SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 55
Download to read offline
Auteursrecht en Open Source
   mr. ir. Arnoud Engelfriet

   a.engelfriet@ictrecht.nl
   @ictrecht
Foto: public.resource.org, CC-BY 2.0
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Source: Wellington Grey, CC-BY-NC 3.0
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
“dat een overeenkomst tot het aanschaffen van
 standaardcomputerprogrammatuur - op een
 gegevensdrager of via een download - voor
 een niet in tijdsduur beperkt gebruik tegen
 betaling van een bepaald bedrag ertoe strekt
 de verkrijger iets te verschaffen dat
 geïndividualiseerd is en waarover hij feitelijke
 macht kan uitoefenen. Dit alles pleit voor
 toepasselijkheid van de kooptitel op een
 zodanige overeenkomst.”

                            HR 27 april 2012, LJN BV1301 (Beeldbrigade)
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
“An author of software cannot oppose the
 resale of his ‘used’ licences allowing the use of
 his programs downloaded from the internet.
 The exclusive right of distribution of a copy of
 a computer program covered by such a licence
 is exhausted on its first sale”



                           HvJ EU 3 juli 2012, zaaknr. C-128/11 (Usedsoft)
“The license
must reflect the
 economic value
of the software”




      Bron: BBC, “Top Gear”
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
HvJ EU 2 mei 2012, zaaknr. C‑406/10 (SAS/WPL)
HvJ EU 2 mei 2012, zaaknr. C‑406/10 (SAS/WPL)
HvJ EG 22 december 2010, LJN C‑393/09
Foto: Free Beer Foundation, CC-BY-SA 2.5
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.5/
Waarom is OSS aantrekkelijk?
     2008            2009                   2010                    2011
Lower costs      Lower costs         Lower costs            Freedom from
                                                            vendor lock-in

Freedom from     Superior            Freedom from           Lower costs
vendor lock-in   security            vendor lock-in

Access to        Freedom from        Rapid pace             Flexibility
code libraries   vendor lock-in      of innovation




                               Bron: Future of open source, North Bridge survey mei 2012
Other          Mozilla
                                          Microsoft

                                                Apache




GPLv2                          BSD
                                      GPLv3

                                   LGPL

                  MIT
          Artistic
 Bron: Black Duck Software,
 Top 20 Most Commonly Used Licenses in Open Source Projects
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Academic licenses




         Foto: Franco Folini, Flickr.com, CC-BY-SA
BSD         MIT / X11
(“Beastie”)
Jacobsen v. Katzer, 535 F.3d 1373 (Fed. Cir. 2008)
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Weak copyleft
Library GPL

                          Mozilla
                          Public
                          License


              Eclipse
              Public
              License
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Static linking   Dynamic linking
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
Bron: Trustyetc.com
Beeld: Shepard Fairey en Mannie Garcia / Associated Press
Static linking   Dynamic linking
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
v3



Foto © Julian Cash 2002
   Used with permission
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
“Installation Information”

  “Source Code”
                                          “Propagation”
       “Entity transaction”
                                                     “Copyright”
“Appropriate Legal
                                   “Modification”
 Notices”
                         “this License”
                              “User Product”
   “System Libraries”
                                                       “The Program”

                                         “Knowingly relying”

“Corresponding
                                                “Conveyance”
 Source”                      “Normally used”
Bron: Box.net
Affero   v3



         Foto © Julian Cash 2002
            Used with permission
Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205
“offer all users interacting with it
remotely through a computer network
 an opportunity to receive the source
                 code”
Vragen?

a.engelfriet@ictrecht.nl
@ictrecht

More Related Content

More from Devnology

What do we really know about the differences between static and dynamic types?
What do we really know about the differences between static and dynamic types?What do we really know about the differences between static and dynamic types?
What do we really know about the differences between static and dynamic types?Devnology
 
Meetup at SIG: Meten is weten
Meetup at SIG: Meten is wetenMeetup at SIG: Meten is weten
Meetup at SIG: Meten is wetenDevnology
 
Software Operation Knowledge
Software Operation KnowledgeSoftware Operation Knowledge
Software Operation KnowledgeDevnology
 
Slides Felienne Hermans Symposium EWI
Slides Felienne Hermans Symposium EWISlides Felienne Hermans Symposium EWI
Slides Felienne Hermans Symposium EWIDevnology
 
The top 10 security issues in web applications
The top 10 security issues in web applicationsThe top 10 security issues in web applications
The top 10 security issues in web applicationsDevnology
 
Hacking Smartcards & RFID
Hacking Smartcards & RFIDHacking Smartcards & RFID
Hacking Smartcards & RFIDDevnology
 
Learn a language : LISP
Learn a language : LISPLearn a language : LISP
Learn a language : LISPDevnology
 
Learn a language : LISP
Learn a language : LISPLearn a language : LISP
Learn a language : LISPDevnology
 
Devnology Back to School: Empirical Evidence on Modeling in Software Development
Devnology Back to School: Empirical Evidence on Modeling in Software DevelopmentDevnology Back to School: Empirical Evidence on Modeling in Software Development
Devnology Back to School: Empirical Evidence on Modeling in Software DevelopmentDevnology
 
Devnology Back to School IV - Agility en Architectuur
Devnology Back to School IV - Agility en ArchitectuurDevnology Back to School IV - Agility en Architectuur
Devnology Back to School IV - Agility en ArchitectuurDevnology
 
Devnology Back to School III : Software impact
Devnology Back to School III : Software impactDevnology Back to School III : Software impact
Devnology Back to School III : Software impactDevnology
 
Devnology back toschool software reengineering
Devnology back toschool software reengineeringDevnology back toschool software reengineering
Devnology back toschool software reengineeringDevnology
 
Introduction to Software Evolution: The Software Volcano
Introduction to Software Evolution: The Software VolcanoIntroduction to Software Evolution: The Software Volcano
Introduction to Software Evolution: The Software VolcanoDevnology
 
Devnology Workshop Genpro 2 feb 2011
Devnology Workshop Genpro 2 feb 2011Devnology Workshop Genpro 2 feb 2011
Devnology Workshop Genpro 2 feb 2011Devnology
 
Devnology Coding Dojo 05-01-2011
Devnology Coding Dojo 05-01-2011Devnology Coding Dojo 05-01-2011
Devnology Coding Dojo 05-01-2011Devnology
 
Spoofax: ontwikkeling van domeinspecifieke talen in Eclipse
Spoofax: ontwikkeling van domeinspecifieke talen in EclipseSpoofax: ontwikkeling van domeinspecifieke talen in Eclipse
Spoofax: ontwikkeling van domeinspecifieke talen in EclipseDevnology
 
Experimenting with Augmented Reality
Experimenting with Augmented RealityExperimenting with Augmented Reality
Experimenting with Augmented RealityDevnology
 
Unit testing and MVVM in Silverlight
Unit testing and MVVM in SilverlightUnit testing and MVVM in Silverlight
Unit testing and MVVM in SilverlightDevnology
 
mobl: Een DSL voor mobiele applicatieontwikkeling
mobl: Een DSL voor mobiele applicatieontwikkelingmobl: Een DSL voor mobiele applicatieontwikkeling
mobl: Een DSL voor mobiele applicatieontwikkelingDevnology
 
Devnology Fitnesse workshop
Devnology Fitnesse workshopDevnology Fitnesse workshop
Devnology Fitnesse workshopDevnology
 

More from Devnology (20)

What do we really know about the differences between static and dynamic types?
What do we really know about the differences between static and dynamic types?What do we really know about the differences between static and dynamic types?
What do we really know about the differences between static and dynamic types?
 
Meetup at SIG: Meten is weten
Meetup at SIG: Meten is wetenMeetup at SIG: Meten is weten
Meetup at SIG: Meten is weten
 
Software Operation Knowledge
Software Operation KnowledgeSoftware Operation Knowledge
Software Operation Knowledge
 
Slides Felienne Hermans Symposium EWI
Slides Felienne Hermans Symposium EWISlides Felienne Hermans Symposium EWI
Slides Felienne Hermans Symposium EWI
 
The top 10 security issues in web applications
The top 10 security issues in web applicationsThe top 10 security issues in web applications
The top 10 security issues in web applications
 
Hacking Smartcards & RFID
Hacking Smartcards & RFIDHacking Smartcards & RFID
Hacking Smartcards & RFID
 
Learn a language : LISP
Learn a language : LISPLearn a language : LISP
Learn a language : LISP
 
Learn a language : LISP
Learn a language : LISPLearn a language : LISP
Learn a language : LISP
 
Devnology Back to School: Empirical Evidence on Modeling in Software Development
Devnology Back to School: Empirical Evidence on Modeling in Software DevelopmentDevnology Back to School: Empirical Evidence on Modeling in Software Development
Devnology Back to School: Empirical Evidence on Modeling in Software Development
 
Devnology Back to School IV - Agility en Architectuur
Devnology Back to School IV - Agility en ArchitectuurDevnology Back to School IV - Agility en Architectuur
Devnology Back to School IV - Agility en Architectuur
 
Devnology Back to School III : Software impact
Devnology Back to School III : Software impactDevnology Back to School III : Software impact
Devnology Back to School III : Software impact
 
Devnology back toschool software reengineering
Devnology back toschool software reengineeringDevnology back toschool software reengineering
Devnology back toschool software reengineering
 
Introduction to Software Evolution: The Software Volcano
Introduction to Software Evolution: The Software VolcanoIntroduction to Software Evolution: The Software Volcano
Introduction to Software Evolution: The Software Volcano
 
Devnology Workshop Genpro 2 feb 2011
Devnology Workshop Genpro 2 feb 2011Devnology Workshop Genpro 2 feb 2011
Devnology Workshop Genpro 2 feb 2011
 
Devnology Coding Dojo 05-01-2011
Devnology Coding Dojo 05-01-2011Devnology Coding Dojo 05-01-2011
Devnology Coding Dojo 05-01-2011
 
Spoofax: ontwikkeling van domeinspecifieke talen in Eclipse
Spoofax: ontwikkeling van domeinspecifieke talen in EclipseSpoofax: ontwikkeling van domeinspecifieke talen in Eclipse
Spoofax: ontwikkeling van domeinspecifieke talen in Eclipse
 
Experimenting with Augmented Reality
Experimenting with Augmented RealityExperimenting with Augmented Reality
Experimenting with Augmented Reality
 
Unit testing and MVVM in Silverlight
Unit testing and MVVM in SilverlightUnit testing and MVVM in Silverlight
Unit testing and MVVM in Silverlight
 
mobl: Een DSL voor mobiele applicatieontwikkeling
mobl: Een DSL voor mobiele applicatieontwikkelingmobl: Een DSL voor mobiele applicatieontwikkeling
mobl: Een DSL voor mobiele applicatieontwikkeling
 
Devnology Fitnesse workshop
Devnology Fitnesse workshopDevnology Fitnesse workshop
Devnology Fitnesse workshop
 

Devnology auteursrecht en open source 20130205

  • 1. Auteursrecht en Open Source mr. ir. Arnoud Engelfriet a.engelfriet@ictrecht.nl @ictrecht
  • 10. “dat een overeenkomst tot het aanschaffen van standaardcomputerprogrammatuur - op een gegevensdrager of via een download - voor een niet in tijdsduur beperkt gebruik tegen betaling van een bepaald bedrag ertoe strekt de verkrijger iets te verschaffen dat geïndividualiseerd is en waarover hij feitelijke macht kan uitoefenen. Dit alles pleit voor toepasselijkheid van de kooptitel op een zodanige overeenkomst.” HR 27 april 2012, LJN BV1301 (Beeldbrigade)
  • 12. “An author of software cannot oppose the resale of his ‘used’ licences allowing the use of his programs downloaded from the internet. The exclusive right of distribution of a copy of a computer program covered by such a licence is exhausted on its first sale” HvJ EU 3 juli 2012, zaaknr. C-128/11 (Usedsoft)
  • 13. “The license must reflect the economic value of the software” Bron: BBC, “Top Gear”
  • 16. HvJ EU 2 mei 2012, zaaknr. C‑406/10 (SAS/WPL)
  • 17. HvJ EU 2 mei 2012, zaaknr. C‑406/10 (SAS/WPL)
  • 18. HvJ EG 22 december 2010, LJN C‑393/09
  • 19. Foto: Free Beer Foundation, CC-BY-SA 2.5 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.5/
  • 20. Waarom is OSS aantrekkelijk? 2008 2009 2010 2011 Lower costs Lower costs Lower costs Freedom from vendor lock-in Freedom from Superior Freedom from Lower costs vendor lock-in security vendor lock-in Access to Freedom from Rapid pace Flexibility code libraries vendor lock-in of innovation Bron: Future of open source, North Bridge survey mei 2012
  • 21. Other Mozilla Microsoft Apache GPLv2 BSD GPLv3 LGPL MIT Artistic Bron: Black Duck Software, Top 20 Most Commonly Used Licenses in Open Source Projects
  • 25. Academic licenses Foto: Franco Folini, Flickr.com, CC-BY-SA
  • 26. BSD MIT / X11 (“Beastie”)
  • 27. Jacobsen v. Katzer, 535 F.3d 1373 (Fed. Cir. 2008)
  • 31. Weak copyleft Library GPL Mozilla Public License Eclipse Public License
  • 40. Static linking Dynamic linking
  • 45. Bron: Trustyetc.com Beeld: Shepard Fairey en Mannie Garcia / Associated Press
  • 46. Static linking Dynamic linking
  • 48. v3 Foto © Julian Cash 2002 Used with permission
  • 50. “Installation Information” “Source Code” “Propagation” “Entity transaction” “Copyright” “Appropriate Legal “Modification” Notices” “this License” “User Product” “System Libraries” “The Program” “Knowingly relying” “Corresponding “Conveyance” Source” “Normally used”
  • 52. Affero v3 Foto © Julian Cash 2002 Used with permission
  • 54. “offer all users interacting with it remotely through a computer network an opportunity to receive the source code”