SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 127
Learning From

Alaska’s Telehealth Experience
                    Stewart Ferguson, PhD
                         John Kokesh, MD
2
3
4
Stewart Ferguson Ph.D. is Acting CIO for the Alaska Native Tribal Health
Consortium and Director of the Alaska Federal Health Care Access
Network (AFHCAN). He currently serves as Vice President of the
American Telemedicine Association.
   He has been involved in development for CT scanners, the forward and inverse
   problems in biomagnetism, and imaging techniques for cardiac activity. He holds
   M.S. and Ph.D. degrees both in Biomedical Engineering, and B.S. degrees in both
   Mathematics and Electrical Engineering.

John Kokesh, MD is Medical Director of the Department of
Otolaryngology at the Alaska Native Medical Center where has has
worked for the past 17 years. His a full time clinician whose focus in
telehealth is developing clinical applications, clinical outcomes
research, education and business processes for store and forward
telemedicine.
   He received his M.D. degree, residency training and head and neck oncology
   fellowship training at the University of Washington. He holds clinical faculty
   appointments at the University of Washington, Loyola University of Chicago and
   Central Michigan University. He is a fellow of the American Board of
                                                                                     5
   Otolaryngology.
Cases Created per Year                                  10 year Operational History
                                                                                                ◦ 20,000 cases / year
                25,000


                                                                                                ◦ 14,000 Alaska Natives served/year
                20,000
Cases Created




                15,000

                10,000                                                                          ◦ 900 Active providers / year
                    5,000                                                                      Whole Product Solution
                              0                                                                 ◦ Design  Manufacturing  Installation 
                                                                                                  Training  Support  Marketing
                                  2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
                                                                               (Proj)




                             16,000
                                      Annual Patient Involvement                               Alaska: 248 sites, 44 organizations
                             14,000                                                             ◦ 37 Tribal organizations
                                                                                                ◦ US Army sites (6) & US Air Force
                             12,000
                # Patients




                             10,000
                              8,000
                              6,000                                                               bases (3)
                              4,000
                              2,000
                                                                                                ◦ State of Alaska Public Health
                                  0
                                      2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
                                                                                                  Nursing (26)
                                                                                   (Proj)       ◦ Community Health Centers
                                                                                               Other states and countries
                                                                                                                                            6
When one has finished
building one’s house, one
  suddenly realizes that in
      the process one has
   learned something one
 really needed to know in
   the worst way – before
                one began

               Nietzsche, 1886
                7
PLEASE NOTE:

        Outcomes will be
presented on Thursday in
      a separate session.




               8
 TheAFHCAN Story … from
 a Program perspective.

 The AFHCAN Story … from
 a Clinician’s perspective.

 Skeletonsin the Closet …
 what we learned, and what
 we did right and wrong.

 Where   to next?
 Theseare our
 experiences.
 ◦ Actual mileage may vary.


 Some of these
 issues only apply to
 large scale systems.
 ◦ E.g. Apportionment,
   centralization.
… from a Program Perspective
ATA Defining Telemedicine
http://www.americantelemed.org/news/definition.html   12
1990-2002




Store &   Live
Forward   VtC
    Remote
   Monitoring
   Asynchronous.
   Low bandwidth requirements           Can create a case
   Static data – e.g. Vital signs        “on the run.”
                                          Doctor can respond
    Static Images
                                      

                                          when available.
    ◦ Digital camera (megapixel)         Many consults are
    ◦ Scans                               not critical.
    ◦ Captured video images              It is needed as a
      (ENT, Dental, Opthal., Naso.)       communication
   Video Clips – esp. from video         tool.
    devices                              Fits with present
   Temporal Data:                        model.
    ECG, stethoscope, tympanomet         Minimal onsite
                                          technical support is
    er                                    needed.
   Textual:
    ◦ Health summaries

                                                                 14
   1st in land mass
    ◦   1,420 miles (N-S)
    ◦   2,400 miles (E-W)

   33,900 miles of shoreline
    ◦   More than all of the
        contiguous states combined.
                                                  National Travel and
•   47th in road miles                            Safety Board (NTSB)
    – 75% Alaskan communities unconnected by reported 436
       a road to a hospital.                      commuter aircraft
    – 25 of these have no airport.                accidents in Alaska
    – 25% Alaskans (46% of Alaskan Natives)       from1990-2004 (2.8
       live in communities of less than 1000      accidents a month) -
       people.                                    accounting for 36%
                                                  of all commuter
•   Population density is 1.1 persons/mile2 aircraft accidents in
    – 70 times smaller than the national average. the US.
                                                                     15
    49% of all physicians in Alaska are primary care
     physicians (2002 data). U.S. average is 28%

    Alaska is 48th in “doctors to residents” ratio
     ◦   65% are located in Anchorage
     ◦   Shortages in many specialties
     ◦   579 Community Health Aides in 200 villages provide nearly
         ½ million encounters each year.

                                       AI/AN      U.S.      Gap
     DISPARITIES:                MD      73.9    220.6   66% Lower
    Health Staff per
                                 DD      24.0     61.8   61% Lower
    100,000 people
                              Nurse     229.0    849.9   73% Lower


                                                                     16
   180 Small Village
                             Health Centers
                             550 Community Health
                              Aides/Practitioners
                             125 Behavioral Health
                              Aides
                             20 Dental Health
                              Aides/ 12 Therapists
                             100 Home
                              health/personal care
Average Alaska village        attendants
      350 Residents


                                                  17
   Radio ’60’s
   Telephone 70’s
   Fax 80’s
   X-ray transmission 80’s
   Computer 90’s
   2 way video 90’s
   Universal Services Fund
    (USF) – broadband
    connectivity - 1999
GOAL: Evaluate the impact of low-bandwidth
telemedicine systems on costs, professional isolation
and provider/patient satisfaction

   Funded by NLM (National Library of Medicine)
    Contract #N01-LM-6-3540
    ◦ University of Alaska Anchorage (UAA)
      Fred Pearce, Ph.D. Principal Investigator
   4 Regional Health Corporations
    ◦ 26 Village clinics,
     3,000 cases 9,000 images
   Email-Based Software
   Basic Cart with video otoscope and camera
   Shipped in small boxes and flown to clinic
   Assembled by local high school students
 The solution need not be
  sophisticated or complex to
  be clinically effective …


 … as long as providers are
  able to gain value.

                                23
40%

35%
                                               Provider Experience
30%
                                               Telemedicine Cases
25%

20%

15%

10%

5%

0%
      0-4   5-9    10-14     15-19     20-24      25-29    30-34
                  Provider Years of Experience


      Clinical experience of health aides
         had no impact on utilization.
 It’s NOT about the technology –
  it’s about the value proposition.
 Experienced health aides saw
  the value – e.g. it let them
  convince the new doc that they
  really were seeing an infected ear.
 Think … “communication tool”
 Non-clinical factors will often
  drive usage and usage
  patterns … perhaps more
  than clinical factors.
 A note about evaluation – be
  careful! Notice Hawthorn
  effect (or top ten ways to kill
  telehealth usage)
Usage
100%


80%                                                                                   will grow
                                                                 Telehealth Cases
                                                                                        faster
                                                                 Linear Predictor
                                                                                      than the
60%
                                                                 Good Predictor
40%                                                                                   number
                                                                                       of sites
20%
                                                                                      involved
 0%
       Maniilaq (11 of 11)    NSHC (5 of 14)   BBAHC (5 of 28)       YKHC (5 of 46)
                             Organization (# clinics involved)
 Partial participation will results in
  less than partial results: We’re
  either all in or it’s not worth doing.
 Full participation and
  organization support is the only
  approach to gain desired
  utilization.
 Pilots may not tell you about
  larger systemic issues and may
  not be predictors of usage.
Cases Created per Year (by Role)
                6,000
                5,000
Cases Created




                4,000
                3,000
                2,000
                1,000
                   0
                         2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
                                                                      (Proj)
                                 Primary Care   Specialty Care


                                                                               30
Source: YKHC Policy PF_O52_PC “Telemedicine Cart Use”
 “I will fire anyone that does
  not do telemedicine” – Janet
  Shackles.
 Policies work.
The Alaska Native Health Board
The Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium
The Alaska Federal Health Care Partnership
    The Alaska Telehealth Advisory Council


                                             33
   Veterans Affairs
   DoD (Army & Air
    Force)
   DHS - (USCG)
   Indian Health Service
    (IHS):
   Alaska Native Tribal
    Healthcare
    Consortium (ANTHC)


                            34
A formal, voluntary,       Underling Philosophy
interagency relationship
                            Learning Organization
between the DoD, DHS,
                            Patient centered
IHS and VA working
                            Health care as close to
together by the sharing
                             home as possible
of each other’s
                            Long term
resources, talents, and
                             relationships
experience to improve
                            Respectful of individual
patient care throughout
                             cultures
the state of Alaska
                            Evolving process
                            Inclusive not exclusive



                                                        35
Alaska State Population: 626,932

                  DoD       Federal/ Tribal Population
Other
                  DHS
                           DoD/DHS          72,950
                           VA               63,000
                           IHS/Tribal       115,000
                     VA    Total            250,950
                            Note: Total Federal/Tribal
                            Population includes both “dual”
                            and “triple” beneficiaries
                  IHS &
                  Tribal



                            *2000 Census Figures
   Alaska Native Tribal
              Health Consortium
              (ANTHC)
              ◦ Management structure and
                support
              ◦ AFHCAN funds were
                centralized in ANTHC
                Appropriations may be used
                 as multi-year funds
AFHCAN MISSION: To improve access to
 health care for federal beneficiaries in Alaska
    through sustainable telehealth systems
AFHCAN MISSION
To improve access to health care for federal
beneficiaries in Alaska through sustainable
            telehealth systems

 Alaska
 Federal
 Health
 Care
 Access
 Network
 Leverage existing
  RELATIONSHIPS and
  collaborative groups.
 Leverage their contacts.
EXECUTIVE BOARD                                               TELEHEALTH
                       CEO / Commanders
             ANMC, VA, USCG, 3MDG, BACH, 354 MDG
                                                                                 Team


                    STEERING BOARD
AFHCP Planning Board Chairman, AFHCP Project Officer, AFHCP Business Office
    Director, ANMC Data Manager, and Clinical and Tribal Representatives

                                                                              AFHCAN
                                                                              Partners
                  Clinical
                                            Training



                             AFHCAN
                              Project
   Technology
                              Office
                                                  Business



                         Informatics
 Project Proposal with defined
  bylaws
 Autonomy of organizations
 Ownership of equipment
 Maintenance of referral
  patterns
 … for developing
  mission, intent, and funding
 … for overall design: Partner
 … for making it happen:
  Dedicated, committed work unit
  with
  staff, equipment, offices, funds, rol
  es and responsibilities.
 … for making it work: Partners
  plus office
                                     42
ATAC members
provide direction,           ATAC
leadership and
coordination of             Statewide
telehealth efforts          Telehealth
throughout Alaska.            Issues



                 ANTHC                    AFHCP
                                         Funded and
                Operating
                                          Supported
                AFHCAN
                                           AFHCAN

                                                      43
 More steering, less rowing.
 There is a role and need to involve
  partners not directly involved in the
  project
 Chance to involve payers, other
  systems, address issues of standards
  and interoperability, look to the
  future, share in successes.
 Created a buzz – and a sense of
  ownership beyond the project.

                                          44
Primary Care
                                                            Kasan
                       Primary Care
                                         Alicia             Clinic
                                                                           SEARHC Juneau
                                        Roberts
                                                                           Medical Center
                                        Medical
                                        Center
     Subregional Center
                                                                        Dental
                                                  Dental                                                Primary Care
     Initial Entry
                             Hydaburg
                               Clinic                                                     Dental
     Both Initial &
     Secondary
                                                Specialty
     Secondary Care                             Clinics                                            SEARHC Sitka
                                                                   Acute Care                         Clinics
     Secondary                                                                    Eye Care
                          Pelican                                                                             Emergency
                                                            MEH
     &Tertiary                              Diagnostic
     Outsourced            Clinic                                                                              Services
     Care                                    Services                                          Mental
                                                                                               Health
                                                         Therapy
Harborview
                          Haines Medical
  ANMC                        Center        Dental
                                            Planned
Providence                                                                                   Angoon Clinic
                 Primary Care
    AK                                                                                          (MLP)
   API
                                      Klukwan                                     Kake                     (Limited Entry)
 Private                               Clinic
MD/Dental                                             Tenahee                    Clinic
                                                                                                             Petersburg
                                                       Clinic                    (MLP)
                                                                                                              Wrangall
                                                                                                             Skagway

                                           The Clinical System                                               Ketchikan
What are your key organizational
goals for telehealth applications?

      Quality of Care

       Access to Care

  Patient Satisfaction

   Continuity of Care

 Information Transfer

  Cost of Care/Saving

                         1     2   3            4     5         6

                Low Priority       Average Priority       High Priority


                                                                          46
 May not tell you what you
  need to know.
 May not tell you where
  telehealth can impact clinical
  care.
 Might not be asking the right
  questions.
   Ear Disease
    ◦ Audiometer, Tympanometer,
      Video Otoscope
   Heart Disease
    ◦ ECG & Vital Signs Monitor
   Respiratory Illness
    ◦ Spirometer & Vital Signs
      Monitor
   Trauma, Skin & Wound
    ◦ Digital Camera
   Dental Problems
    ◦ Dental Camera
   General
    ◦ Scanner & Forms             50
   Base Cart include:
    ◦   Metal Frame
    ◦   Isolated Power System
    ◦   CPU and LCD Touchscreen
    ◦   Expansion Ports for USB, RS232,
        Video In/Out, External Display

   Currently Supported Peripherals
    include:
    ◦   Video Otoscope
    ◦   Digital Camera
    ◦   Scanner
    ◦   Video Conferencing
    ◦   ECG
    ◦   Spirometer
    ◦   Tympanometer
    ◦   Audiometer
    ◦   Dental Camera
    ◦   Vital Signs Monitor
    ◦   Stethoscope
National Telehealth Technology
                  Assessment Center
        Providing a variety of resources to the
NTTAC   telehealth community
           • Device assessment toolkits – five this year
           • Technical support to Regional Telehealth Resource
             Centers
           • News and information on technologies and clinical
             applications


        A robust online community for sharing
        and learning
               • Includes full access to toolkits and forums
               • Hosts and records webinars
               • Helps select technologies for assessment
               • Will have free membership through 2010

            www.TelehealthTAC.org
                        Made possible through support from HRSA and IHS
 Do NOT underestimate the value of a
  well designed SYSTEM (not just a
  collection of devices).
 The devil is truly in the details. This is
  where you need the detail people
  involved.
 Know the conditions you are
  designing for.
 Involve clinicians early and often in
  equipment review, and design.
 Decide if YOU want to become a
  manufacturer.
   Simplicity is
    key for Case
    Creation
   Minimize
    need for
    keyboard
    skills
   Touchscreen
   Color coded


                    56
   Rich Web
    Interface
    for
    Specialists

   Zero
    software
    footprint




                  57
 Minimal computer skills:
  Touchscreens
 High turnover rates (re-
  training): Few choices per
  screen, color coded
 Language barriers: Very
  selective word choice
 Disparate educational levels:
  Reduce complexity to few
  components
 Specialist? Ease of
  acquisition less
  important


 Primary Care
  Provider? Ease of
  acquisition more
  important
 More than hardware – the
  software design is NEVER done.
 Get a solution out quick.
 Know your users – and involve
  them heavily in design decisions.
 Do NOT let your developers add
  every “good” idea. Mandate
  clinical governance in software
  design decisions.
 Again - decide if YOU want to
  become a software developer.
Response Rate to Evaluation Questions
  2010 (Proj) (n=20,004)

       2009 (n=14,542)

       2008 (n=11,030)

       2007 (n=11,137)                                                                       Clinical
         2006 (n=8,817)                                                                       Committee
         2005 (n=7,771)                                                                       supported 1
         2004 (n=7,058)                                                                       question per
         2003 (n=5,058)                                                                       case session
         2002 (n=3,431)

          2001 (n=921)
                                                                                             Configurable
                           0%   10%   20%   30%    40% 50% 60%
                                                   Response Rate (%)
                                                                       70%   80%   90% 100%
                                                                                              questions
                            Consultant Responses       Initiator Responses

ATHS (Alaska Tribal Health System) (1/1/2001 to 8/31/2010)                                                   61
 Build in from the start
 Involve stakeholders in
  design
 Remember Hawthorn
Noatak Health Clinic




            Maniilaq Health Center
Satellite




Satellite




            Alaska Native Medical
               Center (ANMC)         63
 Solution must support the
  workflow
 Do not change workflows to
  support the solution.
 Workflows change. This
  requires a flexible system
 A massive shift in
                                                  the plan allowed
                                                  for design and
Original Plan              Actual Plan            testing phases.
                Oct 1998
                                                 A “multiphased”
  Deploy 40%                 NLM Deploy           approach provided
                                                  confidence for the
                Oct 1999                          rapid deployment
  Deploy 40%                  Equipment           of a basic solution.
  Support 40%                  selected
                Oct 2000
  Deploy 20%                 Deployment
  Support 40%                  Begins
                Oct 2001
  Support 20%                 250th Cart
                             Server-to-Server
                Oct 2002

                                                                         65
 Allow significant time for
  design and development – it
  will pay dividends.
 Plan for delays and problems
  – contingency plans for
  clinical care, problem
  resolution, design changes, …
Provides project oversight, coordination and
centralized management
   Planning                      Informatics and data
   Contractual and                needs
    Legal/regulatory              Clinical Program Design
   Recruitment of providers      Ongoing SLA Monitoring
   Needs and Site                Purchasing
    Assessments                   Deployment / Config.
   Technology Assessment         Support and Training
                                  Marketing
                                  Evaluation
                                                         67
Budget         Budget     % Budget
Lvl                Description                     (Installation)   (Support)   per Site
A1    Tertiary Care Native Medical Center           $1,535,200      $191,800    5.6360%
A2    Tertiary Care Military Medical Center         $1,375,520      $171,840    5.0498%
B1    Hospital - Very high workload                  $696,800       $87,000     2.5579%
B2    Hospital - High workload                       $625,120       $78,040     2.2947%
B3    Hospital - Medium high workload                $590,560       $73,720     2.1679%
B4    Hospital - Low high workload                   $397,520       $49,590     1.4591%
B5    Hospital - workload < 35,000                   $354,560       $44,220     1.3014%
C1    MD Health Center - Fairbanks                   $497,280       $62,060     1.8254%
C2    MD Health Center - VA                          $425,600       $53,100     1.5622%
C3    MD Health Center - Native Primary Care Ctr     $313,360       $39,070     1.1501%
C4    MD Health Center - workload 20,000-50,000      $262,800       $32,750     0.9645%
C5    MD Health Center - workload 10,000-20,000      $145,840       $18,130     0.5351%
C6    MD Health Center - workload < 10,000           $103,360       $12,820     0.3791%
D1    PA Health Center workload > 4000               $107,280       $13,310     0.3935%
D2    PA Health Center workload < 4000                $93,120       $11,540     0.3416%
E1    CHA Health Center workload > 4000              $100,240       $12,430     0.3677%
E2    CHA Health Center workload < 4000               $82,580       $10,260     0.3030%
F1    PHN Health Center workload > 4000               $79,600        $9,850     0.2919%
F2    PHN Health Center workload < 4000               $46,720        $5,740     0.1712% 68
Project Plan $30,685,640
                        5 Year Actuals (FY99-FY03)* $27,456,279
                                          *   Five Year Actuals are $28,332,505 including ATAC


                   Project Plan       Expenditures (FY99-FY03)

              Equipment (Phase 1)

Site Funds and Equipment (Phase 2)

            Software Development

   Project Design and Management

                      Deployment

Unfunded Requirements (e.g. ATAC)

                                     0%   5%       10%     15%    20%     25%    30%     35%
                                                 Percent of Budget or Actuals


                                                                                                 69
 Agree early on where the
  funds sit (central … or not)
 Agree on apportionment
  process
 Portion for
  cash, equipment, support, …
 Portion to remain centralized
… from a Clinician’s Perspective
 Find and develop interest
 Establish acceptance
 Promote usage
 Build programs
 Integrate telehealth into the
  standard way you deliver care
One question: Do we have a problem we
                        need to solve?
ENT Clinic Demand, Supply and Activity
                                          (Jan 2002 - May 2003)
                       60


                       50
Patient Appointments




                       40

                                                                               Avg Demand
                       30
                                                                               Avg Supply
                                                                               Avg Activity
                       20


                       10


                       0
                            Monday   Tuesday   Wednesday   Thursday   Friday




                                                                                              74
 If there is no perception of a
  problem, look elsewhere
 If they don’t think it is broken,
  you can’t fix it
Put the technology in their hands
              Make sure it works
                    Let them play
       Support, support, support
              Go for the easy win
                     Talk about it
How satisfied were you with the use        Willing to have a telemedicine
of the telemedicine technology?            exam for follow-up?
     25
                                                     30
     20
     15                                              20
     10                                              10
      5                                               0
      0
                                                           No    Yes
              Poor Fair GoodVery
                           Good
                                               Overall Satisfaction
How well did the telemedicine technology         With This Visit
help you understand your problem?             25
      30                                      20
                                              15
      20
                                              10
      10
                                               5
          0                                    0
               PoorFair ood
                      G    Very                    Poor Fair Good Very
                          Good                                    Good      79
“I was able to see the
                       problem - then the
                       repaired normal condition
                       … and discussed my
                       problem - very
                       informative!”



“I liked to see with
my own eyes the
inside of my ear!”
 Let your customers (patients)
  create your buzz.
   For clinicians, you have to prove it works
   There must be a value proposition
    •   Better?
    •   More efficient?
    •   You can do what you otherwise can’t do
    •   More profitable?
   254 sets of tubes
    placed at ANMC in
    2000

   1,000 follow up
    appointments needed
    in 12 month period

   Many of these
    patients from remote
    areas
                           83
   To determine if video
    otoscope still images
    (640 x 480 pixel resolution) of
    the tympanic
    membrane following
    surgical placement of
    tympanostomy tubes
    are comparable to an
    in-person microscopic
    examination.
% CONCORDANCE ON PHYSICAL EXAM

                100%         99%        99%                                 99%
                                                    97%         96%
                95%                                                                     94%
                90%                                                                                  90%
                                                                                                              InterProvider (Exam0)
                85%
                80%                                                                                           IntraProvider using all images
                                                                                                                   (Exam0 vs Review1,2)
                75%
                70%                                                                                           IntraProvider using "good" images
                65%                                                                                                (Exam0 vs Review1,2)
% Concordance




                60%
                55%      High level of agreement                                    Correlation between in person
                50%
                45%                                                                  exam and telemedicine exam
                40%
                                                                                     good to excellent
                35%
                30%                                                                 Telemedicine can be used to do
                25%
                20%
                                                                                     routine ear tube follow up
                15%                                                                 Make available several hundred
                10%
                 5%
                                                                                     appointments per year
                 0%
                       Tube In     Tube       Drainage   Perforation Granulation Middle ear   Retracted
                                   Patent                                           fluid
                                              Physical Exam Descriptors

   Kokesh J, Ferguson AS, Patricoski C, Koller K, Zwack G, Provost E, Holck P. “Digital images for postsurgical follow-up of tympanostomy
   tubes in remote Alaska”. Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, 139:87-93, 2008.

   Patricoski C, Kokesh J, Ferguson AS, Koller K, Zwack G, Provost E, Holck P. “A Comparison of In-Person Examination and Video Otoscope
   Imaging for Tympanostomy Tube Follow-Up”. Telemedicine Journal and e-Health, 9(4):331-344, 2003.
   “Waiting time for a field clinic
                                             appointment has gone from
                                             4-5 months a year ago to 1-
                                             2 months now. I've probably
                                             got 100 stories of patients or
                                             parents who were pleased
                                             with the quicker, easier
                                             access to ENT services they
Kokesh J, Ferguson AS, Patricoski C.         received either through
“Preoperative planning for ear surgery
using store-and-forward
                                             telemed or direct referral.”
telemedicine”. Otolaryngology-Head                   Mike Comerford, Audiologist,
and Neck Surgery, 143:253-
257, 2010.                                    Yukon Kuskokwim Health Corporation
 Low hanging fruit is still
  fruit.
 Take it
 Talk about it




                               87
 If you often say “There must
  be a better way” there
  probably is
 Look for these in terms of
  telemedicine



                               88
Take your best ideas and build on them.




                                          89
Traveling a Provider to Promote Efficiency and Rapid
    Delivery of ENT Care Through Telemedicine




Kokesh J, Ferguson AS, Patricoski C, LeMaster B. “Traveling an Audiologist to Provide Otolaryngology
Care Using Store-and-Forward Telemedicine”. Telemedicine and e-Health, 15(8):758-763, 2009.
Patient        Cost
                                                               Visits
Traveling Audiologist Program                                 1,987        ($175,000)

Patient Travel Prevented                                      1,726        $697,090
  Based on Outcomes of:
       • Did patient still need to travel to field clinic?
  Assumptions:                                               Note: 1,153
       • Only travel to hub is being saved.
       • Escort required if patient less than 18 years old
                                                              less than
       • No lodging / per diem calculated                     18 yrs old

Net Savings in Travel Costs                                                $522,090
Realized by Program                                                         (300% ROI)
 Proven technology
 High unmet need
 No other good solutions




                            96
   Evolve successes to predictable levels of
                                 clinical service
   Find and support (but don’t solely rely on)
                      your clinical champions
                         Clinical protocols matter
                But it’s all about RELATIONSHIPS

                                                      97
Champion                       Service Model
   Can                           Guarantee of performance
    ◦   See potential             Agreed upon expectations
    ◦   Create
                                  Sustainable and scalable
    ◦   Innovate
    ◦   Nurture                   Accountable
   Can’t                         Independent of
    ◦ Sustain                      individuals
    ◦ Grow to large scale         Requires support
    ◦ Leave something behind       structure




                                                              98
   Multi-provider, multi-region, multi-
    organization, multi-jurisdiction, patient
    participant….

   Focus on integrating with the way providers
    work and formalizing relationships and
    mutual responsibilities:
    ◦   Who accepts referrals?
    ◦   Do they have specific data requirements?
    ◦   How fast must they answer?
    ◦   How do you track what is happening?
    ◦   How is everyone paid?
    ◦   Who gets notified and must respond when the
        patients telemetry data tanks?

                                                      99
   Software can
    help drive
    clinical
    protocols

   Essential for
    program
    development




                    100
2.6 cases/month                 7.9 cases/month    Almost
                       10
                                                                                     250 more
Avg Monthly Caseload




                       8
                                                                                     patients
                       6                                                             are being
                       4                                                             seen per
                       2                                                             year, a
                       0                                                             savings in
                            -48     -36       -24        -12      0        12   24
                                                                                     80 man-
                                                                                     years of
                                     TIME Relative to CME/Training (months)

                                          Before CME           After CME
                                                                                     waiting
                                                                                     time.
                                          AVG (Before)         AVG (After)




                                                                                                  101
Misunderstanding incentives
     The workload / capacity mismatch
“In addition to” versus “Instead of” trap




                                            102
103
 Know the incentives for
  behavior within your
  system, and make sure that
  they on in alignment with
  what you are trying to
  accomplish
 If they are not, change the
  incentives or move on to a
  different project.
You may be “too
                               successful”

                               System usage
                               may grow faster
                               than you can
                               grow capacity


Have contingency plans – short and long term
Frame telemedicine
                                                       12





                          Median Time per Case (min)
    as a better way to
                                                       10

                                                       8

    do existing work,                                  6

    not just additional                                4


    work                                               2


    Provide appropriate
                                                       0
                                                      Sep-02   Sep-03   Sep-04   Sep-05   Sep-06

    incentives
   Don’t reward work
    well done with
    more work
 If you are not a clinician, “Live a
  day” with your clinician(s)
 Knowing the work, the
  workflow, the systems within
  which they work will provide
  you a huge advantage
 Build
  trust, understanding, rapport

                                   108
… what we learned,
and what we did right and wrong.
… don’t get so caught up in the “doing” that you
 neglect to reflect, speak and write about what
                           you have done so far.
Annual Provider Usage
                                                 (by Experience)
                                  1,000

                                   800




                    # Providers
                                   600

   …early on and                   400


forever. And over                  200


  and over again.
                                     0
                                          2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

                                                     Return     New
Don’t be afraid to pull and reallocate
                           resources.
Make sure you have the expertise and tools
                    you need at the outset
Goodwill eventually runs out.
Where does Telehealth fit into the
 “Health Information Exchange?”
WHAT IS HOT

CONNECTED HEALTH
   AFHCAN’s success in the past has been by ourselves
                     AFHCAN    AFHCAN
                      server    server



          AFHCAN’s future success will be based on
          how well our system can work with others
The goal of HIE is to
                       Health Information
There   VtC   S&F
                       ExchangeaccessTheand
                       facilitate (HIE) to
                       retrieval of clinical data to
                       mobilization of healthcare
                       provide safer, more
                       information electronically
Space                  timely, efficient, effective, e
                       across organizations within
                       a region, patient-centered
                       quitable, community or
                       care.
                       hospital system.

 Here                “Classic” EHR/ EMR

    Now       Soon      Time                   Future
                                                         117
118
118
“Network of Networks”
being developed to provide a secure, nationwide, interoperable health
information infrastructure that will connect providers, consumers, and
others involved in supporting health and healthcare

                    HISPC Electronic Health Record (EHR) Laboratory Results Reporting
                     IS 01:
Policy              The02: Biosurveillance
                     IS Health Information
                    Security and Privacy Empowerment
                     IS 03: Consumer
                    Collaboration
                     IS 04: Emergency Responder Electronic Health Record (ER-EHR)
                    HITSP Consumer Empowerment and Access to Clinical Information
                     IS 05:
Standards            via Media
                    Healthcare Information
                     IS 06: Quality
                    Technology Standards Panel
                     IS 07: Medication Management
                     IS 08: Personalized Healthcare
                    CCHIT Consultations and Transfers of Care
                     IS 09:
Certification       Certification Commission for
                     IS 10: Immunizations and Response Management
                    Healthcare Information
                     IS 11: Public Health Case Reporting
                    Technology
                     IS 12: Patient – Provider Secure Messaging
                     IS 77: Remote Monitoring
Samples:
                    C32 – Summary Document Using HL7 CCD
                        May include administrative
                        (e.g., registration, demographics, insurance, et
                        c.) and clinical (problem list, medication
                        list, allergies, test results, etc) information
                    C48 – Encounter Document
AFHCAN will be          Supports the process of sending patient
going live with         encounter data (excluding laboratory and
                        radiology)
C32 interfaces to
EHRs statewide      C74 – Remote Monitoring Observation
                        Medical information collected by remote
later in 2010.          monitoring management systems from
                        monitoring devices and/or device
                        intermediaries

                    C84 – Consult and History & physical note
                        Support the exchange of information from a
                        consulting provider to a referring provider;
                        and may also be used to provide background
                        information from a referring provider to a
                        consulting provider
                                                             120
2003-2009
                    Blending
                  Specialties




Store &   Live
Forward   VtC
    Remote
   Monitoring
2010 
                 Technology
                   Blending




Store &   Live
Forward   VtC
    Remote
   Monitoring
Traditional Devices
+ New Connectivity
+ New Messaging
 = NEW SOLUTIONS       124
 Recognize that needs and
  technologies will shift during
  the lifetime of your system.
 Constantly re-assess your
  program.
 Look for the next thing.

                              125
   Telehealth is a clinical mandate, not a technical
    initiative.
   Provide a predictable level of service (with scarce
    clinical resources).
   Support local planning and decision making.
   Provide state/national coordination, planning
    and accountability.
   Create efficiencies through centralized services.
   Leverage existing expertise.


                                                     126
Thank You
John Kokesh, MD                 Stewart Ferguson, PhD
Department of Otolaryngology    Alaska Federal Health Care Access
Alaska Native Medical Center       Network (AFHCAN)
4315 Diplomacy Drive            Alaska Native Tribal Health
                                   Consortium
Anchorage, AK 99508
                                4000 Ambassador Drive
                                Anchorage, AK 99508
(907) 729-1416
jkokesh@anthc.org
                                (907) 729-2262
                                sferguson@anthc.org




AFHCAN, Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium, Anchorage, AK

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Reputacion Online en buscadores - Politica2.cero Madrid 2012
Reputacion Online en buscadores - Politica2.cero Madrid 2012Reputacion Online en buscadores - Politica2.cero Madrid 2012
Reputacion Online en buscadores - Politica2.cero Madrid 2012t2ó | Connect. Convert. Grow.
 
Presentación Bienetec. Realidad Aumentada en Entorno Educativo, Escuela 2.0 G...
Presentación Bienetec. Realidad Aumentada en Entorno Educativo, Escuela 2.0 G...Presentación Bienetec. Realidad Aumentada en Entorno Educativo, Escuela 2.0 G...
Presentación Bienetec. Realidad Aumentada en Entorno Educativo, Escuela 2.0 G...sergio-Ballester
 
Entrevistas en La Voz de Medina
Entrevistas en La Voz de MedinaEntrevistas en La Voz de Medina
Entrevistas en La Voz de MedinaAngélica García
 
Semiconductivity-priya
Semiconductivity-priyaSemiconductivity-priya
Semiconductivity-priyaPriyanka Priya
 
Getting Major Donors
Getting Major DonorsGetting Major Donors
Getting Major Donorskjhorn
 
Bosentan- Systematic Review
Bosentan- Systematic ReviewBosentan- Systematic Review
Bosentan- Systematic ReviewHaroon Rashid
 
Incubating Apache Linda (ApacheCon Europe 2012)
Incubating Apache Linda (ApacheCon Europe 2012)Incubating Apache Linda (ApacheCon Europe 2012)
Incubating Apache Linda (ApacheCon Europe 2012)Sergio Fernández
 
Programa fiestas de julio 2012
Programa fiestas de julio 2012Programa fiestas de julio 2012
Programa fiestas de julio 2012TENERIFEWEEK
 
Sector Financiero Panamá Aspectos Criminológicos
Sector Financiero Panamá Aspectos CriminológicosSector Financiero Panamá Aspectos Criminológicos
Sector Financiero Panamá Aspectos CriminológicosGloria Cheng
 
Comprension lectora
Comprension lectoraComprension lectora
Comprension lectoramajetove
 
A clara se le movía un diente
A clara se le movía un dienteA clara se le movía un diente
A clara se le movía un dientecatalega
 
Planificación, implementación y evaluación de la Agricultura Climáticamente I...
Planificación, implementación y evaluación de la Agricultura Climáticamente I...Planificación, implementación y evaluación de la Agricultura Climáticamente I...
Planificación, implementación y evaluación de la Agricultura Climáticamente I...FAO
 
IoT.est Project ID Card
IoT.est Project ID CardIoT.est Project ID Card
IoT.est Project ID Cardiotest
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Reputacion Online en buscadores - Politica2.cero Madrid 2012
Reputacion Online en buscadores - Politica2.cero Madrid 2012Reputacion Online en buscadores - Politica2.cero Madrid 2012
Reputacion Online en buscadores - Politica2.cero Madrid 2012
 
Presentación Bienetec. Realidad Aumentada en Entorno Educativo, Escuela 2.0 G...
Presentación Bienetec. Realidad Aumentada en Entorno Educativo, Escuela 2.0 G...Presentación Bienetec. Realidad Aumentada en Entorno Educativo, Escuela 2.0 G...
Presentación Bienetec. Realidad Aumentada en Entorno Educativo, Escuela 2.0 G...
 
EMPRENDER ES FACIL. Manual autoempleo
EMPRENDER ES FACIL. Manual autoempleoEMPRENDER ES FACIL. Manual autoempleo
EMPRENDER ES FACIL. Manual autoempleo
 
telescopios-guia-practica
telescopios-guia-practicatelescopios-guia-practica
telescopios-guia-practica
 
Entrevistas en La Voz de Medina
Entrevistas en La Voz de MedinaEntrevistas en La Voz de Medina
Entrevistas en La Voz de Medina
 
Semiconductivity-priya
Semiconductivity-priyaSemiconductivity-priya
Semiconductivity-priya
 
Glycine survey in china
Glycine survey in chinaGlycine survey in china
Glycine survey in china
 
Getting Major Donors
Getting Major DonorsGetting Major Donors
Getting Major Donors
 
Bosentan- Systematic Review
Bosentan- Systematic ReviewBosentan- Systematic Review
Bosentan- Systematic Review
 
Incubating Apache Linda (ApacheCon Europe 2012)
Incubating Apache Linda (ApacheCon Europe 2012)Incubating Apache Linda (ApacheCon Europe 2012)
Incubating Apache Linda (ApacheCon Europe 2012)
 
Programa fiestas de julio 2012
Programa fiestas de julio 2012Programa fiestas de julio 2012
Programa fiestas de julio 2012
 
Sector Financiero Panamá Aspectos Criminológicos
Sector Financiero Panamá Aspectos CriminológicosSector Financiero Panamá Aspectos Criminológicos
Sector Financiero Panamá Aspectos Criminológicos
 
Comprension lectora
Comprension lectoraComprension lectora
Comprension lectora
 
What has helped me get this far in my business?
What has helped me get this far in my business?What has helped me get this far in my business?
What has helped me get this far in my business?
 
A clara se le movía un diente
A clara se le movía un dienteA clara se le movía un diente
A clara se le movía un diente
 
Planificación, implementación y evaluación de la Agricultura Climáticamente I...
Planificación, implementación y evaluación de la Agricultura Climáticamente I...Planificación, implementación y evaluación de la Agricultura Climáticamente I...
Planificación, implementación y evaluación de la Agricultura Climáticamente I...
 
IoT.est Project ID Card
IoT.est Project ID CardIoT.est Project ID Card
IoT.est Project ID Card
 

Similar to Learning from Alaska's Pioneering Telehealth Experience

AFHCAN & Alaska Telemedicine
AFHCAN & Alaska TelemedicineAFHCAN & Alaska Telemedicine
AFHCAN & Alaska TelemedicineSamantha Haas
 
Stewart ferguson afhcan
Stewart ferguson afhcanStewart ferguson afhcan
Stewart ferguson afhcanSamantha Haas
 
Presentation eahfc 2012
Presentation eahfc 2012Presentation eahfc 2012
Presentation eahfc 2012UHF-EAHF2012
 
PC-medical tourism in metro manila
PC-medical tourism in metro manilaPC-medical tourism in metro manila
PC-medical tourism in metro manilaSarit Tiyawongsuwan
 
Barbara starfield presentation cancun wonca may 05 27-10
Barbara starfield presentation cancun wonca may 05 27-10Barbara starfield presentation cancun wonca may 05 27-10
Barbara starfield presentation cancun wonca may 05 27-10Miguel Pizzanelli
 
ABC of Oct and octa
ABC of Oct and octaABC of Oct and octa
ABC of Oct and octaAjitThakur45
 
RAPIDARC- NEW ERA IN RADIOTHERAPY
RAPIDARC- NEW ERA IN RADIOTHERAPYRAPIDARC- NEW ERA IN RADIOTHERAPY
RAPIDARC- NEW ERA IN RADIOTHERAPYPuneet Seth
 
Qualcomm Slides Clint McClellan
Qualcomm Slides Clint McClellanQualcomm Slides Clint McClellan
Qualcomm Slides Clint McClellanMarco Thompson
 
Information Visualization for Health Care
Information Visualization for Health CareInformation Visualization for Health Care
Information Visualization for Health CareKrist Wongsuphasawat
 
Plenary 1 Driving Quality Through Innovation
Plenary 1 Driving Quality Through InnovationPlenary 1 Driving Quality Through Innovation
Plenary 1 Driving Quality Through InnovationNHSScotlandEvent
 
Investing In Your Health Final
Investing In Your Health FinalInvesting In Your Health Final
Investing In Your Health Finalscamello
 
Dr.Harold_OverviewofAmericanCollegeofCardiology_SJMC Cardiovascular Symposium
Dr.Harold_OverviewofAmericanCollegeofCardiology_SJMC Cardiovascular SymposiumDr.Harold_OverviewofAmericanCollegeofCardiology_SJMC Cardiovascular Symposium
Dr.Harold_OverviewofAmericanCollegeofCardiology_SJMC Cardiovascular SymposiumStJosephsMedicalCenter
 
Gasact and you murray selig
Gasact and you   murray seligGasact and you   murray selig
Gasact and you murray seliglblasset
 

Similar to Learning from Alaska's Pioneering Telehealth Experience (20)

AFHCAN & Alaska Telemedicine
AFHCAN & Alaska TelemedicineAFHCAN & Alaska Telemedicine
AFHCAN & Alaska Telemedicine
 
Stewart ferguson afhcan
Stewart ferguson afhcanStewart ferguson afhcan
Stewart ferguson afhcan
 
Presentation eahfc 2012
Presentation eahfc 2012Presentation eahfc 2012
Presentation eahfc 2012
 
Dd
DdDd
Dd
 
PC-medical tourism in metro manila
PC-medical tourism in metro manilaPC-medical tourism in metro manila
PC-medical tourism in metro manila
 
Igrt Perspectives
Igrt PerspectivesIgrt Perspectives
Igrt Perspectives
 
Barbara starfield presentation cancun wonca may 05 27-10
Barbara starfield presentation cancun wonca may 05 27-10Barbara starfield presentation cancun wonca may 05 27-10
Barbara starfield presentation cancun wonca may 05 27-10
 
Vilnius pres lesleyanne hawthorne
Vilnius pres lesleyanne hawthorneVilnius pres lesleyanne hawthorne
Vilnius pres lesleyanne hawthorne
 
ABC of Oct and octa
ABC of Oct and octaABC of Oct and octa
ABC of Oct and octa
 
RAPIDARC- NEW ERA IN RADIOTHERAPY
RAPIDARC- NEW ERA IN RADIOTHERAPYRAPIDARC- NEW ERA IN RADIOTHERAPY
RAPIDARC- NEW ERA IN RADIOTHERAPY
 
British Columbia Medical Journal - November 2010
British Columbia Medical Journal - November 2010British Columbia Medical Journal - November 2010
British Columbia Medical Journal - November 2010
 
Qualcomm Slides Clint McClellan
Qualcomm Slides Clint McClellanQualcomm Slides Clint McClellan
Qualcomm Slides Clint McClellan
 
UNC Defense & Research
UNC Defense & ResearchUNC Defense & Research
UNC Defense & Research
 
Information Visualization for Health Care
Information Visualization for Health CareInformation Visualization for Health Care
Information Visualization for Health Care
 
IRC_Capabilities
IRC_CapabilitiesIRC_Capabilities
IRC_Capabilities
 
Plenary 1 Driving Quality Through Innovation
Plenary 1 Driving Quality Through InnovationPlenary 1 Driving Quality Through Innovation
Plenary 1 Driving Quality Through Innovation
 
Investing In Your Health Final
Investing In Your Health FinalInvesting In Your Health Final
Investing In Your Health Final
 
Dr.Harold_OverviewofAmericanCollegeofCardiology_SJMC Cardiovascular Symposium
Dr.Harold_OverviewofAmericanCollegeofCardiology_SJMC Cardiovascular SymposiumDr.Harold_OverviewofAmericanCollegeofCardiology_SJMC Cardiovascular Symposium
Dr.Harold_OverviewofAmericanCollegeofCardiology_SJMC Cardiovascular Symposium
 
Gasact and you murray selig
Gasact and you   murray seligGasact and you   murray selig
Gasact and you murray selig
 
View From the North
View From the NorthView From the North
View From the North
 

More from Health Informatics New Zealand

The Austin Health Diabetes Discovery Initiative: Using technology to support ...
The Austin Health Diabetes Discovery Initiative: Using technology to support ...The Austin Health Diabetes Discovery Initiative: Using technology to support ...
The Austin Health Diabetes Discovery Initiative: Using technology to support ...Health Informatics New Zealand
 
Shaping Informatics for Allied Health - Refining our voice
Shaping Informatics for Allied Health - Refining our voiceShaping Informatics for Allied Health - Refining our voice
Shaping Informatics for Allied Health - Refining our voiceHealth Informatics New Zealand
 
Laptop computers enhancing clinical care in community allied health service
Laptop computers enhancing clinical care in community allied health serviceLaptop computers enhancing clinical care in community allied health service
Laptop computers enhancing clinical care in community allied health serviceHealth Informatics New Zealand
 
Safe IT Practices: making it easy to do the right thing
Safe IT Practices: making it easy to do the right thingSafe IT Practices: making it easy to do the right thing
Safe IT Practices: making it easy to do the right thingHealth Informatics New Zealand
 
Reducing hospitalisations and arrests of mental health patients through the u...
Reducing hospitalisations and arrests of mental health patients through the u...Reducing hospitalisations and arrests of mental health patients through the u...
Reducing hospitalisations and arrests of mental health patients through the u...Health Informatics New Zealand
 
Using the EMR in early recognition and management of sepsis
Using the EMR in early recognition and management of sepsisUsing the EMR in early recognition and management of sepsis
Using the EMR in early recognition and management of sepsisHealth Informatics New Zealand
 
Allied Health and informatics: Identifying our voice - can you hear us?
Allied Health and informatics: Identifying our voice - can you hear us?Allied Health and informatics: Identifying our voice - can you hear us?
Allied Health and informatics: Identifying our voice - can you hear us?Health Informatics New Zealand
 
Change in the data collection landscape: opportunity, possibilities and poten...
Change in the data collection landscape: opportunity, possibilities and poten...Change in the data collection landscape: opportunity, possibilities and poten...
Change in the data collection landscape: opportunity, possibilities and poten...Health Informatics New Zealand
 
Overview of the New Zealand Maternity Clinical Information System
Overview of the New Zealand Maternity Clinical Information SystemOverview of the New Zealand Maternity Clinical Information System
Overview of the New Zealand Maternity Clinical Information SystemHealth Informatics New Zealand
 
Electronic prescribing system medication errors: Identification, classificati...
Electronic prescribing system medication errors: Identification, classificati...Electronic prescribing system medication errors: Identification, classificati...
Electronic prescribing system medication errors: Identification, classificati...Health Informatics New Zealand
 
Global trends in technology for retailers and how they are impacting the phar...
Global trends in technology for retailers and how they are impacting the phar...Global trends in technology for retailers and how they are impacting the phar...
Global trends in technology for retailers and how they are impacting the phar...Health Informatics New Zealand
 
"Not flying under the radar": Developing an App for Patient-led Management of...
"Not flying under the radar": Developing an App for Patient-led Management of..."Not flying under the radar": Developing an App for Patient-led Management of...
"Not flying under the radar": Developing an App for Patient-led Management of...Health Informatics New Zealand
 
The quantified self: Does personalised monitoring change everything?
The quantified self: Does personalised monitoring change everything?The quantified self: Does personalised monitoring change everything?
The quantified self: Does personalised monitoring change everything?Health Informatics New Zealand
 

More from Health Informatics New Zealand (20)

The Austin Health Diabetes Discovery Initiative: Using technology to support ...
The Austin Health Diabetes Discovery Initiative: Using technology to support ...The Austin Health Diabetes Discovery Initiative: Using technology to support ...
The Austin Health Diabetes Discovery Initiative: Using technology to support ...
 
Shaping Informatics for Allied Health - Refining our voice
Shaping Informatics for Allied Health - Refining our voiceShaping Informatics for Allied Health - Refining our voice
Shaping Informatics for Allied Health - Refining our voice
 
Surveillance of social media: Big data analytics
Surveillance of social media: Big data analyticsSurveillance of social media: Big data analytics
Surveillance of social media: Big data analytics
 
The Power of Surface Modelling
The Power of Surface ModellingThe Power of Surface Modelling
The Power of Surface Modelling
 
Laptop computers enhancing clinical care in community allied health service
Laptop computers enhancing clinical care in community allied health serviceLaptop computers enhancing clinical care in community allied health service
Laptop computers enhancing clinical care in community allied health service
 
Making surgical practice improvement easy
Making surgical practice improvement easyMaking surgical practice improvement easy
Making surgical practice improvement easy
 
Safe IT Practices: making it easy to do the right thing
Safe IT Practices: making it easy to do the right thingSafe IT Practices: making it easy to do the right thing
Safe IT Practices: making it easy to do the right thing
 
Beyond EMR - so you've got an EMR - what next?
Beyond EMR - so you've got an EMR - what next?Beyond EMR - so you've got an EMR - what next?
Beyond EMR - so you've got an EMR - what next?
 
Empowered Health
Empowered HealthEmpowered Health
Empowered Health
 
Reducing hospitalisations and arrests of mental health patients through the u...
Reducing hospitalisations and arrests of mental health patients through the u...Reducing hospitalisations and arrests of mental health patients through the u...
Reducing hospitalisations and arrests of mental health patients through the u...
 
Using the EMR in early recognition and management of sepsis
Using the EMR in early recognition and management of sepsisUsing the EMR in early recognition and management of sepsis
Using the EMR in early recognition and management of sepsis
 
Allied Health and informatics: Identifying our voice - can you hear us?
Allied Health and informatics: Identifying our voice - can you hear us?Allied Health and informatics: Identifying our voice - can you hear us?
Allied Health and informatics: Identifying our voice - can you hear us?
 
Change in the data collection landscape: opportunity, possibilities and poten...
Change in the data collection landscape: opportunity, possibilities and poten...Change in the data collection landscape: opportunity, possibilities and poten...
Change in the data collection landscape: opportunity, possibilities and poten...
 
Overview of the New Zealand Maternity Clinical Information System
Overview of the New Zealand Maternity Clinical Information SystemOverview of the New Zealand Maternity Clinical Information System
Overview of the New Zealand Maternity Clinical Information System
 
Nhitb wednesday 9am plenary (sadhana first)
Nhitb wednesday 9am plenary (sadhana first)Nhitb wednesday 9am plenary (sadhana first)
Nhitb wednesday 9am plenary (sadhana first)
 
Oncology treatment patterns in the South Island
Oncology treatment patterns in the South IslandOncology treatment patterns in the South Island
Oncology treatment patterns in the South Island
 
Electronic prescribing system medication errors: Identification, classificati...
Electronic prescribing system medication errors: Identification, classificati...Electronic prescribing system medication errors: Identification, classificati...
Electronic prescribing system medication errors: Identification, classificati...
 
Global trends in technology for retailers and how they are impacting the phar...
Global trends in technology for retailers and how they are impacting the phar...Global trends in technology for retailers and how they are impacting the phar...
Global trends in technology for retailers and how they are impacting the phar...
 
"Not flying under the radar": Developing an App for Patient-led Management of...
"Not flying under the radar": Developing an App for Patient-led Management of..."Not flying under the radar": Developing an App for Patient-led Management of...
"Not flying under the radar": Developing an App for Patient-led Management of...
 
The quantified self: Does personalised monitoring change everything?
The quantified self: Does personalised monitoring change everything?The quantified self: Does personalised monitoring change everything?
The quantified self: Does personalised monitoring change everything?
 

Recently uploaded

Call Girls Thane Just Call 9910780858 Get High Class Call Girls Service
Call Girls Thane Just Call 9910780858 Get High Class Call Girls ServiceCall Girls Thane Just Call 9910780858 Get High Class Call Girls Service
Call Girls Thane Just Call 9910780858 Get High Class Call Girls Servicesonalikaur4
 
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy PlatformSee the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy PlatformKweku Zurek
 
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Hebbal Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Availablenarwatsonia7
 
Call Girls Service In Shyam Nagar Whatsapp 8445551418 Independent Escort Service
Call Girls Service In Shyam Nagar Whatsapp 8445551418 Independent Escort ServiceCall Girls Service In Shyam Nagar Whatsapp 8445551418 Independent Escort Service
Call Girls Service In Shyam Nagar Whatsapp 8445551418 Independent Escort Serviceparulsinha
 
Hemostasis Physiology and Clinical correlations by Dr Faiza.pdf
Hemostasis Physiology and Clinical correlations by Dr Faiza.pdfHemostasis Physiology and Clinical correlations by Dr Faiza.pdf
Hemostasis Physiology and Clinical correlations by Dr Faiza.pdfMedicoseAcademics
 
Dwarka Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
Dwarka Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...Dwarka Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
Dwarka Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...rajnisinghkjn
 
Russian Call Girls in Pune Riya 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call gi...
Russian Call Girls in Pune Riya 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call gi...Russian Call Girls in Pune Riya 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call gi...
Russian Call Girls in Pune Riya 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call gi...Miss joya
 
Call Girls Hsr Layout Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Hsr Layout Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Hsr Layout Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Hsr Layout Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Availablenarwatsonia7
 
Kolkata Call Girls Services 9907093804 @24x7 High Class Babes Here Call Now
Kolkata Call Girls Services 9907093804 @24x7 High Class Babes Here Call NowKolkata Call Girls Services 9907093804 @24x7 High Class Babes Here Call Now
Kolkata Call Girls Services 9907093804 @24x7 High Class Babes Here Call NowNehru place Escorts
 
call girls in munirka DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in munirka  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in munirka  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in munirka DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️saminamagar
 
call girls in green park DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in green park  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in green park  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in green park DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️saminamagar
 
Housewife Call Girls Bangalore - Call 7001305949 Rs-3500 with A/C Room Cash o...
Housewife Call Girls Bangalore - Call 7001305949 Rs-3500 with A/C Room Cash o...Housewife Call Girls Bangalore - Call 7001305949 Rs-3500 with A/C Room Cash o...
Housewife Call Girls Bangalore - Call 7001305949 Rs-3500 with A/C Room Cash o...narwatsonia7
 
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...Miss joya
 
Book Call Girls in Yelahanka - For 7001305949 Cheap & Best with original Photos
Book Call Girls in Yelahanka - For 7001305949 Cheap & Best with original PhotosBook Call Girls in Yelahanka - For 7001305949 Cheap & Best with original Photos
Book Call Girls in Yelahanka - For 7001305949 Cheap & Best with original Photosnarwatsonia7
 
Mumbai Call Girls Service 9910780858 Real Russian Girls Looking Models
Mumbai Call Girls Service 9910780858 Real Russian Girls Looking ModelsMumbai Call Girls Service 9910780858 Real Russian Girls Looking Models
Mumbai Call Girls Service 9910780858 Real Russian Girls Looking Modelssonalikaur4
 
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAAjennyeacort
 
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli 📞 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli 📞 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% SafeBangalore Call Girls Marathahalli 📞 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli 📞 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safenarwatsonia7
 
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...narwatsonia7
 
Glomerular Filtration and determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
Glomerular Filtration and  determinants of glomerular filtration .pptxGlomerular Filtration and  determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
Glomerular Filtration and determinants of glomerular filtration .pptxDr.Nusrat Tariq
 
Call Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Chennai
Call Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service ChennaiCall Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Chennai
Call Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service ChennaiNehru place Escorts
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls Thane Just Call 9910780858 Get High Class Call Girls Service
Call Girls Thane Just Call 9910780858 Get High Class Call Girls ServiceCall Girls Thane Just Call 9910780858 Get High Class Call Girls Service
Call Girls Thane Just Call 9910780858 Get High Class Call Girls Service
 
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy PlatformSee the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
 
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Hebbal Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Service In Shyam Nagar Whatsapp 8445551418 Independent Escort Service
Call Girls Service In Shyam Nagar Whatsapp 8445551418 Independent Escort ServiceCall Girls Service In Shyam Nagar Whatsapp 8445551418 Independent Escort Service
Call Girls Service In Shyam Nagar Whatsapp 8445551418 Independent Escort Service
 
Hemostasis Physiology and Clinical correlations by Dr Faiza.pdf
Hemostasis Physiology and Clinical correlations by Dr Faiza.pdfHemostasis Physiology and Clinical correlations by Dr Faiza.pdf
Hemostasis Physiology and Clinical correlations by Dr Faiza.pdf
 
Dwarka Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
Dwarka Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...Dwarka Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
Dwarka Sector 6 Call Girls ( 9873940964 ) Book Hot And Sexy Girls In A Few Cl...
 
Russian Call Girls in Pune Riya 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call gi...
Russian Call Girls in Pune Riya 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call gi...Russian Call Girls in Pune Riya 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call gi...
Russian Call Girls in Pune Riya 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call gi...
 
Call Girls Hsr Layout Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Hsr Layout Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Hsr Layout Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Hsr Layout Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Kolkata Call Girls Services 9907093804 @24x7 High Class Babes Here Call Now
Kolkata Call Girls Services 9907093804 @24x7 High Class Babes Here Call NowKolkata Call Girls Services 9907093804 @24x7 High Class Babes Here Call Now
Kolkata Call Girls Services 9907093804 @24x7 High Class Babes Here Call Now
 
call girls in munirka DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in munirka  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in munirka  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in munirka DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
call girls in green park DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in green park  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in green park  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in green park DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
Housewife Call Girls Bangalore - Call 7001305949 Rs-3500 with A/C Room Cash o...
Housewife Call Girls Bangalore - Call 7001305949 Rs-3500 with A/C Room Cash o...Housewife Call Girls Bangalore - Call 7001305949 Rs-3500 with A/C Room Cash o...
Housewife Call Girls Bangalore - Call 7001305949 Rs-3500 with A/C Room Cash o...
 
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
 
Book Call Girls in Yelahanka - For 7001305949 Cheap & Best with original Photos
Book Call Girls in Yelahanka - For 7001305949 Cheap & Best with original PhotosBook Call Girls in Yelahanka - For 7001305949 Cheap & Best with original Photos
Book Call Girls in Yelahanka - For 7001305949 Cheap & Best with original Photos
 
Mumbai Call Girls Service 9910780858 Real Russian Girls Looking Models
Mumbai Call Girls Service 9910780858 Real Russian Girls Looking ModelsMumbai Call Girls Service 9910780858 Real Russian Girls Looking Models
Mumbai Call Girls Service 9910780858 Real Russian Girls Looking Models
 
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
 
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli 📞 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli 📞 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% SafeBangalore Call Girls Marathahalli 📞 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli 📞 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
 
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 7001305949 Top Class Call Girl Service A...
 
Glomerular Filtration and determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
Glomerular Filtration and  determinants of glomerular filtration .pptxGlomerular Filtration and  determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
Glomerular Filtration and determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
 
Call Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Chennai
Call Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service ChennaiCall Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Chennai
Call Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Chennai
 

Learning from Alaska's Pioneering Telehealth Experience

  • 1. Learning From Alaska’s Telehealth Experience Stewart Ferguson, PhD John Kokesh, MD
  • 2. 2
  • 3. 3
  • 4. 4
  • 5. Stewart Ferguson Ph.D. is Acting CIO for the Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium and Director of the Alaska Federal Health Care Access Network (AFHCAN). He currently serves as Vice President of the American Telemedicine Association. He has been involved in development for CT scanners, the forward and inverse problems in biomagnetism, and imaging techniques for cardiac activity. He holds M.S. and Ph.D. degrees both in Biomedical Engineering, and B.S. degrees in both Mathematics and Electrical Engineering. John Kokesh, MD is Medical Director of the Department of Otolaryngology at the Alaska Native Medical Center where has has worked for the past 17 years. His a full time clinician whose focus in telehealth is developing clinical applications, clinical outcomes research, education and business processes for store and forward telemedicine. He received his M.D. degree, residency training and head and neck oncology fellowship training at the University of Washington. He holds clinical faculty appointments at the University of Washington, Loyola University of Chicago and Central Michigan University. He is a fellow of the American Board of 5 Otolaryngology.
  • 6. Cases Created per Year  10 year Operational History ◦ 20,000 cases / year 25,000 ◦ 14,000 Alaska Natives served/year 20,000 Cases Created 15,000 10,000 ◦ 900 Active providers / year 5,000  Whole Product Solution 0 ◦ Design  Manufacturing  Installation  Training  Support  Marketing 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 (Proj) 16,000 Annual Patient Involvement  Alaska: 248 sites, 44 organizations 14,000 ◦ 37 Tribal organizations ◦ US Army sites (6) & US Air Force 12,000 # Patients 10,000 8,000 6,000 bases (3) 4,000 2,000 ◦ State of Alaska Public Health 0 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Nursing (26) (Proj) ◦ Community Health Centers  Other states and countries 6
  • 7. When one has finished building one’s house, one suddenly realizes that in the process one has learned something one really needed to know in the worst way – before one began Nietzsche, 1886 7
  • 8. PLEASE NOTE: Outcomes will be presented on Thursday in a separate session. 8
  • 9.  TheAFHCAN Story … from a Program perspective.  The AFHCAN Story … from a Clinician’s perspective.  Skeletonsin the Closet … what we learned, and what we did right and wrong.  Where to next?
  • 10.  Theseare our experiences. ◦ Actual mileage may vary.  Some of these issues only apply to large scale systems. ◦ E.g. Apportionment, centralization.
  • 11. … from a Program Perspective
  • 13. 1990-2002 Store & Live Forward VtC Remote Monitoring
  • 14. Asynchronous.  Low bandwidth requirements  Can create a case  Static data – e.g. Vital signs “on the run.” Doctor can respond Static Images   when available. ◦ Digital camera (megapixel)  Many consults are ◦ Scans not critical. ◦ Captured video images  It is needed as a (ENT, Dental, Opthal., Naso.) communication  Video Clips – esp. from video tool. devices  Fits with present  Temporal Data: model. ECG, stethoscope, tympanomet  Minimal onsite technical support is er needed.  Textual: ◦ Health summaries 14
  • 15. 1st in land mass ◦ 1,420 miles (N-S) ◦ 2,400 miles (E-W)  33,900 miles of shoreline ◦ More than all of the contiguous states combined. National Travel and • 47th in road miles Safety Board (NTSB) – 75% Alaskan communities unconnected by reported 436 a road to a hospital. commuter aircraft – 25 of these have no airport. accidents in Alaska – 25% Alaskans (46% of Alaskan Natives) from1990-2004 (2.8 live in communities of less than 1000 accidents a month) - people. accounting for 36% of all commuter • Population density is 1.1 persons/mile2 aircraft accidents in – 70 times smaller than the national average. the US. 15
  • 16. 49% of all physicians in Alaska are primary care physicians (2002 data). U.S. average is 28%  Alaska is 48th in “doctors to residents” ratio ◦ 65% are located in Anchorage ◦ Shortages in many specialties ◦ 579 Community Health Aides in 200 villages provide nearly ½ million encounters each year. AI/AN U.S. Gap DISPARITIES: MD 73.9 220.6 66% Lower Health Staff per DD 24.0 61.8 61% Lower 100,000 people Nurse 229.0 849.9 73% Lower 16
  • 17. 180 Small Village Health Centers 550 Community Health Aides/Practitioners 125 Behavioral Health Aides 20 Dental Health Aides/ 12 Therapists 100 Home health/personal care Average Alaska village attendants  350 Residents 17
  • 18.
  • 19. Radio ’60’s  Telephone 70’s  Fax 80’s  X-ray transmission 80’s  Computer 90’s  2 way video 90’s  Universal Services Fund (USF) – broadband connectivity - 1999
  • 20. GOAL: Evaluate the impact of low-bandwidth telemedicine systems on costs, professional isolation and provider/patient satisfaction  Funded by NLM (National Library of Medicine) Contract #N01-LM-6-3540 ◦ University of Alaska Anchorage (UAA)  Fred Pearce, Ph.D. Principal Investigator  4 Regional Health Corporations ◦ 26 Village clinics,  3,000 cases 9,000 images
  • 21. Email-Based Software  Basic Cart with video otoscope and camera  Shipped in small boxes and flown to clinic  Assembled by local high school students
  • 22.
  • 23.  The solution need not be sophisticated or complex to be clinically effective …  … as long as providers are able to gain value. 23
  • 24. 40% 35% Provider Experience 30% Telemedicine Cases 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 Provider Years of Experience Clinical experience of health aides had no impact on utilization.
  • 25.  It’s NOT about the technology – it’s about the value proposition.  Experienced health aides saw the value – e.g. it let them convince the new doc that they really were seeing an infected ear.  Think … “communication tool”
  • 26.
  • 27.  Non-clinical factors will often drive usage and usage patterns … perhaps more than clinical factors.  A note about evaluation – be careful! Notice Hawthorn effect (or top ten ways to kill telehealth usage)
  • 28. Usage 100% 80% will grow Telehealth Cases faster Linear Predictor than the 60% Good Predictor 40% number of sites 20% involved 0% Maniilaq (11 of 11) NSHC (5 of 14) BBAHC (5 of 28) YKHC (5 of 46) Organization (# clinics involved)
  • 29.  Partial participation will results in less than partial results: We’re either all in or it’s not worth doing.  Full participation and organization support is the only approach to gain desired utilization.  Pilots may not tell you about larger systemic issues and may not be predictors of usage.
  • 30. Cases Created per Year (by Role) 6,000 5,000 Cases Created 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 (Proj) Primary Care Specialty Care 30
  • 31. Source: YKHC Policy PF_O52_PC “Telemedicine Cart Use”
  • 32.  “I will fire anyone that does not do telemedicine” – Janet Shackles.  Policies work.
  • 33. The Alaska Native Health Board The Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium The Alaska Federal Health Care Partnership The Alaska Telehealth Advisory Council 33
  • 34. Veterans Affairs  DoD (Army & Air Force)  DHS - (USCG)  Indian Health Service (IHS):  Alaska Native Tribal Healthcare Consortium (ANTHC) 34
  • 35. A formal, voluntary, Underling Philosophy interagency relationship  Learning Organization between the DoD, DHS,  Patient centered IHS and VA working  Health care as close to together by the sharing home as possible of each other’s  Long term resources, talents, and relationships experience to improve  Respectful of individual patient care throughout cultures the state of Alaska  Evolving process  Inclusive not exclusive 35
  • 36. Alaska State Population: 626,932 DoD Federal/ Tribal Population Other DHS DoD/DHS 72,950 VA 63,000 IHS/Tribal 115,000 VA Total 250,950 Note: Total Federal/Tribal Population includes both “dual” and “triple” beneficiaries IHS & Tribal *2000 Census Figures
  • 37. Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium (ANTHC) ◦ Management structure and support ◦ AFHCAN funds were centralized in ANTHC  Appropriations may be used as multi-year funds AFHCAN MISSION: To improve access to health care for federal beneficiaries in Alaska through sustainable telehealth systems
  • 38. AFHCAN MISSION To improve access to health care for federal beneficiaries in Alaska through sustainable telehealth systems Alaska Federal Health Care Access Network
  • 39.  Leverage existing RELATIONSHIPS and collaborative groups.  Leverage their contacts.
  • 40. EXECUTIVE BOARD TELEHEALTH CEO / Commanders ANMC, VA, USCG, 3MDG, BACH, 354 MDG Team STEERING BOARD AFHCP Planning Board Chairman, AFHCP Project Officer, AFHCP Business Office Director, ANMC Data Manager, and Clinical and Tribal Representatives AFHCAN Partners Clinical Training AFHCAN Project Technology Office Business Informatics
  • 41.  Project Proposal with defined bylaws  Autonomy of organizations  Ownership of equipment  Maintenance of referral patterns
  • 42.  … for developing mission, intent, and funding  … for overall design: Partner  … for making it happen: Dedicated, committed work unit with staff, equipment, offices, funds, rol es and responsibilities.  … for making it work: Partners plus office 42
  • 43. ATAC members provide direction, ATAC leadership and coordination of Statewide telehealth efforts Telehealth throughout Alaska. Issues ANTHC AFHCP Funded and Operating Supported AFHCAN AFHCAN 43
  • 44.  More steering, less rowing.  There is a role and need to involve partners not directly involved in the project  Chance to involve payers, other systems, address issues of standards and interoperability, look to the future, share in successes.  Created a buzz – and a sense of ownership beyond the project. 44
  • 45. Primary Care Kasan Primary Care Alicia Clinic SEARHC Juneau Roberts Medical Center Medical Center Subregional Center Dental Dental Primary Care Initial Entry Hydaburg Clinic Dental Both Initial & Secondary Specialty Secondary Care Clinics SEARHC Sitka Acute Care Clinics Secondary Eye Care Pelican Emergency MEH &Tertiary Diagnostic Outsourced Clinic Services Care Services Mental Health Therapy Harborview Haines Medical ANMC Center Dental Planned Providence Angoon Clinic Primary Care AK (MLP) API Klukwan Kake (Limited Entry) Private Clinic MD/Dental Tenahee Clinic Petersburg Clinic (MLP) Wrangall Skagway The Clinical System Ketchikan
  • 46. What are your key organizational goals for telehealth applications? Quality of Care Access to Care Patient Satisfaction Continuity of Care Information Transfer Cost of Care/Saving 1 2 3 4 5 6 Low Priority Average Priority High Priority 46
  • 47.  May not tell you what you need to know.  May not tell you where telehealth can impact clinical care.  Might not be asking the right questions.
  • 48.
  • 49.
  • 50. Ear Disease ◦ Audiometer, Tympanometer, Video Otoscope  Heart Disease ◦ ECG & Vital Signs Monitor  Respiratory Illness ◦ Spirometer & Vital Signs Monitor  Trauma, Skin & Wound ◦ Digital Camera  Dental Problems ◦ Dental Camera  General ◦ Scanner & Forms 50
  • 51. Base Cart include: ◦ Metal Frame ◦ Isolated Power System ◦ CPU and LCD Touchscreen ◦ Expansion Ports for USB, RS232, Video In/Out, External Display  Currently Supported Peripherals include: ◦ Video Otoscope ◦ Digital Camera ◦ Scanner ◦ Video Conferencing ◦ ECG ◦ Spirometer ◦ Tympanometer ◦ Audiometer ◦ Dental Camera ◦ Vital Signs Monitor ◦ Stethoscope
  • 52.
  • 53.
  • 54. National Telehealth Technology Assessment Center Providing a variety of resources to the NTTAC telehealth community • Device assessment toolkits – five this year • Technical support to Regional Telehealth Resource Centers • News and information on technologies and clinical applications A robust online community for sharing and learning • Includes full access to toolkits and forums • Hosts and records webinars • Helps select technologies for assessment • Will have free membership through 2010 www.TelehealthTAC.org Made possible through support from HRSA and IHS
  • 55.  Do NOT underestimate the value of a well designed SYSTEM (not just a collection of devices).  The devil is truly in the details. This is where you need the detail people involved.  Know the conditions you are designing for.  Involve clinicians early and often in equipment review, and design.  Decide if YOU want to become a manufacturer.
  • 56. Simplicity is key for Case Creation  Minimize need for keyboard skills  Touchscreen  Color coded 56
  • 57. Rich Web Interface for Specialists  Zero software footprint 57
  • 58.  Minimal computer skills: Touchscreens  High turnover rates (re- training): Few choices per screen, color coded  Language barriers: Very selective word choice  Disparate educational levels: Reduce complexity to few components
  • 59.  Specialist? Ease of acquisition less important  Primary Care Provider? Ease of acquisition more important
  • 60.  More than hardware – the software design is NEVER done.  Get a solution out quick.  Know your users – and involve them heavily in design decisions.  Do NOT let your developers add every “good” idea. Mandate clinical governance in software design decisions.  Again - decide if YOU want to become a software developer.
  • 61. Response Rate to Evaluation Questions 2010 (Proj) (n=20,004) 2009 (n=14,542) 2008 (n=11,030) 2007 (n=11,137)  Clinical 2006 (n=8,817) Committee 2005 (n=7,771) supported 1 2004 (n=7,058) question per 2003 (n=5,058) case session 2002 (n=3,431) 2001 (n=921)  Configurable 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% Response Rate (%) 70% 80% 90% 100% questions Consultant Responses Initiator Responses ATHS (Alaska Tribal Health System) (1/1/2001 to 8/31/2010) 61
  • 62.  Build in from the start  Involve stakeholders in design  Remember Hawthorn
  • 63. Noatak Health Clinic Maniilaq Health Center Satellite Satellite Alaska Native Medical Center (ANMC) 63
  • 64.  Solution must support the workflow  Do not change workflows to support the solution.  Workflows change. This requires a flexible system
  • 65.  A massive shift in the plan allowed for design and Original Plan Actual Plan testing phases. Oct 1998  A “multiphased” Deploy 40% NLM Deploy approach provided confidence for the Oct 1999 rapid deployment Deploy 40% Equipment of a basic solution. Support 40% selected Oct 2000 Deploy 20% Deployment Support 40% Begins Oct 2001 Support 20% 250th Cart Server-to-Server Oct 2002 65
  • 66.  Allow significant time for design and development – it will pay dividends.  Plan for delays and problems – contingency plans for clinical care, problem resolution, design changes, …
  • 67. Provides project oversight, coordination and centralized management  Planning  Informatics and data  Contractual and needs Legal/regulatory  Clinical Program Design  Recruitment of providers  Ongoing SLA Monitoring  Needs and Site  Purchasing Assessments  Deployment / Config.  Technology Assessment  Support and Training  Marketing  Evaluation 67
  • 68. Budget Budget % Budget Lvl Description (Installation) (Support) per Site A1 Tertiary Care Native Medical Center $1,535,200 $191,800 5.6360% A2 Tertiary Care Military Medical Center $1,375,520 $171,840 5.0498% B1 Hospital - Very high workload $696,800 $87,000 2.5579% B2 Hospital - High workload $625,120 $78,040 2.2947% B3 Hospital - Medium high workload $590,560 $73,720 2.1679% B4 Hospital - Low high workload $397,520 $49,590 1.4591% B5 Hospital - workload < 35,000 $354,560 $44,220 1.3014% C1 MD Health Center - Fairbanks $497,280 $62,060 1.8254% C2 MD Health Center - VA $425,600 $53,100 1.5622% C3 MD Health Center - Native Primary Care Ctr $313,360 $39,070 1.1501% C4 MD Health Center - workload 20,000-50,000 $262,800 $32,750 0.9645% C5 MD Health Center - workload 10,000-20,000 $145,840 $18,130 0.5351% C6 MD Health Center - workload < 10,000 $103,360 $12,820 0.3791% D1 PA Health Center workload > 4000 $107,280 $13,310 0.3935% D2 PA Health Center workload < 4000 $93,120 $11,540 0.3416% E1 CHA Health Center workload > 4000 $100,240 $12,430 0.3677% E2 CHA Health Center workload < 4000 $82,580 $10,260 0.3030% F1 PHN Health Center workload > 4000 $79,600 $9,850 0.2919% F2 PHN Health Center workload < 4000 $46,720 $5,740 0.1712% 68
  • 69. Project Plan $30,685,640 5 Year Actuals (FY99-FY03)* $27,456,279 * Five Year Actuals are $28,332,505 including ATAC Project Plan Expenditures (FY99-FY03) Equipment (Phase 1) Site Funds and Equipment (Phase 2) Software Development Project Design and Management Deployment Unfunded Requirements (e.g. ATAC) 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% Percent of Budget or Actuals 69
  • 70.  Agree early on where the funds sit (central … or not)  Agree on apportionment process  Portion for cash, equipment, support, …  Portion to remain centralized
  • 71. … from a Clinician’s Perspective
  • 72.  Find and develop interest  Establish acceptance  Promote usage  Build programs  Integrate telehealth into the standard way you deliver care
  • 73. One question: Do we have a problem we need to solve?
  • 74. ENT Clinic Demand, Supply and Activity (Jan 2002 - May 2003) 60 50 Patient Appointments 40 Avg Demand 30 Avg Supply Avg Activity 20 10 0 Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday 74
  • 75.  If there is no perception of a problem, look elsewhere  If they don’t think it is broken, you can’t fix it
  • 76. Put the technology in their hands Make sure it works Let them play Support, support, support Go for the easy win Talk about it
  • 77.
  • 78.
  • 79. How satisfied were you with the use Willing to have a telemedicine of the telemedicine technology? exam for follow-up? 25 30 20 15 20 10 10 5 0 0 No Yes Poor Fair GoodVery Good Overall Satisfaction How well did the telemedicine technology With This Visit help you understand your problem? 25 30 20 15 20 10 10 5 0 0 PoorFair ood G Very Poor Fair Good Very Good Good 79
  • 80. “I was able to see the problem - then the repaired normal condition … and discussed my problem - very informative!” “I liked to see with my own eyes the inside of my ear!”
  • 81.  Let your customers (patients) create your buzz.
  • 82. For clinicians, you have to prove it works  There must be a value proposition • Better? • More efficient? • You can do what you otherwise can’t do • More profitable?
  • 83. 254 sets of tubes placed at ANMC in 2000  1,000 follow up appointments needed in 12 month period  Many of these patients from remote areas 83
  • 84. To determine if video otoscope still images (640 x 480 pixel resolution) of the tympanic membrane following surgical placement of tympanostomy tubes are comparable to an in-person microscopic examination.
  • 85. % CONCORDANCE ON PHYSICAL EXAM 100% 99% 99% 99% 97% 96% 95% 94% 90% 90% InterProvider (Exam0) 85% 80% IntraProvider using all images (Exam0 vs Review1,2) 75% 70% IntraProvider using "good" images 65% (Exam0 vs Review1,2) % Concordance 60% 55% High level of agreement  Correlation between in person 50% 45% exam and telemedicine exam 40% good to excellent 35% 30%  Telemedicine can be used to do 25% 20% routine ear tube follow up 15%  Make available several hundred 10% 5% appointments per year 0% Tube In Tube Drainage Perforation Granulation Middle ear Retracted Patent fluid Physical Exam Descriptors Kokesh J, Ferguson AS, Patricoski C, Koller K, Zwack G, Provost E, Holck P. “Digital images for postsurgical follow-up of tympanostomy tubes in remote Alaska”. Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, 139:87-93, 2008. Patricoski C, Kokesh J, Ferguson AS, Koller K, Zwack G, Provost E, Holck P. “A Comparison of In-Person Examination and Video Otoscope Imaging for Tympanostomy Tube Follow-Up”. Telemedicine Journal and e-Health, 9(4):331-344, 2003.
  • 86. “Waiting time for a field clinic appointment has gone from 4-5 months a year ago to 1- 2 months now. I've probably got 100 stories of patients or parents who were pleased with the quicker, easier access to ENT services they Kokesh J, Ferguson AS, Patricoski C. received either through “Preoperative planning for ear surgery using store-and-forward telemed or direct referral.” telemedicine”. Otolaryngology-Head Mike Comerford, Audiologist, and Neck Surgery, 143:253- 257, 2010. Yukon Kuskokwim Health Corporation
  • 87.  Low hanging fruit is still fruit.  Take it  Talk about it 87
  • 88.  If you often say “There must be a better way” there probably is  Look for these in terms of telemedicine 88
  • 89. Take your best ideas and build on them. 89
  • 90. Traveling a Provider to Promote Efficiency and Rapid Delivery of ENT Care Through Telemedicine Kokesh J, Ferguson AS, Patricoski C, LeMaster B. “Traveling an Audiologist to Provide Otolaryngology Care Using Store-and-Forward Telemedicine”. Telemedicine and e-Health, 15(8):758-763, 2009.
  • 91.
  • 92.
  • 93.
  • 94.
  • 95. Patient Cost Visits Traveling Audiologist Program 1,987 ($175,000) Patient Travel Prevented 1,726 $697,090 Based on Outcomes of: • Did patient still need to travel to field clinic? Assumptions: Note: 1,153 • Only travel to hub is being saved. • Escort required if patient less than 18 years old less than • No lodging / per diem calculated 18 yrs old Net Savings in Travel Costs $522,090 Realized by Program (300% ROI)
  • 96.  Proven technology  High unmet need  No other good solutions 96
  • 97. Evolve successes to predictable levels of clinical service  Find and support (but don’t solely rely on) your clinical champions  Clinical protocols matter  But it’s all about RELATIONSHIPS 97
  • 98. Champion Service Model  Can  Guarantee of performance ◦ See potential  Agreed upon expectations ◦ Create  Sustainable and scalable ◦ Innovate ◦ Nurture  Accountable  Can’t  Independent of ◦ Sustain individuals ◦ Grow to large scale  Requires support ◦ Leave something behind structure 98
  • 99. Multi-provider, multi-region, multi- organization, multi-jurisdiction, patient participant….  Focus on integrating with the way providers work and formalizing relationships and mutual responsibilities: ◦ Who accepts referrals? ◦ Do they have specific data requirements? ◦ How fast must they answer? ◦ How do you track what is happening? ◦ How is everyone paid? ◦ Who gets notified and must respond when the patients telemetry data tanks? 99
  • 100. Software can help drive clinical protocols  Essential for program development 100
  • 101. 2.6 cases/month 7.9 cases/month Almost 10 250 more Avg Monthly Caseload 8 patients 6 are being 4 seen per 2 year, a 0 savings in -48 -36 -24 -12 0 12 24 80 man- years of TIME Relative to CME/Training (months) Before CME After CME waiting time. AVG (Before) AVG (After) 101
  • 102. Misunderstanding incentives The workload / capacity mismatch “In addition to” versus “Instead of” trap 102
  • 103. 103
  • 104.
  • 105.  Know the incentives for behavior within your system, and make sure that they on in alignment with what you are trying to accomplish  If they are not, change the incentives or move on to a different project.
  • 106. You may be “too successful” System usage may grow faster than you can grow capacity Have contingency plans – short and long term
  • 107. Frame telemedicine 12  Median Time per Case (min) as a better way to 10 8 do existing work, 6 not just additional 4 work 2 Provide appropriate 0  Sep-02 Sep-03 Sep-04 Sep-05 Sep-06 incentives  Don’t reward work well done with more work
  • 108.  If you are not a clinician, “Live a day” with your clinician(s)  Knowing the work, the workflow, the systems within which they work will provide you a huge advantage  Build trust, understanding, rapport 108
  • 109. … what we learned, and what we did right and wrong.
  • 110. … don’t get so caught up in the “doing” that you neglect to reflect, speak and write about what you have done so far.
  • 111. Annual Provider Usage (by Experience) 1,000 800 # Providers 600 …early on and 400 forever. And over 200 and over again. 0 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Return New
  • 112. Don’t be afraid to pull and reallocate resources.
  • 113. Make sure you have the expertise and tools you need at the outset
  • 115. Where does Telehealth fit into the “Health Information Exchange?”
  • 116. WHAT IS HOT CONNECTED HEALTH AFHCAN’s success in the past has been by ourselves AFHCAN AFHCAN server server AFHCAN’s future success will be based on how well our system can work with others
  • 117. The goal of HIE is to Health Information There VtC S&F ExchangeaccessTheand facilitate (HIE) to retrieval of clinical data to mobilization of healthcare provide safer, more information electronically Space timely, efficient, effective, e across organizations within a region, patient-centered quitable, community or care. hospital system. Here “Classic” EHR/ EMR Now Soon Time Future 117
  • 119. “Network of Networks” being developed to provide a secure, nationwide, interoperable health information infrastructure that will connect providers, consumers, and others involved in supporting health and healthcare HISPC Electronic Health Record (EHR) Laboratory Results Reporting IS 01: Policy The02: Biosurveillance IS Health Information Security and Privacy Empowerment IS 03: Consumer Collaboration IS 04: Emergency Responder Electronic Health Record (ER-EHR) HITSP Consumer Empowerment and Access to Clinical Information IS 05: Standards via Media Healthcare Information IS 06: Quality Technology Standards Panel IS 07: Medication Management IS 08: Personalized Healthcare CCHIT Consultations and Transfers of Care IS 09: Certification Certification Commission for IS 10: Immunizations and Response Management Healthcare Information IS 11: Public Health Case Reporting Technology IS 12: Patient – Provider Secure Messaging IS 77: Remote Monitoring
  • 120. Samples: C32 – Summary Document Using HL7 CCD May include administrative (e.g., registration, demographics, insurance, et c.) and clinical (problem list, medication list, allergies, test results, etc) information C48 – Encounter Document AFHCAN will be Supports the process of sending patient going live with encounter data (excluding laboratory and radiology) C32 interfaces to EHRs statewide C74 – Remote Monitoring Observation Medical information collected by remote later in 2010. monitoring management systems from monitoring devices and/or device intermediaries C84 – Consult and History & physical note Support the exchange of information from a consulting provider to a referring provider; and may also be used to provide background information from a referring provider to a consulting provider 120
  • 121.
  • 122. 2003-2009 Blending Specialties Store & Live Forward VtC Remote Monitoring
  • 123. 2010  Technology Blending Store & Live Forward VtC Remote Monitoring
  • 124. Traditional Devices + New Connectivity + New Messaging = NEW SOLUTIONS 124
  • 125.  Recognize that needs and technologies will shift during the lifetime of your system.  Constantly re-assess your program.  Look for the next thing. 125
  • 126. Telehealth is a clinical mandate, not a technical initiative.  Provide a predictable level of service (with scarce clinical resources).  Support local planning and decision making.  Provide state/national coordination, planning and accountability.  Create efficiencies through centralized services.  Leverage existing expertise. 126
  • 127. Thank You John Kokesh, MD Stewart Ferguson, PhD Department of Otolaryngology Alaska Federal Health Care Access Alaska Native Medical Center Network (AFHCAN) 4315 Diplomacy Drive Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium Anchorage, AK 99508 4000 Ambassador Drive Anchorage, AK 99508 (907) 729-1416 jkokesh@anthc.org (907) 729-2262 sferguson@anthc.org AFHCAN, Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium, Anchorage, AK