SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Download to read offline
254 VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE
MĀORI PRIMARY HEALTH CARE TREASURES
Pounamu (greenstone) is the most precious of stone to Māori.
‘Ahakoa he iti, he pounamu’
(Although it is small, it is valuable)
Pounamu
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
POUNAMU
Applying a Māori-centred consultation
approach for engaging with Māori patients:
an undergraduate medical student case study
Rhys Parry MBChB;1
Bernadette Jones RGON, DPH;2
Ben Gray MBChB, MBHL FRNZCGP;3
Tristram
Ingham MBChB2
CORRESPONDENCE TO:
Bernadette Jones
Department of
Medicine, University
of Otago Wellington,
POB 7343, Wellington
South, Wellington
6242, New Zealand
bernadette.jones@
otago.ac.nz
J PRIM HEALTH CARE
2014;6(3):254–260.
1
University of Otago
Wellington, Wellington,
New Zealand
2
Department of Medicine,
University of Otago
Wellington, Wellington
3
Department of General
Practice and Primary Health
Care, University of Otago
Wellington, Wellington
Introduction
For some years now the dominant text for teach-
ing consultation skills has been ‘patient-centred
medicine’.1
Although this method is used interna-
tionally, it was developed in Canada, with a strong
cultural bias towards Western European patients,
and its very title, as a method, is at odds with
a traditional Māori way of viewing the world.2
There are indications that, for Māori, inaccurate
and inappropriate medical assessment can lead to
misdiagnosis and mistreatment and thus can con-
tribute to existing health inequalities in a number
of areas.3
There is also evidence that, while most
clinicians engage with patients with good intent,
knowingly or unknowingly, they can contribute
to negative patient experiences and ethnic/racial
disparities in health.4
In order to prevent this and
to ensure positive health experiences for Māori, it
is vital to learn culturally appropriate and effec-
tive methods of engaging with Māori patients.5
As part of the curriculum at the University of
Otago, Aotearoa/New Zealand, undergraduate
medical students learn the Calgary–Cambridge
guide to medical interviewing.6
As well as this,
they combine their biomedical knowledge with
Hauora Māori (Māori health) principles and apply
these using a Māori patient long-case interview.
The main focus of this long-case is to apply an
holistic approach to interviewing Māori patients,
based on the combination of the Hui Process (a
Māori communication and patient engagement
process)5
and the Meihana Model (an holis-
tic Māori model of health).3
The Hui Process
provides a Māori-centred approach to history-
taking, developed from the customary Māori
practices that are observed at hui (meetings). This
is initially taught during a marae-based (Māori
meeting place), cultural immersion programme
to fourth-year medical students, who learn a
culturally competent way to interview Māori
patients following a four-step process.7
Dur-
ing this immersion programme, these students
are also taught the Meihana Model, a clinically
focused Māori model of health, as a framework
for history taking.3
This model was designed to
synthesise clinical and cultural competencies,
to better serve Māori within a clinical setting.
Whānau (extended family) are identified at the
centre of the interview, and this model challeng-
es the student/practitioner to explicitly engage
with the whānau as part of the interview and any
subsequent treatment plan.
The following is a description of the practical
application of these Hauora Māori principles in
a clinical hospital setting, including excerpts
from a case assignment written by a fourth-year
student, after conducting an interview with a
Māori patient.
The first step, the mihimihi (greeting), begins
with the student introducing themselves, ex-
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE 255
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
POUNAMU
plaining their role, confirming patient details,
including ethnicity, stating the reason for
the interview, and obtaining fully informed
consent. Use of basic te reo (Māori language)
is encouraged, as appropriate, during this step
and throughout the interview. This use of
te reo has been recognised as a contributing
factor in building a trusted patient–doctor
relationship.8
The second phase, the process of whakawha-
naungatanga or the building of a relationship,
follows the exchange of mihimihi, and continues
throughout the interview. Whakawhanaun-
gatanga is a critical concept of demonstrated
relevance to both culturally appropriate research,9
and clinical encounters with Māori patients.10
It is grounded in the key cultural principle
of acknowledging the interconnectedness and
interdependence of an individual, members of the
whānau, immediate and extended family, com-
munity and wider society. In the clinical context,
whakawhanaungatanga has a purposeful focus
directed towards the health professional estab-
lishing a cultural connection with the patient,
thus distinguishing it from basic rapport.11
The
process provides a holistic context that permits
the student to place the information gathered
within a cultural framework, ensuring a more
accurate interpretation and understanding of the
patient.12
A vital part of this step is the student’s
sharing of appropriate stories and information, so
as to balance the interview and avoid a one-sided
interrogation scenario.
Excerpts from the student case study
The process of whakawhanaungatanga, or the
building of the relationship, was initiated by the
exchange of mihi, the sharing of our stories. This
exchange took place before any thought was given
to the ‘information gathering’ biomedical approach,
oft practised in Western Medicine. We exchanged
stories about where we’d come from: JT (the
patient) talked of her childhood; being raised by
her grandfather, and how she spoke te reo at home.
Her iwi heritage gave an opportunity to create a
common bond, as my wife has ancestry to the same
iwi. Whakawhanaungatanga is an ongoing process
and was maintained and reinforced throughout our
kōrero (talk) through:
(1) an emphasis on seeing JT as a whole person, in
contrast with the reductionist focus-on-the-medi-
cal-condition approach; and
(2) through reference back to the information
shared in our mihi.
It was evident throughout our kōrero that a connec-
tion had been made and this was reinforced when,
at the end of our two-and-a-half hours together, JT
gave me her contact details and asked me to make
sure that I keep in touch. We were not time-pres-
sured and this allowed space for the conversation
to go places that it likely would not have if I was
the house surgeon admitting JT or the GP [general
practitioner] seeing her in clinic. This raises the
question of the adequacy of 15-minute GP appoint-
ments, or biomedically/tinana (physical health)–
only focused consultations to facilitate conversation
that has the ability to promote real consideration of
one’s health status and behaviours.
In the clinical context, whakawhanaungatanga has
a purposeful focus directed towards the health
professional establishing a cultural connection with
the patient, thus distinguishing it from basic rapport
The third step of the Hui Process is the kaupa-
pa—the main purpose/reason for the interview is
largely dependent on the effectiveness of the first
two steps. In order to be able to obtain in-depth
information, it is important that the patient feels
at ease and can trust the student/clinician with
sharing their sensitive personal information.
For many Māori, this information is viewed as a
taonga (treasure) belonging not only to them as
individuals but also intrinsically linked to their
tı̄puna (ancestors) with whom they remain con-
nected to through the generations.
As we got to talking and I actually listened (as op-
posed to charging in with question after question), I
began to discover a lovely and vibrant, but ‘broken’
lady. The interview progressed in a semi-struc-
tured kind of way, loosely following the pattern
described above and that of the Meihana Model,
where health is seen as encompassing six different
256 VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE
facets (tinana—physical health; whānau—the fam-
ily aspect; hinengaro—mental health; wairua—spir-
itual health; taiao—the environmental aspect; and
iwi katoa—the wider health system context).
Tinana (physical health)
JT was admitted to the respiratory ward, where she
spent six days receiving treatment for pulmonary
oedema. When visited by the respiratory nurse at
her home (five days ago), she was found to be breath-
less, unable to complete full sentences, and ‘gasping
for air’. An ambulance was called and she was taken
to the emergency department for assessment. She
had recently been discharged following a similar
episode. An occasional unproductive cough and
some pain associated with this was reported but oth-
erwise nil of note. She had a number of comorbidi-
ties, including: congestive heart failure; ischaemic
heart disease, with previous non-ST elevation myo-
cardial infarction; chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease; asthma; obesity hypoventilation syndrome;
Type 2 diabetes (insulin dependent); paroxysmal
atrial fibrillation; and osteoarthritis of both hips,
for which she was awaiting total hip replacements.
She regularly took multiple medications: insulin;
salbutamol; fluticasone/salmeterol; simvastatin;
metoprolol; quinapril; frusemide; and fluoxetine.
She had been seeing a dietician and felt her diet was
good, with plenty of fruit and vegetables. JT is an
ex-smoker, with a 15 pack–year history.
Whānau (family/social supports)
JT is one of 16 children; she has four children of
her own and eight mokopuna (grandchildren). Both
her parents died early but she had little information
to give about their health. JT lives at home with her
partner who is also unwell, but has good support
from her children who live close by. She has some
home help. No whānau were present during our
kōrero (talk) but she mentioned that they are quite
worried about her health. JT discussed her iwi
(tribe), hapū (sub-tribe), and marae (meeting house)
affiliations, along with her maunga (mountain),
the basis of her sense of connectedness. She has no
marae involvement in Wellington but is involved
with a number of kaumātua (elder) groups. JT is
now retired but used to work as a social worker,
and was involved with the policy board for a local
health provider and a number of other groups.
Hinengaro (psychological/emotional)
Regarding her beliefs about medication and adher-
ence, JT had an ‘I just do as I’m told’ attitude, and
felt her control of diabetes was a good example of
success. Enforced bed-rest has afforded JT the time
to reflect and given the benefit of hindsight she
sees herself as being mostly responsible for her poor
health. This made her feel unhappy:
[The] truth hurts. [Expletive] does it ever!
An hour into our kōrero, I said to JT that it seemed
as if she had come to a point of realisation and that
she was starting to take ownership of her own
health. This seemed to resonate with her, as she
broke down in tears, agreeing that this was exactly
how she felt and it had taken her a very long time
to come to this realisation.
Wairua (spiritual/connectedness)
With reference to Wairua, JT’s comment was that
she believes in a Māori model of health, by which
she was referring to the Whare Tapa Whā model.13
A Catholic nun had visited her today to take her
through a karakia (prayer/incantation), but in gen-
eral she felt that she didn’t really take great care of
her wairua, her spiritual health.
Taiao (environment)
JT and her partner live in a modified home on a flat
section (her previous home had steps) with a wet
shower area, a handle above the bed and a number
of other modifications. Due to her immobility
(both hip osteoarthritis and obesity-related), she
uses a walking frame when outside the house. Some
home help is currently provided and this is being
reviewed with a view to increasing this service.
Iwi Katoa (health systems)
JT has her own GP and felt that she had easy and
good access to health care, but thought this was
likely related to her position as a social worker (pre-
viously) and her role with the local health provider.
She said that she knew many Māori who don’t
know where to go when they have health concerns,
and therefore don’t seek help.
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
POUNAMU
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE 257
Māori cultural beliefs and values
JT describes Māori as ‘the same but different’, in
that those from different iwi and hapū often have
different beliefs about health. For example, talking
about different aspects of health is tapu (sacred/
restricted) for some and there can therefore be a
reluctance to seek help. Māori are whakamā (embar-
rassed/shy) when talking about certain sensitive
body parts. She said that she loves the cervical
screening television advertisements for Pacific
women (shown on New Zealand television) but
wished there was something similar for Māori. JT
felt it was important for the elders in the commu-
nity to stand up and model good health practices
to the younger generations—she said that she felt
she hasn’t done a great job of doing this so far, but
plans to change that.
Poroporoaki
The final step of the Hui Process, the Poroporo-
aki (closing or concluding the encounter) is an
important part of the interview process. Evidence
shows that, for Māori, this part of the consulta-
tion can be suboptimal and incomplete at times,
and is an important part of a culturally appropri-
ate and effective health literacy approach with
patients.5
Case study: Poroporoaki
Poroporoaki is the process of farewell and con-
clusion of a meeting. It allows each party the
opportunity to share their thoughts regarding the
encounter and, in this context, ask questions and
to negotiate future plans. Our kōrero drew to a
close when JT again spoke of the sense that she felt
responsible for her ill health. She believed that she
had played a large part in her current poor health
state, saying that she had neglected to take care of
herself, and had deferred seeking help for health
concerns. We talked of the opportunity she now
had to take ownership of her health and she ex-
plained that her mokopuna were the motivation for
this. She felt that our conversation had allowed her
an opportunity to ‘get a load off her chest’ and that
she hoped ‘people would see a change in her’.
I asked JT for her opinion on what the causes were
for the discrepancies in health status between
Māori and non-Māori, to which she responded that
she felt many Māori need to take responsibility for
their own health. In addition, she added that non-
Māori doctors need to learn how to talk with Māori
patients so that they will be more likely to share
information about themselves.
I asked explicitly if she had any questions for me
and allowed space for her to consider her response.
JT’s only question was to ask that I keep in touch,
to which I promised to email and visit her again
during her stay in hospital (which I did the follow-
ing day). JT hoped that our meeting would be of
use to me in my medical training and she offered
this advice to me, as a doctor-in-training: ‘learn
well, do well, be true to yourself’ and asked me to:
‘give back to Māori’.
Student reflections
JT’s comments (regarding taking more responsi-
bility for their health) demonstrate a degree of
internalised racism, where many Māori blame
themselves to a greater or lesser extent for their
poor health outcomes. While individual, whānau
and community responsibility is undoubtedly im-
portant, this cannot occur in the absence of a high
level of health literacy and good access to preven-
tive and curative medicine, and while suffering
under a disproportionate burden of socioeconomic
and structural determinants of health. If accurate
history taking is a priority for forming correct
diagnosis and treatment of patients, then the lens
must also fall on the responsibility of health profes-
sionals to follow JT’s advice and simply ‘learn how
to talk with Māori patients’. Culturally validated
tools, such as the Hui Process, along with Māori
models of health, such as the Meihana Model,
exist not only for student doctors but for all health
professionals to utilise in order to reduce health
disparities in Aoteoroa/New Zealand.
My kōrero with JT was an enjoyable and rewarding
experience. I felt privileged to be a conduit for JT to
reflect on the state of her health and come to such
a revelation, and ultimately play a small role in her
healing process. Both the sessions on ‘Interviewing
a Māori patient’ and ‘Calgary–Cambridge meets
the Hui-Process’ at Ngātokowaru marae prepared
me well for this interview and I was able to loosely
follow the Meihana Model and the Hui Process
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
POUNAMU
258 VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE
as a framework. Having utilised these tools now
will help to give shape and structure to my future
interactions with Māori patients.
Thought provoking episode report
Another aspect of the undergraduate medical
programme at the University of Otago Wel-
lington is the teaching of reflective practice.
Students are asked to write a ‘Thought Provoking
Episode Report’ (TPER), choosing an episode that
provokes their thinking and analysis regarding
the professional and ethical issues raised by the
episode. The following is an excerpt submitted
by the student while reflecting on his interview
using the Hui Process and Meihana Model.
This was an eye-opening and thought-provoking
experience. I was bemused and disappointed to
discover that I’d become so cynical as to want to
conduct an interview that took as little time as
possible in order to move on to the next item on my
list of things to do. This approach could not have
fostered the kind of relationship that allowed time
and space for openness, reflection and ultimately
healing. Fortunately the Hui Process, Meihana
Model, and a small measure of good sense, derailed
our conversation from the path it would likely have
taken. In the end, we were not time-pressured and
this allowed space for the conversation to go places
that it likely would not have if I was the house
surgeon admitting JT, the GP seeing her in clinic,
or indeed the medical student whose goal at the
outset was taking as little time to glean as much
information as possible. Taking the time to listen to
our patients is a critically important skill. Indeed,
it is likely the most important, and this has been
hammered home to me by this experience. In the
face of the busy medical student, house surgeon or
GP life, I must not forget that taking the time to
listen is a skill to be treasured and honed, and can
yield great results.
It strikes me that doctors hold a privileged position
in many people’s lives: on occasion patients will
share their most intimate thoughts and fears, and
often we will be the only party privy to these.
What a position of responsibility; what we do with
this information is surely of great importance.
We must deal with such matters sensitively and
endeavour to offer encouragement and hope where
possible, although often to just lend an ear will be
the best medicine.
I wonder if taking up JT’s request to keep in touch
via email was wise. As a general rule, I think that
this is not a good practice to get into the habit of
doing and flirts with the professional patient–doc-
tor boundary. However, in this context, given JT’s
cultural background and the nature of our conversa-
tion, I felt it appropriate to send an email encourag-
ing JT in her newfound desire to take ownership of
her health.
I find one of the difficulties of history taking is
having a hidden agenda—knowing I have to come
back to the next ‘tick-box’ on my list of must-ask
questions, instead of focusing on and really listen-
ing to the person in front of me. However, by the
same token, without an agenda (specifically the
Hui Process and Meihana Model in this instance),
I may not have asked the questions that provoked
such thought in JT and thus a different outcome
may have resulted. Having used these tools now
will help to give shape and structure to my future
interactions with both Māori and non-Māori
patients alike.
Overall, this experience was a threefold success,
in that: 1) it provided the opportunity to put into
practice the skills of taking a clinical history from
a patient using Māori-focused models; 2) it allowed
JT the chance to take stock of, and empowered her
to take steps toward regaining control over, her
health; and 3) it allowed me the chance to reflect
upon our interview and to rethink some of my
initial attitudes towards our meeting.
Discussion
In this case, a fourth-year undergraduate medical
student applied the Hui Process and Meihana
Model, two Māori-centred clinical interviewing
tools, to assist him to conduct a culturally ap-
propriate interview with a hospitalised Māori pa-
tient. In so doing, the student was able to achieve
a successful interview, and appreciate that using
these tools had allowed him to engage in a man-
ner, and on a level, that resonated deeply with
both him and the patient. While results may
vary depending on the expertise of the individual
student, it seems likely in this instance that the
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
POUNAMU
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE 259
Figure 1. Alignment of the Hui Process with the Calgary–Cambridge model
THE PATIENT INTERVIEW
Mihi Initiating the session
Whakawhanaungatanga Building the relationship
Kaupapa Gathering information
Poroporoaki
Explanation, planning
and closing session
CALGARY–CAMBRIDGE
THE
HUI
PROCESS
effectiveness of the consultation was significantly
enhanced by utilising this culturally congruent
methodology.
As an indigenous health framework, the Hui
Process and Meihana Model have been in practice
across the University of Otago for seven years. In
that time, they have been evaluated by medical
students, health practitioners, Māori patients and
whānau, and have been rated favourably, as clini-
cally relevant frameworks that support health
practitioners to work effectively with Māori
patients and whānau.14
The University of Otago has, in recent years,
adopted the Calgary–Cambridge guide to com-
munication skills for medical students.6
Although
this too comes from a ‘Western medicine’ cultural
background, many of the studies on which the
method was developed were derived from anthro-
pological and cross-cultural studies. Interestingly,
the Hui Process maps easily onto the Calgary–
Cambridge model, particularly if the text around
cultural diversity is applied.6
Figure 1 illustrates
that, although the two interviewing models dif-
fer significantly in their epistemological roots,
there are basic similarities in structure and intent,
which renders them mutually compatible.
Given the unequal health outcomes for Māori
and the burden of comorbidities this population
suffers, it is imperative that our future doctors
have the ability to identify and analyse contrib-
uting risk factors at both the individual patient
level and also at a broader health systems level.
It is all too easy as health professionals to point
the responsibility for poor health solely at the
individual patient and lifestyle factors, rather
than exploring the societal inequalities in health
determinants, the access to and quality of health
care, and thus, ignoring the impact of factors
generating and perpetuating health disparities.15
In a recent revision of the Meihana Model,14
further domains, such as Ngā Hau E Whā have
been added, incorporating aspects of external so-
cietal influences that may impact on the patient’s
health and wellbeing. Ngā Hau E Whā, literally
translated as ‘the four winds’, incorporates factors
such as colonisation, racism, marginalisation, and
migration, and discusses the potential impact of
these on the historical and current health of the
patient and whānau.
In the fifth-year undergraduate Hauora Māori
training, students repeat the case study process
outlined in this article, and are also required to
incorporate a critical analysis of the underly-
ing determinants of health that may have had
an impact on the presentation, and the role of
the health system in perpetuating or mitigat-
ing health inequalities. Such analysis would
involve recognition of the significant burden
of disease this patient faced, and consideration
of the contributions of low self-efficacy, health
literacy, intergenerational trauma, acculturation,
urbanisation/migration, socioeconomic depriva-
tion, differential life-opportunities, structural
discrimination, and the availability of Kaupapa-
Māori and/or culturally appropriate mainstream
primary care services.
A further relevant issue raised in this instance, is
the extent to which ethical values are culturally
bound. Teaching around ‘boundaries’ discour-
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
POUNAMU
260 VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE
ages students from sharing their personal stories
or continuing contact with a patient after seeing
them; however, implicit within the process of
whakawhanaungatanga, is the embodiment of
genuine interest, concern, and hence obligation
towards the patient. Ideally, this process requires
the student/doctor to demonstrate this com-
mitment through subsequent contact with the
patient and appropriate follow-up. Most students
who use this process manage to find ways to
discharge this obligation within the parameters
of an appropriate doctor/student–patient relation-
ship (e.g. sitting with the patient until they go to
theatre, coming back to the ward at a later time
to meet whānau members when they are visiting,
or ‘checking in’ with the patient daily for the
remainder of their hospital stay). In the case pre-
sented, the student made the right call in ‘flirting
with the patient contact boundary’ (that is, the
student’s email contact relating to the patient’s
health seems appropriate taking this into account,
although not usual practice).
If the outcome of a consultation with a Māori
patient can be improved by having a more cul-
turally congruent consultation model, to what
extent should this encourage all health profes-
sionals to re-evaluate their consultation model
with all their patients? If a broad view of culture
is taken, then the majority of our patients are
culturally different from ourselves and from the
dominant Western medical view of the world,
and perhaps it is time that the monochromatic
mantra of the standard history taking format6
be
recognised as too narrow and content-oriented.
Broader approaches that retain a purposive clini-
cal enquiry but better recognise the sociocultural
context of the patient (such as the Hui Process
and Meihana Model) need now to be accepted as
the new norm.
5. Lacey C, Huria T, Beckert L, Gilles M, Pitama S. The Hui Pro-
cess: a framework to enhance the doctor–patient relationship
with Māori. N Z Med J. 2011;124:72–8.
6. Silverman J, Kurtz SM, Draper J. Skills for communicating with
patients. 2nd ed. Oxford, UK: Radcliffe Medical Press; 2005.
7. Jones B, Ingham T. The use of research-based indigenous
case studies for teaching undergraduate medical students.
In: Leaders in Indigenous Medical Education Network (LIME)
Good practice case studies. Volume 2. Melbourne: Onemda
VicHealth Koori Health Unit, The University of Melbourne;
2013:24–8.
8. Pitama S, Ahuriri-Driscoll A, Huria T, Lacey C, Robertson
P. The value of te reo in primary care. J Prim Health Care.
2011;3:123–7.
9. Jones B, Ingham T, Davies C, Cram F. Whānau Tuatahi: Māori
community partnership research using a kaupapa Māori meth-
odology. Mai Review. 2010;3:1–14.
10. Cherrington L. Te Hohounga: Mai i te tirohanga Māori (The
process of reconciliation: towards a Māori view). Wellington,
NZ: Ministry of Social Development; 2009.
11. Ingham TR, Jones B. Engaging with a Māori patient: the
Hui Process in clinical practice. Hauora Māori Noho Marae.
Ōrongomai Marae, Upper Hutt: University of Otago Welling-
ton; 2013.
12. Bishop R. Freeing ourselves from neo-colonial domination in
research: a Māori approach to creating knowledge. Int J Qual
Stud Educ. 1998;11:199–219.
13. Durie M. Whaiora Māori Health Development. 2nd ed. Mel-
bourne, Australia: Oxford University Press; 1998.
14. Pitama S, Huria T, Lacey C. Improving Māori health through
clinical assessment: Waikare o te Waka o Meihana. N Z Med J.
2014;127:107–19.
15. Jones CP, Jones CY, Perry GS, Barclay G, Jones CA. Address-
ing the social determinants of children’s health: a cliff analogy.
J Health Care Poor Underserved. 2009;20:1–12.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would
like to thank JT for the
taonga of her kōrero. JT
subsequently passed away
prior to the publication
of this case study, so
our condolences and
thanks also go to JT’s
whānau for allowing her
story to be shared for
the benefit of improved
cultural competence of
medical students and
health professionals in
Aotearoa New Zealand.
He mihi poroporoaki
ki a koe e te Whaea.
Haere, moe mai, okioki.
We would also like to
acknowledge the staff
at the Māori Indigenous
Health Institute (MIHI)
of the University of
Otago Christchurch for
the initial development
of the Hui Process and
Meihana Model.
He mihi nui ki a koutou.
COMPETING INTERESTS
None declared.
References
1. Stewart M, Brown JB, Weston WW, McWhinney IR, McWil-
liam CL, Freeman TR. Patient-centred medicine: transforming
the clinical method. 2nd ed. Oxford, UK: Radcliffe Medical
Press Ltd; 2003.
2. Mead SM. Tikanga Māori: living by Māori values. Wellington,
NZ: Huia Publishers; 2003.
3. Pitama S, Robertson P, Cram F, Gillies M, Huria T, Dallas-Katoa
W. Meihana Model: a clinical assessment framework. N Z J
Psych. 2007;36:118–125.
4. Cram F, Smith L, Johnstone W. Mapping the themes of Māori
talk about health. N Z Med J. 2003;116:1170.
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
POUNAMU

More Related Content

Similar to Applying A Maori-Centred Consultation Approach For Engaging With Maori Patients An Undergraduate Medical Student Case Study

Gorter et al TRACE main paper BMJ Open May 2015
Gorter et al TRACE main paper BMJ Open May 2015Gorter et al TRACE main paper BMJ Open May 2015
Gorter et al TRACE main paper BMJ Open May 2015Oksana Hlyva
 
Impact of health education on tuberculosis drug adherence
Impact of health education on tuberculosis drug adherenceImpact of health education on tuberculosis drug adherence
Impact of health education on tuberculosis drug adherenceSkillet Tony
 
Introduction to palliative care
Introduction to palliative careIntroduction to palliative care
Introduction to palliative careJWilliamKamya
 
Dr. Ameri and class,After reflecting over the course of Advanced.docx
Dr. Ameri and class,After reflecting over the course of Advanced.docxDr. Ameri and class,After reflecting over the course of Advanced.docx
Dr. Ameri and class,After reflecting over the course of Advanced.docxmadlynplamondon
 
61114100 case-study-ob-ward-edited
61114100 case-study-ob-ward-edited61114100 case-study-ob-ward-edited
61114100 case-study-ob-ward-editedhomeworkping4
 
Hospice And Palliative Care Essay
Hospice And Palliative Care EssayHospice And Palliative Care Essay
Hospice And Palliative Care EssayNeedHelpWritingAPape
 
Activities Of Living-Case Study
Activities Of Living-Case StudyActivities Of Living-Case Study
Activities Of Living-Case StudyOnlinePaperWritingSe
 
Tradtional and complementary medicine
Tradtional and complementary medicineTradtional and complementary medicine
Tradtional and complementary medicineSsalongo Ssennuni Eric
 
Patient centred care
Patient centred carePatient centred care
Patient centred caresmrutihaval
 
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20Mallika Vhora
 
SAAD COLLEGE OF NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCESUNIVERSI.docx
SAAD COLLEGE OF NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCESUNIVERSI.docxSAAD COLLEGE OF NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCESUNIVERSI.docx
SAAD COLLEGE OF NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCESUNIVERSI.docxrtodd599
 
BSN Courses | Nursing | University of Nebraska Medical Center
BSN Courses | Nursing | University of Nebraska Medical CenterBSN Courses | Nursing | University of Nebraska Medical Center
BSN Courses | Nursing | University of Nebraska Medical CenterElise Beshlian
 
Evidence Based Medicine
Evidence Based MedicineEvidence Based Medicine
Evidence Based MedicineChristy Hunt
 
Dental Myth, Fallacies and Misconceptions and its Association with Socio-Dent...
Dental Myth, Fallacies and Misconceptions and its Association with Socio-Dent...Dental Myth, Fallacies and Misconceptions and its Association with Socio-Dent...
Dental Myth, Fallacies and Misconceptions and its Association with Socio-Dent...DrRipika Sharma
 
Laws concern to administration of Medication by Nurse
 Laws concern to administration of Medication by Nurse Laws concern to administration of Medication by Nurse
Laws concern to administration of Medication by Nursemanisha kulkarni
 
Do Maternity Policies in the UK in practice enable and empower women to make ...
Do Maternity Policies in the UK in practice enable and empower women to make ...Do Maternity Policies in the UK in practice enable and empower women to make ...
Do Maternity Policies in the UK in practice enable and empower women to make ...Claire Carey
 
Obtaining Patient Information and Anxiety in Novice Nursing Students ,Article...
Obtaining Patient Information and Anxiety in Novice Nursing Students ,Article...Obtaining Patient Information and Anxiety in Novice Nursing Students ,Article...
Obtaining Patient Information and Anxiety in Novice Nursing Students ,Article...jour644
 

Similar to Applying A Maori-Centred Consultation Approach For Engaging With Maori Patients An Undergraduate Medical Student Case Study (20)

Health education
Health educationHealth education
Health education
 
Gorter et al TRACE main paper BMJ Open May 2015
Gorter et al TRACE main paper BMJ Open May 2015Gorter et al TRACE main paper BMJ Open May 2015
Gorter et al TRACE main paper BMJ Open May 2015
 
Impact of health education on tuberculosis drug adherence
Impact of health education on tuberculosis drug adherenceImpact of health education on tuberculosis drug adherence
Impact of health education on tuberculosis drug adherence
 
Introduction to palliative care
Introduction to palliative careIntroduction to palliative care
Introduction to palliative care
 
Adolescent Medical Home Policy Brief July 2016. Tebb, K.P., Pica, G., Peake, ...
Adolescent Medical Home Policy Brief July 2016. Tebb, K.P., Pica, G., Peake, ...Adolescent Medical Home Policy Brief July 2016. Tebb, K.P., Pica, G., Peake, ...
Adolescent Medical Home Policy Brief July 2016. Tebb, K.P., Pica, G., Peake, ...
 
Dr. Ameri and class,After reflecting over the course of Advanced.docx
Dr. Ameri and class,After reflecting over the course of Advanced.docxDr. Ameri and class,After reflecting over the course of Advanced.docx
Dr. Ameri and class,After reflecting over the course of Advanced.docx
 
International Journal of Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology
International Journal of Reproductive Medicine & GynecologyInternational Journal of Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology
International Journal of Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology
 
61114100 case-study-ob-ward-edited
61114100 case-study-ob-ward-edited61114100 case-study-ob-ward-edited
61114100 case-study-ob-ward-edited
 
Hospice And Palliative Care Essay
Hospice And Palliative Care EssayHospice And Palliative Care Essay
Hospice And Palliative Care Essay
 
Activities Of Living-Case Study
Activities Of Living-Case StudyActivities Of Living-Case Study
Activities Of Living-Case Study
 
Tradtional and complementary medicine
Tradtional and complementary medicineTradtional and complementary medicine
Tradtional and complementary medicine
 
Patient centred care
Patient centred carePatient centred care
Patient centred care
 
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
 
SAAD COLLEGE OF NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCESUNIVERSI.docx
SAAD COLLEGE OF NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCESUNIVERSI.docxSAAD COLLEGE OF NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCESUNIVERSI.docx
SAAD COLLEGE OF NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCESUNIVERSI.docx
 
BSN Courses | Nursing | University of Nebraska Medical Center
BSN Courses | Nursing | University of Nebraska Medical CenterBSN Courses | Nursing | University of Nebraska Medical Center
BSN Courses | Nursing | University of Nebraska Medical Center
 
Evidence Based Medicine
Evidence Based MedicineEvidence Based Medicine
Evidence Based Medicine
 
Dental Myth, Fallacies and Misconceptions and its Association with Socio-Dent...
Dental Myth, Fallacies and Misconceptions and its Association with Socio-Dent...Dental Myth, Fallacies and Misconceptions and its Association with Socio-Dent...
Dental Myth, Fallacies and Misconceptions and its Association with Socio-Dent...
 
Laws concern to administration of Medication by Nurse
 Laws concern to administration of Medication by Nurse Laws concern to administration of Medication by Nurse
Laws concern to administration of Medication by Nurse
 
Do Maternity Policies in the UK in practice enable and empower women to make ...
Do Maternity Policies in the UK in practice enable and empower women to make ...Do Maternity Policies in the UK in practice enable and empower women to make ...
Do Maternity Policies in the UK in practice enable and empower women to make ...
 
Obtaining Patient Information and Anxiety in Novice Nursing Students ,Article...
Obtaining Patient Information and Anxiety in Novice Nursing Students ,Article...Obtaining Patient Information and Anxiety in Novice Nursing Students ,Article...
Obtaining Patient Information and Anxiety in Novice Nursing Students ,Article...
 

More from Jennifer Holmes

Essay On Sports And Games. Essay on Sport Sample
Essay On Sports And Games. Essay on Sport SampleEssay On Sports And Games. Essay on Sport Sample
Essay On Sports And Games. Essay on Sport SampleJennifer Holmes
 
Transgender Essays. Lgbt rights essay. LGBT Rights Argumentative Essay: Grea...
Transgender Essays.  Lgbt rights essay. LGBT Rights Argumentative Essay: Grea...Transgender Essays.  Lgbt rights essay. LGBT Rights Argumentative Essay: Grea...
Transgender Essays. Lgbt rights essay. LGBT Rights Argumentative Essay: Grea...Jennifer Holmes
 
Ray Charles Essay. Ray Charles - Biography Poster Teaching Resources
Ray Charles Essay. Ray Charles - Biography Poster  Teaching ResourcesRay Charles Essay. Ray Charles - Biography Poster  Teaching Resources
Ray Charles Essay. Ray Charles - Biography Poster Teaching ResourcesJennifer Holmes
 
American Revolution Essays. American revolution Essay Example Topics and Wel...
American Revolution Essays. American revolution Essay Example  Topics and Wel...American Revolution Essays. American revolution Essay Example  Topics and Wel...
American Revolution Essays. American revolution Essay Example Topics and Wel...Jennifer Holmes
 
Proposal Writing Topics. 186 Creative Proposal Ess
Proposal Writing Topics. 186 Creative Proposal EssProposal Writing Topics. 186 Creative Proposal Ess
Proposal Writing Topics. 186 Creative Proposal EssJennifer Holmes
 
Macaulay Honors College Admission Essays - Sampl
Macaulay Honors College Admission Essays - SamplMacaulay Honors College Admission Essays - Sampl
Macaulay Honors College Admission Essays - SamplJennifer Holmes
 
2Nd Grade Blank Writing Paper - 2 Pack Classic Rule
2Nd Grade Blank Writing Paper - 2 Pack Classic Rule2Nd Grade Blank Writing Paper - 2 Pack Classic Rule
2Nd Grade Blank Writing Paper - 2 Pack Classic RuleJennifer Holmes
 
🎉 5 Paragraph Essay Example 5Th Grade. Compare & Con
🎉 5 Paragraph Essay Example 5Th Grade. Compare & Con🎉 5 Paragraph Essay Example 5Th Grade. Compare & Con
🎉 5 Paragraph Essay Example 5Th Grade. Compare & ConJennifer Holmes
 
How To Write An Essay In 5 Steps - Steps To Write A Go
How To Write An Essay In 5 Steps - Steps To Write A GoHow To Write An Essay In 5 Steps - Steps To Write A Go
How To Write An Essay In 5 Steps - Steps To Write A GoJennifer Holmes
 
Top 10 Write In The Rain Paper Carbonless Copy Paper NomA
Top 10 Write In The Rain Paper Carbonless Copy Paper NomATop 10 Write In The Rain Paper Carbonless Copy Paper NomA
Top 10 Write In The Rain Paper Carbonless Copy Paper NomAJennifer Holmes
 
Psychology Research Project Topics. 50 Topics For Psyc
Psychology Research Project Topics. 50 Topics For PsycPsychology Research Project Topics. 50 Topics For Psyc
Psychology Research Project Topics. 50 Topics For PsycJennifer Holmes
 
002 Essay Example Purpose Of An Thatsnotus
002 Essay Example Purpose Of An Thatsnotus002 Essay Example Purpose Of An Thatsnotus
002 Essay Example Purpose Of An ThatsnotusJennifer Holmes
 
UK Politics 9PL001 Essay Plans Edexcel Paper 1 A-L
UK Politics 9PL001 Essay Plans Edexcel Paper 1 A-LUK Politics 9PL001 Essay Plans Edexcel Paper 1 A-L
UK Politics 9PL001 Essay Plans Edexcel Paper 1 A-LJennifer Holmes
 
Striking How To Start A Scholarship Essay Thats
Striking How To Start A Scholarship Essay ThatsStriking How To Start A Scholarship Essay Thats
Striking How To Start A Scholarship Essay ThatsJennifer Holmes
 
Narrative Writing 5 Examples Format Pdf Examples - Riset
Narrative Writing 5 Examples Format Pdf Examples - RisetNarrative Writing 5 Examples Format Pdf Examples - Riset
Narrative Writing 5 Examples Format Pdf Examples - RisetJennifer Holmes
 
003 6Th Grade Argumentative Essay Topi. Online assignment writing service.
003 6Th Grade Argumentative Essay Topi. Online assignment writing service.003 6Th Grade Argumentative Essay Topi. Online assignment writing service.
003 6Th Grade Argumentative Essay Topi. Online assignment writing service.Jennifer Holmes
 
Law School Guides Great Personal Statements For L
Law School Guides Great Personal Statements For LLaw School Guides Great Personal Statements For L
Law School Guides Great Personal Statements For LJennifer Holmes
 
Printable Origami Instructions Crane - Teachc
Printable Origami Instructions Crane - TeachcPrintable Origami Instructions Crane - Teachc
Printable Origami Instructions Crane - TeachcJennifer Holmes
 
Martin Luther King Jr Writing Paper. 5 Ideas For A Resea
Martin Luther King Jr Writing Paper. 5 Ideas For A ReseaMartin Luther King Jr Writing Paper. 5 Ideas For A Resea
Martin Luther King Jr Writing Paper. 5 Ideas For A ReseaJennifer Holmes
 
Outline Mla Format Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Outline Mla Format Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.Outline Mla Format Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Outline Mla Format Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.Jennifer Holmes
 

More from Jennifer Holmes (20)

Essay On Sports And Games. Essay on Sport Sample
Essay On Sports And Games. Essay on Sport SampleEssay On Sports And Games. Essay on Sport Sample
Essay On Sports And Games. Essay on Sport Sample
 
Transgender Essays. Lgbt rights essay. LGBT Rights Argumentative Essay: Grea...
Transgender Essays.  Lgbt rights essay. LGBT Rights Argumentative Essay: Grea...Transgender Essays.  Lgbt rights essay. LGBT Rights Argumentative Essay: Grea...
Transgender Essays. Lgbt rights essay. LGBT Rights Argumentative Essay: Grea...
 
Ray Charles Essay. Ray Charles - Biography Poster Teaching Resources
Ray Charles Essay. Ray Charles - Biography Poster  Teaching ResourcesRay Charles Essay. Ray Charles - Biography Poster  Teaching Resources
Ray Charles Essay. Ray Charles - Biography Poster Teaching Resources
 
American Revolution Essays. American revolution Essay Example Topics and Wel...
American Revolution Essays. American revolution Essay Example  Topics and Wel...American Revolution Essays. American revolution Essay Example  Topics and Wel...
American Revolution Essays. American revolution Essay Example Topics and Wel...
 
Proposal Writing Topics. 186 Creative Proposal Ess
Proposal Writing Topics. 186 Creative Proposal EssProposal Writing Topics. 186 Creative Proposal Ess
Proposal Writing Topics. 186 Creative Proposal Ess
 
Macaulay Honors College Admission Essays - Sampl
Macaulay Honors College Admission Essays - SamplMacaulay Honors College Admission Essays - Sampl
Macaulay Honors College Admission Essays - Sampl
 
2Nd Grade Blank Writing Paper - 2 Pack Classic Rule
2Nd Grade Blank Writing Paper - 2 Pack Classic Rule2Nd Grade Blank Writing Paper - 2 Pack Classic Rule
2Nd Grade Blank Writing Paper - 2 Pack Classic Rule
 
🎉 5 Paragraph Essay Example 5Th Grade. Compare & Con
🎉 5 Paragraph Essay Example 5Th Grade. Compare & Con🎉 5 Paragraph Essay Example 5Th Grade. Compare & Con
🎉 5 Paragraph Essay Example 5Th Grade. Compare & Con
 
How To Write An Essay In 5 Steps - Steps To Write A Go
How To Write An Essay In 5 Steps - Steps To Write A GoHow To Write An Essay In 5 Steps - Steps To Write A Go
How To Write An Essay In 5 Steps - Steps To Write A Go
 
Top 10 Write In The Rain Paper Carbonless Copy Paper NomA
Top 10 Write In The Rain Paper Carbonless Copy Paper NomATop 10 Write In The Rain Paper Carbonless Copy Paper NomA
Top 10 Write In The Rain Paper Carbonless Copy Paper NomA
 
Psychology Research Project Topics. 50 Topics For Psyc
Psychology Research Project Topics. 50 Topics For PsycPsychology Research Project Topics. 50 Topics For Psyc
Psychology Research Project Topics. 50 Topics For Psyc
 
002 Essay Example Purpose Of An Thatsnotus
002 Essay Example Purpose Of An Thatsnotus002 Essay Example Purpose Of An Thatsnotus
002 Essay Example Purpose Of An Thatsnotus
 
UK Politics 9PL001 Essay Plans Edexcel Paper 1 A-L
UK Politics 9PL001 Essay Plans Edexcel Paper 1 A-LUK Politics 9PL001 Essay Plans Edexcel Paper 1 A-L
UK Politics 9PL001 Essay Plans Edexcel Paper 1 A-L
 
Striking How To Start A Scholarship Essay Thats
Striking How To Start A Scholarship Essay ThatsStriking How To Start A Scholarship Essay Thats
Striking How To Start A Scholarship Essay Thats
 
Narrative Writing 5 Examples Format Pdf Examples - Riset
Narrative Writing 5 Examples Format Pdf Examples - RisetNarrative Writing 5 Examples Format Pdf Examples - Riset
Narrative Writing 5 Examples Format Pdf Examples - Riset
 
003 6Th Grade Argumentative Essay Topi. Online assignment writing service.
003 6Th Grade Argumentative Essay Topi. Online assignment writing service.003 6Th Grade Argumentative Essay Topi. Online assignment writing service.
003 6Th Grade Argumentative Essay Topi. Online assignment writing service.
 
Law School Guides Great Personal Statements For L
Law School Guides Great Personal Statements For LLaw School Guides Great Personal Statements For L
Law School Guides Great Personal Statements For L
 
Printable Origami Instructions Crane - Teachc
Printable Origami Instructions Crane - TeachcPrintable Origami Instructions Crane - Teachc
Printable Origami Instructions Crane - Teachc
 
Martin Luther King Jr Writing Paper. 5 Ideas For A Resea
Martin Luther King Jr Writing Paper. 5 Ideas For A ReseaMartin Luther King Jr Writing Paper. 5 Ideas For A Resea
Martin Luther King Jr Writing Paper. 5 Ideas For A Resea
 
Outline Mla Format Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Outline Mla Format Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.Outline Mla Format Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Outline Mla Format Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
 

Recently uploaded

Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxOH TEIK BIN
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxSayali Powar
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13Steve Thomason
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfSoniaTolstoy
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAĐĄY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAĐĄY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAĐĄY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAĐĄY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdfssuser54595a
 
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its CharacteristicsScience 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its CharacteristicsKarinaGenton
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAssociation for Project Management
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfchloefrazer622
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...EduSkills OECD
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactdawncurless
 
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon ACrayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon AUnboundStockton
 
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxMENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxPoojaSen20
 
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and ModeMeasures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and ModeThiyagu K
 
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Sapana Sha
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSDStaff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
 
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
 
CĂłdigo Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
CĂłdigo Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1CĂłdigo Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
CĂłdigo Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
 
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAĐĄY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAĐĄY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAĐĄY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAĐĄY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
 
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its CharacteristicsScience 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
 
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon ACrayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
 
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdfTataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
 
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxMENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
 
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and ModeMeasures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
 
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
 
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 

Applying A Maori-Centred Consultation Approach For Engaging With Maori Patients An Undergraduate Medical Student Case Study

  • 1. 254 VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE MĀORI PRIMARY HEALTH CARE TREASURES Pounamu (greenstone) is the most precious of stone to Māori. ‘Ahakoa he iti, he pounamu’ (Although it is small, it is valuable) Pounamu CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT POUNAMU Applying a Māori-centred consultation approach for engaging with Māori patients: an undergraduate medical student case study Rhys Parry MBChB;1 Bernadette Jones RGON, DPH;2 Ben Gray MBChB, MBHL FRNZCGP;3 Tristram Ingham MBChB2 CORRESPONDENCE TO: Bernadette Jones Department of Medicine, University of Otago Wellington, POB 7343, Wellington South, Wellington 6242, New Zealand bernadette.jones@ otago.ac.nz J PRIM HEALTH CARE 2014;6(3):254–260. 1 University of Otago Wellington, Wellington, New Zealand 2 Department of Medicine, University of Otago Wellington, Wellington 3 Department of General Practice and Primary Health Care, University of Otago Wellington, Wellington Introduction For some years now the dominant text for teach- ing consultation skills has been ‘patient-centred medicine’.1 Although this method is used interna- tionally, it was developed in Canada, with a strong cultural bias towards Western European patients, and its very title, as a method, is at odds with a traditional Māori way of viewing the world.2 There are indications that, for Māori, inaccurate and inappropriate medical assessment can lead to misdiagnosis and mistreatment and thus can con- tribute to existing health inequalities in a number of areas.3 There is also evidence that, while most clinicians engage with patients with good intent, knowingly or unknowingly, they can contribute to negative patient experiences and ethnic/racial disparities in health.4 In order to prevent this and to ensure positive health experiences for Māori, it is vital to learn culturally appropriate and effec- tive methods of engaging with Māori patients.5 As part of the curriculum at the University of Otago, Aotearoa/New Zealand, undergraduate medical students learn the Calgary–Cambridge guide to medical interviewing.6 As well as this, they combine their biomedical knowledge with Hauora Māori (Māori health) principles and apply these using a Māori patient long-case interview. The main focus of this long-case is to apply an holistic approach to interviewing Māori patients, based on the combination of the Hui Process (a Māori communication and patient engagement process)5 and the Meihana Model (an holis- tic Māori model of health).3 The Hui Process provides a Māori-centred approach to history- taking, developed from the customary Māori practices that are observed at hui (meetings). This is initially taught during a marae-based (Māori meeting place), cultural immersion programme to fourth-year medical students, who learn a culturally competent way to interview Māori patients following a four-step process.7 Dur- ing this immersion programme, these students are also taught the Meihana Model, a clinically focused Māori model of health, as a framework for history taking.3 This model was designed to synthesise clinical and cultural competencies, to better serve Māori within a clinical setting. Whānau (extended family) are identified at the centre of the interview, and this model challeng- es the student/practitioner to explicitly engage with the whānau as part of the interview and any subsequent treatment plan. The following is a description of the practical application of these Hauora Māori principles in a clinical hospital setting, including excerpts from a case assignment written by a fourth-year student, after conducting an interview with a Māori patient. The first step, the mihimihi (greeting), begins with the student introducing themselves, ex-
  • 2. VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE 255 CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT POUNAMU plaining their role, confirming patient details, including ethnicity, stating the reason for the interview, and obtaining fully informed consent. Use of basic te reo (Māori language) is encouraged, as appropriate, during this step and throughout the interview. This use of te reo has been recognised as a contributing factor in building a trusted patient–doctor relationship.8 The second phase, the process of whakawha- naungatanga or the building of a relationship, follows the exchange of mihimihi, and continues throughout the interview. Whakawhanaun- gatanga is a critical concept of demonstrated relevance to both culturally appropriate research,9 and clinical encounters with Māori patients.10 It is grounded in the key cultural principle of acknowledging the interconnectedness and interdependence of an individual, members of the whānau, immediate and extended family, com- munity and wider society. In the clinical context, whakawhanaungatanga has a purposeful focus directed towards the health professional estab- lishing a cultural connection with the patient, thus distinguishing it from basic rapport.11 The process provides a holistic context that permits the student to place the information gathered within a cultural framework, ensuring a more accurate interpretation and understanding of the patient.12 A vital part of this step is the student’s sharing of appropriate stories and information, so as to balance the interview and avoid a one-sided interrogation scenario. Excerpts from the student case study The process of whakawhanaungatanga, or the building of the relationship, was initiated by the exchange of mihi, the sharing of our stories. This exchange took place before any thought was given to the ‘information gathering’ biomedical approach, oft practised in Western Medicine. We exchanged stories about where we’d come from: JT (the patient) talked of her childhood; being raised by her grandfather, and how she spoke te reo at home. Her iwi heritage gave an opportunity to create a common bond, as my wife has ancestry to the same iwi. Whakawhanaungatanga is an ongoing process and was maintained and reinforced throughout our kōrero (talk) through: (1) an emphasis on seeing JT as a whole person, in contrast with the reductionist focus-on-the-medi- cal-condition approach; and (2) through reference back to the information shared in our mihi. It was evident throughout our kōrero that a connec- tion had been made and this was reinforced when, at the end of our two-and-a-half hours together, JT gave me her contact details and asked me to make sure that I keep in touch. We were not time-pres- sured and this allowed space for the conversation to go places that it likely would not have if I was the house surgeon admitting JT or the GP [general practitioner] seeing her in clinic. This raises the question of the adequacy of 15-minute GP appoint- ments, or biomedically/tinana (physical health)– only focused consultations to facilitate conversation that has the ability to promote real consideration of one’s health status and behaviours. In the clinical context, whakawhanaungatanga has a purposeful focus directed towards the health professional establishing a cultural connection with the patient, thus distinguishing it from basic rapport The third step of the Hui Process is the kaupa- pa—the main purpose/reason for the interview is largely dependent on the effectiveness of the first two steps. In order to be able to obtain in-depth information, it is important that the patient feels at ease and can trust the student/clinician with sharing their sensitive personal information. For many Māori, this information is viewed as a taonga (treasure) belonging not only to them as individuals but also intrinsically linked to their tı̄puna (ancestors) with whom they remain con- nected to through the generations. As we got to talking and I actually listened (as op- posed to charging in with question after question), I began to discover a lovely and vibrant, but ‘broken’ lady. The interview progressed in a semi-struc- tured kind of way, loosely following the pattern described above and that of the Meihana Model, where health is seen as encompassing six different
  • 3. 256 VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE facets (tinana—physical health; whānau—the fam- ily aspect; hinengaro—mental health; wairua—spir- itual health; taiao—the environmental aspect; and iwi katoa—the wider health system context). Tinana (physical health) JT was admitted to the respiratory ward, where she spent six days receiving treatment for pulmonary oedema. When visited by the respiratory nurse at her home (five days ago), she was found to be breath- less, unable to complete full sentences, and ‘gasping for air’. An ambulance was called and she was taken to the emergency department for assessment. She had recently been discharged following a similar episode. An occasional unproductive cough and some pain associated with this was reported but oth- erwise nil of note. She had a number of comorbidi- ties, including: congestive heart failure; ischaemic heart disease, with previous non-ST elevation myo- cardial infarction; chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; asthma; obesity hypoventilation syndrome; Type 2 diabetes (insulin dependent); paroxysmal atrial fibrillation; and osteoarthritis of both hips, for which she was awaiting total hip replacements. She regularly took multiple medications: insulin; salbutamol; fluticasone/salmeterol; simvastatin; metoprolol; quinapril; frusemide; and fluoxetine. She had been seeing a dietician and felt her diet was good, with plenty of fruit and vegetables. JT is an ex-smoker, with a 15 pack–year history. Whānau (family/social supports) JT is one of 16 children; she has four children of her own and eight mokopuna (grandchildren). Both her parents died early but she had little information to give about their health. JT lives at home with her partner who is also unwell, but has good support from her children who live close by. She has some home help. No whānau were present during our kōrero (talk) but she mentioned that they are quite worried about her health. JT discussed her iwi (tribe), hapū (sub-tribe), and marae (meeting house) affiliations, along with her maunga (mountain), the basis of her sense of connectedness. She has no marae involvement in Wellington but is involved with a number of kaumātua (elder) groups. JT is now retired but used to work as a social worker, and was involved with the policy board for a local health provider and a number of other groups. Hinengaro (psychological/emotional) Regarding her beliefs about medication and adher- ence, JT had an ‘I just do as I’m told’ attitude, and felt her control of diabetes was a good example of success. Enforced bed-rest has afforded JT the time to reflect and given the benefit of hindsight she sees herself as being mostly responsible for her poor health. This made her feel unhappy: [The] truth hurts. [Expletive] does it ever! An hour into our kōrero, I said to JT that it seemed as if she had come to a point of realisation and that she was starting to take ownership of her own health. This seemed to resonate with her, as she broke down in tears, agreeing that this was exactly how she felt and it had taken her a very long time to come to this realisation. Wairua (spiritual/connectedness) With reference to Wairua, JT’s comment was that she believes in a Māori model of health, by which she was referring to the Whare Tapa Whā model.13 A Catholic nun had visited her today to take her through a karakia (prayer/incantation), but in gen- eral she felt that she didn’t really take great care of her wairua, her spiritual health. Taiao (environment) JT and her partner live in a modified home on a flat section (her previous home had steps) with a wet shower area, a handle above the bed and a number of other modifications. Due to her immobility (both hip osteoarthritis and obesity-related), she uses a walking frame when outside the house. Some home help is currently provided and this is being reviewed with a view to increasing this service. Iwi Katoa (health systems) JT has her own GP and felt that she had easy and good access to health care, but thought this was likely related to her position as a social worker (pre- viously) and her role with the local health provider. She said that she knew many Māori who don’t know where to go when they have health concerns, and therefore don’t seek help. CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT POUNAMU
  • 4. VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE 257 Māori cultural beliefs and values JT describes Māori as ‘the same but different’, in that those from different iwi and hapū often have different beliefs about health. For example, talking about different aspects of health is tapu (sacred/ restricted) for some and there can therefore be a reluctance to seek help. Māori are whakamā (embar- rassed/shy) when talking about certain sensitive body parts. She said that she loves the cervical screening television advertisements for Pacific women (shown on New Zealand television) but wished there was something similar for Māori. JT felt it was important for the elders in the commu- nity to stand up and model good health practices to the younger generations—she said that she felt she hasn’t done a great job of doing this so far, but plans to change that. Poroporoaki The final step of the Hui Process, the Poroporo- aki (closing or concluding the encounter) is an important part of the interview process. Evidence shows that, for Māori, this part of the consulta- tion can be suboptimal and incomplete at times, and is an important part of a culturally appropri- ate and effective health literacy approach with patients.5 Case study: Poroporoaki Poroporoaki is the process of farewell and con- clusion of a meeting. It allows each party the opportunity to share their thoughts regarding the encounter and, in this context, ask questions and to negotiate future plans. Our kōrero drew to a close when JT again spoke of the sense that she felt responsible for her ill health. She believed that she had played a large part in her current poor health state, saying that she had neglected to take care of herself, and had deferred seeking help for health concerns. We talked of the opportunity she now had to take ownership of her health and she ex- plained that her mokopuna were the motivation for this. She felt that our conversation had allowed her an opportunity to ‘get a load off her chest’ and that she hoped ‘people would see a change in her’. I asked JT for her opinion on what the causes were for the discrepancies in health status between Māori and non-Māori, to which she responded that she felt many Māori need to take responsibility for their own health. In addition, she added that non- Māori doctors need to learn how to talk with Māori patients so that they will be more likely to share information about themselves. I asked explicitly if she had any questions for me and allowed space for her to consider her response. JT’s only question was to ask that I keep in touch, to which I promised to email and visit her again during her stay in hospital (which I did the follow- ing day). JT hoped that our meeting would be of use to me in my medical training and she offered this advice to me, as a doctor-in-training: ‘learn well, do well, be true to yourself’ and asked me to: ‘give back to Māori’. Student reflections JT’s comments (regarding taking more responsi- bility for their health) demonstrate a degree of internalised racism, where many Māori blame themselves to a greater or lesser extent for their poor health outcomes. While individual, whānau and community responsibility is undoubtedly im- portant, this cannot occur in the absence of a high level of health literacy and good access to preven- tive and curative medicine, and while suffering under a disproportionate burden of socioeconomic and structural determinants of health. If accurate history taking is a priority for forming correct diagnosis and treatment of patients, then the lens must also fall on the responsibility of health profes- sionals to follow JT’s advice and simply ‘learn how to talk with Māori patients’. Culturally validated tools, such as the Hui Process, along with Māori models of health, such as the Meihana Model, exist not only for student doctors but for all health professionals to utilise in order to reduce health disparities in Aoteoroa/New Zealand. My kōrero with JT was an enjoyable and rewarding experience. I felt privileged to be a conduit for JT to reflect on the state of her health and come to such a revelation, and ultimately play a small role in her healing process. Both the sessions on ‘Interviewing a Māori patient’ and ‘Calgary–Cambridge meets the Hui-Process’ at Ngātokowaru marae prepared me well for this interview and I was able to loosely follow the Meihana Model and the Hui Process CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT POUNAMU
  • 5. 258 VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE as a framework. Having utilised these tools now will help to give shape and structure to my future interactions with Māori patients. Thought provoking episode report Another aspect of the undergraduate medical programme at the University of Otago Wel- lington is the teaching of reflective practice. Students are asked to write a ‘Thought Provoking Episode Report’ (TPER), choosing an episode that provokes their thinking and analysis regarding the professional and ethical issues raised by the episode. The following is an excerpt submitted by the student while reflecting on his interview using the Hui Process and Meihana Model. This was an eye-opening and thought-provoking experience. I was bemused and disappointed to discover that I’d become so cynical as to want to conduct an interview that took as little time as possible in order to move on to the next item on my list of things to do. This approach could not have fostered the kind of relationship that allowed time and space for openness, reflection and ultimately healing. Fortunately the Hui Process, Meihana Model, and a small measure of good sense, derailed our conversation from the path it would likely have taken. In the end, we were not time-pressured and this allowed space for the conversation to go places that it likely would not have if I was the house surgeon admitting JT, the GP seeing her in clinic, or indeed the medical student whose goal at the outset was taking as little time to glean as much information as possible. Taking the time to listen to our patients is a critically important skill. Indeed, it is likely the most important, and this has been hammered home to me by this experience. In the face of the busy medical student, house surgeon or GP life, I must not forget that taking the time to listen is a skill to be treasured and honed, and can yield great results. It strikes me that doctors hold a privileged position in many people’s lives: on occasion patients will share their most intimate thoughts and fears, and often we will be the only party privy to these. What a position of responsibility; what we do with this information is surely of great importance. We must deal with such matters sensitively and endeavour to offer encouragement and hope where possible, although often to just lend an ear will be the best medicine. I wonder if taking up JT’s request to keep in touch via email was wise. As a general rule, I think that this is not a good practice to get into the habit of doing and flirts with the professional patient–doc- tor boundary. However, in this context, given JT’s cultural background and the nature of our conversa- tion, I felt it appropriate to send an email encourag- ing JT in her newfound desire to take ownership of her health. I find one of the difficulties of history taking is having a hidden agenda—knowing I have to come back to the next ‘tick-box’ on my list of must-ask questions, instead of focusing on and really listen- ing to the person in front of me. However, by the same token, without an agenda (specifically the Hui Process and Meihana Model in this instance), I may not have asked the questions that provoked such thought in JT and thus a different outcome may have resulted. Having used these tools now will help to give shape and structure to my future interactions with both Māori and non-Māori patients alike. Overall, this experience was a threefold success, in that: 1) it provided the opportunity to put into practice the skills of taking a clinical history from a patient using Māori-focused models; 2) it allowed JT the chance to take stock of, and empowered her to take steps toward regaining control over, her health; and 3) it allowed me the chance to reflect upon our interview and to rethink some of my initial attitudes towards our meeting. Discussion In this case, a fourth-year undergraduate medical student applied the Hui Process and Meihana Model, two Māori-centred clinical interviewing tools, to assist him to conduct a culturally ap- propriate interview with a hospitalised Māori pa- tient. In so doing, the student was able to achieve a successful interview, and appreciate that using these tools had allowed him to engage in a man- ner, and on a level, that resonated deeply with both him and the patient. While results may vary depending on the expertise of the individual student, it seems likely in this instance that the CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT POUNAMU
  • 6. VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE 259 Figure 1. Alignment of the Hui Process with the Calgary–Cambridge model THE PATIENT INTERVIEW Mihi Initiating the session Whakawhanaungatanga Building the relationship Kaupapa Gathering information Poroporoaki Explanation, planning and closing session CALGARY–CAMBRIDGE THE HUI PROCESS effectiveness of the consultation was significantly enhanced by utilising this culturally congruent methodology. As an indigenous health framework, the Hui Process and Meihana Model have been in practice across the University of Otago for seven years. In that time, they have been evaluated by medical students, health practitioners, Māori patients and whānau, and have been rated favourably, as clini- cally relevant frameworks that support health practitioners to work effectively with Māori patients and whānau.14 The University of Otago has, in recent years, adopted the Calgary–Cambridge guide to com- munication skills for medical students.6 Although this too comes from a ‘Western medicine’ cultural background, many of the studies on which the method was developed were derived from anthro- pological and cross-cultural studies. Interestingly, the Hui Process maps easily onto the Calgary– Cambridge model, particularly if the text around cultural diversity is applied.6 Figure 1 illustrates that, although the two interviewing models dif- fer significantly in their epistemological roots, there are basic similarities in structure and intent, which renders them mutually compatible. Given the unequal health outcomes for Māori and the burden of comorbidities this population suffers, it is imperative that our future doctors have the ability to identify and analyse contrib- uting risk factors at both the individual patient level and also at a broader health systems level. It is all too easy as health professionals to point the responsibility for poor health solely at the individual patient and lifestyle factors, rather than exploring the societal inequalities in health determinants, the access to and quality of health care, and thus, ignoring the impact of factors generating and perpetuating health disparities.15 In a recent revision of the Meihana Model,14 further domains, such as Ngā Hau E Whā have been added, incorporating aspects of external so- cietal influences that may impact on the patient’s health and wellbeing. Ngā Hau E Whā, literally translated as ‘the four winds’, incorporates factors such as colonisation, racism, marginalisation, and migration, and discusses the potential impact of these on the historical and current health of the patient and whānau. In the fifth-year undergraduate Hauora Māori training, students repeat the case study process outlined in this article, and are also required to incorporate a critical analysis of the underly- ing determinants of health that may have had an impact on the presentation, and the role of the health system in perpetuating or mitigat- ing health inequalities. Such analysis would involve recognition of the significant burden of disease this patient faced, and consideration of the contributions of low self-efficacy, health literacy, intergenerational trauma, acculturation, urbanisation/migration, socioeconomic depriva- tion, differential life-opportunities, structural discrimination, and the availability of Kaupapa- Māori and/or culturally appropriate mainstream primary care services. A further relevant issue raised in this instance, is the extent to which ethical values are culturally bound. Teaching around ‘boundaries’ discour- CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT POUNAMU
  • 7. 260 VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 3 • SEPTEMBER 2014 JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE ages students from sharing their personal stories or continuing contact with a patient after seeing them; however, implicit within the process of whakawhanaungatanga, is the embodiment of genuine interest, concern, and hence obligation towards the patient. Ideally, this process requires the student/doctor to demonstrate this com- mitment through subsequent contact with the patient and appropriate follow-up. Most students who use this process manage to find ways to discharge this obligation within the parameters of an appropriate doctor/student–patient relation- ship (e.g. sitting with the patient until they go to theatre, coming back to the ward at a later time to meet whānau members when they are visiting, or ‘checking in’ with the patient daily for the remainder of their hospital stay). In the case pre- sented, the student made the right call in ‘flirting with the patient contact boundary’ (that is, the student’s email contact relating to the patient’s health seems appropriate taking this into account, although not usual practice). If the outcome of a consultation with a Māori patient can be improved by having a more cul- turally congruent consultation model, to what extent should this encourage all health profes- sionals to re-evaluate their consultation model with all their patients? If a broad view of culture is taken, then the majority of our patients are culturally different from ourselves and from the dominant Western medical view of the world, and perhaps it is time that the monochromatic mantra of the standard history taking format6 be recognised as too narrow and content-oriented. Broader approaches that retain a purposive clini- cal enquiry but better recognise the sociocultural context of the patient (such as the Hui Process and Meihana Model) need now to be accepted as the new norm. 5. Lacey C, Huria T, Beckert L, Gilles M, Pitama S. The Hui Pro- cess: a framework to enhance the doctor–patient relationship with Māori. N Z Med J. 2011;124:72–8. 6. Silverman J, Kurtz SM, Draper J. Skills for communicating with patients. 2nd ed. Oxford, UK: Radcliffe Medical Press; 2005. 7. Jones B, Ingham T. The use of research-based indigenous case studies for teaching undergraduate medical students. In: Leaders in Indigenous Medical Education Network (LIME) Good practice case studies. Volume 2. Melbourne: Onemda VicHealth Koori Health Unit, The University of Melbourne; 2013:24–8. 8. Pitama S, Ahuriri-Driscoll A, Huria T, Lacey C, Robertson P. The value of te reo in primary care. J Prim Health Care. 2011;3:123–7. 9. Jones B, Ingham T, Davies C, Cram F. Whānau Tuatahi: Māori community partnership research using a kaupapa Māori meth- odology. Mai Review. 2010;3:1–14. 10. Cherrington L. Te Hohounga: Mai i te tirohanga Māori (The process of reconciliation: towards a Māori view). Wellington, NZ: Ministry of Social Development; 2009. 11. Ingham TR, Jones B. Engaging with a Māori patient: the Hui Process in clinical practice. Hauora Māori Noho Marae. Ōrongomai Marae, Upper Hutt: University of Otago Welling- ton; 2013. 12. Bishop R. Freeing ourselves from neo-colonial domination in research: a Māori approach to creating knowledge. Int J Qual Stud Educ. 1998;11:199–219. 13. Durie M. Whaiora Māori Health Development. 2nd ed. Mel- bourne, Australia: Oxford University Press; 1998. 14. Pitama S, Huria T, Lacey C. Improving Māori health through clinical assessment: Waikare o te Waka o Meihana. N Z Med J. 2014;127:107–19. 15. Jones CP, Jones CY, Perry GS, Barclay G, Jones CA. Address- ing the social determinants of children’s health: a cliff analogy. J Health Care Poor Underserved. 2009;20:1–12. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to thank JT for the taonga of her kōrero. JT subsequently passed away prior to the publication of this case study, so our condolences and thanks also go to JT’s whānau for allowing her story to be shared for the benefit of improved cultural competence of medical students and health professionals in Aotearoa New Zealand. He mihi poroporoaki ki a koe e te Whaea. Haere, moe mai, okioki. We would also like to acknowledge the staff at the Māori Indigenous Health Institute (MIHI) of the University of Otago Christchurch for the initial development of the Hui Process and Meihana Model. He mihi nui ki a koutou. COMPETING INTERESTS None declared. References 1. Stewart M, Brown JB, Weston WW, McWhinney IR, McWil- liam CL, Freeman TR. Patient-centred medicine: transforming the clinical method. 2nd ed. Oxford, UK: Radcliffe Medical Press Ltd; 2003. 2. Mead SM. Tikanga Māori: living by Māori values. Wellington, NZ: Huia Publishers; 2003. 3. Pitama S, Robertson P, Cram F, Gillies M, Huria T, Dallas-Katoa W. Meihana Model: a clinical assessment framework. N Z J Psych. 2007;36:118–125. 4. Cram F, Smith L, Johnstone W. Mapping the themes of Māori talk about health. N Z Med J. 2003;116:1170. CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT POUNAMU