Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Exploring the challenges in using OER for Teacher Education in Ghana: a pilot study
1. Lisa Taner
Postgraduate Research Student
Institute of Educational Technology
The Open University
Lesley Boyd, The Open University
Bea de los Arcos www.flickr.com/photos/celtatis/15651016535/
2. Jointly funded 1+3 studentship
openTEL
The Open Technology Enhanced Learning (openTEL) is a priority research
area, bringing together researchers from across the Open University to
focus on research in TEL.
http://www.open.ac.uk/blogs/opentel/
3. SRA-IDII
The Open University’s Strategic Research Area in
International Development and Inclusive Innovation
IDII groundbreaking research sets out to:
• Tackle global inequity
• Reshape market processes to ensure innovation involves and serves the needs of all
• Work in partnership with poor and marginalised people to realise a fairer and more
sustainable world.
http://www.open.ac.uk/ikd/
8. Don’t panic!
You deserve to be here.
We aren’t looking for THIS, but..
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lego_Color_Bricks.jpg
9.
10. Context
Primary education in Sub-Saharan Africa faces a critical shortage of teachers
estimated at 25 million (UNESCO, 2015).
Teacher’s professional development varied with a diversity of approaches.
Many in-service teachers have received little or no training historically.
MDGs had some success in growing primary enrolment but there is variation in
completion rates.
In addition to millions missing out on school, many attending are being failed by a
system that fails to meet their needs and lacking the literacy and numeracy skills to
raise themselves out of poverty.
12. SDG (4.c) by 2030 to: substantially increase the
supply of qualified teachers, including through
international cooperation for teacher training in
developing countries to ensure inclusive and
quality education for all.
https://c1.staticflickr.com/1/713/22825341484_2f48edd012_b.jpg
18. What does the literature say?
• Lewin and Stuart (2003) explored initial teacher education in five
countries including Ghana where they found the academic level of
many entrants to be weak, with many insecure in core subjects. In
addition, there were issues with the training teachers received:
‘sometimes the colleges appear to be training students for schools as
tutors think they ought to be, rather than for schools as they are’.
• Others have commented that existing teacher training provision does
not position trainee teachers as autonomous, decision-making
individuals (Akyeampong et al, 2013).
• Learners need education to be inclusive, relevant and democratic
(Tikly and Barrett, 2011) as teacher education in lower income
countries has often focused on numbers and not quality.
23. The potential of OER
• school based forms of open and distance learning using new
communication technologies are the only viable way forward (Moon,
2009).
• ‘true power of comparative research around the impact and use of open
educational resources is only just being realised’ (Farrow et al, 2015)
• OER for teacher professional development are one way in which this urgent
skills gap can be filled (Moon, 2007 and Power, 2013).
• Open and distance learning and interventions can enhance and
significantly contribute to teacher professional development and in service
training (Shohela & Banks, 2010, TESSA, TESS-India, EIA.)
• Current methods inadequate, inefficient, expensive and is not closing the
gap on getting children into school. (Moon et al, 2013)
24. Mobile telephone access is
leapfrogging fixed land-line
phone ownership
Growth of mobile tech and
internet in SSA
Photo: https://www.flickr.com/photos/lac-bac/6347652875
25. Research questions
To what extent are primary teachers
in Ghana making use of OER for their
professional development?
What resources do teachers draw
upon to develop their teaching
practice?
What conditions encourage/support
teachers to use OER?
26. • How can OERs be better developed or designed to be of
practical use to primary classroom teachers?
• How do teachers use OERs within and for multilingual
learning environments?
30. OER teacher education programmes
English in Action Bangladesh http://www.eiabd.com/eia/
TESSA http://www.tessafrica.net
TESS India http://www.tess-india.edu.in
The Research on Open Educational Resources for Development
(ROER4D) project http://roer4d.org
OER Africa http://www.oerafrica.org/
31. Conceptual framework and
rationale
Qualitative, ethnographic research
approach
Participatory research as it has
‘an affinity with equity, social
justice and a ‘transformative
paradigm’ (Cohen et al, 2011).
32. Are teachers more likely to adapt and share OER in informal ways or as
part of small communities of practice than in solitary situations?
Is informal adaptation and sharing more prevalent than is recorded in
the literature (‘dark reuse’)?
OU graduate
Entered teaching- always connected to the OU
Part funded MA- action research
Advisory and consultancy work: global learning and EAL/ EMA
Aspired to doctoral study
Many professional development opportunities overseas
Led funded school partnership with rural Ghanaian school, reciprocal visits, shared learning through MA module.
Akwaaba- welcome.
Open University module Education and Development, in particular
TMA01 background information on situation of school teachers in sub-Saharan Africa with focus on teacher supply, education and training
TMA02 group briefing note/presentation on development of ICT to support teacher education via mobile technologies, specifically phones, to improve teaching practices.
A fortuitous email-
…Studentships in 4 research areas that matched my proposal.
MRes began Oct 2016- 4 modules, 8 assignments, a 15-17,000 word dissertation.
Using my dissertation as pilot study for PhD.
A pile of Lego blocks, of assorted colors and sizes, 1/12/107 Source Lego Color Bricks Author Alan Chia
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lego_Color_Bricks.jpg
Tweet @global_teacher
17 goals to transform our world
The Sustainable Development Goals, adopted on 25 September 2015 as a part of the 2030 Agenda.
Date 31/12/16 Author MariaGershuni https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sustainable_Development_Goals.jpg
https://c1.staticflickr.com/1/713/22825341484_2f48edd012_b.jpg
CC licensed
How can all our research relate to the SDGs?
-Body of research around use of TESSA materials
-Despite Ghana’s relative political/ democratic stability, the World Economic Forum (2015) ranks Ghana 121/ 144 for health and primary education, despite successes at pupil enrolment and closing the gender equality gap
Ghana has historically favoured lengthy and conventional full-time training and has a system of posting teachers to locations well away from their homes and communities.
Ghana’s policy on posting teachers to remote locations, often outside their cultural and linguistic communities, means they can often find themselves expected to teach in a language they are unfamiliar with.
Akyeampong et al (2013)
Ghana's ‘extremely poor’ have notably lower attendance, some households citing lack of progress in learning among other reasons why many of these children drop out.
Disproportionate amount of time allocated to developing subject content knowledge over pedagogy
repetition of sec content (all Ghanaian trainees have completed senior secondary school) leaves little time for focus on num and lit skills and concepts req’d by early learners nor with how children learn.
Also see Ansah- multilingual contexts (2014)
National to pupil level
National: national policies
Local: institutional structures/ practices- teacher educators- trainee teachers and also in-service teachers- pupils’ learning
Murphy and Wolfenden, 2013
Teacher Education, Development eg Openness in Development, Tech initiatives e.g. One Laptop Per Child
Contextual documents: local (school and regional policy, ITT policy),
national e.g. Government Ministry policy/strategy, global e.g. Global Monitoring reports,
OER/ Educational Technology e.g. ROER4D materials/ TESSA
Teachers are paddling against the tide on all fronts it seems.
Language- Ansah (2014) ‘Primary schools’ teaching syllabuses and materials, apart from text books on Ghanaian languages within subject teaching, are always in English.’
Adaptation- (Buckler and Wolfenden, 2012) Adapting OERs for local contexts remains a huge challenge.
So how do teachers use and adapt OERs for their contexts so that they meet the needs of these highly complex multilingual populations?
Emerging findings from TESS-India suggested resistance on behalf of participants to make significant changes to OERs, which Perryman et al (2014) suggest could be ‘a disinclination to disrupt hierarchical notions about who owns (and should own) knowledge and who should share it.’
UNESCO’s recent message suggests language as a key barrier, too: ‘linguistic diversity creates challenges within the education system, notably in areas of teacher recruitment, curriculum development and the provision of teaching materials’ (2016).
Any issues you have encountered?
Reaching ‘the right’ teachers
Methodology
Interdisciplinary research
Too many research Qs- funneling.
Given this urgent challenge, OER are one way to fill the teacher professional development skills gap to ensure that teachers have access to quality materials that support their classroom practice in diverse learning environments.
Need to move away from the campus based model of teacher training as this will not keep pace with increasing demand on teacher places. We also need to consider alternative models of provisions which focus on school based training, reconsidering training lengths pre service and a combination of pre and in in service training.
Ghana Dec 16 - nearly 20 million subscriptions/- just under 70% population (nca.or.gh)
Photo: https://www.flickr.com/photos/lac-bac/6347652875 Boys playing leapfrog / Garçons jouant à saute-mouton
Boys playing leapfrog Creator(s) Rosemary Gilliat. Library and Archives Canada, e010836120 1956-1960 Reference No. MIKAN 3697380
collectionscanada.gc.ca/ourl/res.php?url_ver=Z39.88-2004&...
Looking for ways teachers autonomously develop themselves to improve their own practice IRL and in online spaces
Are teacher OER fit for purpose?- Initially thought could research teachers use on a continuum of adaptation- (Weller) but stepped back from the assumption they are being used.
Shadowing and observations
Semi structured in- depth interviews
Materials review (OER materials, lesson plans,
national policies)
Participant generated photographs (right words?)
Materials review (OER materials, lesson plans, national policies)
Milligan L. (2016) Insider-outsider-inbetweener? Researcher positioning, participative methods and cross-cultural educational research. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education. 2016 Mar 3;46(2):235-50.
Photo: http://maxpixel.freegreatpicture.com/Young-Lady-Phone-Female-African-Woman-Black-1889405
Approaching the research questions through a critical and participatory research approach as it has ‘an affinity with equity, social justice and a ‘transformative paradigm’ (Cohen et al, p.32).
Gathering qualitative research data allows for a deeper insight into teachers’ methods and motivations.
By September, MRes complete- filling in the gaps a little. Lots left.
Feedback pls- methodology, including quant elements, any glaring issues.
Medaase- thank you.
All slides using cc images are acknowledged.
Slide1 Bea de los Arcos https://www.flickr.com/photos/celtatis/15651016535/
Slide 34 Lesley Boyd, The Open University.
With thanks to Bea and Lesley.