A review of our Foresight scenarios on the future of intelligent infrastructure systems, five years on. Presented at The Future of Transport conference in Leuven, Belgium, June 2010.
907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in Engineering
Iis Scenarios Revisited Curry Leuven0610
1. Learning from the UK’s
Intelligent Infrastructure
Scenarios
Andrew Curry, The Futures Company
2. Foresight’s Intelligent Infrastructure Futures
• Foresight: takes a long-term view of long-
term issues where science and technology
can be influential
• Intelligent Infrastructure Systems project was
sponsored by the Department of Transport,
which still uses the scenarios as part of its
long-term thinking
• The project combined drivers analysis,
scenarios development, systems work, and
socio-technical studies, as well as ‘state of
science’ reviews from leading academics -
social scientists as well as technologists
• The output is in the public domain and can
be freely downloaded:
http://www.foresight.gov.uk/OurWork/Comple
tedProjects/IIS/KeyInfo/Index.asp
2
3. Summarising the scenarios
Accepting of Intelligent
Infrastructure
Good Intentions Perpetual Motion
High Impact Low impact
Transport Transport
Tribal Trading Urban Colonies
Resistant to Intelligent
Infrastructure
3
4. Technology applied
Accepting of Intelligent
Infrastructure
Perpetual Motion
High Impact Low impact
Transport Transport
Resistant to Intelligent
Infrastructure
4
5. Designing out demand
Accepting of Intelligent
Infrastructure
High Impact Low impact
Transport Transport
‘At a gross density
of 50 dph, 5,000
dwellings can be
within a 10 minute
walk of public
services, schools
and viable public Urban Colonies
transport.’
MJP Architects, ‘Sustainable Suburbia’ Resistant to Intelligent
Infrastructure
54
6. The impact of resource limits
Accepting of Intelligent
Infrastructure
High Impact Low impact
Transport Transport
Tribal Trading
Resistant to Intelligent
Infrastructure
64
7. Reduction through rationing
Accepting of Intelligent
Infrastructure
Economic Insecurity
Good Intentions
High Impact Low impact
Transport Transport
Resistant to Intelligent
Infrastructure
74
8. Accepting of Intelligent
Infrastructure
Economic
Insecurity
Good Intentions Perpetual Motion
High Impact Low impact
Transport Transport
Tribal Trading Urban Colonies
Resistant to Intelligent
Infrastructure
8
9. Reflecting on the scenarios
• The only reliable way to reduce personal
transport demand is to focus on access not
mobility
– this takes a generation
– but it is happening
• Technology can help - but it needs to be
applied to reducing demand for private
personal transport
– otherwise it reduces equity
9
10. Reflecting on the scenarios
• So far reducing personal transport use has only
happened generally as a result of fuel price
increases
– but this is a risky way to manage transport outcomes
• Decisive changes in transport behaviour are
likely to come quickly only through rationing or
pricing
– but car users resent it
– so this is a tough political challenge
– there need to be clear benefits associated with the
change
10
11. “How do you want
your kids to live?
Do you want to
walk or drive to get
Enrique Penalosa bread? That' s the
basis of thinking
about cities.”
http://www.resurgence.org/magazine/article518-CITIES-OF-JOY.html
11