SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
501
                                   CARPET IN EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES:
                                                              CARPE T END USE SEGMENTS



                               LE AR N I N G O B J EC TIVE S
                               ■    Evaluate how students and teachers feel about carpet.
                               ■    Show how carpet helped improve student achievement at Charles Young
                                    Elementary School.
                               ■    List some physical and non-physical benefits of carpeting for classrooms.
                               ■    Offer ways to improve acoustics in schools.
                               ■    List ways that carpet contributes to good indoor air quality.
                               ■    Describe why carpet is a good flooring choice for schools.




                                                                                    Jenkins • Peer Architects

SCH O O L S I N TH E U. S . A .
Statistics
In the United States, approximately 120,000 schools provide for the educational needs of at least 54 million students.
On average, students receive 20% of their environmental exposure in schools.

According to a 2002 research report, the US General Accounting Office indicated a national need of over 100
billion dollars for the restoration of public elementary and secondary schools. The rehabilitations are crucial for the
health, safety, and comfort of students and staff: 50% of public school facilities throughout the United States have
environmental problems caused by water intrusion, inefficient HVAC systems, and ineffective or non-existent
cleaning programs. However, the use of the appropriate carpet can contribute in creating healthy learning
environments in all of these schools.




                             Course 000501, HSW/SD, Provider G391                          Course #5715, Subject Code 5.8, General Knowledge


                   “Carpet in Acute Care Facilities” is one of a series of CEU courses about the benefits of carpet in various commercial
                   end use segments, developed by the Carpet and Rug Institute, the national trade association for the flooring industry.
                   Use the learning objectives above to focus your study. To earn one AIA/CES Learning Unit, including one hour of
                   health safety welfare/sustainable design (HSW/SD) credit or 1.0 CEU credits with IDCEC, answer the questions at the
                   end of this booklet and follow the reporting instructions for submitting your registration and response information
                   to the Carpet and Rug Institute.



The Carpet and Rug Institute           |   Box 2048      |   Dalton, GA 30722         |   carpet-rug.org          |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
2
                                                               Schools are Centers for the Community
                                                               According to the National Clearinghouse for Education Facilities, the
                                                               latest design trend for schools makes them centers for the community.
                                                               Classrooms and other school facilities often serve as ideal places for
                                                               community-sponsored events, club meetings, after school functions,
                                                               and extra-curricular activities. These endeavors make better use of
                                                               facilities that already exist and lend students and teachers increased
                                                               exposure to the school setting.




                               Jenk ins • Peer Architec ts
                                                               But limited funds make it tempting for school officials to overlook the
                                                               importance of design features in classrooms, failing to consider design
                                                               benefits for children, teachers, and people in the community who
                                                               might use the schools on a regular basis.



                                                               Survey of Teachers
                                                               In 2000, Beth Schapiro & Associates, a research firm based in Atlanta,
                                                               administered a national survey to 1,050 public school teachers.
                                                               “The results of the survey indicate that teachers across the country
                                                               and from all grade levels realize that a well-designed classroom
                                                               enhances their ability to teach and their students’ ability to learn.
                                                               The results also suggest that most teachers see the advantages of
                                                               carpet in the classroom, particularly the acoustics, comfort, and
                                                               flexibility of carpet.” (Beth Schapiro & Associates, 2001)
                               Jenk ins • Peer Architec ts




                                                               More specifically, the survey revealed the following about teachers’
                                                               experience of design:
                                                               ■ 92% think classroom design strongly impacts achievement.
                                                               ■ 18% gave their rooms an ‘A’ for design.
                                                               ■ 99% said school design is important for learning.
                                                               ■ 89% said design is incentive for teachers to stay.
                                                               ■ 79% think design is important for student attendance.




The Carpet and Rug Institute   |                             Box 2048   |   Dalton, GA 30722    |   carpet-rug.org    |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
3

                                 Elementary School Case Study
                                 “In many ways, the list of criteria for healthy, high-performance school environments
                                 parallels the list of carpet’s recognized benefits,” notes Frank Hurd, Vice President and
                                 Chief Operating Officer of the Carpet and Rug Institute, in a recent article on flooring
                                 in high performance schools, written for the Educational Facility Planner. (Hurd, 2009)
                                 In the article, Hurd elucidates the ways in which carpet meets the list of criteria:

                              “Carpet has contributed to high-quality school environments for many years. Valued by
                              educational facility designers for its color and design flexibility, carpet’s softness makes
     it a safer as well as more comfortable flooring choice. In a classroom, carpet reduces noise, defines learning
     areas, and cuts down glare. In terms of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), carpet is one of the lowest-
     emitting of all building materials, and multiple studies demonstrate how clean, dry, carpet actually contributes
     to improved indoor air quality. Hard science illustrates how carpet in schools helps create environments where
     teachers are happy to teach and students are excited about learning.” (Hurd, 2009) Hurd goes on to illustrate
     the ways in which carpet provides visual, thermal and acoustic comfort, ease of maintenance, material/energy
     efficiency and increased safety.

     In another study, Michael A. Berry, research professor at U.N.C. Chapel Hill, conducted a case study* of the
     restoration of the Charles Young Elementary School in Washington, D.C. The impetus for the study was the
     increasing research indicating several levels of relationship between educational performance and the
     environmental quality of schools. More precisely, as stated by Dr. Berry,
     ■ Facility management systems determine environmental quality in schools.
     ■ The quality of the school environment shapes attitudes of students, teachers and staff.
     ■ Attitudes affect teaching and learning behavior.
     ■ Behavior affects performance.
     ■ Educational performance determines future outcomes of individuals and society as a whole. (Berry, 2002)

     To implement the research, the school installed more than 45,000 square feet of new carpet to create
     attractive, comfortable, open classrooms free of glare and noise. In addition to installation, the carpet
     industry donated effective vacuums, carpet cleaning equipment, supplies, maintenance schedules, and proper
     training, so that future carpet issues could be prevented. These changes, supplies and training allowed the
     school to meet the essential environmental criteria for a comfortable, constructive setting for learning:
     adequate space and ample, natural lighting, clean, inviting appearance and student-friendly conditions –
     which support both student and teacher retention – low noise levels and a consistent, comfortable
     temperature.

     Through the study Dr. Berry found an “obvious link between students’ environment and educational
     performance.” (Berry, 2002) The Charles Young Elementary School became a model for other schools.
     Communication ability improved between students and teachers. More importantly, standardized test
     scores in math and reading, done before and after the restoration, confirmed a dramatic improvement
     in student performance post-restoration.

     Notably, twenty-five percent of the students improved their test scores from “below basic” to “basic” or higher
     levels. A portion of this study, published in the proceedings of Indoor Air 2002*, found the higher test scores
     partially attributable to the school’s more comfortable and inviting mixed-carpeted environment.

     *A new independent case study is underway and results will be published at a later date.




The Carpet and Rug Institute            |   Box 2048     |   Dalton, GA 30722          |   carpet-rug.org   |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
4

           Accurate Information about Carpet in Schools
           Many schools have used carpet as a preferred floor covering for many years because of
           its enhancing features – comfort, warmth, noise control, glare reduction, and protection from
           slips and falls.

           However, there are misperceptions that carpet contributes to unhealthy indoor air quality
           because it cannot be properly maintained in schools. But in fact, carpet is easier and less
           expensive to maintain than hard-surface flooring, and independent research studies indicate
           that clean carpet poses no health risk in schools or any other environment.

           Given considerable debate about the most appropriate flooring material for use in schools,
           in IAQ Design Tools for Schools, the EPA recognizes existing advantages and disadvantages
           associated with all types of floor coverings. For example, carpet offers acoustical and comfort
           benefits not usually available with other floor coverings. Regular and effective cleaning and
           maintenance are essential for any type of floor covering.




           Replacing Carpet with Hard Surface Floors
           As the Charles Young School study points out, under-funded operating budgets and limited
           long-term accountability for the decision-making outcome leads to misguided restoration
           policies. The decision to replace carpet with hard floors dodges the issue and responsibility
           of effective cleaning, as pollutants rest on hard surfaces and are easily kicked up into indoor
           air. Lower morale and poorer health ensue, working against the learning process.

           The study of the Charles Young Elementary School examines the connection between morale
           of students and the environmental condition of the school. Studies show that academically
           successful schools foster a sense of well being, and this sense is the essence of a healthy
           environment. Therefore, care should be taken in discontinuing the use of carpet in schools,
           as students, teachers, and staff need an elevated level of comfort in their teaching and
           learning environments. Carpeting offers soft surfaces on which to stand for long hours,
           warm and energizing colors, glare reduction, and most importantly, noise control.




The Carpet and Rug Institute     |   Box 2048   |   Dalton, GA 30722     |   carpet-rug.org   |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
5

TH E B E N E FITS O F C AR PET

Physical Benefits
According to Dr. Lorraine Maxwell, professor of human-environment
relations at Cornell University, “Children have different responses to
various classroom settings, which is why it is so important to make sure
their classrooms are designed to stimulate them in the best possible way.
Ways to make a classroom more comfortable include having carpet on the
floor, windows to let in natural light, assorted classroom arrangements,
and ample space to work comfortably.”

Beth Schapiro & Associates’ national survey of teachers (2000), also high-
lighted safety, comfort, lighting, acoustics, and climate control as the top
five classroom design elements impacting the learning environment.

Teachers overwhelmingly listed carpet as an important design feature
because it
■    Provides comfortable seating for students
■    Makes floor areas usable workspace
■    Provides a soft, quiet environment
■    Gives overall comfort
■    Helps reduce glare
■    Minimizes risk of injury, accidents and slips and falls

The final point deserves additional attention: the survey also found that teachers categorize
carpet’s ability to minimize the risk of accidents as its main benefit.

The U.S. Consumer Product Commission reported that more people die of indoor falls than
any other kind of accident. According to Dr. Alan Hedge, Professor of Department of Design
and Environmental analysis at Cornell University, the falls due to slips and tripping rank as the
second leading cause of accidental death in the United States. (Hurd, 2009) Furthermore, these
accidents are equally distributed between work and home, and children aged 10 and younger
were the second age group most likely to be injured by falls.

In wet conditions the risk of a slip on hard surfaces is twice that of carpet because carpet
increases surface traction. Plus, hard surfaces are less forgiving and more likely to result in more
injury. Yet there has been a trend away from carpet in schools, particularly in hallways and on
stairs where the majority of falling accidents occur. In other words, slick hard surfaces become
accidents waiting to happen during the commotion and bustle of rainy school mornings. With
less glare, extra traction, added cushioning, a softer landing, and fewer injuries, carpet’s ability
to prevent falls and therefore minimize liability makes it a good flooring choice.




    The Carpet and Rug Institute        |   Box 2048    |   Dalton, GA 30722   |   carpet-rug.org      |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
6

TO P 5 WAYS TO I M PROVE CL ASS ROOM ACOUSTI CS
Inattention in students may not always be caused by learning or behavioral disorders. Sometimes noise level prevents a
student from hearing properly and/or assimilating lessons. Note the following five ways to improve classroom acoustics.

1. Carefully select and design air-conditioning systems.
2. Limit room ceiling height.
3. Use sound-absorbing surfaces throughout rooms.
4. Install carpeting instead of hard floors.
5. Emphasize teacher training, smaller class sizes, and better room environments.



                                       Non-Physical Benefits
                                       A high performance school is designed to reduce stress, as lowered stress
                                       results in higher performance. Design features like carpet enhance aesthetics
                                       and comfort and send a message of care and concern, thereby epitomizing
                                       a well-managed school.

                                       Acoustic Benefits
                                       Noise affects learning negatively. Carpet’s capacity to absorb sound and muffle
                                       background noise allows students to hear better, pay attention more, and think
                                       more clearly while learning.

                                       In a 1995 survey by the General Accounting Office, school administrators
                                       ranked poor acoustics as the most significant problem affecting the learning
                                       environment. Researchers at a 1997 conference of the Acoustical Society of
                                       America presented the following evidence: excessive noise levels impair
                                       a young child’s speech perception, reading and spelling ability, behavior,
                                       attention and overall academic performance. Ongoing studies continue
                                       to support these findings.

  Gary Sieben, Professor of Architecture at the University of Florida and one of the world’s foremost experts on
  architectural acoustics, along with Professors Carl Crandell and Mary Jo Hassel, set out to identify and cure
  acoustical problems in classrooms. They studied what students were and were not hearing, and why. Startlingly
  they found that “Students beyond the first or second row in a typical classroom hear only 50 percent” of
  what their teachers say.

  The Canadian Association of Speech-Language Pathologists and Audiologists (CASLPA) also warn that noisy
  classrooms strongly affect a child’s ability to learn as well as a teacher’s ability to teach. Results from a
  Canadian Language and Literacy Research Network study show that “one in six words is not understood
  by the average Grade 1 student due to excessive background noise and poor acoustics in Canadian
  classrooms.” (D’Aoust, 2007)

  Carpet improves this ratio. For example, in the case study of the Charles Young School, students’ reading skills
  improved because of “open classes and flexibility of teaching associated with total usable space that includes
  the floors.” (CRI Technical Services)




            The Carpet and Rug Institute       |   Box 2048   |   Dalton, GA 30722    |   carpet-rug.org   |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
7
The State of California has conducted research revealing that effective sound control in
open spaces is “virtually impossible to achieve” without carpet. (State of California, 1998)
In fact, according to a study by the American Society of Interior Designers, carpet is 10 times
more effective in reducing noise than other types of flooring. Noise levels can be reduced
even more when polyurethane cushioned backing is added to the carpet. (Carpet Scores
Good Marks in Schools, 2008)

Maintenance Cost Effectiveness
The installation of hard-surface flooring and its ensuing high-cost, labor-intensive maintenance
plagues school budgets. Maintenance costs include labor, materials, and equipment. Planners
need to look beyond the initial cost when choosing flooring because “inexpensive” floors can
quickly become expensive floors. To keep costs down, it is critical that schools conduct cost
benefit flooring analyses and develop awareness of the economic benefits of carpeting.

According to Canadian Facility Management & Design (April 2002) “Maintenance is the single
most costly element in most floor coverings. Thus, the most important economic consideration
is the true life-cycle cost of a floor covering. For example, over the life cycle of flooring, heavy
traffic areas will raise the costs of hard-surface flooring by 18% when compared to the life
cycle cost of carpeted flooring.” (CRI Technical Services, 2003) Also, maintenance cost for the
installation of carpet is less than for hard-surface flooring. In addition, carpet with built
in stain resistance offers even greater savings in the long run.

Life-Cycle Cost Benefit
The life-cycle cost is one of carpet’s main benefits. Preventive maintenance is the key.

Jeff Bishop, Chair of the Certification Board of the Institute of Inspection, Cleaning, and
Restoration Certification (IICRC, Vancouver, WA), conducted a study in 2002 revealing that
hard-surface floors require two and a half times more cleaning time than carpet. Also,
cleaning supplies cost approximately seven times more for vinyl floors than for carpet.
The study concluded that “Upfront purchase and installation costs for VCT are actually
less than those for carpet, but at the end of the 22-year time period, carpet expenditures
proved to be more cost effective than VCT.”

Overall, the study shows that it costs 48% less annually (light to medium traffic areas such as
teacher offices, conference rooms, break areas, media centers, auditoriums, and administrative
offices) and 65% less annually (heavy traffic areas such as corridors and classrooms) to maintain
carpet. This means a savings of 31% (light to medium traffic) and 58% (heavy) of total costs
over a 22-year period. Put another way, over a 22-year period carpet costs $18.29 per square
foot, while VCT costs are more than double at $38.82.

It is very important to choose the right carpet for specific areas in order to maximize savings
and maintain their appeal. For example, carpet that is tight looped and densely tufted with a
low profile will be optimally functional for many areas in schools, as this construction can with-
stand heavy traffic. Carpet color is another consideration: light colors brighten hallways and
rooms, but should be avoided in heavy traffic areas. Small patterns can be ideal for their ability
to hide soil and add charm. Specifiers can consult industry guidelines to insure selecting the
right carpet for the specific application. Carpet is classified according to its ability to withstand
expected traffic, thereby indicating its functional characteristics and performance capacity
in any given area. (Carpet Scores Good Marks in Schools, CRI, 2008)



The Carpet and Rug Institute        |   Box 2048   |   Dalton, GA 30722      |   carpet-rug.org    |    70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
8
                              M AI NTE NAN CE AN D PR E VE NTIVE M E ASU R E S

                              Scheduled, routine vacuuming removes 90% to 95% of all dry soil by weight, making
                              vacuuming the single most effective and economical means of keeping a floor clean.
                              Proper equipment is vital, so CRI identifies machines with the Seal of Approval/Green
                              Label designation, which have been tested to meet strict standards for soil removal and
                              dust containment. For complete details on the program, including a listing of approved
                              vacuum cleaners, go to the CRI web site, www.carpet-rug.org.

                              Preventive measures and continuous maintenance induces a sense of caring among
                              employees, students and community. This sense comes not only from the suggestion
                              of care and comfort but also from the physical environment that carpet creates. As
                              discussed below, findings show that carpet, compared to hard surface floors, keeps
                              more soil, dust, and other indoor air pollutants out of the air. To insure this status,
                              carpet must be cleaned adequately to prevent allergens from forming, especially
                              in areas where humidity control is an issue.

                              Studies show that both “indoor and ambient environment pollution are significantly
Note these easy ways
                              controlled through an effectively managed indoor cleaning program.” (Berry, 2003)
to be proactive about         Michael Berry cites several scientific studies that exhibit the necessity of proper and
keeping carpet clean:         regular cleaning. For example, The Denver Study shows that “the highest concentrations
                              of airborne pollutants were associated with environments that were moderately to
                              heavily soiled, cleaned infrequently, or were cleaned with methods that had excessive
■ Clean exterior
                              chemical or particle residue.” (Berry, 2003) The Frank Porter Graham Child Development
   walkways often             Center Study supports the Denver findings by conducting research in a building
   by shoveling snow,         consisting of 70% carpet, demonstrating that properly and frequently cleaned
   removing leaves,           carpets do not present indoor air problems.
   sand and other
                              C AR PET I N DUSTRY E NVI RO N M E NTAL I N ITIATIVE S
   debris.
■ Restrict food and           The carpet industry joins the most progressive in the country in addressing the potential
   beverages to               human health, environmental and sustainability factors of its products. It continues to
   specific areas.            shrink its environmental footprint in many ways, including the reduction of landfill
                              use, carbon dioxide emissions, water and energy consumption, waste generation,
■ Prohibit chewing
                              transportation, packaging, and hazardous air pollutants.
   gum.
■ Place trashcans in          Reduce, reuse, recycle
   easily accessible          The carpet industry has been committed to the environment for many years.
   areas                      CRI assessed its members’ environmental progress and found carpet companies
                              dramatically increasing their sustainable efforts. Consider these facts:
                              ■   Many companies reported reductions in toxic air emission while increasing
                                  production. One company reduced its nitrous oxide emissions by 70% simply by
                                  installing a low NOX burner system in the boiler.
                              ■   Companies significantly reduced their use of water and electricity. One company
                                  worked with the local utility company to develop technology for the reuse of beck
                                  dye bath water. This cut water usage for the process by an astounding 50%.
                              ■   Voluntary solid waste recycling jumped from small percentages to as much as 90%,
                                  while solid waste to landfill decreased from large percentages to less than
                                  10% in the last 6 to 10 years.


              The Carpet and Rug Institute     |   Box 2048   |   Dalton, GA 30722    |   carpet-rug.org    |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
9
Carpet and IAQ
In order to protect indoor environmental air quality, specifiers must
address IAQ questions, understand the problems engendered by the entry
of outdoor and indoor pollutants, and address flooring for sensitive
environments.

Volatile Organic Compounds
The carpet industry has worked closely for years with academic institutions,
the government, and independent laboratories to evaluate carpet’s role in
the indoor environment. According to CRI, scientific evidence throughout
evaluations indicates no links of adverse human health effect to VOC
(volatile organic compounds) emissions from carpet. “Recurring reviews of
the scientific literature find no evidence that properly maintained carpet
poses a risk to public health…. In fact, where the air quality was measured,
air over carpet was time and again less polluted than air over hard floors.”
(CRI Technical Services, 2003)

Carpet and the products used in the installation process undergo regular
emissions testing. In the approved protocols for ASTM Standard D5116,
everything must fall below a minimum emissions level of 0.5 mg/m³. Using
these scientific standards, CRI established the Green Label and Green Label
Plus programs to guarantee that customers may knowingly purchase the
lowest emitting carpet, adhesives, and cushions available. CRI tests these
stringent criteria annually, semi-annually or quarterly to ensure quality.

VOC levels diminish greatly within the first 24 hours of installing carpet.
Proper fresh air ventilation renders indoor VOC levels undetectable within
48 to 72 hours after installation.

Mold and Allergens
Synthetic fibers in clean, dry carpet cannot grow mold. Carpet traps dirt
particles and allergens for vacuuming. Further, non-carpeted rooms have
allergen air concentration levels at 10-100 times more than carpeted rooms.

Moisture trapped below a carpet can result in mold growth and the release of mold spores into indoor air.
Designers should select carpet that has been tested for VOC emissions under the CRI Green Label Plus testing
program. This testing program meets California’s Collaborative for High Performance School (CHPS) low-
emitting materials standard. When the Green Label is attached to a carpet, floor adhesive, or cushion, it
signifies independent, representative testing of the product type and insures that it meets the requirements
for each program established by CRI.

Humidity is an environmental contributor to molds and allergens. The Air Quality Sciences Study of Carpet
Cleaning found that moving poorly maintained carpet from a high humidity indoor setting to one with humidity
controlled at less than 65% discontinued the growth of all mold. “After cleaning, test results from the previously
contaminated carpet were comparable to those of a clean control carpet in terms of biocontaminants in the
carpet and airborne particles.” (Berry, 2003)




The Carpet and Rug Institute       |   Box 2048   |   Dalton, GA 30722   |    carpet-rug.org   |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
10
           In addition to humidity control, regular and effective cleaning is the number one tool for an
           allergen-free, healthy environment. For example, The Hydro Labs Mold Study concluded that
           hot water extraction is highly effective in reducing mold growth. It concluded further that
           clean carpet “does not support mold growth even at prolonged and elevated temperature
           and humidity levels,” and clearly demonstrated that “vacuuming carpet surfaces is highly
           effective in reducing and managing the levels of culturable mold spore.” (Berry, 2003)

           Professor of Design and Environmental Analysis at Cornell University, Alan Hedge, determined
           through a 2001 study that concerns about carpet contributing to an increase in respiratory
           problems are unfounded. “As long as schools keep floors clean and use high-efficiency
           microfiltration vacuum bags, carpets can be a healthy, safe, and economical floor covering.”

           Proper cleaning and maintenance is a critical component of any flooring system.

           “Assessment of Carpet in Sensitive Environments.” Dr. Michael Berry’s 2001 report defines
           sensitive environments as those that directly affect the very young, the very old, and those
           who are ill. Dr. Barry studied the correlation between carpet and IAQ (indoor air quality) by
           examining the results of hundreds of other studies. He found that “Carpet is a preferred and
           widely used floor covering associated with minimal complaints…. About 1.2 billion square
           yards of carpet are installed every year. Complaints per square yard of carpet are extremely
           small…. Research to date, going back over 30 years, consistently shows carpet to be a
           safe and healthy product.” (Berry, 2003)

           Conclusion
           Carpet lends a relaxed feel to educational facilities through enhanced comfort, acoustics,
           and safety, all of which lead to better concentration, performance, attendance rates and
           the potential for higher test scores. In addition, the life-cycle costs of carpet installation
           and maintenance are more economical that those of hard surface flooring. Further, properly
           maintained carpet tends to reduce particles in the air and can enhance IAQ by holding
           allergens at bay and preventing their release into the air of heavily trafficked areas. These
           combined benefits make carpet an excellent flooring choice for school settings by
           contributing to a better environment for students, teachers, and all school personnel
           in various critical ways. (Berry, 2003)




The Carpet and Rug Institute     |   Box 2048   |   Dalton, GA 30722    |   carpet-rug.org    |   70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
11
B I B LI O G R APHY | 501 C AR PET FO R E DUC ATI O NAL FACI LITI E S
Berry, Michael A., Ph.D. “Carpet in the Modern Indoor Environment: Summary of a Science-Based Assessment of Carpet.”
    University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 2003.
    “Educational Performance, Environmental Management, and Cleaning Effectiveness in School Environments,” April, 2001.
    “Final Report of the Hydrolab Project 2001: Flooring, Humidity, and Mold Growth.” Prepared for The Carpet and Rug Institute,
    February 20, 2002.
    “Healthy School Environment and Enhanced Educational Performance: The Case of Charles Young Elementary School,
    Washington, DC.” Prepared for The Carpet and Rug Institute, January 12, 2002.

Beth Schapiro & Associates. “National Survey of Public Teachers.” Prepared for The Carpet and Rug Institute and
    The International Interior Design Association Foundation, March, 2001.

Bishop, Jeff. “A Life-Cycle Cost Analysis for Floor Coverings in School Facilities,” March, 2002.

“Carpet: Creating a Better Learning Environment.” Supplement to College Planning & Management and School
    Planning & Management.” In cooperation with The Carpet and Rug Institute, May 2001.

“Carpet: The Educated Choice for Schools. Life-Cycle Cost Analysis.” Educational pamphlet for The Carpet and Rug Institute, 2000.

“Carpet and High Performance Schools.” CRI Technical Services, January, 2003.

“Carpet Maintenance for School Facilities.” Educational pamphlet for The Carpet and Rug Institute, 2000.

“Carpet Makes the Grade In Schools.” Educational pamphlet for The Carpet and Rug Institute.

“Carpet Usage & Allergic Reactions in Sweden.” http://www.carpetrug.org/pdf_word_docs/Swedish_Chart.pdf.

“Carpet Scores Good Marks in Schools: A Smart, Sustainable, Solution in Floor Coverings.” Architectural Record. Carpet and
    Rug Institute, 2008.

Cole, E.C. et.al. “Indoor Environment Characterization of a Non-Problem Building: Assessment of Cleaning Effectiveness.”
    Research Triangle Report Number 94U-4479-014, Research Triangle Institute, March 1994.

D’Aoust, Angie. “Experts Warn of Noisy Classrooms: Audiologists and Speech-Language Pathologists warn of learning problems
    associated with noise.” CASLPA-ACOA, 2007.

Foarde, Karin, Deborah Franke and Dr. Michael A. Berry. “Cleaning Effectiveness Demonstration in a Carpeted School.” w
    CRI Scientific Resources at http://www.carpet-rug.org/carpet-and-rug-industry/research-and-resources/scientific-research/
    studies-alphabetically-by-title.cfm, November, 2002.

Grass, Stephen video writer/producer. How Interior Design Solutions Help Create Better Learning Environments.
    Carpet and Rug Institute, 2004.

Harmel, Kristin. “Listen to the Teacher: Good Classroom Acoustics are Vital to Effective Learning.” Explore: Research at the
    University of Florida, Spring, 2000.

Hurd, Frank. “Carpet Aids Learning in High-Performance Schools.” Educational Facility Planner, Volume 43: Issue 4 (pp. 19-22),
    Spring 2009.

Lang, Susan. “Carpets in Schools Don’t Compromise Indoor Air Quality.” Cornell Human Ecology, March 19, 2001.

Lang, Susan. “CU expert: Carpets in Schools Benefit Indoor Air Quality.” Cornell Chronicle, March 29, 2001.

State of California, School Sound Level Study, School Facilities and Transportation Division, California State Department
     of Education, 1998.

“Myths & Truths about Carpet.” Educational pamphlet for The Carpet and Rug Institute, July, 2004.
12
Last Name                                  First Name
Job Title                                  Firm Name
Address                                                                  City                                    State       Zip
Telephone                                  FAX                           E-mail
AIA ID Number                      Completion Date (M/D/Y)                IDCEC Number and Organization (IIDA, ASID, IDC, NEWH)
Check one:       $25.00 payment enclosed (Make check payable to the Carpet and Rug Institute, Box 2048, Dalton, GA 30722-2048.)
                 Charge         Visa       Mastercard         American Express        Card #                                       Exp.Date

Signature

PROGRAM TITLE: “CARPET IN EDUCATIONAL FACILITES” (8/10) AIA/CES CREDIT: This article will earn you one AIA/CES LU hour of health,
safety and welfare/sustainable design (HSW/SD) credit or .1 CEU credit from IDCEC (valid for credit through July, 2012) DIRECTIONS: Select
one answer for each question in the box beside the possible answers. Send or fax this page to Pat Jennings, The Carpet and Rug Institute, 730
 College Drive, Dalton, GA 30720 or fax to 706.278.8835 or scan and email to pjennings@carpet-rug.org along with your check or credit card
information. A minimum score of 80% is required to earn credit. A certificate of completion will be sent to each person who passes the test.


1. According to a survey of teachers, most feel that school design and classroom design:
     a) Do not impact learning                     c) Strongly impact learning
     b) Have little impact on learning             d) None of the above
2. Carpet was added to classrooms at Charles Young Elementary School in order to:
     a) Make the staff more comfortable            c) Appeal to outside groups who want to use the school during off-hours
     b) Reduce noise                               d) All of the above
3. One benefit of the 45,000 square feet of new carpeting installed in Charles Young Elementary School was that student test scores:
     a) Stayed the same                    c) Rose significantly
     b) Changed slightly                   d) Drastically lowered
4. A non-physical benefit of carpeting in schools is that it:
     a) Lets the students know that the school staff cares about them             c) Creates a warm, aesthetic environment
     b) May reduce stress                                                         d) All of the above
5. Academically successful schools show:
     a) A sense of well-being among students               c) Little interaction between parents and teachers
     b) A strong emphasis on athletics                     d) Little interaction between students and teachers
6. A good benefit analysis will show that carpet may be:
     a) More expensive to maintain                c) Less expensive overall than other types of flooring
     b) Less expensive to maintain                d) All of the above
7. The Acoustical Society of America reports that acoustical problems in classrooms are alleviated by the use of carpet.
  One of these acoustical problems was:
     a) Warmth                           c) Comfort
     b) Behavior and attention           d) Both a & c
8. The U.S. Consumer Report Commission reported that in 1993 more people died in                            than in any other type of accident.
     a) Automobile accidents             c) Slipping on ice
     b) Skiing accidents                 d) Indoor falls
9. CRI’s Green Label Plus programs offers customers:
     a) Lowest emitting carpet, adhesive and cushion                       c) Annual/semi-annual/quarterly testing of certified products
     b) Assurance that products meet stringent low-VOC criteria            d) All of the above
10. Proper cleaning and maintenance of carpet will assure that neither                             nor                   will cause any problems.
     a) Moisture, temperature            c) Students, teachers
     b) Mold, allergens                  d) None of the above

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

淺談 Domain name 網域名稱姓名學 by Ben Lin
淺談 Domain name 網域名稱姓名學 by Ben Lin淺談 Domain name 網域名稱姓名學 by Ben Lin
淺談 Domain name 網域名稱姓名學 by Ben Lin悠識學院
 
Digital & Social Marketing
Digital & Social MarketingDigital & Social Marketing
Digital & Social MarketingJISC BCE
 
ALCTS 2014 Presentation
ALCTS 2014 PresentationALCTS 2014 Presentation
ALCTS 2014 Presentationandreadisd
 
Invasion of the dynamic language weenies
Invasion of the dynamic language weeniesInvasion of the dynamic language weenies
Invasion of the dynamic language weeniesSrijit Kumar Bhadra
 
Embedding BCE - Institutional Showcase (Keele)
Embedding BCE - Institutional Showcase (Keele)Embedding BCE - Institutional Showcase (Keele)
Embedding BCE - Institutional Showcase (Keele)JISC BCE
 
Mne to na notebooku funguje
Mne to na notebooku fungujeMne to na notebooku funguje
Mne to na notebooku fungujeJuraj Bednar
 
Potential Issues within BCE
Potential Issues within BCEPotential Issues within BCE
Potential Issues within BCEJISC BCE
 
Social Media and Face-to-Face Meetings
Social Media and Face-to-Face MeetingsSocial Media and Face-to-Face Meetings
Social Media and Face-to-Face MeetingsMichelle Bruno
 
Facebook 應用程式企劃與行銷案例
Facebook 應用程式企劃與行銷案例Facebook 應用程式企劃與行銷案例
Facebook 應用程式企劃與行銷案例悠識學院
 
Parenting 21st Century Children
Parenting 21st Century ChildrenParenting 21st Century Children
Parenting 21st Century ChildrenGraham Whisen
 
There’s More Value to Event Social Walls Than Projecting Awesome Selfies
There’s More Value to Event Social Walls Than Projecting Awesome SelfiesThere’s More Value to Event Social Walls Than Projecting Awesome Selfies
There’s More Value to Event Social Walls Than Projecting Awesome SelfiesMichelle Bruno
 
LODのOLAP分析を可能にするETLフレームワークの提案
LODのOLAP分析を可能にするETLフレームワークの提案LODのOLAP分析を可能にするETLフレームワークの提案
LODのOLAP分析を可能にするETLフレームワークの提案Hiroyuki Inoue
 
Telefónia a VoIP barcamp
Telefónia a VoIP barcampTelefónia a VoIP barcamp
Telefónia a VoIP barcampJuraj Bednar
 
Webinar: Clinical Trial Registration Jan 2009
Webinar: Clinical Trial Registration Jan 2009Webinar: Clinical Trial Registration Jan 2009
Webinar: Clinical Trial Registration Jan 2009Mukesh Kumar, PhD, RAC
 

Viewers also liked (20)

淺談 Domain name 網域名稱姓名學 by Ben Lin
淺談 Domain name 網域名稱姓名學 by Ben Lin淺談 Domain name 網域名稱姓名學 by Ben Lin
淺談 Domain name 網域名稱姓名學 by Ben Lin
 
Digital & Social Marketing
Digital & Social MarketingDigital & Social Marketing
Digital & Social Marketing
 
Peer Awards Full
Peer Awards FullPeer Awards Full
Peer Awards Full
 
ALCTS 2014 Presentation
ALCTS 2014 PresentationALCTS 2014 Presentation
ALCTS 2014 Presentation
 
Bobby97
Bobby97Bobby97
Bobby97
 
Invasion of the dynamic language weenies
Invasion of the dynamic language weeniesInvasion of the dynamic language weenies
Invasion of the dynamic language weenies
 
Embedding BCE - Institutional Showcase (Keele)
Embedding BCE - Institutional Showcase (Keele)Embedding BCE - Institutional Showcase (Keele)
Embedding BCE - Institutional Showcase (Keele)
 
Vendors Shop Earth
Vendors Shop EarthVendors Shop Earth
Vendors Shop Earth
 
Ians Slides
Ians SlidesIans Slides
Ians Slides
 
Mne to na notebooku funguje
Mne to na notebooku fungujeMne to na notebooku funguje
Mne to na notebooku funguje
 
Potential Issues within BCE
Potential Issues within BCEPotential Issues within BCE
Potential Issues within BCE
 
Social Media and Face-to-Face Meetings
Social Media and Face-to-Face MeetingsSocial Media and Face-to-Face Meetings
Social Media and Face-to-Face Meetings
 
Facebook 應用程式企劃與行銷案例
Facebook 應用程式企劃與行銷案例Facebook 應用程式企劃與行銷案例
Facebook 應用程式企劃與行銷案例
 
Parenting 21st Century Children
Parenting 21st Century ChildrenParenting 21st Century Children
Parenting 21st Century Children
 
There’s More Value to Event Social Walls Than Projecting Awesome Selfies
There’s More Value to Event Social Walls Than Projecting Awesome SelfiesThere’s More Value to Event Social Walls Than Projecting Awesome Selfies
There’s More Value to Event Social Walls Than Projecting Awesome Selfies
 
LODのOLAP分析を可能にするETLフレームワークの提案
LODのOLAP分析を可能にするETLフレームワークの提案LODのOLAP分析を可能にするETLフレームワークの提案
LODのOLAP分析を可能にするETLフレームワークの提案
 
Am Sa Fug
Am Sa FugAm Sa Fug
Am Sa Fug
 
Telefónia a VoIP barcamp
Telefónia a VoIP barcampTelefónia a VoIP barcamp
Telefónia a VoIP barcamp
 
Examen Facil
Examen FacilExamen Facil
Examen Facil
 
Webinar: Clinical Trial Registration Jan 2009
Webinar: Clinical Trial Registration Jan 2009Webinar: Clinical Trial Registration Jan 2009
Webinar: Clinical Trial Registration Jan 2009
 

Similar to 501 Ceu L Idcec 7 9 2010

Learner interaction in_elearning_lamar_research_institute_3-21-14
Learner interaction in_elearning_lamar_research_institute_3-21-14Learner interaction in_elearning_lamar_research_institute_3-21-14
Learner interaction in_elearning_lamar_research_institute_3-21-14Lamar University
 
Lab organiztion & Management presentation.pptx
Lab organiztion & Management presentation.pptxLab organiztion & Management presentation.pptx
Lab organiztion & Management presentation.pptxchristopherMasters5
 
Uwf future of tech
Uwf future of techUwf future of tech
Uwf future of techkseder
 
Assessment of outdoor spaces like corridors and courtyards in a school enviro...
Assessment of outdoor spaces like corridors and courtyards in a school enviro...Assessment of outdoor spaces like corridors and courtyards in a school enviro...
Assessment of outdoor spaces like corridors and courtyards in a school enviro...IRJET Journal
 
Lbsc742 teacherpresentation
Lbsc742 teacherpresentationLbsc742 teacherpresentation
Lbsc742 teacherpresentationcorrado2003
 
Education Roundtable Survey Electronic Version
Education Roundtable Survey Electronic VersionEducation Roundtable Survey Electronic Version
Education Roundtable Survey Electronic VersionJMMcGuire
 
iNacol quality workshop october 2012
iNacol quality workshop october 2012iNacol quality workshop october 2012
iNacol quality workshop october 2012LaBonte Randy
 
Online tutoring towards a signature pedagogy
Online tutoring   towards a signature pedagogyOnline tutoring   towards a signature pedagogy
Online tutoring towards a signature pedagogymhallissy
 
21 Century Curriculum
21 Century Curriculum  21 Century Curriculum
21 Century Curriculum Halah2014
 
What's the big deal about Blended Learning - Models, Results and Challenges
What's the big deal about Blended Learning - Models, Results and ChallengesWhat's the big deal about Blended Learning - Models, Results and Challenges
What's the big deal about Blended Learning - Models, Results and ChallengesTerry Anderson
 
21st Century Standards and Curriculum
21st Century Standards and Curriculum21st Century Standards and Curriculum
21st Century Standards and CurriculumHalah2014
 
Problem-based Learning
Problem-based LearningProblem-based Learning
Problem-based Learninggreer_susan
 
The Learning Environments by Cam Weston
The Learning Environments by Cam WestonThe Learning Environments by Cam Weston
The Learning Environments by Cam Westonwestoid33
 
The Teacher as Designer of Instructional Technology: Transcending time and te...
The Teacher as Designer of Instructional Technology: Transcending time and te...The Teacher as Designer of Instructional Technology: Transcending time and te...
The Teacher as Designer of Instructional Technology: Transcending time and te...David B. Whittier, Ed D
 
Nssa Professional Development 10 05-2015kada
Nssa   Professional Development 10 05-2015kadaNssa   Professional Development 10 05-2015kada
Nssa Professional Development 10 05-2015kadaKay Abernathy, Ed.D.
 

Similar to 501 Ceu L Idcec 7 9 2010 (20)

Learner interaction in_elearning_lamar_research_institute_3-21-14
Learner interaction in_elearning_lamar_research_institute_3-21-14Learner interaction in_elearning_lamar_research_institute_3-21-14
Learner interaction in_elearning_lamar_research_institute_3-21-14
 
Lab organiztion & Management presentation.pptx
Lab organiztion & Management presentation.pptxLab organiztion & Management presentation.pptx
Lab organiztion & Management presentation.pptx
 
Uwf future of tech
Uwf future of techUwf future of tech
Uwf future of tech
 
Assessment of outdoor spaces like corridors and courtyards in a school enviro...
Assessment of outdoor spaces like corridors and courtyards in a school enviro...Assessment of outdoor spaces like corridors and courtyards in a school enviro...
Assessment of outdoor spaces like corridors and courtyards in a school enviro...
 
Lbsc742 teacherpresentation
Lbsc742 teacherpresentationLbsc742 teacherpresentation
Lbsc742 teacherpresentation
 
Education Roundtable Survey Electronic Version
Education Roundtable Survey Electronic VersionEducation Roundtable Survey Electronic Version
Education Roundtable Survey Electronic Version
 
Technology learning
Technology learningTechnology learning
Technology learning
 
Technology learning
Technology learningTechnology learning
Technology learning
 
iNacol quality workshop october 2012
iNacol quality workshop october 2012iNacol quality workshop october 2012
iNacol quality workshop october 2012
 
Bif Student Lab
Bif Student LabBif Student Lab
Bif Student Lab
 
Online tutoring towards a signature pedagogy
Online tutoring   towards a signature pedagogyOnline tutoring   towards a signature pedagogy
Online tutoring towards a signature pedagogy
 
21 Century Curriculum
21 Century Curriculum  21 Century Curriculum
21 Century Curriculum
 
Reimagining the Classroom
Reimagining the ClassroomReimagining the Classroom
Reimagining the Classroom
 
What's the big deal about Blended Learning - Models, Results and Challenges
What's the big deal about Blended Learning - Models, Results and ChallengesWhat's the big deal about Blended Learning - Models, Results and Challenges
What's the big deal about Blended Learning - Models, Results and Challenges
 
21st Century Standards and Curriculum
21st Century Standards and Curriculum21st Century Standards and Curriculum
21st Century Standards and Curriculum
 
Problem-based Learning
Problem-based LearningProblem-based Learning
Problem-based Learning
 
The Learning Environments by Cam Weston
The Learning Environments by Cam WestonThe Learning Environments by Cam Weston
The Learning Environments by Cam Weston
 
The Teacher as Designer of Instructional Technology: Transcending time and te...
The Teacher as Designer of Instructional Technology: Transcending time and te...The Teacher as Designer of Instructional Technology: Transcending time and te...
The Teacher as Designer of Instructional Technology: Transcending time and te...
 
Detailed ASSESSMENT
Detailed ASSESSMENTDetailed ASSESSMENT
Detailed ASSESSMENT
 
Nssa Professional Development 10 05-2015kada
Nssa   Professional Development 10 05-2015kadaNssa   Professional Development 10 05-2015kada
Nssa Professional Development 10 05-2015kada
 

More from Peer Resource Group

More from Peer Resource Group (9)

PRG Competencies 2011
PRG Competencies 2011PRG Competencies 2011
PRG Competencies 2011
 
Seminar Offerings 2011 New
Seminar Offerings 2011 NewSeminar Offerings 2011 New
Seminar Offerings 2011 New
 
Prg Seminar Offerings 2010 2 Pg
Prg Seminar Offerings 2010 2 PgPrg Seminar Offerings 2010 2 Pg
Prg Seminar Offerings 2010 2 Pg
 
6 Differentiating Marketplace11 24 08
6 Differentiating Marketplace11 24 086 Differentiating Marketplace11 24 08
6 Differentiating Marketplace11 24 08
 
6 Differentiating Marketplace11 24 08
6 Differentiating Marketplace11 24 086 Differentiating Marketplace11 24 08
6 Differentiating Marketplace11 24 08
 
Happiness Intro
Happiness IntroHappiness Intro
Happiness Intro
 
Prospecting Power 2010 Jh Example Slides
Prospecting Power 2010 Jh Example SlidesProspecting Power 2010 Jh Example Slides
Prospecting Power 2010 Jh Example Slides
 
Amu Dealing W Dissat Cust Lo Res
Amu Dealing W Dissat Cust Lo ResAmu Dealing W Dissat Cust Lo Res
Amu Dealing W Dissat Cust Lo Res
 
Sla New Hire Brochure Rev8
Sla New Hire Brochure Rev8Sla New Hire Brochure Rev8
Sla New Hire Brochure Rev8
 

501 Ceu L Idcec 7 9 2010

  • 1. 501 CARPET IN EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES: CARPE T END USE SEGMENTS LE AR N I N G O B J EC TIVE S ■ Evaluate how students and teachers feel about carpet. ■ Show how carpet helped improve student achievement at Charles Young Elementary School. ■ List some physical and non-physical benefits of carpeting for classrooms. ■ Offer ways to improve acoustics in schools. ■ List ways that carpet contributes to good indoor air quality. ■ Describe why carpet is a good flooring choice for schools. Jenkins • Peer Architects SCH O O L S I N TH E U. S . A . Statistics In the United States, approximately 120,000 schools provide for the educational needs of at least 54 million students. On average, students receive 20% of their environmental exposure in schools. According to a 2002 research report, the US General Accounting Office indicated a national need of over 100 billion dollars for the restoration of public elementary and secondary schools. The rehabilitations are crucial for the health, safety, and comfort of students and staff: 50% of public school facilities throughout the United States have environmental problems caused by water intrusion, inefficient HVAC systems, and ineffective or non-existent cleaning programs. However, the use of the appropriate carpet can contribute in creating healthy learning environments in all of these schools. Course 000501, HSW/SD, Provider G391 Course #5715, Subject Code 5.8, General Knowledge “Carpet in Acute Care Facilities” is one of a series of CEU courses about the benefits of carpet in various commercial end use segments, developed by the Carpet and Rug Institute, the national trade association for the flooring industry. Use the learning objectives above to focus your study. To earn one AIA/CES Learning Unit, including one hour of health safety welfare/sustainable design (HSW/SD) credit or 1.0 CEU credits with IDCEC, answer the questions at the end of this booklet and follow the reporting instructions for submitting your registration and response information to the Carpet and Rug Institute. The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 2. 2 Schools are Centers for the Community According to the National Clearinghouse for Education Facilities, the latest design trend for schools makes them centers for the community. Classrooms and other school facilities often serve as ideal places for community-sponsored events, club meetings, after school functions, and extra-curricular activities. These endeavors make better use of facilities that already exist and lend students and teachers increased exposure to the school setting. Jenk ins • Peer Architec ts But limited funds make it tempting for school officials to overlook the importance of design features in classrooms, failing to consider design benefits for children, teachers, and people in the community who might use the schools on a regular basis. Survey of Teachers In 2000, Beth Schapiro & Associates, a research firm based in Atlanta, administered a national survey to 1,050 public school teachers. “The results of the survey indicate that teachers across the country and from all grade levels realize that a well-designed classroom enhances their ability to teach and their students’ ability to learn. The results also suggest that most teachers see the advantages of carpet in the classroom, particularly the acoustics, comfort, and flexibility of carpet.” (Beth Schapiro & Associates, 2001) Jenk ins • Peer Architec ts More specifically, the survey revealed the following about teachers’ experience of design: ■ 92% think classroom design strongly impacts achievement. ■ 18% gave their rooms an ‘A’ for design. ■ 99% said school design is important for learning. ■ 89% said design is incentive for teachers to stay. ■ 79% think design is important for student attendance. The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 3. 3 Elementary School Case Study “In many ways, the list of criteria for healthy, high-performance school environments parallels the list of carpet’s recognized benefits,” notes Frank Hurd, Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of the Carpet and Rug Institute, in a recent article on flooring in high performance schools, written for the Educational Facility Planner. (Hurd, 2009) In the article, Hurd elucidates the ways in which carpet meets the list of criteria: “Carpet has contributed to high-quality school environments for many years. Valued by educational facility designers for its color and design flexibility, carpet’s softness makes it a safer as well as more comfortable flooring choice. In a classroom, carpet reduces noise, defines learning areas, and cuts down glare. In terms of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), carpet is one of the lowest- emitting of all building materials, and multiple studies demonstrate how clean, dry, carpet actually contributes to improved indoor air quality. Hard science illustrates how carpet in schools helps create environments where teachers are happy to teach and students are excited about learning.” (Hurd, 2009) Hurd goes on to illustrate the ways in which carpet provides visual, thermal and acoustic comfort, ease of maintenance, material/energy efficiency and increased safety. In another study, Michael A. Berry, research professor at U.N.C. Chapel Hill, conducted a case study* of the restoration of the Charles Young Elementary School in Washington, D.C. The impetus for the study was the increasing research indicating several levels of relationship between educational performance and the environmental quality of schools. More precisely, as stated by Dr. Berry, ■ Facility management systems determine environmental quality in schools. ■ The quality of the school environment shapes attitudes of students, teachers and staff. ■ Attitudes affect teaching and learning behavior. ■ Behavior affects performance. ■ Educational performance determines future outcomes of individuals and society as a whole. (Berry, 2002) To implement the research, the school installed more than 45,000 square feet of new carpet to create attractive, comfortable, open classrooms free of glare and noise. In addition to installation, the carpet industry donated effective vacuums, carpet cleaning equipment, supplies, maintenance schedules, and proper training, so that future carpet issues could be prevented. These changes, supplies and training allowed the school to meet the essential environmental criteria for a comfortable, constructive setting for learning: adequate space and ample, natural lighting, clean, inviting appearance and student-friendly conditions – which support both student and teacher retention – low noise levels and a consistent, comfortable temperature. Through the study Dr. Berry found an “obvious link between students’ environment and educational performance.” (Berry, 2002) The Charles Young Elementary School became a model for other schools. Communication ability improved between students and teachers. More importantly, standardized test scores in math and reading, done before and after the restoration, confirmed a dramatic improvement in student performance post-restoration. Notably, twenty-five percent of the students improved their test scores from “below basic” to “basic” or higher levels. A portion of this study, published in the proceedings of Indoor Air 2002*, found the higher test scores partially attributable to the school’s more comfortable and inviting mixed-carpeted environment. *A new independent case study is underway and results will be published at a later date. The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 4. 4 Accurate Information about Carpet in Schools Many schools have used carpet as a preferred floor covering for many years because of its enhancing features – comfort, warmth, noise control, glare reduction, and protection from slips and falls. However, there are misperceptions that carpet contributes to unhealthy indoor air quality because it cannot be properly maintained in schools. But in fact, carpet is easier and less expensive to maintain than hard-surface flooring, and independent research studies indicate that clean carpet poses no health risk in schools or any other environment. Given considerable debate about the most appropriate flooring material for use in schools, in IAQ Design Tools for Schools, the EPA recognizes existing advantages and disadvantages associated with all types of floor coverings. For example, carpet offers acoustical and comfort benefits not usually available with other floor coverings. Regular and effective cleaning and maintenance are essential for any type of floor covering. Replacing Carpet with Hard Surface Floors As the Charles Young School study points out, under-funded operating budgets and limited long-term accountability for the decision-making outcome leads to misguided restoration policies. The decision to replace carpet with hard floors dodges the issue and responsibility of effective cleaning, as pollutants rest on hard surfaces and are easily kicked up into indoor air. Lower morale and poorer health ensue, working against the learning process. The study of the Charles Young Elementary School examines the connection between morale of students and the environmental condition of the school. Studies show that academically successful schools foster a sense of well being, and this sense is the essence of a healthy environment. Therefore, care should be taken in discontinuing the use of carpet in schools, as students, teachers, and staff need an elevated level of comfort in their teaching and learning environments. Carpeting offers soft surfaces on which to stand for long hours, warm and energizing colors, glare reduction, and most importantly, noise control. The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 5. 5 TH E B E N E FITS O F C AR PET Physical Benefits According to Dr. Lorraine Maxwell, professor of human-environment relations at Cornell University, “Children have different responses to various classroom settings, which is why it is so important to make sure their classrooms are designed to stimulate them in the best possible way. Ways to make a classroom more comfortable include having carpet on the floor, windows to let in natural light, assorted classroom arrangements, and ample space to work comfortably.” Beth Schapiro & Associates’ national survey of teachers (2000), also high- lighted safety, comfort, lighting, acoustics, and climate control as the top five classroom design elements impacting the learning environment. Teachers overwhelmingly listed carpet as an important design feature because it ■ Provides comfortable seating for students ■ Makes floor areas usable workspace ■ Provides a soft, quiet environment ■ Gives overall comfort ■ Helps reduce glare ■ Minimizes risk of injury, accidents and slips and falls The final point deserves additional attention: the survey also found that teachers categorize carpet’s ability to minimize the risk of accidents as its main benefit. The U.S. Consumer Product Commission reported that more people die of indoor falls than any other kind of accident. According to Dr. Alan Hedge, Professor of Department of Design and Environmental analysis at Cornell University, the falls due to slips and tripping rank as the second leading cause of accidental death in the United States. (Hurd, 2009) Furthermore, these accidents are equally distributed between work and home, and children aged 10 and younger were the second age group most likely to be injured by falls. In wet conditions the risk of a slip on hard surfaces is twice that of carpet because carpet increases surface traction. Plus, hard surfaces are less forgiving and more likely to result in more injury. Yet there has been a trend away from carpet in schools, particularly in hallways and on stairs where the majority of falling accidents occur. In other words, slick hard surfaces become accidents waiting to happen during the commotion and bustle of rainy school mornings. With less glare, extra traction, added cushioning, a softer landing, and fewer injuries, carpet’s ability to prevent falls and therefore minimize liability makes it a good flooring choice. The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 6. 6 TO P 5 WAYS TO I M PROVE CL ASS ROOM ACOUSTI CS Inattention in students may not always be caused by learning or behavioral disorders. Sometimes noise level prevents a student from hearing properly and/or assimilating lessons. Note the following five ways to improve classroom acoustics. 1. Carefully select and design air-conditioning systems. 2. Limit room ceiling height. 3. Use sound-absorbing surfaces throughout rooms. 4. Install carpeting instead of hard floors. 5. Emphasize teacher training, smaller class sizes, and better room environments. Non-Physical Benefits A high performance school is designed to reduce stress, as lowered stress results in higher performance. Design features like carpet enhance aesthetics and comfort and send a message of care and concern, thereby epitomizing a well-managed school. Acoustic Benefits Noise affects learning negatively. Carpet’s capacity to absorb sound and muffle background noise allows students to hear better, pay attention more, and think more clearly while learning. In a 1995 survey by the General Accounting Office, school administrators ranked poor acoustics as the most significant problem affecting the learning environment. Researchers at a 1997 conference of the Acoustical Society of America presented the following evidence: excessive noise levels impair a young child’s speech perception, reading and spelling ability, behavior, attention and overall academic performance. Ongoing studies continue to support these findings. Gary Sieben, Professor of Architecture at the University of Florida and one of the world’s foremost experts on architectural acoustics, along with Professors Carl Crandell and Mary Jo Hassel, set out to identify and cure acoustical problems in classrooms. They studied what students were and were not hearing, and why. Startlingly they found that “Students beyond the first or second row in a typical classroom hear only 50 percent” of what their teachers say. The Canadian Association of Speech-Language Pathologists and Audiologists (CASLPA) also warn that noisy classrooms strongly affect a child’s ability to learn as well as a teacher’s ability to teach. Results from a Canadian Language and Literacy Research Network study show that “one in six words is not understood by the average Grade 1 student due to excessive background noise and poor acoustics in Canadian classrooms.” (D’Aoust, 2007) Carpet improves this ratio. For example, in the case study of the Charles Young School, students’ reading skills improved because of “open classes and flexibility of teaching associated with total usable space that includes the floors.” (CRI Technical Services) The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 7. 7 The State of California has conducted research revealing that effective sound control in open spaces is “virtually impossible to achieve” without carpet. (State of California, 1998) In fact, according to a study by the American Society of Interior Designers, carpet is 10 times more effective in reducing noise than other types of flooring. Noise levels can be reduced even more when polyurethane cushioned backing is added to the carpet. (Carpet Scores Good Marks in Schools, 2008) Maintenance Cost Effectiveness The installation of hard-surface flooring and its ensuing high-cost, labor-intensive maintenance plagues school budgets. Maintenance costs include labor, materials, and equipment. Planners need to look beyond the initial cost when choosing flooring because “inexpensive” floors can quickly become expensive floors. To keep costs down, it is critical that schools conduct cost benefit flooring analyses and develop awareness of the economic benefits of carpeting. According to Canadian Facility Management & Design (April 2002) “Maintenance is the single most costly element in most floor coverings. Thus, the most important economic consideration is the true life-cycle cost of a floor covering. For example, over the life cycle of flooring, heavy traffic areas will raise the costs of hard-surface flooring by 18% when compared to the life cycle cost of carpeted flooring.” (CRI Technical Services, 2003) Also, maintenance cost for the installation of carpet is less than for hard-surface flooring. In addition, carpet with built in stain resistance offers even greater savings in the long run. Life-Cycle Cost Benefit The life-cycle cost is one of carpet’s main benefits. Preventive maintenance is the key. Jeff Bishop, Chair of the Certification Board of the Institute of Inspection, Cleaning, and Restoration Certification (IICRC, Vancouver, WA), conducted a study in 2002 revealing that hard-surface floors require two and a half times more cleaning time than carpet. Also, cleaning supplies cost approximately seven times more for vinyl floors than for carpet. The study concluded that “Upfront purchase and installation costs for VCT are actually less than those for carpet, but at the end of the 22-year time period, carpet expenditures proved to be more cost effective than VCT.” Overall, the study shows that it costs 48% less annually (light to medium traffic areas such as teacher offices, conference rooms, break areas, media centers, auditoriums, and administrative offices) and 65% less annually (heavy traffic areas such as corridors and classrooms) to maintain carpet. This means a savings of 31% (light to medium traffic) and 58% (heavy) of total costs over a 22-year period. Put another way, over a 22-year period carpet costs $18.29 per square foot, while VCT costs are more than double at $38.82. It is very important to choose the right carpet for specific areas in order to maximize savings and maintain their appeal. For example, carpet that is tight looped and densely tufted with a low profile will be optimally functional for many areas in schools, as this construction can with- stand heavy traffic. Carpet color is another consideration: light colors brighten hallways and rooms, but should be avoided in heavy traffic areas. Small patterns can be ideal for their ability to hide soil and add charm. Specifiers can consult industry guidelines to insure selecting the right carpet for the specific application. Carpet is classified according to its ability to withstand expected traffic, thereby indicating its functional characteristics and performance capacity in any given area. (Carpet Scores Good Marks in Schools, CRI, 2008) The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 8. 8 M AI NTE NAN CE AN D PR E VE NTIVE M E ASU R E S Scheduled, routine vacuuming removes 90% to 95% of all dry soil by weight, making vacuuming the single most effective and economical means of keeping a floor clean. Proper equipment is vital, so CRI identifies machines with the Seal of Approval/Green Label designation, which have been tested to meet strict standards for soil removal and dust containment. For complete details on the program, including a listing of approved vacuum cleaners, go to the CRI web site, www.carpet-rug.org. Preventive measures and continuous maintenance induces a sense of caring among employees, students and community. This sense comes not only from the suggestion of care and comfort but also from the physical environment that carpet creates. As discussed below, findings show that carpet, compared to hard surface floors, keeps more soil, dust, and other indoor air pollutants out of the air. To insure this status, carpet must be cleaned adequately to prevent allergens from forming, especially in areas where humidity control is an issue. Studies show that both “indoor and ambient environment pollution are significantly Note these easy ways controlled through an effectively managed indoor cleaning program.” (Berry, 2003) to be proactive about Michael Berry cites several scientific studies that exhibit the necessity of proper and keeping carpet clean: regular cleaning. For example, The Denver Study shows that “the highest concentrations of airborne pollutants were associated with environments that were moderately to heavily soiled, cleaned infrequently, or were cleaned with methods that had excessive ■ Clean exterior chemical or particle residue.” (Berry, 2003) The Frank Porter Graham Child Development walkways often Center Study supports the Denver findings by conducting research in a building by shoveling snow, consisting of 70% carpet, demonstrating that properly and frequently cleaned removing leaves, carpets do not present indoor air problems. sand and other C AR PET I N DUSTRY E NVI RO N M E NTAL I N ITIATIVE S debris. ■ Restrict food and The carpet industry joins the most progressive in the country in addressing the potential beverages to human health, environmental and sustainability factors of its products. It continues to specific areas. shrink its environmental footprint in many ways, including the reduction of landfill use, carbon dioxide emissions, water and energy consumption, waste generation, ■ Prohibit chewing transportation, packaging, and hazardous air pollutants. gum. ■ Place trashcans in Reduce, reuse, recycle easily accessible The carpet industry has been committed to the environment for many years. areas CRI assessed its members’ environmental progress and found carpet companies dramatically increasing their sustainable efforts. Consider these facts: ■ Many companies reported reductions in toxic air emission while increasing production. One company reduced its nitrous oxide emissions by 70% simply by installing a low NOX burner system in the boiler. ■ Companies significantly reduced their use of water and electricity. One company worked with the local utility company to develop technology for the reuse of beck dye bath water. This cut water usage for the process by an astounding 50%. ■ Voluntary solid waste recycling jumped from small percentages to as much as 90%, while solid waste to landfill decreased from large percentages to less than 10% in the last 6 to 10 years. The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 9. 9 Carpet and IAQ In order to protect indoor environmental air quality, specifiers must address IAQ questions, understand the problems engendered by the entry of outdoor and indoor pollutants, and address flooring for sensitive environments. Volatile Organic Compounds The carpet industry has worked closely for years with academic institutions, the government, and independent laboratories to evaluate carpet’s role in the indoor environment. According to CRI, scientific evidence throughout evaluations indicates no links of adverse human health effect to VOC (volatile organic compounds) emissions from carpet. “Recurring reviews of the scientific literature find no evidence that properly maintained carpet poses a risk to public health…. In fact, where the air quality was measured, air over carpet was time and again less polluted than air over hard floors.” (CRI Technical Services, 2003) Carpet and the products used in the installation process undergo regular emissions testing. In the approved protocols for ASTM Standard D5116, everything must fall below a minimum emissions level of 0.5 mg/m³. Using these scientific standards, CRI established the Green Label and Green Label Plus programs to guarantee that customers may knowingly purchase the lowest emitting carpet, adhesives, and cushions available. CRI tests these stringent criteria annually, semi-annually or quarterly to ensure quality. VOC levels diminish greatly within the first 24 hours of installing carpet. Proper fresh air ventilation renders indoor VOC levels undetectable within 48 to 72 hours after installation. Mold and Allergens Synthetic fibers in clean, dry carpet cannot grow mold. Carpet traps dirt particles and allergens for vacuuming. Further, non-carpeted rooms have allergen air concentration levels at 10-100 times more than carpeted rooms. Moisture trapped below a carpet can result in mold growth and the release of mold spores into indoor air. Designers should select carpet that has been tested for VOC emissions under the CRI Green Label Plus testing program. This testing program meets California’s Collaborative for High Performance School (CHPS) low- emitting materials standard. When the Green Label is attached to a carpet, floor adhesive, or cushion, it signifies independent, representative testing of the product type and insures that it meets the requirements for each program established by CRI. Humidity is an environmental contributor to molds and allergens. The Air Quality Sciences Study of Carpet Cleaning found that moving poorly maintained carpet from a high humidity indoor setting to one with humidity controlled at less than 65% discontinued the growth of all mold. “After cleaning, test results from the previously contaminated carpet were comparable to those of a clean control carpet in terms of biocontaminants in the carpet and airborne particles.” (Berry, 2003) The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 10. 10 In addition to humidity control, regular and effective cleaning is the number one tool for an allergen-free, healthy environment. For example, The Hydro Labs Mold Study concluded that hot water extraction is highly effective in reducing mold growth. It concluded further that clean carpet “does not support mold growth even at prolonged and elevated temperature and humidity levels,” and clearly demonstrated that “vacuuming carpet surfaces is highly effective in reducing and managing the levels of culturable mold spore.” (Berry, 2003) Professor of Design and Environmental Analysis at Cornell University, Alan Hedge, determined through a 2001 study that concerns about carpet contributing to an increase in respiratory problems are unfounded. “As long as schools keep floors clean and use high-efficiency microfiltration vacuum bags, carpets can be a healthy, safe, and economical floor covering.” Proper cleaning and maintenance is a critical component of any flooring system. “Assessment of Carpet in Sensitive Environments.” Dr. Michael Berry’s 2001 report defines sensitive environments as those that directly affect the very young, the very old, and those who are ill. Dr. Barry studied the correlation between carpet and IAQ (indoor air quality) by examining the results of hundreds of other studies. He found that “Carpet is a preferred and widely used floor covering associated with minimal complaints…. About 1.2 billion square yards of carpet are installed every year. Complaints per square yard of carpet are extremely small…. Research to date, going back over 30 years, consistently shows carpet to be a safe and healthy product.” (Berry, 2003) Conclusion Carpet lends a relaxed feel to educational facilities through enhanced comfort, acoustics, and safety, all of which lead to better concentration, performance, attendance rates and the potential for higher test scores. In addition, the life-cycle costs of carpet installation and maintenance are more economical that those of hard surface flooring. Further, properly maintained carpet tends to reduce particles in the air and can enhance IAQ by holding allergens at bay and preventing their release into the air of heavily trafficked areas. These combined benefits make carpet an excellent flooring choice for school settings by contributing to a better environment for students, teachers, and all school personnel in various critical ways. (Berry, 2003) The Carpet and Rug Institute | Box 2048 | Dalton, GA 30722 | carpet-rug.org | 70 6 . 27 8 . 3176
  • 11. 11 B I B LI O G R APHY | 501 C AR PET FO R E DUC ATI O NAL FACI LITI E S Berry, Michael A., Ph.D. “Carpet in the Modern Indoor Environment: Summary of a Science-Based Assessment of Carpet.” University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 2003. “Educational Performance, Environmental Management, and Cleaning Effectiveness in School Environments,” April, 2001. “Final Report of the Hydrolab Project 2001: Flooring, Humidity, and Mold Growth.” Prepared for The Carpet and Rug Institute, February 20, 2002. “Healthy School Environment and Enhanced Educational Performance: The Case of Charles Young Elementary School, Washington, DC.” Prepared for The Carpet and Rug Institute, January 12, 2002. Beth Schapiro & Associates. “National Survey of Public Teachers.” Prepared for The Carpet and Rug Institute and The International Interior Design Association Foundation, March, 2001. Bishop, Jeff. “A Life-Cycle Cost Analysis for Floor Coverings in School Facilities,” March, 2002. “Carpet: Creating a Better Learning Environment.” Supplement to College Planning & Management and School Planning & Management.” In cooperation with The Carpet and Rug Institute, May 2001. “Carpet: The Educated Choice for Schools. Life-Cycle Cost Analysis.” Educational pamphlet for The Carpet and Rug Institute, 2000. “Carpet and High Performance Schools.” CRI Technical Services, January, 2003. “Carpet Maintenance for School Facilities.” Educational pamphlet for The Carpet and Rug Institute, 2000. “Carpet Makes the Grade In Schools.” Educational pamphlet for The Carpet and Rug Institute. “Carpet Usage & Allergic Reactions in Sweden.” http://www.carpetrug.org/pdf_word_docs/Swedish_Chart.pdf. “Carpet Scores Good Marks in Schools: A Smart, Sustainable, Solution in Floor Coverings.” Architectural Record. Carpet and Rug Institute, 2008. Cole, E.C. et.al. “Indoor Environment Characterization of a Non-Problem Building: Assessment of Cleaning Effectiveness.” Research Triangle Report Number 94U-4479-014, Research Triangle Institute, March 1994. D’Aoust, Angie. “Experts Warn of Noisy Classrooms: Audiologists and Speech-Language Pathologists warn of learning problems associated with noise.” CASLPA-ACOA, 2007. Foarde, Karin, Deborah Franke and Dr. Michael A. Berry. “Cleaning Effectiveness Demonstration in a Carpeted School.” w CRI Scientific Resources at http://www.carpet-rug.org/carpet-and-rug-industry/research-and-resources/scientific-research/ studies-alphabetically-by-title.cfm, November, 2002. Grass, Stephen video writer/producer. How Interior Design Solutions Help Create Better Learning Environments. Carpet and Rug Institute, 2004. Harmel, Kristin. “Listen to the Teacher: Good Classroom Acoustics are Vital to Effective Learning.” Explore: Research at the University of Florida, Spring, 2000. Hurd, Frank. “Carpet Aids Learning in High-Performance Schools.” Educational Facility Planner, Volume 43: Issue 4 (pp. 19-22), Spring 2009. Lang, Susan. “Carpets in Schools Don’t Compromise Indoor Air Quality.” Cornell Human Ecology, March 19, 2001. Lang, Susan. “CU expert: Carpets in Schools Benefit Indoor Air Quality.” Cornell Chronicle, March 29, 2001. State of California, School Sound Level Study, School Facilities and Transportation Division, California State Department of Education, 1998. “Myths & Truths about Carpet.” Educational pamphlet for The Carpet and Rug Institute, July, 2004.
  • 12. 12 Last Name First Name Job Title Firm Name Address City State Zip Telephone FAX E-mail AIA ID Number Completion Date (M/D/Y) IDCEC Number and Organization (IIDA, ASID, IDC, NEWH) Check one: $25.00 payment enclosed (Make check payable to the Carpet and Rug Institute, Box 2048, Dalton, GA 30722-2048.) Charge Visa Mastercard American Express Card # Exp.Date Signature PROGRAM TITLE: “CARPET IN EDUCATIONAL FACILITES” (8/10) AIA/CES CREDIT: This article will earn you one AIA/CES LU hour of health, safety and welfare/sustainable design (HSW/SD) credit or .1 CEU credit from IDCEC (valid for credit through July, 2012) DIRECTIONS: Select one answer for each question in the box beside the possible answers. Send or fax this page to Pat Jennings, The Carpet and Rug Institute, 730 College Drive, Dalton, GA 30720 or fax to 706.278.8835 or scan and email to pjennings@carpet-rug.org along with your check or credit card information. A minimum score of 80% is required to earn credit. A certificate of completion will be sent to each person who passes the test. 1. According to a survey of teachers, most feel that school design and classroom design: a) Do not impact learning c) Strongly impact learning b) Have little impact on learning d) None of the above 2. Carpet was added to classrooms at Charles Young Elementary School in order to: a) Make the staff more comfortable c) Appeal to outside groups who want to use the school during off-hours b) Reduce noise d) All of the above 3. One benefit of the 45,000 square feet of new carpeting installed in Charles Young Elementary School was that student test scores: a) Stayed the same c) Rose significantly b) Changed slightly d) Drastically lowered 4. A non-physical benefit of carpeting in schools is that it: a) Lets the students know that the school staff cares about them c) Creates a warm, aesthetic environment b) May reduce stress d) All of the above 5. Academically successful schools show: a) A sense of well-being among students c) Little interaction between parents and teachers b) A strong emphasis on athletics d) Little interaction between students and teachers 6. A good benefit analysis will show that carpet may be: a) More expensive to maintain c) Less expensive overall than other types of flooring b) Less expensive to maintain d) All of the above 7. The Acoustical Society of America reports that acoustical problems in classrooms are alleviated by the use of carpet. One of these acoustical problems was: a) Warmth c) Comfort b) Behavior and attention d) Both a & c 8. The U.S. Consumer Report Commission reported that in 1993 more people died in than in any other type of accident. a) Automobile accidents c) Slipping on ice b) Skiing accidents d) Indoor falls 9. CRI’s Green Label Plus programs offers customers: a) Lowest emitting carpet, adhesive and cushion c) Annual/semi-annual/quarterly testing of certified products b) Assurance that products meet stringent low-VOC criteria d) All of the above 10. Proper cleaning and maintenance of carpet will assure that neither nor will cause any problems. a) Moisture, temperature c) Students, teachers b) Mold, allergens d) None of the above