building in South AfricaKantar
 
Keeping Your Cool
Keeping Your CoolKeeping Your Cool
Keeping Your CoolKantar
 
Future of Tracking: Transforming how we do it not what we do
Future of Tracking: Transforming how we do it not what we doFuture of Tracking: Transforming how we do it not what we do
Future of Tracking: Transforming how we do it not what we doKantar
 
Winning with Video in a Multiscreen World
Winning with Video in a Multiscreen WorldWinning with Video in a Multiscreen World
Winning with Video in a Multiscreen WorldKantar
 
AdReaction Gen X, Y and Z - Engaging across generations
AdReaction Gen X, Y and Z - Engaging across generationsAdReaction Gen X, Y and Z - Engaging across generations
AdReaction Gen X, Y and Z - Engaging across generationsKantar
 
The Lifeblood of Luxury Brand Success
The Lifeblood of Luxury Brand SuccessThe Lifeblood of Luxury Brand Success
The Lifeblood of Luxury Brand SuccessKantar
 
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Global Brands - Key Lessons over 11 Years
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Global Brands - Key Lessons over 11 YearsBrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Global Brands - Key Lessons over 11 Years
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Global Brands - Key Lessons over 11 YearsKantar
 
The Power of Corporate Brand from BrandZ
The Power of Corporate Brand from BrandZThe Power of Corporate Brand from BrandZ
The Power of Corporate Brand from BrandZKantar
 
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Chinese Brands 2016
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Chinese Brands 2016BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Chinese Brands 2016
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Chinese Brands 2016Kantar
 
#Gettingmediaright With Millward Brown
#Gettingmediaright With Millward Brown#Gettingmediaright With Millward Brown
#Gettingmediaright With Millward BrownKantar
 
THE UK Stars OF 2015’s Christmas Advertising - Infographic
THE UK Stars OF 2015’s Christmas Advertising - InfographicTHE UK Stars OF 2015’s Christmas Advertising - Infographic
THE UK Stars OF 2015’s Christmas Advertising - InfographicKantar
 
Ad Receptivity: An Inconvenient Truth
Ad Receptivity:  An Inconvenient TruthAd Receptivity:  An Inconvenient Truth
Ad Receptivity: An Inconvenient TruthKantar
 
Drive More Brand Spend Into Digital
Drive More Brand Spend Into DigitalDrive More Brand Spend Into Digital
Drive More Brand Spend Into DigitalKantar
 
How Technology And New Platforms Are Changing Brand Communications
How Technology And New Platforms Are Changing Brand CommunicationsHow Technology And New Platforms Are Changing Brand Communications
How Technology And New Platforms Are Changing Brand CommunicationsKantar
 
Is It The Death Or Rebirth Of Digital Advertising?
Is It The Death Or Rebirth Of Digital Advertising?Is It The Death Or Rebirth Of Digital Advertising?
Is It The Death Or Rebirth Of Digital Advertising?Kantar
 
Insights2020: Driving Customer-Centric Business Growth
Insights2020: Driving Customer-Centric Business Growth Insights2020: Driving Customer-Centric Business Growth
Insights2020: Driving Customer-Centric Business Growth Kantar
 
Millward Brown AdReaction: Video Creative in a Digital World Global Report
Millward Brown AdReaction: Video Creative in a Digital World Global ReportMillward Brown AdReaction: Video Creative in a Digital World Global Report
Millward Brown AdReaction: Video Creative in a Digital World Global ReportKantar
 
The top media trends that consumers don’t even know about
The top media trends that consumers don’t even know aboutThe top media trends that consumers don’t even know about
The top media trends that consumers don’t even know aboutKantar
 

More from Kantar (20)

BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017 by Martin Guerrieria, Global Brand...
BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017 by Martin Guerrieria, Global Brand...BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017 by Martin Guerrieria, Global Brand...
BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017 by Martin Guerrieria, Global Brand...
 
BrandZ™ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017
BrandZ™ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017BrandZ™ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017
BrandZ™ Top 50 Most Valuable UK Brands 2017
 
The Power of Digital in Brand Building in South Africa
The Power of Digital in Brand Building in South AfricaThe Power of Digital in Brand Building in South Africa
The Power of Digital in Brand Building in South Africa
 
Keeping Your Cool
Keeping Your CoolKeeping Your Cool
Keeping Your Cool
 
Future of Tracking: Transforming how we do it not what we do
Future of Tracking: Transforming how we do it not what we doFuture of Tracking: Transforming how we do it not what we do
Future of Tracking: Transforming how we do it not what we do
 
Winning with Video in a Multiscreen World
Winning with Video in a Multiscreen WorldWinning with Video in a Multiscreen World
Winning with Video in a Multiscreen World
 
AdReaction Gen X, Y and Z - Engaging across generations
AdReaction Gen X, Y and Z - Engaging across generationsAdReaction Gen X, Y and Z - Engaging across generations
AdReaction Gen X, Y and Z - Engaging across generations
 
The Lifeblood of Luxury Brand Success
The Lifeblood of Luxury Brand SuccessThe Lifeblood of Luxury Brand Success
The Lifeblood of Luxury Brand Success
 
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Global Brands - Key Lessons over 11 Years
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Global Brands - Key Lessons over 11 YearsBrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Global Brands - Key Lessons over 11 Years
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Global Brands - Key Lessons over 11 Years
 
The Power of Corporate Brand from BrandZ
The Power of Corporate Brand from BrandZThe Power of Corporate Brand from BrandZ
The Power of Corporate Brand from BrandZ
 
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Chinese Brands 2016
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Chinese Brands 2016BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Chinese Brands 2016
BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable Chinese Brands 2016
 
#Gettingmediaright With Millward Brown
#Gettingmediaright With Millward Brown#Gettingmediaright With Millward Brown
#Gettingmediaright With Millward Brown
 
THE UK Stars OF 2015’s Christmas Advertising - Infographic
THE UK Stars OF 2015’s Christmas Advertising - InfographicTHE UK Stars OF 2015’s Christmas Advertising - Infographic
THE UK Stars OF 2015’s Christmas Advertising - Infographic
 
Ad Receptivity: An Inconvenient Truth
Ad Receptivity:  An Inconvenient TruthAd Receptivity:  An Inconvenient Truth
Ad Receptivity: An Inconvenient Truth
 
Drive More Brand Spend Into Digital
Drive More Brand Spend Into DigitalDrive More Brand Spend Into Digital
Drive More Brand Spend Into Digital
 
How Technology And New Platforms Are Changing Brand Communications
How Technology And New Platforms Are Changing Brand CommunicationsHow Technology And New Platforms Are Changing Brand Communications
How Technology And New Platforms Are Changing Brand Communications
 
Is It The Death Or Rebirth Of Digital Advertising?
Is It The Death Or Rebirth Of Digital Advertising?Is It The Death Or Rebirth Of Digital Advertising?
Is It The Death Or Rebirth Of Digital Advertising?
 
Insights2020: Driving Customer-Centric Business Growth
Insights2020: Driving Customer-Centric Business Growth Insights2020: Driving Customer-Centric Business Growth
Insights2020: Driving Customer-Centric Business Growth
 
Millward Brown AdReaction: Video Creative in a Digital World Global Report
Millward Brown AdReaction: Video Creative in a Digital World Global ReportMillward Brown AdReaction: Video Creative in a Digital World Global Report
Millward Brown AdReaction: Video Creative in a Digital World Global Report
 
The top media trends that consumers don’t even know about
The top media trends that consumers don’t even know aboutThe top media trends that consumers don’t even know about
The top media trends that consumers don’t even know about
 

Recently uploaded

Ice Cream Brand Harmony Study - TINT Emotional Profiling Research
Ice Cream Brand Harmony Study - TINT Emotional Profiling ResearchIce Cream Brand Harmony Study - TINT Emotional Profiling Research
Ice Cream Brand Harmony Study - TINT Emotional Profiling ResearchTINT Marketing
 
What's Happening with Your Microsoft Advertising's Search Campaigns? - Sophie...
What's Happening with Your Microsoft Advertising's Search Campaigns? - Sophie...What's Happening with Your Microsoft Advertising's Search Campaigns? - Sophie...
What's Happening with Your Microsoft Advertising's Search Campaigns? - Sophie...Sophie Logan
 
Dhanuka Agritech Limited - Sales and Marketing Intern
Dhanuka Agritech Limited - Sales and Marketing InternDhanuka Agritech Limited - Sales and Marketing Intern
Dhanuka Agritech Limited - Sales and Marketing Internrisabhpandeyconnect
 
Ppt regarding of Digital Marketing cours
Ppt regarding of Digital Marketing coursPpt regarding of Digital Marketing cours
Ppt regarding of Digital Marketing courstegveersingh09
 
SVETLANA YONCHEVA Evolution of digital marketing.pdf
SVETLANA YONCHEVA Evolution of digital marketing.pdfSVETLANA YONCHEVA Evolution of digital marketing.pdf
SVETLANA YONCHEVA Evolution of digital marketing.pdfvikrs213
 
Unifying feature management with experiments - Server Side Webinar (1).pdf
Unifying feature management with experiments - Server Side Webinar (1).pdfUnifying feature management with experiments - Server Side Webinar (1).pdf
Unifying feature management with experiments - Server Side Webinar (1).pdfVWO
 
scope in Digital Marketing & advertising
scope in Digital Marketing & advertisingscope in Digital Marketing & advertising
scope in Digital Marketing & advertisingKBS SHOP
 
Elevate Your Design Skills: Enroll in Pune's Premier UI/UX Design Course
Elevate Your Design Skills: Enroll in Pune's Premier UI/UX Design CourseElevate Your Design Skills: Enroll in Pune's Premier UI/UX Design Course
Elevate Your Design Skills: Enroll in Pune's Premier UI/UX Design Courseamirshaikhv21realtyp
 
TAM AdEx-A Pixelated view into Digital Advertising Trends for Y 2023.pdf
TAM AdEx-A Pixelated view into Digital Advertising Trends for Y 2023.pdfTAM AdEx-A Pixelated view into Digital Advertising Trends for Y 2023.pdf
TAM AdEx-A Pixelated view into Digital Advertising Trends for Y 2023.pdfSocial Samosa
 
The best Crypto Marketing Strategies pdf
The best Crypto Marketing Strategies pdfThe best Crypto Marketing Strategies pdf
The best Crypto Marketing Strategies pdfShifali roy
 
Top 15 Emerging Technologies for the Modern World
Top 15 Emerging Technologies for the Modern WorldTop 15 Emerging Technologies for the Modern World
Top 15 Emerging Technologies for the Modern WorldD Cloud Solutions
 
Crafting High-Converting eCommerce Landing Pages
Crafting High-Converting eCommerce Landing PagesCrafting High-Converting eCommerce Landing Pages
Crafting High-Converting eCommerce Landing PagesVWO
 
A_B Testing Personalized Meditation Recommendations.pdf
A_B Testing Personalized Meditation Recommendations.pdfA_B Testing Personalized Meditation Recommendations.pdf
A_B Testing Personalized Meditation Recommendations.pdfVWO
 
Marketing Team of 1, A Framework To Win!
Marketing Team of 1, A Framework To Win!Marketing Team of 1, A Framework To Win!
Marketing Team of 1, A Framework To Win!Joseph Skibbie
 
Cricket Playbook for Growth Marketers: Adjust x Glance report
Cricket Playbook for Growth Marketers: Adjust x Glance reportCricket Playbook for Growth Marketers: Adjust x Glance report
Cricket Playbook for Growth Marketers: Adjust x Glance reportSocial Samosa
 
A navigation of two creative processes Study
A navigation of two creative processes StudyA navigation of two creative processes Study
A navigation of two creative processes Studystuwilson.co.uk
 
2024 Google SERP Features: New Strategies To Gain Visibility
2024 Google SERP Features: New Strategies To Gain Visibility2024 Google SERP Features: New Strategies To Gain Visibility
2024 Google SERP Features: New Strategies To Gain VisibilitySearch Engine Journal
 
Increase Your Website Sales & Leads Webinar
Increase Your Website Sales & Leads WebinarIncrease Your Website Sales & Leads Webinar
Increase Your Website Sales & Leads WebinarSEO Optimizers
 
ToShare_UG 13_03_24_Full_BelgianTrailblazerCommunity.pptx
ToShare_UG 13_03_24_Full_BelgianTrailblazerCommunity.pptxToShare_UG 13_03_24_Full_BelgianTrailblazerCommunity.pptx
ToShare_UG 13_03_24_Full_BelgianTrailblazerCommunity.pptxivanrazine1
 
The 2024 Next Gen Attention Study - www.livewire.group
The 2024 Next Gen Attention Study - www.livewire.groupThe 2024 Next Gen Attention Study - www.livewire.group
The 2024 Next Gen Attention Study - www.livewire.groupLivewire
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Ice Cream Brand Harmony Study - TINT Emotional Profiling Research
Ice Cream Brand Harmony Study - TINT Emotional Profiling ResearchIce Cream Brand Harmony Study - TINT Emotional Profiling Research
Ice Cream Brand Harmony Study - TINT Emotional Profiling Research
 
What's Happening with Your Microsoft Advertising's Search Campaigns? - Sophie...
What's Happening with Your Microsoft Advertising's Search Campaigns? - Sophie...What's Happening with Your Microsoft Advertising's Search Campaigns? - Sophie...
What's Happening with Your Microsoft Advertising's Search Campaigns? - Sophie...
 
Dhanuka Agritech Limited - Sales and Marketing Intern
Dhanuka Agritech Limited - Sales and Marketing InternDhanuka Agritech Limited - Sales and Marketing Intern
Dhanuka Agritech Limited - Sales and Marketing Intern
 
Ppt regarding of Digital Marketing cours
Ppt regarding of Digital Marketing coursPpt regarding of Digital Marketing cours
Ppt regarding of Digital Marketing cours
 
SVETLANA YONCHEVA Evolution of digital marketing.pdf
SVETLANA YONCHEVA Evolution of digital marketing.pdfSVETLANA YONCHEVA Evolution of digital marketing.pdf
SVETLANA YONCHEVA Evolution of digital marketing.pdf
 
Unifying feature management with experiments - Server Side Webinar (1).pdf
Unifying feature management with experiments - Server Side Webinar (1).pdfUnifying feature management with experiments - Server Side Webinar (1).pdf
Unifying feature management with experiments - Server Side Webinar (1).pdf
 
scope in Digital Marketing & advertising
scope in Digital Marketing & advertisingscope in Digital Marketing & advertising
scope in Digital Marketing & advertising
 
Elevate Your Design Skills: Enroll in Pune's Premier UI/UX Design Course
Elevate Your Design Skills: Enroll in Pune's Premier UI/UX Design CourseElevate Your Design Skills: Enroll in Pune's Premier UI/UX Design Course
Elevate Your Design Skills: Enroll in Pune's Premier UI/UX Design Course
 
TAM AdEx-A Pixelated view into Digital Advertising Trends for Y 2023.pdf
TAM AdEx-A Pixelated view into Digital Advertising Trends for Y 2023.pdfTAM AdEx-A Pixelated view into Digital Advertising Trends for Y 2023.pdf
TAM AdEx-A Pixelated view into Digital Advertising Trends for Y 2023.pdf
 
The best Crypto Marketing Strategies pdf
The best Crypto Marketing Strategies pdfThe best Crypto Marketing Strategies pdf
The best Crypto Marketing Strategies pdf
 
Top 15 Emerging Technologies for the Modern World
Top 15 Emerging Technologies for the Modern WorldTop 15 Emerging Technologies for the Modern World
Top 15 Emerging Technologies for the Modern World
 
Crafting High-Converting eCommerce Landing Pages
Crafting High-Converting eCommerce Landing PagesCrafting High-Converting eCommerce Landing Pages
Crafting High-Converting eCommerce Landing Pages
 
A_B Testing Personalized Meditation Recommendations.pdf
A_B Testing Personalized Meditation Recommendations.pdfA_B Testing Personalized Meditation Recommendations.pdf
A_B Testing Personalized Meditation Recommendations.pdf
 
Marketing Team of 1, A Framework To Win!
Marketing Team of 1, A Framework To Win!Marketing Team of 1, A Framework To Win!
Marketing Team of 1, A Framework To Win!
 
Cricket Playbook for Growth Marketers: Adjust x Glance report
Cricket Playbook for Growth Marketers: Adjust x Glance reportCricket Playbook for Growth Marketers: Adjust x Glance report
Cricket Playbook for Growth Marketers: Adjust x Glance report
 
A navigation of two creative processes Study
A navigation of two creative processes StudyA navigation of two creative processes Study
A navigation of two creative processes Study
 
2024 Google SERP Features: New Strategies To Gain Visibility
2024 Google SERP Features: New Strategies To Gain Visibility2024 Google SERP Features: New Strategies To Gain Visibility
2024 Google SERP Features: New Strategies To Gain Visibility
 
Increase Your Website Sales & Leads Webinar
Increase Your Website Sales & Leads WebinarIncrease Your Website Sales & Leads Webinar
Increase Your Website Sales & Leads Webinar
 
ToShare_UG 13_03_24_Full_BelgianTrailblazerCommunity.pptx
ToShare_UG 13_03_24_Full_BelgianTrailblazerCommunity.pptxToShare_UG 13_03_24_Full_BelgianTrailblazerCommunity.pptx
ToShare_UG 13_03_24_Full_BelgianTrailblazerCommunity.pptx
 
The 2024 Next Gen Attention Study - www.livewire.group
The 2024 Next Gen Attention Study - www.livewire.groupThe 2024 Next Gen Attention Study - www.livewire.group
The 2024 Next Gen Attention Study - www.livewire.group
 

The Disappearing Iceberg

  • 1. 1 POINT OF VIEW The Disappearing Iceberg SHARE But really, results of new research show that there is nowhere near as much beneath the surface as the iceberg image suggests. What the new science actually seems to challenge is the metaphor of the iceberg itself. 95 PERCENT WRONG The iceberg concept is supported by the idea, often cited as a fact, that “95 percent of what the brain does is unconscious.” This is said with the clearly intended implication that 95 percent of brand decision making is unconscious. Thus—if this were true—marketers would need to focus almost exclusively on subconscious processes to truly understand consumers and influence their buying decisions. However, the 95 percent figure is just a hypothetical concept. There seem to be no scientific papers that substantiate this number. It is undoubtedly true that a huge amount of the brain’s energy is consumed by processes below the level of awareness, but many of these processes have to do with biological regulation and low-level sensory processing, not decision making. Neither does the 95 percent figure fit with evidence from our study of brands. When we apply tools that tap into automatic, non- conscious processes, we don’t find evidence of a bubbling mass of associations and responses. The Disappearing Iceberg It has become a mantra:“Recent learning from cognitive science is challenging long-held assumptions of the market research industry.”And the mantra is true—but not in the way most people think. The typical assumption is that new research into fast, instinctive processing supports the idea that people’s considered responses to survey questions are just the tip of the iceberg—that the bulk of the meaning that brands hold for people is below the surface. Graham Page Head of Global Research Solutions graham.page@millwardbrown.com www.millwardbrown.com We have deployed these types of tools on hundreds of projects in the last few years, and what they actually show us is that few brands evoke many ideas or responses without much effort. For instance, we have used a variation of the Harvard Implicit Association Test to measure instinctive emotional responses to brands. Compared to the strong responses elicited by happy pictures of family and children (which are positive) and snakes, starving children, and Hitler (which are negative), the emotional responses evoked by brands tend to be very modest (and either neutral or mildly positive). These findings are in fact entirely consistent with the cognitive science that sparked the discussion on changing assumptions. The core of the science on “fast” and “slow” thinking is that both processes contribute to decision making, with fast processes, such as instinctive emotional reactions, framing the slower processes. Where possible, we will use our fast processes for decision making such as selecting a brand. But if and when our instinctive responses are vague, muted, or absent, or we are motivated to think carefully, slower processing takes over. The emotional responses evoked by brands tend to be very modest.
  • 2. 2 POINT OF VIEW The Disappearing Iceberg SHARE INSTANT MEANING The nub of the challenge for brands is to create an instant impression of the brand without effortful thought. Few brands automatically convey the type of meaning that allows people to make the quick, effortless decisions that their brains are wired to favor. The notable brands that are the exception to the rule, the ones that do create instantly relevant and positive meaning, enjoy a major advantage over their competitors. Volvo equals safety, Red Bull is energy, Ikea is cost-effective style. Coke’s relentless pursuit of “happiness” demonstrates their ambition to create such an instinctive link. Our mental workspace is incredibly limited. Brands with instant meaning can get into that workspace fast, allowing people to make quick decisions and keep competitors from even being considered. Building instant meaning should be a key objective for brands. BUILDING ON RESEARCH Most research encourages people to consider their existing impressions of brands and then try to construct something from them, such as a personality or a set of values. We aren’t actually testing their memories. When we ask about the feelings generated by an ad or words that apply to a brand, people aren’t digging FROM DIGGING TO BUILDING So where’s the rest of the iceberg? Perhaps we need a better metaphor for people’s impressions of brands and the role of research in understanding them. For years it has been assumed that the role of the researcher is to dig—to go beneath the surface. This is reflected in the language we use to describe our analysis—we mine the data, we uncover insights. But if there is relatively little to be uncovered for many brands, perhaps this concept is not serving us well. A better metaphor might be that of construction, of building on a foundation. When we ask people to think about what comes to mind in relation to a specific brand, most consumers can come up with answers for all but the least- known brands. They reflect on the associations they do have, however modest they may be, and extrapolate. A construction metaphor may be more useful to us than that of the iceberg. First, it’s a better reflection of reality for most brands. Second, it helps us better understand the nature and task of research. Finally, it highlights not only the challenge for most brands but also the opportunity. A construction metaphor may be more useful to us than that of the iceberg.
  • 3. 3 POINT OF VIEW The Disappearing Iceberg SHARE GETTING THE GIST We do know that it is the immediate gist of a brand that counts for fast decisions. Research questions are likely to be much more nuanced than many of the associations that consumers have in their minds, so looking across metrics at the gist of the answers is likely to give a much more meaningful insight than worrying about whether people differentiated between minutiae like “tastes delicious” and “has a satisfying taste.” In our advertising and brand research, Millward Brown has introduced questions that focus on brand and advertising gist rather than detail for just this reason. Asking people in an open way for their brand associations produces data that looks less rich and detailed (e.g., Red Bull is energy) but is a much more accurate view of what is in play at the time of the decision. People can and do answer long and complicated image grids, but this reinforces a misleading impression of what is going on at the moment of truth. THE SELF-CONSTRUCTED WORLD An iceberg is something to be wondered at and studied. A brand is built by us, as marketers and as consumers. Our brains are constantly assembling thoughts and feelings in order to into their memories for ideas they have filed away. Instead, they are making judgments about brands that they may never have made before, and as they do this, they are telling us something about the shape and nature of the brand’s associations and what they might mean in the real world. This is really as it should be, since ultimately the consequences of brand associations drive behavior, not the associations themselves. Similarly, when we ask people projective questions about brands, we are not tapping a pre-established set of values that have been subconsciously processed—we are discovering the direction and territory that a brand may be able to occupy, and which will make intuitive sense to people. Critics of introspective research approaches have correctly pointed out that in a research situation, we ask people to engage with brands and/or advertising in a much more conscious and thoughtful way than they will in “real life.” But that does not invalidate the results. If people don’t register a brand’s intended meaning or message when they are actively thinking about it, it seems unlikely that they would do so when they are not making an effort. Our brains are constantly assembling thoughts and feelings in order to make sense of the world around us.
  • 4. 4 POINT OF VIEW The Disappearing Iceberg SHARE about brands as it was about measuring what they do think, we have realized the need for better tools to measure real-world thinking. The current surge in adoption of such tools has allowed us to get to a more realistic view of the impact of fast thinking for brands and clarified one of the core aims of marketing: to generate instant meaning. By using tools that differentiate between what is easily accessible in consumers’ minds versus what could be built from that, we are better placed to give realistic guidance and measurement. And marketers would be wise to focus at least as much on the alleged five percent as they do on what lies below the surface. make sense of the world around us. A building metaphor is much more helpful for both informing strategy and interpreting the “brand constructs” people produce. And the metaphor becomes more powerful for us as our research incorporates approaches that measure fast thinking and instinctive responses as well as slow and effortful thinking. As we said earlier, decision making uses both fast and slow processes, with instinctive emotional reactions framing and influencing the slower processes—and the framing has a key impact on the brands that consumers build. BEYOND THE ICEBERG Understanding the implications of new cognitive science discoveries may have challenged assumptions about what we do, but the industry is better for it. By understanding that our work has been as much about measuring what consumers might think If you enjoyed “The Disappearing Iceberg,” you might also be interested in: “Ad Research Faces the Future” “Why show faces to understand emotion when you can watch them instead?” “Watch Graham Page interviewed on the BBC World News” To read more about mobile apps and digital marketing, please visit www.mb-blog.com.